Preview

Ethical Reproductive Technologies

Best Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3008 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Reproductive Technologies
Ethics of reproductive technologies
Introduction
With most technological advances in the field of medicine, ethical considerations and concerns are formed. "Just because we can do something , should we do it?" This is a question that has plagued scientists in the last half of the twentieth century. The field of reproductive medicine in particular has faced this question-- perhaps more than any other field. For the first time in history, as an outgrowth of in vitro fertilization technology and research, the three components of parenthood - the genetic, the gestational, and the nurturant - can be separated, so that the loss of one does not necessarily result in the loss of the others.

For a man or woman who may not be able to conceive a
…show more content…
In addition, permitting sex selection, even in male dominated cultures could be positive, as it avoids the harm of compelling women to successive pregnancies until they have sons [9]. Even if a sex ratio imbalance does occur, some argue that this would serve to increase women’s value in the eyes of men [4]. It is also reasoned that parental autonomy and reproductive liberties are more important than equality [4,] [9], 0]. This technology allows medical professionals to aid the desires of couples with strong preferences for a particular sex- so why should they be denied if there is no demonstrable harm to others? [1] [5] There are potential psychological harms for the sex-selected offspring, as they might not live up to their parents’ high expectations [11]
.
Also, “shopping” for a particular sex devalues the dignity of children and their wellbeing [7]. It is proposed that they are effectively being used as a means to gratify their parents [12] and that moral and family dimensions are more important than consumer choice [13]. Children should not be accepted or rejected because of their sex- they should be loved unconditionally [10] [3]. Some believe that parents should not be granted inappropriate control of non-essential characteristics [14], as they could lose sight of the pleasure of children [11]

Designer
…show more content…
I believe that parents are acting in the best interests of their child by having a second child to save the first. PGD could also be used to enable parents to choose superficial characteristics such as eye colour, intelligence, beauty and so on [1]. This practice is highly controversial, as it would mean that children could become primarily valued according to the attractiveness of their expected characteristics [1]. It could also prevent the child from developing its own personality and identity, and they would be burdened with living up to the standards they were “designed” to meet [1] [16]

It is feared that selection of certain favourable traits will lead to discrimination and stigmatisation of people without those traits [1]. This could also damage the sense of self-worth and identity of disabled people, if they were viewed as “genetically inferior” [21] [22]. The expensive nature of PGD would mean that only wealthy people could afford it, so a “genetic overclass” would be established that had

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Hsm 542 Week 1&2 Discussion

    • 45403 Words
    • 182 Pages

    | Given the contentious debate surrounding issues of procreation, develop an institutional policy, which can be applied to the range of treatment and research issues related to procreation.…

    • 45403 Words
    • 182 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first benefit is to prevent or minimize a decrease in future fertility. By preventing this avoidable decrease, that child is given to the opportunity to make future reproductive choices. Failing to offer fertility preservation deprives the child of a choice that he or she would have otherwise had. The second benefit is the demonstration of concern for the child’s future fertility. Undergoing a fertility preservation procedure is no guarantee that the patient will become a parent to a baby who is genetically related to him or her. However, the attempt to preserve the child’s fertility demonstrates the parents’ and clinicians’ concern for the child’s future reproductive choices. These significant benefits justify a presumption in favor of attempting fertility preservation, assuming that there are effective and established techniques…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Advancements in modern technologies in the field of assisted reproductive technology (ART) have opened up the world to a vast array of possibilities. Scientists have developed the ability to retrieve and preserve individual gametes and embryos by way of cryopreservation, a technique that involves preserving biological materials at very low temperatures outside the body for years. . This field of in vitro fertilization (IVF), worth $2 billion annually in the United States, has forced us to think about human tissue in ways never before thought possible. These advancements have meant that it is now possible for children to be conceived after the death of one of their genetic parents. The first reported case of posthumous sperm retrieval (PSR) was in 1980 and between then and 1995 there were 82 requests for PSR in the US alone. While PSR has enabled males (predominately), previously deemed sterile once again fertile, it has posed a number of issues that have been described as the “most challenging, difficult and sensitive that are likely to be encountered in the field of medicine”. Jocelyn Edwards; Re the estate of the late Mark Edwards represented the first time in NSW that a woman was allowed to harvest the sperm of her deceased partner. However, it highlighted a number of issues concerning the control of processes involving gametes, the right to use and control them and whether gametes can actually be considered as property, as well as the obvious moral and ethical issues with completing such a radical procedure. Furthermore, there are those that concern the rights of the child, as well as the danger of commercialisation. This essay will explore each of the policy issues raised in Re Edwards and the concerns for the broader community spectrum as a whole.…

    • 2744 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some examples of actual and alleged unethical conduct in practicing assisted reproductive technologies (ART) have given rise public debate about these rapidly progressing technologies. In certain instances it was believed that eggs stored for posterity by patients were used to impregnate others without any explanation, permission, or the informed consent of the parties. Although this was not the first time revelation of potential deception has ever come to light in the field of ART. There have been other cases where a doctor who operated a private clinic used his own sperm for artificial insemination without the patients consent. (Riddick, 2006) The following discusses assisted reproduction, surrogate parenting, what are the implications on the definition of parenting, is surrogate parenting good or bad, as well as if surrogate parenting a way to exploit the poor.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Designer Babies Analysis

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ghose argues that being able to determine the sex of the baby could potentially lead to a sex-discrimination against women in society. This article also brings up the idea that if a parent was able to choose the traits of the child, this can worsen the relationship between the parent and the child, due to the fact that this can parents could be presented with tyrannical expectations (Ghose 2014). If a parent is able to dictate the traits of the child, this could hypothetically put pressure on the child that should also have the rest of his life…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Preimplantation diagnosis

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages

    He then lays out the possible underlying beliefs as to why parents choose this for their children. Firstly, in Parents having fewer children, it would only be in the best interest of your child to be given the most successful genetic prospects. Next, if the health care and social services were unable to fully accommodate treating serious genetic conditions, it would only be common sense for this generation to utilize the advancements in preventing them. Lastly, rather then this being detrimental to people who seek the testing, the real moral danger lies within enhancing discrimination against genetic impairments.…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Abortion: Roe Vs. Wade

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The control of fertility has always been a topic issue for women. Different pre conception and post conception procedures have been practiced since the ancient times. Abortion has become a major topic for everyone in the United States. It became very focused when the Roe Vs. Wade case was passed. This is because many individuals have strong, colliding opinions on abortion and it’s laws. The two main group views of abortion are pro-life and pro-choice. Pro-life are individuals who believe abortion is wrong, and pro-choice are people who believe it is up to the mother to choose what she wants. While one particular view has not been proven to be correct or incorrect, it has brought many persuasions to the table on what should be considered the…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When having a child, one of the most important things that parents hope for is that their child will be healthy. For a long time, parents wouldn’t know if their child would have any disabilities until they were born. Now with PGD (preimplantation genetic diagnosis), doctors are able to find deadly diseases in embryos. “The procedure is performed before implantation thus allowing the couple to decide if they wish to continue with the pregnancy.” (American Society for Reproductive Medicine.) This is causing designer babies to become a popular choice for parents that really hope to have…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Eugenic indication became especially significant once prenatal diagnosis technologies were refined” (Bashford 546). PGD helps Eugenics reach a disease-free society, which is desirable for all. This assures Eugenicists in getting rid of the “feebleminded” or “unfit” population. Ruth Schwartz Cowan found the history of fetal sex identification through amniocentesis and its use by Danish researchers to sex-linked hemophilia in 1959 (Bashford 546). “This new knowledge could be “applied” because of the preexisting eugenic indication for legal abortion: the Danish 1938 eugenic law permitted abortion if there was a risk that the child would be born with “severe and non-curable abnormality of physical disease. Where eugenic abortion laws were not available, the imperative to terminate pregnancy, in light of the new diagnostic capacity, drove abortion’s legalization, as much as did women’s arguments for reproductive choice” (Bashford 546). This clearly states how well PGD is connected to eugenics in allowing women to choose the type of child they “ideally” want and to terminate the children born with genetic disorders. Conversely, PGD is seen as wrong to others because of religious points of view that life starts at conception. “Able-bodied people tend to underestimate the quality of life of disabled people. The majority do not wish that they had never been born, they and their families value their…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This theory proposes that a child watches a role model that is perceived as similar to itself (i.e. same-sex) and sees the situations in which they are rewarded or punished. They encode this behaviour, and then later attempt the acts they saw receive positive sanctions. If the child is also rewarded for the behaviour, this reinforces the benefits of the conduct, and the child will continue to do it. The parental reinforcement in children’s play seems great, mainly because people in general have quite fixed opinions about what is appropriate for boys and girls play, which tends to form from preconceived ideas of the different traits of the genders. An example for this is that birth parents view their sons as bigger and stronger (Rubin, Provenzano, & Luria, 1974, cited by Spelke, & Pinker, 2005) and this is reflected in how they treat the child. For instance, Smith and Lloyd (1978) gave mothers ‘masculine’, ‘feminine’ and ‘neutral’ toys and found that when a baby was dressed as a boy the mothers encouraged masculine behaviour such as motor activity play. Lytton and Romney (1991) also found further evidence to support…

    • 2418 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Here, when parents are planning on having a baby, they are faced with having to decide whether they want a genetically engineered baby or whether they want to let nature run its course. However, this decision involves much more than a simple yes or no, as this decision will decide their child’s social location and will assign them a master status. Deciding to genetically engineer their baby, parents are assuring their baby the master label of valid, but parents who decide to let nature run its course, are taking the huge risk of having a no-perfect child who will be labeled with the master status of ‘invalid,’ one which can’t be changed.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    -discrimination exists and it is primarily between two groups. The valid’s, as they are called here, are the dominant group who oppress the group known as the invalids, which is the group consisting of the less privileged individuals. However, in this society, privileged and less privileged does not refer to the individuals in terms of wealth or power, but instead, in terms of genetics. Here, discrimination has been reduced down to genes, and this determines your place in society.…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sex Selection Practice

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Sex selection practice has been studied in a various number of countries, where guidelines and policies were determined regarding accepting or refusing it. (10) In the UK, the Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (HFEA) banned sex selection practice for non-medical purposes, as it is believed to be associated with physical, psychological and financial burdensome. (4.6) (HFEA) regulates and controls sex selection in the UK with legal regulations, restrictions and a license should be provided to authorize the legal practice of sex selection in special cases. The license for sex selection is authorized in particular cases such as; when there is a high risk of the embryo to have a serious gender or non-gender linked genetic, chromosomal,…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many individuals or couples are not blessed to have their own children because of their…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Procedures such as artificial insemination and in vitro fertilization are procedures that are very expensive. The most accurate sex-selection methods are the most expensive (tens of thousands of dollars) and often mean you have to undergo invasive infertility treatments and take fertility drugs with potential side effects. If the majority of children are born in the lab, what will be the social status of those born through sex? Will insurance companies refuse to cover cancer treatments for children whose parents did not invest in customization? What will economic competition look like between two baby customization companies? Will we be offered “basic” models and then expensive genetic upgrades? “If you want a child who plays the violin and can run like Usain Bolt, that will be an extra $50,000.” The only families who could afford these procedures are the families who are very wealthy. The amount of money just for choosing the gender is ridiculously expensive let alone choosing specific…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays