Preview

Comparing The Amish World And The Modern World

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
969 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing The Amish World And The Modern World
In the assignment that I am going to explore “A world of Difference” and show connections between the four texts I have selected they are: Witness by Peter Weir (Film), Meg Merrilies by John Keats (Poem), The Bath by Janet Frame (S/S) and What I ever wanted by Vikki Wakefield (Novel). This texts/film has similarities or connections through characters that are involved in them are: Rachael (Film), Meg (Poem)? Unnamed (s/s) and Jemima (Novel). Through them involved the way he/she live, background (Culture) and appearance.
“Different cultures and people have their own way of living.”
In the film “Witness” directed by Peter Weir is an interesting genre that shares two different worlds. “The Amish world and the Modern world.” It shares the way
…show more content…
Her husband passed away and she is known as a Widow. She has a prosperous home, a family but without electricity and showers. Her appearance is according to her background, culture protocol of what she wears from the Modern days 1982. In her culture, the frames of her life they have never seen violence, no guns and weapon are allowed, as well no music, no dancing. They cannot drink alcohol just lemonade juice. They are not allowed to touch a man except your husband but most of all fighting is not accepted. For transportation carts and horses are what they use, and that is the main differences between the Amish world and the Modern world. Modern world uses cars, Trains, Buses, Motorcycles for transport, and violence (fighting, killers etc.) is everywhere and live a city busy life. Rachael’s daily routines have been planned and she does her part as an Amish woman. I truly think that Peter Weir (The Director) did a really good job that he links the saying and expressions together within the characters actions that Rachael could be able to pass on the message through film by using two different languages English and Germany. This shows the relationship between Rachael, her family and her culture with values Love, Family and Safety.
In the poem “Meg Merrilies” by John Keats talks about an elderly lady who is a gypsy. This shares different world people live in and how they control their lives. It also
…show more content…
She has no family but nature. She lives out of doors on the moors of Scotland in a wide world and in a wide nature. Her brothers were the “craggy hills, and her sisters larchen trees” (Found in Poem). Her bath was the river, and she had no food, “an old red cloak” she wore that the weather was cold. “A chip hat she had on” and she would at least she would stare at the moon when there is nothing to do. She made her garlanding (flowers etc.), plaited mats and gave them to cottagers she met she met along the bush. She wove and she would sing (Stanza 5). She does not talk to anyone but her book is a church-yard tomb. Her environment is unclean because she sleeps under trees in a brown heath turf bed that is not comfortable and a place where people hardly seen very emotional and inspiring that helped me to understand the main fact of the poem and I felt mournful about the life that others out there is living. Her world is her life of challenge, she has No rule, No expectations but lived as she did

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The poem discusses the funeral of a woman and how she is presented in her funeral as someone people would be more likely to romanticize than what she actually was, perhaps out of a misguided sign of respect. The other more hidden meaning behind the poem is the author's reaction to the women herself and how she is portrayed in almost a spiteful, angry way because of his anger over her wasting her life in gray dullness.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem follows the narrator’s internal monologue as he revisits a place of nostalgia that ignited his love of nature. His fears that the picturesque scene of his childhood has been idealized are quieted as he sees the place for the first time in five years, falling in love with the environment all over again. He even credits nature as “The anchor of my purest thoughts, the nurse,/The guide, the guardian of my heart, and soul/Of all my moral being” (Wordsworth LL. 109-111). His ecological thinking recharges his soul and makes him feel joyful about life once again. Nature also connects the narrator to his sister, who he sees himself in because of their love of the countryside. He acknowledges his sister the first time in the poem as his “dear, dear Friend; and in thy voice I catch/The language of my former heart, and read/My former pleasures in the shooting lights/Of thy wild eyes” (Wordsworth LL.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children in school are well behavior and know that they should always do as they are told by the teacher. The Amish culture teaches children and adults that they should be kind, nonaggressive, and respectful to others. The Amish do not receive money from the government, they are not allowed to participate in war, they don’t believe in material things, and they don’t believe in living in the city. The Amish do not use or have any electronics. They believe that you should feel blessed for what God gives you in life. They speak in a version of Pennsylvania Dutch. The Amish do not drive cars; their means of transportation is horse and buggy. In many people’s eyes, the Amish are strange and very different. As English men and women, we do not understand this way of life. We are used to and embrace all the modern conveniences. In the Amish culture, this simple way of life is normal and what they believe in. I think that this source is one of the best one I found on Amish culture for a research paper. It goes into great detail about what how the Amish live and what their value system is.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Amish is a group of traditionalist Christians that rely on simple living, plain dress and refuse to adapt to modern technology. The history of the Amish started in Switzerland in 1693 led by Jakob Amman. Today majority of the traditional descendants of the Amish live in Pennsylvania and Ohio.…

