Preview

Compare And Contrast Plato's Gorgias

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
494 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Plato's Gorgias
In Plato’s Gorgias, two different perspectives are argued on how to obtain happiness. The first perspective, Callicles, who believes an undisciplined life, leads to happiness whereas Socrates argues that self-control is needed to be happy. In this essay I will argue that Socrates is correct that self-discipline is essential for true happiness.
The ultimate end goal in life is to be happy. Happiness by definition is the state of which one is happy. The term is subjective, but most agree “happy” is associated with “good”. Something good can’t be something bad at the same time, yet pleasure is simultaneous with pain. If pleasure can be felt with something else, but good cannot, therefor pleasure doesn’t equal good and can’t be happiness. Since pleasure isn’t what’s good and what’s good is happiness, how can feeding into your vices lead to happiness?
…show more content…
This would contradict the idea that living without limiting your desires brings happiness. I’m happy, up until I realize the consequence it has, then the temporary happiness would disappear.
The cycle would then continue, I would pursue another pleasure and end in the same situation as before. After awhile of living in the moment and going after everything you want, consequences occur. In life, if you live without limiting your desires and feeding into your vices, inner peace can never be achieved because you will never find happiness in the end.
However, how realistic is it to live a life with self-control? Humans aren’t perfect creatures, and temptation is always present. Will feeding an appetite every once in a while compromise happiness? We aren’t perfect humans; living with complete self-discipline is too high of a standard to attain. It’s almost more reasonable to believe a happy, realistic life is to only feed appetites in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Buddha once vowed that “if a man can control his mind he can find the way to Enlightenment, and all wisdom and virtue will naturally come to him.” This quote correlates to Plato’s works written shortly after the Peloponnesian War (431 BC- -404 BC) between Athens and Sparta, arising from Sparta’s fear of Athens’s increasing power and knowledge. This relates to the Socratic dialogues The Gorgias and The Republic illustrating significance of temperance towards pursue of the good and explicates the deceitfulness of imitative poetry through Socrates. Polus, the adversary of The Gorgias’s second phase, maintains that to suffer injustice is worse than to commit injustice, something that Socrates later disproves. The third and final phase of The Gorgias,…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates beforehand disproving Gorgias and Polus in The Gorgias, now takes on a rival who he deems qualified enough: Callicles. Here, they discuss the value of temperance and the indulgence of pleasures. Callicles remarks to Socrates, “In the rightly-developed man the passions ought not to be controlled, but that we should let them grow to the upmost and somehow or other satisfy them, and that that is virtue” (Plato 74). Callicles says that to allow growth and indulge in your desires is real virtue. A man who is slave of his own restraint cannot be happy. According to him, satisfying longings is natural and even noble, but because the weaker cannot attain this and are ashamed of their own weakness, they reprimand intemperance and instead praise…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Plato’s Gorgias, Socrates and a fellow interlocutor, Callicles of Acharnae, fervently discuss the relationship between pleasure and good. It is in this philosophical debate that Callicles states a good life as one that consists of having as much unrestricted pleasure as possible; therefore, implying that the pleasant and the good are identical. However, Socrates contends otherwise, and attempts to convince Callicles of the error in his ways by proving that good is ultimately not the same as pleasure. Socrates does so by employing two key arguments that render Callicles case unsupported and fallacious.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many reasons people are almost never satisfied with what they have or what they intend to have. It seems to be a natural characteristic that our society has adopted. You might wonder and question yourself if that it actually true? If you think about it you would clearly be able to realize that we as humans have all practiced this acts and made it manipulate our life. As you think about what I just said you are most likely to realize that this actions can be expanded too. People’s self-implications make them believe that they are always right which can lead to their tendency to defeat or not believing expert’s advices. With all of that being said, we can now easily relate to Kent Sepkowitz, the…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Buddha’s teachings enforce that allowing oneself to experience extremes throughout life is to allow suffering and the avoidance of Nirvana. Both hedonism (or “the indulgence in the sense pleasures”) and self mortification are considered “painful and unprofitable”, though in different ways. Thus, the Buddha teaches the middle path, the Cessation of Suffering. The importance of absence from worldly attachments, from extremes, from tangibility is underlined by its reward: Nirvana, a sweet, peaceful emptiness. This text, over and over, associates the absence, the cessation, the lack, and the emptiness with desirability. Meanwhile, attachment, ordinariness, greed and hedonism are to be avoided. This is all to achieve, again, a lack of existence, to refrain from “re-becoming” in the cycle of…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Plato’s writings on happiness are seen as a representation of Socrate’s view since Plato was his student, and presents his writings on happiness in three dialogues, namely Euthydemus, The Symposium and The Republic. As to necessary conditions for happiness in the Euthydemus, he argues first that happiness is what everybody desires; it is the end or goal of all our activities, unconditional good; secondly, he says that happiness does not depend on external things but rather how those things are used. For instance, one cannot claim that money brings happiness, but rather how money is used is what determines happiness. An ignorant person will waste away the money and end up worse than before, but a wise person will use the money well for his own good, and the same applies to external things, such as looks or even…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine a set of binoculars; with two small peep holes for your eyes to see through and two larger lenses which magnify whatever it is that one may be looking at. Now there are two types of people in the world, one who looks through the small lenses and views the bigger picture, and one who takes a look through the bigger lenses to see a more narrowed finding. Those who see the bigger picture will have a different perspective than those who choose to look at the narrow view as will their beliefs. For when one looks through the narrow view, their outlook on life will be made that whatever it is they try to attain, it will appear further than it truly is and will never be happy. Where as the one who views the bigger picture will see what is realistic and find their peace easier.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyone Wants an Extravagant Lifestyle: Is Your Soul worth Losing to the Seven Deadly Sins…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Louis P. Pojman's Analysis

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Aristotle was Plato’s prize pupil who discussed the types of moments where moral correctness may be applied to certain events, nature of virtues involved in the sound morality of humans as well as the ways to achieve happiness in one’s life. The overall question that Aristotle tends to ask himself and try to answer is the question that pertains to human character and personality, what do we as humans need to do, to be considered as a good person. Aristotle explained that every activity has a final cause and purpose at which it aims to achieve and he argued that since there is not an infinite amount of goods, there has to be one type of good that is the highest and most important which humans strive towards. He continues to describe this ultimate good and decided that it could be called happiness, however the only puzzling question left is, what is happiness? Due to its existence in so many forms it is tough to describe happiness as one true thing…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    People do get caught up in the pleasure that they are getting because the pleasure makes them happy. They start to get way into their pleasure that they are receiving and they forget about everything around them. As mentioned in the text, "But we also choose them for the sake of happiness, supporting that through the we shall be happy" (Aristotle, 8). We all want to be happy in some way, shape or form so we will do whatever it takes to be happy. It doesn't matter if it's by searching into the world to find that pleasure, eating for pleasure or creating a way to get pleased. In the text, “Let us grant that we must wait to see the end, and must then count someone blessed” (Aristotle, 13). When you have to try hard to stay happy, the happiness doesn't stay. As said in the text, "For we suppose happiness is enduring and definitely not prone to fluctuate, but the same person’s fortunes often turn to and fro” (Aristotle,…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The thing about bad habits is that we develop them because the activities are advantageous, pleasant, or rewarding in some way. My bad habit was rewarding in the fact that I was losing weight, and to reap continuous rewards, one must continue performing the same action that led to the reward the first time. This is how we as humans learn all of our behaviors; however, mine in particular led to something so awful. I was in the hospital for months being fed through tubes, something I would not wish upon my worst enemy. Anorexia nervosa is a serious, and in my case, a life-threatening eating disorder that is characterized by inadequate food intake leading to a weight that is clearly too low. My obsession with controlling my eating and body consumed me and sent me spiraling into depression, ruining friendships and ending…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Socrates Good Life

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages

    What makes a person’s life good? Is it virtue? Pleasure? Power? In Plato’s Gorgias, though didn’t end up with a mutual agreement, Socrates and Callacles fight each other’s views and quarrel to come to a conclusion of the meaning of a good life.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why do I say that? I say that because everyone is in charge of their own life, and no one can tell you what to do. Smoking cigarettes for example, if the person chooses to smoke cigarettes it’s his or her choice. Yes, it’s a bad habit but if you choose to do it who can stop you. That brings me to this conclusion about breaking habits. Yes, changing your routine to a habit will help you as long as you get the same reward but if you’re not motivated to do so how can you ever change a habit. Anyone can say they are going to quit smoking cigarettes but if they are not mentally ready how can they? Being motivated and mentally strong are the only two ways I see that can really help you change or lose a…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    . In “the sources of happiness” his holiness the Dalai Lama and Howard Cutler said “true happiness relates more to the mind and heart. Happiness that depends on mainly on physical pleasure is unstable, one day it’s there , the next day it may not” (30). Now as that clearly states, pleasure is something that can bring you temporary happiness but it only last for a certain time and it may not always be there, unlike happiness, once you reach that point in your life it will always be there, well that might not always be the case because you never know what the future is holding for us, but for now that feeling of joy you have is something alot wish to…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These are just some of the reasons humans can’t possibly form and keep a Utopian society. We are not perfect in any way at all. We can’t handle harsh diets, multiple movements, and dealing with people in perfect ways. This falls back into people being self-indulgent. Maybe one day people can create a “perfect society,” But not anytime…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays