Preview

Dai Sijie The Lost Meaning

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1286 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dai Sijie The Lost Meaning
A Lost Meaning: From Book to Movie
Most books that are reincarnated into movies do not typically portray the book as the reader has interpreted it. Whether it be plot twist, random addition of scenes or a whole new ending, a movie generally never completely follows the book it is based on. This stems from the fact that the directors are in fact not the authors of the book being made into a film and therefore, the director can make the changes he or she deems more palatable to the audience. I found it very surprising that Dai Sijie would choose to make the movie contain the differences it did in regards to the book, especially the ending. Dai noted in his interview with Alan Riding that he does indeed keep “in touch with two of his ‘re-education’ colleagues - both studied in the United States and returned to China to teach - when he visits Beijing” ("Artistic Odyssey: Film to Fiction to Film."). From this statement, the new ending in the movie flowered. What I do not understand is why he would desire a changed ending. Dai mentions that he believes a
…show more content…
While I was somewhat educated on the Cultural Revolution in China, it was not until I began to try to find reasoning behind Dai putting in the Three Gorges Dam flooding the village at the ending of the movie that I really dug deep and discovered how and why the Cultural Revolution happened, the effects of the Cultural revolution on the environment, economy and the Chinese population. When I began to read Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress, I knew it was fiction and therefore, my mindset was focused on the faultiness of the book and not on how much of the book was actually derived from real-life experiences and events that occurred from 1966-1977. Maybe I was the only one foolish enough to set my mindset this way, but I am thankful for the change in mindset after writing this

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the story Red Scarf Girl by Ji Li Jiang, Ji Li Jiang is a model student and she has always been a determined person. Ji Li is a kindhearted girl that is always helpful to her classmates and has a good leadership. When Ji Li was little, she “[donated their] cast-iron kettle to [support Chairman Mao,] and when natural disasters had caused food shortages, she “[grew] pots of seaweed on the balcony”(27). This shows that Ji Li strongly believes in Chairman Mao and she tries to participate in the Cultural Revolution as much as she can. Ji Li “[knows that] the movement [of the campaign of destroying the fourolds is] vital to [their] country's future”(27) ,so she tries to help out anyway possible. Ji Li [feels…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary Of Sikokame

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to the Huichol legend, Sikoakame was a child that had been abandoned by his mother, Nakawe. His brother Wakuri searched for him to bring him back home, but Sikoakame refused, and to escape, became a snake. But Wakuri followed him and Sikoakame, irritated by his brother’s persistence, became a lighting bolt and stroke him. Wakuri then shattered into many pieces that became corn grains of many colors: white, blue, yellow, red and black, and these were scattered all over the Blue Mountain, where they became corn-children.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What happened in chapter 1 The Wobbling pivot was that there was two men fighting over a bicycle and there were people listening to them in Tianamen Square. There was a riot that had happened in China where there was a riot that happened and there were a lot of people protesting for domestic traqulity in Bejing. In the streets of Changchun there were people in taxis and most of them that took a ride was businessman and foreigners because the fares prices were very high. There were policeman that were extremely violent or didn’t care about their actions about how they treated people in certain cities and china as a whole was corrupted. For example when some girl had been raped and killed there was no justice against that and the family pleaded for a trial and they got it but it took a while. Another example is when the girl had got murdered and was raped and she died and the young girl funeral was held but officials said that killing is not a crime. Also there were people trying to fight for their individual rights like people had anger over the unsafe mines and the polluted water that was not safe to drink. There were unsafe working conditions and endless demands of local officials for bribes and sex privileges. There had been a problem with the farming with the water supplies poisoned and their crops being ruined and there could be rising incidences of cancer and that was a panic. There were peoples homes destroyed for no apparent reason and if they resisted thousands were fined and even going to jail some of the time. The main two things that the officials wanted were money and power which they only got if from family or any kind of racial connections. There were many cities that were under attack in China and the people still protested and many were killed and very few police officers. If you broke any laws in China you may have been sentenced to death regarding these protests. There were other things like Education, public safety; food security and culture…

    • 394 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    After two weeks of reading and , they called me down to the dining room. “What and began telling me about their own struggles in China. To this day, I remember their stories about growing up in a culture in which they were sent to the countryside at 18 years old, a time when most westerners began their college education. Indefinitely assigned to manual labor, my parents worked through harsh conditions:…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Hundred Flowers undoubtedly had a less significant impact than other events considered turning points in Mao’s China such as the establishment of the PRC, the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, but it did still have a notable impact on various areas of Chinese life, particularly in the short term.…

    • 528 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel gives insight as to what was happening in the war between the Chinese and the Japanese. For example on page 21, it is revealed that Shanghai was repeatedly bombed and was purposefully set on fire in certain locations that were not destroyed by the bombs. Aside from the World War being described, the novel does a good job of teaching about the Chinese and Japanese culture. Throughout the novel, hobbies such as gardening and painting are often brought up. The mentioning of such simple hobbies helps the reader comprehend what the common citizens saw as an escape to get their minds off of the war. Ultimately, the book’s combination of both personal information used with the actual historical events of the war help the reader have a better understanding of what was truly occurring during this time, making it an interesting book that is a good source of learning general historical information about World War…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    more than a crazy Indian who doesn't want to talk so pretends to be deaf and…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jan Wong starts out as a naïve, nineteen year old, Canadian student who is displeased with the capitalistic nature of her surroundings. It was the early seventies and to the author, she was experiencing a cultural revolution all her own. Opposition to the Vietnam War was strongly prevalent, the notion of feminism was beginning to arise, and there was a strong desire against conformity of any nature. The author grew up middle class to second generation Chinese citizens and was fueled by bourgeois guilt, and by a feeling of separation from her roots. “Curiosity about my ancestry made me feel ashamed that I couldn’t speak Chinese and knew so little about China” (14). After devouring every morsel of information that she could, she firmly believed Mao and his “comrades” were the only people who had a legit shot at establishing a utopic society. It was official. Jan Wong was going to Beijing.…

    • 1587 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Little Chinese Seamstress

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Chinese Communist leader Mao Zedong’s implemented the Cultural Revolution and spread perpetual fear of death during his rule in China. Educated citizens faced humiliation, exile, beatings, and millions of youths had no choice, but to relocate to the countryside for their “re-education.” He classified books as propaganda and the owners as traitors who should suffer severe consequences. In Dai Sijie’s Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress, the narrator and Luo risk getting caught with novels in their possession so that they can continue to escape the harsh reality of their life through them. Dai Sijie chooses to specify the Hunchback of Notre Dame, the Count of Monte Cristo, and Ursule Mirouët to emphasize the main theme of love, supported…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    2. Throughout the novel, there is a shift in the tone of the book. He begins his story in a happy tone. His mother becomes sick and dies, beginning the change in tone. In chapter 5 he creates a monster. He sees the immorality in breaking the laws of nature. His knowledge is too great for his own good.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The narrator telling the story described how her parents had her go outside while they talked about grown up things. When she walked into the house, smoke was everywhere, and she urgently asked her grandma if there was a fire. Then the grandma assured her that there was nothing to worry about, and her parents were just burning pictures wearing mandarin jackets and old-fashioned long gowns considered as fourolds. The Red Scarf Girl immediately became curious, and started to look at the pictures that were being burned. Her parents burned all of the pictures that the Red Guards could possibly think only rich kids could afford things such as riding a camel. This story’s attitude is very different from “China’s Cultural Revolution” because in the Red Scarf Girl, the narrator was only talking about how they were buring pictures, and in “China’s Cultural Revolution” it talked about how things were before and after The Cultural Revolution. ‘“Your mother heard today that photos of people in old-fashioned long gowns and mandarin jackets are considered fourolds. So your parents are burning them in the bathroom”’ (Jiang). This quote from the text is presenting how her parents are buring pictures that are no longer allowed to be kept due to The Cultural…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our adaptation centers around Wang Jiafan, a Chinese student, who was forced to accuse Chen Jiaqian of raping her. Jiaqian was set up because he offended the Party Secretary of his village, Teng Xinfu, and was a…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Daoist Symbolism

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Daoism is a philosophy that uses images and allegories to explain its concepts of balance and harmony, two of it’s main aspects. By understanding the analogy of the wheel, one can better understand Daoism and many of its principles. The image of the wheel symbolizes the Dao: the ultimate being of perfect harmony, egolessness, and fullness. The wheel represents the way that the Dao substantially stays the same, but moves and changes places. It incorporates aspects of typical Daoist compliments: it is made up of the hub and the spokes, and both function in different ways to complete the substance of the wheel. The spokes, many in number, surround the hub equally and physically. Because they are made of materials, they can potentially fade or wear away. The spokes all connect to the middle of the wheel and meet at the center place called the hub. Unlike the spokes, the hub is empty and contains nothing. Although this lack of material cannot be defined positively, it has significance in its emptiness, stability, cohesiveness, and singularity.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    But at the end, he still wants to marry Cunegonde and only sees the positive things such as him finds her. He does not worry about the fact that everyone has been killed but lived again or that the women were used as sex slaves. No, at the end he is still somewhat innocent, wanting to live a happy life. He did gain some insight but not a whole lot. Meaning not enough to make him change. He is still the same innoncent and naïve…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Most compelling film “Farewell My Concubine” by Chinese filmmaker Chen Kaige depicts clamorous historical events broken out in China in twentieth century as well as human desire of love and ambition. Chen’s brilliant direct and cast of the love triangle within the film stimulate the viewers and smoothen the connections between rapid developments of the story. Six major periods include: the Warlord Era (1927-1937), War of Resistance against Japan (1937-1945), China’s War of Liberation (1945-1949), After Liberation and before the launching of Culture Revolution (1949-1966), Launching of Culture Revolution (1966-1976) and After Culture Revolution and adaptation of Reform and Open Policy (1976-1979). “Farewell My Concubine,” consisting fifty-two years in total, have great significances in expressing the moments of changes that China faced. The wide span of experience made Chen Kaige to “[convey] a very critical political message through the story plot” about Culture Revolution. Not only this film has influence over politic views of the viewers, but it also has complete influence on fifth generation films, the modern Chinese Cinema.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays