English III
3/04
The Puritan society was very judgmental. In both the Scarlet Letter and The Minister’s Black Veil, author Nathaniel Hawthorne showed how people tend to judge before the truth was revealed. there are many similarities between Mr.Hopper, Dimmesdale, and Chillingworth. All three characters hid something very important in their life.
In The Minister's Black Veil, Mr. Hooper is a character that changes as his church members change. Mr. Hooper changed internally as he struggles with secret sin and his first appearance in the black veil shocks and even frightens the individuals in the church however, as time goes on, the veil is almost seen as routine to the congregation. In his older years, he becomes referred to as Father Hooper, and is honored by being asked to speak at the Election Sermon. Even though his place within the church is higher than it was before the addition of the veil, people still treat him with some suspicion.
In the Scarlet Letter Dimmesdale is the pastor that everyone respects just like Mr.Hopper, yet he is slightly unhappy. Unlike Mr.Hopper who wear the black veil but becomes more happier, Dimmesdale slowly rips himself apart mentally throughout the book trying to decide whether he should come out with his secret or lie to everyone. Dimmesdale's entire life is a living lie because he preached to his congregation about being pure and not sinning yet he committed one of the worst sins possible in the christian faith. In the end, he gave in and confessed his sin which is unlike Mr.Hopper who died with his sin unrevealed to anyone.
Chillingworth begins in the story as a gentleman, but he slowly turns evil when he realizes what happened between Dimmesdale and Hester. He tortures Dimmesdale everyday like clockwork, and tortured him mentally. He turns extremely evil in his quest for revenge and continues to torture Dimmesdale and drive him crazy. Dimmesdale changes from a priest to a sinner and Chillingworth changes from gentleman to an evil killer.
In conclusion, The Puritan society would judge anyone even a pastor. Nathaniel Hawthorne showed how people tend to judge before the truth was revealed in both the Scarlet Letter and The Minister’s Black Veil.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Chillingworth. He is Hester’s former husband, a wonderful physician. He chooses to keep his identity a secret upon arriving back to town after being in Indian captivity for two years. After finding out about Hester’s child, he vows to get revenge from whomever it belongs to. Chillingworth goes from being a kind, smart, and gentle old man to an evil, plotting, vengeful ball of fury. He sets his eyes upon the Reverend Mr. Dimmesdale, and immediately recognizes him as Pearls father. He arranges to be Dimmesdale’s roommate, and from that moment on makes his life a living hell. The reverend slowly diminishes under Chillingworth’s evil power, as Chillingworth grows stronger by the day. When Dimmesdale finally confessed his sin and died, Chillingworth lost all his power. He crumbled, and died soon…
- 711 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Richard Perle, a political advisor of the 1940s, once said, “Sometimes the things we...do seem objectionable in the eyes of others” (“Brainy Quote” 7). This is true of people and situations we encounter in our everyday lives, and all of us are most likely deemed objectionable more frequently than we realize. Our behaviors can appear undesirable, offensive, or scornful to others, while we may not conceive it ourselves. This is certainly true of the way readers perceive Dimmesdale’s actions to be in The Scarlet Letter, an acclaimed novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne. The story is a romance involving characters that have been embroidered so intricately…
- 1474 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Dimmesdale practiced self-punishment as a substitute to public humiliation that was a common discipline in The Scarlet Letter. The forest was home of the Black Man and a place to be free. Although the forest is a place to be safe, Dimmesdale became tempted to sin effortlessly. Therefore, the forest and the Black Man aroused man's…
- 628 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The aspects aren’t just with the minister but with everyone around him. This is proven by their reactions to his lectures about secret sin. The point can be made that they’re upset because of the veil, but the argument is that they are really afraid of the darkness of secret sin the minister speaks of. The veil causes terror, not because of its literal appearance, but the truth it represents; secret sin is universal (Alex). All humans are incarcerated in the shadows of their own veil. For this, we need to talk about one of the strongest elements of the meaning behind the…
- 616 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Only when alone does his remorse attack him. He not once accuses Chillingsworth to be the direct source of evil until he is with another person, Hester. His sorrow and regret only hurt him, but if he would have showed his true feelings alongside Hester, yes he would have lost his reputation, but he would also protect the values that he preaches about. He could have taken some of the pressure off of Hester and Pearl. Or even allowed Robert Chillingworth to move on. But, the Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale received what he wished most of all: living life without his own scarlet letter for the public to see. The clergyman destroyed himself and those around him, all for the superficiality of a reputation. It makes one wonder at what lengths and sacrifices are people willing to go to before accepting and confronting their own scarlet…
- 894 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Critically, ambiguity is the purpose of the veil since it causes such a controversy in the town. The contrast between the explicit and the implicit nature of the veil shows with Elizabeth’s comments “there is nothing terrible in this piece of crape” (5) and town reactions. Due to the speculation, Mr. Hooper’s status in the town changed, becoming increasingly separated from the community as the ambiguous nature of the veil gained spread. Then, there is the question of is there any real purpose beyond the effect it had on the village since Mr. Hooper prevented him from ever taking off the…
- 500 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s novel, The Scarlet Letter, Reverend Dimmesdale is struggling with publicizing his sin so that he can seek forgiveness. Dimmesdale and hester have committed adultery, and Pearl is the result. He also struggles because the community keeps referring to him as a holy man because he is a minister of the town, but no one knows the truth except Hester. As the storyline progresses in The Scarlet Letter, Reverend Dimmesdale is a silent sufferer, then a secret, guilt-ridden sinner, and finally a tortured, broken confessor.…
- 939 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Reverend Hooper came out to his congregation, ¨dressed with due clerical neatness¨ (Pg.267). Hoopers appearance suggested that he is a very clean and well dressed person. ¨There was one thing remarkable about his appearance. Hanging down over his face, so low as to be shaken by his breath, Mr.Hooper had on a black veil.¨ (Pg 268). He has on a veil to symbolize his sermon and the a point he is trying to get across.…
- 478 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The minister’s black veil is revealed in Mr. Hooper's remarks to Elizabeth when she wonders why he had chosen to wear that mysterious black veil.Mr. Hooper was the pastor who gives a sermon on the subject of sins which, when he is giving the sermon he wears the black veil, which makes people wonder why he wears that. No one dares to ask him why he wears it , the only person who had the courage to ask was his fiance Elizabeth. He is asked to remove it but he refuses to do so. It was so strange how everywhere he went he always had that mysterious black veil.…
- 1296 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
He will stop at nothing to know the name of the man that slept with Hester. She is afraid to tell him that it is Dimmesdale, but her not telling is not hurting Chillingworth because he believes that "[Dimmesdale] is [his]” (4.23). With this statement he is assuring Hester that no matter what is done, he will know the truth. What he originally wanted to do when he found out about Dimmesdale is not certain in the novel. It was not, however, to torture him mentally for seven plus years out of revenge. Something (more than likely a demonic force) pushed him to do something that was “not indeed precisely what he had laid out for himself to tread” (11.1). No matter what he wanted to do, it ruined his own life along with Dimmesdale’s. Chillingworth even begins to look like a demon at one point in the story. When Dimmesdale and Hester are in the forest talking they see him in the dark. It was not a normal sighting, however, “so vivid was the expression[…]that it seemed still to remain painted on the darkness” (12.34). His face could clearly be seen in the dark of the night. The expression hangs there like a bad omen, signifying that Chillingworth will be back for the two of them. Pearl even calls Chillingworth "the black man" and tries to whisk Hester away from him before he "[catches her] like he [caught] the minister" (10.22).Chillingworth knows the extent of his revenge and how inhumane it is, but does not stop it. It is even said to be “blacker than [Dimmesdale and Hester’s] sin” (17.21). He has no control over what he is doing because an inhumane entity is controlling his body and mind. He went from being a well off scholar to an evil man bent on avenging his name, after being hurt by Dimmesdale and Hester. It would be better for “[Dimmesdale] to have died at once” (4.18) rather than continue to live in a world where a possessed man is out to get him. Death is the only way for…
- 1499 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
People are not always what they seem to be. Roger Chillingworth in The Scarlet Letter shows that everyone sins but some people’s sins are worse than others.The Scarlet Letter shows Chillingworth’s sins throughout the book. One of Hawthorne’s intentions was having Chillingworth as the worst sinner, because he used his herbs to keep Dimmesdale alive-he prolonged Dimmesdale’s torture, he used “black medicine”, and when Dimmesdale stopped taking the herbs, he passed away.…
- 650 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Everyone in their life goes through guilt and regret, and may have things in common with Dimmesdale. In the excerpt The Characters Reveal the Story’s Meaning from Hawthorne: A Critical Study by Hyatt H. Waggoner, he states “He first descends from his original position as the saintly guide and inspiration of the novel as very nearly the worst of the sinners in his hypocrisy and cowardice.” (Waggoner 74). Readers can learn from Dimmesdale in many ways. From reading the novel, they can see how much damage regret and guilt causes. In The Scarlet Letter, Hawthorne states the moral of the story, “Be true! Be true! Be true! Show freely to the world, if not your worst, yet some trait whereby the worst may be inferred!” (Hawthorne 286). This quote tells you to be true to yourself and be you. Dimmesdale is a perfect example of this, because he wasn’t true to himself and ended up paying a huge price for his guilt. Everyone knows that lying is a sin, and can have major consequences. Even if you tell your secret, you can still feel guilt after the fact. Dimmesdale is a very relatable character, and readers can understand him the most, as well as learn from him throughout the…
- 719 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
During the conversation between Hester and the physician, Chillingworth is aware of his continuing torture of Dimmesdale when he says “[Dimmesdale] has been conscious of me. He has felt an influence dwelling always upon him like a curse” (Hawthorne 155). This proves that he enjoys his obsession with the minister. He continues to cold-heartedly torment the frailing Dimmesdale. On the night that Chillingworth sees Dimmesdale’s chest, Chillingworth has a moment of “ecstasy” during which he understands “how Satan comports himself when a precious human soul is lost to heaven” (Hawthorne 126). Chillingworth begins to develop an understanding of the way the devil feels when he successfully tortures his victims in hell. His ability to empathize with Satan explains why Hester and the rest of the town views him as a psychopath. Throughout this section of the book, the ex-husband who was wronged now embodies…
- 986 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
During the early settlement of New England, there was a period where a strict society-based religious group, called the Puritans, dictated law. In this religion, they followed extremely harsh laws for punishment such as sinning, as found in The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne. In his novel, Hawthorne uses the symbolism of Dimmesdale, the leech, and the punishment scaffold to contribute to his overall theme of guilt.…
- 890 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Dimmesdale knew how the community saw him and could not face the truth, so he hid it. Dimmesdale lived two different lives, one was the religious face that everyone loved and looked up too. On the other hand, when he was alone all he did was beat himself up mentally and physically. Soon the guilt made Dimmesdale weaker and weaker and he wanted to tell the truth, and tried multiple times, but he never found the courage. He allowed the guilt of lying and manipulating the people to eventually kill him all because he couldn’t deal with what the community might think.…
- 460 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays