Flappers Disadvantages

DiPaolo, Brian. “Flappers.” Issues & Controversies in American History. Infobase Publishing, 2 July 2007. Web. 6 Feb. 2013 This source is an article that investigates on whether the flappers have a positive or negative impact on the American culture and if they deserved to earn the right to pursue their freedom. DiPaolo’s main claim is that the flappers have an equal amounts of benefits and disadvantages to the societies. To support the author’s argument, he presents two polarized groups that have completly opposite point of views in regards to the flapper culture. To develop and build upon his claim, DiPaolo presents a side-by-side analysis on both groups by using various case studies, scholarly works, and other visual sources to show
The author claims that the temporary freedom that flappers got to consume did not maximize the feminist potentials nor reach their original goals. To support his claim, Reinsch shows that even though the flappers did contribute to more freedom and provide more benefits for women, it also led to many controversial discourses in health and medical fields. The author presents statistical researches and studies to demonstrate that the emergence of flappers could possibly become potential threats of “racial hygiene” and marriages. Through this, Reinsch is able to develop her sub-claim that the feminist movement did not reach its maximize potentials under the influences of consumer society and affect how the Germans perceive the flappers
Emily Spivack, who is an editor at Sentimental Value, could be considered as a valid and credible source giving the facts that she has published many works in the New York Times and Wall Street Journal focusing on how fashions and cultures are intertwined with each other. The goal of this author in this article is to provide a deeper understanding of the flapper culture in the United States by portraying them in a positive light. Even though flappers are widely accepted in our current societies, it is important to note that they were extremely controversial and led to many debates by the older generation back in the time. To achieve her purpose, Spivack breaks down every component relating to flappers and investigates their process of breaking the gender norms and achieving greater equality, in hopes for the female audiences to be more aware of the significant impacts of flappers in the women history and how they could personally relate to each other. This source will provide solid background information for my research topic, particularly on how flappers in the 1920s challenged the traditional gender roles in the United States. Specifically, this source approaches my research topic from a fashion point of view and demonstrates how the fashion trends alter Americans’ beauty standards. Specially, this article series aligns with my argument on how the overall American population