Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Discuss the tone and theme of "A Small, Good Thing"

Good Essays
309 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Discuss the tone and theme of "A Small, Good Thing"
In Carver's story, "A Small, Good Thing," the tone appears to be that of sadness. The story contains a few tones including bitterness, pity, and even love. Despite this, sadness seems to be the overpowering tone. The following are the two situations that bring the sadness throughout the story:

"There was a Negro boy in surgery last night," Ann said. [. . .] "He passed away," said the nurse at the counter. (Carver)

Scotty, honey, it's Mommy and Daddy," she said. "Scotty?" The boy looked at them, but without any sign of recognition. [. . .] His lips parted as his last breath was puffed through his throat and exhaled gently through the clenched teeth. (Carver)

This story deals with people dying, lack of hope, and unfortunate events that happen in life. All of these events add to the intense sadness in the lives of the characters. The baker tries in the end to give the family a sense of happiness, or to ease the sadness brought on by the death of their son.

The theme in this story is that, despite how bad life gets, there is always hope or something that one can do that will bring forth a sense of happiness. As the baker said, "Eating is a small, good thing in a time like this." (Carver) The baker tries to comfort the parents in their time of grief. In one sense, he feels the same pain of isolation as they do. He is cut off from the outside world in his bakery, yet he is able to feel their pain and help them.

As in life, the story deals with the most painful of situations, dealing with the loss of a loved one. Just life reality, many who are on the outside do not fully understand the pain of death until it happens to them, yet they are able to comfort those in times of need.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Learning to Cope

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Just about everyone has lost that one person that they really care about and they know that everything can change at the drop of a hat. Death is an unexpected occurrence that could sometimes have long lasting mental and physical effects on people. In the play Down the Aisle by Patricia Leigh Gaborik a young girl Katie and her family are learning to cope with the death of their loved one. People handle the death of a loved one in different ways, and Katie tries to handle the death of her father by holding on to all the good memories she had of him. Not only is Katie deeply affected by their lost but the rest of her family is learning to cope with their lost by taking on different roles when he pasts. The father is a symbolic character in this play because he is the rock of their family, because he is strong and dependable. Each character in the play experiences different conflicts and changes in their relationship after losing the person they all loved the most.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In “The Story Of Tom Brennan” written by J.C Burke in a story about destruction, guilt and shame through the story there are allot of up and downs after the crash the family is not the same and tom knows that it will never be the same the story uses destructive power to add some problems to the story to keep it going the crash causes a couple of problems to everyone not just the family the whole community is effected guilt tom and kylie both feel guilty like they were the cause for the crash shame the family lie in shame they feel like there family is bad and the community don’t help that is why they mover because the whole family is looked down upon by the town of Mumbili. The family is affected by destruction in every way the family has changed after the event it has cause the whole community to change fin who was in the crash and her family are affected As well after fin became paraplegic her mum has to change the way she raises her son and fins dreams are crushed after one night so much has happened to the families and friends of the victims in the crash. Tom’s life has changed him and his mum grows further away slowly not talking to each other. Kylies life has changed to she has lost all her friends because they had to move schools. And fin has nothing left and her mother has trouble looking after her it is hard on every one. When the crash happens tom feels like he is the one who has cause the crash he feels guilty in every way he feels like he could have stopped what happened and kylie feels the same way she has the same feeling as tom and they are in the same place both feeling guilty of what happened that night both hiding it and keeping it bottled up inside them that is why they always fight it is because they both feel like they could have done something about it stopped the whole incident from happening fin sought of has the same feeling that if she didn’t get in the car that night nothing would have happened and it would all be the…