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem begins with the narrator telling herself, “A few more steps, old feet.” (line 1). The old feet she refers to are the ancestor’s feet, that appear to be old and worn out from the rigorous journey they take. The speaker then goes on to say, “In pale tea I’ll see / me with her, tasting wild grapes” (lines 4-5). This shows her reminder of her ancestors in nature. The pale tea is the symbol of the clean, clear simplicity of nature and when the speaker simplifies herself, to the bare nothingness of nature it reveals to her, her ancestors. Then in the following lines, “at dawn, tasting dew / on tender leaves, another year.” (lines 6-7). The dawn represents a new day, a new start where she can again acknowledge her heritage. After, the speaker says, “her hands still guiding me, / at sunset grinding seeds” (lines 11-12). These hands guiding the speaker, are her ancestors leading her through their stories and nature around…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the main things you see some if not all is smoking cigarettes, even the girls while they are still dressed in their Amish cloth. “Cultural group membership is acquired though the guidance of primary caretaker and peer association during out formative years” Toomey and Chung p. 93. This time is part of a bigger problem for the Amish sect as it brings about a mind set of total independence on the part of their youth; something many, especially boys, have difficulty handling appropriately at this young age. In addition, it is viewed by some as "a casual look the other way time" on the part of the Amish parents and other adults. It can be acknowledged that some Amish parents do relax their standards some when their offspring turn 16 and some permit exploration to an extent. However, it is hard to believe any Amish parent would ever tell their 16 year old to go out and experience the "world" as one is led to believe by this documentary.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Primarily, This dramatic thriller exposes the contrasting worlds of modern American "English" society with the traditional and nostalgic existence of the Pennsylvanian Amish community. However, as the viewer is taken on the intended emotional journey a number of other themes are also exposed and deserve consideration.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Witness essay 2012 hsc

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The 1985 film ‘witness’ directed by Peter weir is a crime/drama that develops the theme of conflict though individual power on a social, cultural and personal level. These areas of power are highlighted through the use of film techniques such as; camera shots, camera angles, lighting and costume. The film outlines the juxtaposition between mainstream American society and the Amish community in regional Pennsylvania, the theme of power between Book and his world precisely emphasize this juxtaposition. The competent American society is seen as a violent and arrogant group of people, whereas the Amish community is seen as the defenceless peaceful, religious group of people.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example the first stanza, lines 1 through 5, tell of her first heartbreak from her husband. the caesura puts expression of sadness,sorrow, and grief. As well, in the fifth line states right out “my exile”.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Sociology Amish society

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Amish society is very different from American society. Both societies have different beliefs and value very different things. The Amish reject modern advances, while the rest of America is constantly striving for the latest technology. The Amish believe in humility and religion above most everything else in life. They have very simple lives and believe in surviving with just the necessities. They are very community and family oriented. Americans put more value on money, material possessions, becoming “successful,” and having fun. Most Americans are independent and fend for themselves, while the Amish work together as a community and are very close.…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The composer conveys a strong feeling of grief and pain in the poem. The composer creates an empathy towards the widower, by expressing just how lonely he feels after his wife had died, and he had to stay in the place that they had shared together. Through the use of multiple metaphors, "The Christmas paddocks aching in the heat/The windless trees, the nettles in the yard" , the composer builds a path into how the widower is 'aching' after the grief of losing his wife. 'windless trees' implies the feeling of death, as the trees have no leaves, whilst 'nettles' evokes the pain and burning he is feeling at this difficult time. The reader realises that this might be a difficult time for the widower, and empathises to attempt to feel what he feels.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mod B

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A young Amish boy being a sole witness to a murder, policeman John Book goes into hiding in an Amish community to protect the boy until trial. Whilst hiding, he develops an understanding of the Amish culture and forms a relationship with the community.…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    compare and contrast

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Select three literary works that you have read in class, and that you think are connected in at least one way through convention or device. Consider the following: theme, genre, literary technique, culture, use of literary devices such as symbolism, and how diction is used to suggest culture, class, ethnicity, historical period, or age. Use the three works you have selected to complete the Literature Compare and contrast table.…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Devil's Playground

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages

    reversal, and religions of humility; in which all aid to analyze the Amish culture in the film…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Last Thursday, the ELI took all the students to Amish country. We all went by bus. We went to an Amish house where we met Mike. Mike made a presentation about Amish life. He showed their clothes. He told us that the Amish came from Germany. He told us that the Amish want to be separate from society. They don't have electricity, so they use lanterns, also they don't have cars they use buggies. I learned many things from the presentation. Firstly, the Amish are peaceful people. They don't involve themselves selves in wars and fights, secondly, their religion is Christianity. They take the rules of the Bible literally. For example, in the Bible it says men don't shave their beards so they don't shave their beards. Thirdly, the Amish can date, but their way of dating has to be disciplinal. For example, when they date, they don't touch each other until they get married. Fourthly, Amish's lifestyle is about farming and doing chores. They work all week except on Sunday. Fifthly, Amish like to have a large family. When they get married, they keep having children until they pass away. Lastly, they don't have churches. Their idea about church is to worship God in someone's house. Every Sunday, Amish gather in someone's house and they sing songs and eat supper and also worship God. After Mike finished his presentation. We went to an elderly woman's house. She had a store where she sells bakeries and cheese. As soon as I got out of the bus a dog was running toward me so I ran scarily. While I was running I felled down and I hurt my neck. The elderly woman yelled to the dog and he left me. After that, we went to an Amish's family. They made dinner for us. They were very nice people. The food was delicious but unfortunately I didn't enjoy it, because I was in so much pain and I wasn't in the mood. After we had dinner, we all thanked the family and appreciated them. Before we got in the bus we took so many pictures of each other. By the way Amish don't…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays