Discuss The Juxtaposition Between Dogmas And Human Nature

Through the juxtaposition between dogmas and human nature, Marx also highlights how humans cannot credit human nature to dogmas and abstract ideas, like religion. Religion does not provide a stable human nature. Throughout the essay, he critiques classic German philosophical belief that religion shapes man. Instead, they are shaped by the point in history they were born in. Our relation to nature is historically specific. Human ideology, our belief system, consciousness, morality, religion, metaphysics, philosophy, etc. are all shaped by the modes of production. Your place in a social organization, and the overall conditions of the historical period will consequently shape your ideology. So, there is not a predisposed rationality within man. Rather, human rationality is a social product where different rationalities are produced in different periods.
Nonetheless, needs also shape and modify the needs for future generations. Relating back to the example of the tribal family, their most basic and fundamental need is to acquire food and habitation. Tools —which are both manual tools and things like capitalism, modes of social organization, technology, physical implements, and socioeconomic relations — are created. So, a physical organization can help determine what exactly one’s needs are. When the family meets their first basic need, they have developed enough tools, such as slaves, to join other tribes and develop private