    • 591 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    intriguing story that keeps the reader's attention the whole time. Using the anecdote puts the reader at the scene as if they watched the events take place right before their own eyes, allowing the reader to see a ‘major life event,’ death.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Instead of being a film that is gloomy and sad, the film has the remaining family members preparing a feast and arguing over where to bury the body. We don’t ever feel sad that the character is dead in the first place. We just laugh at the way they go about putting her to rest. They set the story up so that we focus less on the death and more about the bickering between family members. One of the characters also pokes fun at certain aspects of religion, which is always a very controversial topic in movies.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, in this story, the author demonstrates the positive influence that relationships have on the characters. This is shown when Rudy Steiner and Liesel Meminger decide to leave bread on the empty roads of Dachau for the Jewish prisoners. When Rudy and Liesel pedal together toward Dachau, they stop at a road. Rudy passes a bag full of bread to Liesel and says: “Take a handful.” “I’m not sure this is a good idea.”…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scarlet Ibis Theme

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is shown that threw out the story the narrator's pride continues to grow over his brother. The significance the argument is that pride can change everyone that it can make the unexpected happen. The author shows in the story that the narrator really loves his brother, but he does not know it himself until the end when he pushes his brother to his death. It is learned from this story not to take things for granted to appreciate everything in life before someone pushes it away. This story shows us the difference is people and the human in them and that everything can change off of one…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Parenthood Movie Review

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The main character had a terrible relationship with his father. They didn’t see eye to eye at all. The father just took him to baseball games and left him there with an usher that he paid to watch him. The absence of a father figure was significant to his childhood. When he grew up he tried to be anything but that memory. He was involved in his children’s lives. This would be a family theme where the parent separates themselves from the child, so they could attend to their own matters in life. The next theme can be seen in the family that has the young girl being feed information like a sponge ruining her childhood so she could get ahead intellectually. The parents did not see her as a child but as some sort of machine. It is not the proper way to raise a child. She was socially awkward and didn’t have the social skills to socialize with the other children at Kevin’s birthday party. This theme is where the parents treat the child as an object rather than a living being. The next one is in the single mom with the two kids. She struggles to support for her family and her children disrespect her all the time. The son was so distant from her and left all the time, while the daughter was in love with a troubled boy. The son was having problems with himself since she went through puberty and he didn’t have a father figure to explain all the changes in his body and while he was feeling certain things. Todd became that father figure when he married the boy’s sister and got to explain what was happening through experience. This helped out the single mother trying to support her two children. The youngest son and brother of Gil the main character displayed the same type of parenting as the grandfather did with Gil, abandoning his child and dumping him with whoever would take care of him.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The most important thing that I have learned in the study of Howard Thurman (mystic, prophet, poet, philosopher and theologian), is the idea that out of religious faith emerges social responsibility. Thurman’s understanding of the role of meditation and the contemplative life informed his every action. I admire his ability as a man of quiet spirit to find the unity in all living things, which created for him a harmony with nature, self, people; and, more importantly, with God. Surely, Howard Thurman’s philosophy seems to have an understanding of the interconnectedness of all living things. I believe his quiet spirit is the influence that helped to mold his thoughts and actions…

    • 1736 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Death is a horrendous thing that can cause an irreplaceable hole in somebody’s life. Death can also represent chaos and the pain of another character in the story. In Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, the deaths of Johnny, Dally, and Bob created an intriguing plot and unveiled the hidden feelings and personalities of characters who react to the deaths, like Dally and Randy. The major deaths in The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton, which are the deaths of Candy’s Dog, Curley’s Wife, and Lennie, displayed the personalities of the characters who killed them and developed the story in the book. The theme of death reveals hidden elements of characters who strongly felt a certain way about the character. Even though death is the end of a character, it…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tears of a Tiger

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Tears Of A Tiger, teaches many heart felt lessons about life after death. It shows how people cope with the lose of a loved one and how tough it can be to move on. In the book Andy Jackson the main character feels guilty and believes he should be the one who died not rob Washington his best friend. " Well, if you really want to know, I wanted to die right after the accident I wanted it to be me dead instead of Robbie". (24 draper) This quote shows you the trouble Andy has coping with robs death and how he feels responsible. Death happens everyday and is a sore subject for some people, but in this book you can see how they deal with it, and try to live life after death.…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the first paragraph alone, many important aspects of the narrator's character are revealed. It is revealed to the reader that the narrator was in love and is grieving for the woman he loved. It is also in the first paragraph where the major conflict is revealed. The major conflict, in which the narrator is involved, is his own torment from the memory of his dead wife. This is evident when the narrator says, "When I saw our room again, our bed, our furniture, everything that remains of the life of a human being after death – I was seized by such a violent attack of fresh grief that I felt like opening the window and throwing myself onto the street." Initially, the author intends the reader to feel sorry for the narrator and his loss. The thing that motivates the narrator in the conflict is his resolution to finish grieving before it consumes him. This is evident when he says, "Happy is the man whose heart forgets everything that it has contained."…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Suffering and loss is a regular situation in the human life cycle, it is vital to learn how to deal with it so that it doesn’t affect the rest of our lives negatively. In Scott Russell Sanders’s Ten Reasons Why We’ll Always Need a Good Story he explains that one of the reasons is to help us deal and become aware of suffering, loss, and death. During our youth we often don’t consider the end of the life cycle. However, in life we will always encounter grieving from a loved one’s death. The first time we experience some sort of grieving it may be very hard to handle and may cause depression. Stories help us prepare for moments of suffering, loss, and death with fictional experiences which show us how to deal with these unfortunate events. In the three short stories we read at least one character in each story is forced to deal with suffering, loss, or death. In the short story Bluffing by Gail Helgason, Liam has an unfortunate accident and experiences physical pain as well as the emotional pain of his deteriorating relationship with Gabriella. In Two Words by Isabel Allende, Belisa Crepusculario is devastated by the death of her entire family due to their impoverished lifestyle and the love between her and the Colonel causes them to miss each other. In The Indisputable Weight of the Ocean by Darryl Berger, Edmund deals with not being able to see his father and deals with the suffering of moving to a suburban area.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    As time passes and as the world shifts, people pass away and they never come back. People who are left on the world, now without the others’ presence, must live with knowing they will never get to see them again and that now all they have left is the memories of when their loved ones were still around. Judd Mulvaney has the realisation and through it, the reader is able to see how he is caring and innocent. His naivety is something not to be ashamed of, nor is it something that he should keep. He must learn about death in order to move on and live life to the fullest of his own potential. From here, he can treasure each step, each moment, and each breath, knowing that he only gets this one shot to live. And he…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Small, Good Thing Essay

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “A small, good thing” by Raymond Carver brings a lot of vivid images to mind for me. Even though the writing is minimalistic, the story came alive. The lack of description enabled me to read the story and project characters from my own life in the place of the ones the author had created. From the beginning of “A small, good thing” I put my nephew, my niece, and my own son in the place of the boy in the story. The emotional tie to the stories outcome is what made me keep reading. For me, the meaning of the story is forgiveness. There is a family that has lost a beloved son, a baker who made a cake for someone who is yelling at him and refusing to pick up the cake, and a family waiting for their son to get out of surgery. The story follows Scotty’s mother as she deals with her son’s hospitalization. In the beginning the mother is very judgmental and alone in her pain, but throughout the story she opens up; first to her husband, and then to the baker. The reason I think the story is about forgiveness is that all the characters in the story must forgive to have the peace at the end. The mother and father must forgive the baker for his insensitive calls, and realize that he is a lonely man whose life revolves around the bakery. The baker must forgive the man and his wife for their anger and for not coming to pick up their cake. He has to let it go, and help the man and woman cope with the greatest loss of their lifetime. He gives them forgiveness and compassion, and they come to peace…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story proves that death can be positive in the sense that it can mirror how one is valued by others. This is seen through the characters of Colby 's friends and how they spare no expense in…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays