Explain the Utilitarian & Deontological Aspects of Informational Privacy for Employers & Employees

Topics: Ethics, Morality, Utilitarianism Pages: 4 (1197 words) Published: May 15, 2011
Explain the Utilitarian & Deontological aspects of informational privacy for employers & employees

Patricia Dunn, placed number 17 on FORBES list of most powerful women, landed herself four felony counts by making unethically chivalrous decisions. Patricia Dunn, once a chairwoman on the board of Hewlett-Packard, a position she held from February 2005 until September 2006. Her tenure was cut short on October 4, 2006 as she was charged with four felony counts for her role in a spying scandal.

Five months later on March 14, 2007, California Supreme Court judge Ray Cunningham dropped criminal charges against her in the “interest of justice” on all four felony counts: fraudulent use of wire, radio or television transmissions; taking, copying, and using computer data without authorization. (A&E Television Networks 2011)

She broke the golden rule of honor by teaming up and taking unethical measures to seek out a “leaker. She claims she had no idea “pretexting” (the practice of deceiving individuals into surrendering personal information for fraudulent purposes) could involve identity misrepresentation. In addition, she testified that she believed personal phone records could be obtained through legal methods.

Showing more respect to her peers by giving them the benefit of the doubt would have been a more Utilitarianistic direction. Had she openly expressed the concern with HP’s long term strategy being public, it may have been resolved just that simply.

SO, where does this leave Patty Dunns ethical reasoning? Her utilitarianism reasoning does not show happiness for the greater number. Her deontological reasoning held a lot to be desired by failing to ensure laws and regulations were standard. Ultimately, it appears that Patricia Dunn did not have a strategy or plan of attack.

In Patty Dunn’s case it seems she failed to implement either deontological or utilitarianism reasoning. Had she followed a more...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Compare Utilitarian and Deontological Theory Essay
  • Deontological and Utilitarian arguments for Abortion Essay
  • Explain the key features of Utilitarian Essay
  • Deontological Vs Utilitarian Ethics Essay
  • Explain Utilitarian Ethics Essay
  • Utilitarian and Deontological Theory Drug Testing Essay
  • Utilitarian and Deontological Implications of the Bank of America and Wikileaks Scandal Essay
  • Essay about Legal Ethics-Deontological, Utilitarian, and Casuistry Perspectives

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free