Preview

Compare And Contrast Mcmurphy And Mr Keating

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
214 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Mcmurphy And Mr Keating
McMurphy and Mr Keating both receive consequences from rebelling against conformity with McMurphy receiving a lobotomy and ultimately losing his life, and Mr Keating losing his much loved job. Both are the face of rebellion against conformity. Therefore, creating such negative endings for them gives the audience the idea that freedom can be dangerous. Also, Billy and Neil both show the devastating cost of freedom when they take their own lives. Billy commits suicide after he is pushed to break the conservative ways that have dictated his life. Although he temporarily loses his stutter – a sign he is confident, it begins to reappear as he realises the consequences of his actions. He pleads with the big nurse and can hardly say a full sentence,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    I made a promise to the supervisor applicants that I would get back to them by the end of the week regarding the supervisor position.…

    • 85 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    John Colter and Tom Murphy were very different but still they had a few of the same things. One similar thing that was between their backpacks was that they had food. Tom Murphy brought his food while either the people he was traveling with or he killed animals, John Colter had food. Tom Murphy had a large winter coat and mittens with him. He also had an emergency medical kit and his pack weighed 70 to 80 pounds but John Colter had a gun and some ammunition in his pack and his only weighed 30 pounds.…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Effective listening involves more than just hearing what other people are saying. Listening errors occur and usually result in misunderstandings, missed business opportunities, premature judgments, and wasted time and money. To get the full meaning of what someone says requires energy and discipline, both of which contribute to what is known as active listening. In the article "Learn to listen, and you'll learn to sell," David Connolly explains that, "the best agents in the insurance industry talk only 20% of the time during an interview with a new prospect, and that 20% is in the form of questions." David Connolly is an independent agent, owner of Splinter Group Consulting, and executive vice president of the Cabinetmaker's Association. David…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    John McCarthy and Mark Wolfson from the University of Minnesota collected data emphasizing on three distinct features that facilitated the mobilization of resources. These three features are strategy, agency, and organizational structure. Agency is related to the mobilization of volunteer labor and membership. Here McCarthy and Wolfson use this term to describe it as “the sheer amount of effort activists invest in collective action rather than its caliber” (McCarthy and Wolfson p. 1071). Through this concept of agency, they expected the more the organizations put their effort in their movement, the more the resources are mobilized. Strategy is related with the mobilization of membership based on the emphasis on victim services. It has been viewed by previous scholars as the most important feature in the success of the organizations’ movement against drunk driving.…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Angus MacQueen is a producer and director, for People's Century from 1900-1999, Gulag in 2000, and Drug Lord: The Legend of Shorty in 2014. During 2006 through 2008 Angus Macqueen was Head of Documentaries at Channel 4 Television in London, he was also director in the Spotlight at the Chicago International Documentary Festival, in 2004. His award was the News & Documentary Emmy Award for Outstanding Continuing Coverage of a News Story – Long Form and had three nominations which include British Academy Television Award for Best Factual Series, British Academy Television Award for Best Single Documentary, and British Academy Television Huw Wheldon Award For The Best Arts Programme or Series. Angus Macqueen has a correlation to why it took…

    • 153 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    unorthodox ways. They emerged themselves into clean and new slates, a sense of solitude. As…

    • 159 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Harry Harlow and Mary Ainsworth shared a common interest in attachment. Although their work is different and how they went about doing their experiments there were similarities between the pair as both of them did studies to see how attachment presented itself in different individuals.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Harper Lee’s novel To Kill a Mockingbird, seven year old Charles Baker Harris, also known as Dill, is shipped from Meridian, Mississippi to Maycomb, Alabama to stay with his aunt, Miss Rachel. His recently-divorced mom and his step-dad pay little attention to him; they buy him toys to play with in his room, so not to bother them, and they send him off to Maycomb during the summer. In J.D. Salinger’s coming of age story, The Catcher in the Rye, protagonist Holden Caulfield comes from a very wealthy Manhattan family that sends him to different boarding schools, no matter how many times he flunks out. There are numerous similarities between Dill and Holden, namely the hardships they each face, including a great loss of innocence.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holden Caulfield is a very sophisticated character created by J.D. Salinger, not comparable to many characters in other novels. One character he relates strongly with is Phoebe Caulfield. As Holden superior in age to Phoebe, she is clearly the more mature person in state of mind. Phoebe tries to be the best that she can be in school, achieving A’s on almost everything she does, while Holden doesn’t apply himself in anything but English class. One thing that they have in common is the knowledge to have a good conversation, something that most people don’t have. With their many differences, Holden still admires Phoebe and wishes to talk to her whenever he can, because she is about the only person that is willing to talk to a crazy person.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    BEfore McMurphy arrived, the patients believed in everything Big Nurse said and continued to follow the rules without hesitation. However, as McMurphy starts to mock the rules and give the patients opportunities to speak up, they become me vocal, and power starts to shift within the ward. In the beginning of the text, everything is controlled by Big Nurse, as said in the text when she says, “Of course, you may take the suggestion up with the rest of the staff at some time, but I'm afraid everyone's feelings will correspond with mine” (98), implying that her word is final. At this time, McMurphy is asking politely to watch the baseball game, and Big Nurse uses her power to decline without hearing his reasoning.When they throw a party in the ward, however, without any supervision, Big Nurse is nowhere to be found. All the patients come together and decide to get drunk, invite a prostitute, and have fun. Without regard to the rules, Chief starts to realize that as he partied, “ it came to me as a kind of sudden surprise that I was drunk, actually drunk, glowing and grinning and staggering drunk for the first time since the Army, drunk along with half a dozen other guys and a couple of girls—right on the Big Nurse's ward!” (311). This is the moment when the patients finally completely let loose and have fun. This is important because even though McMurphy plans everything, the patients don't back out like usual and finally let loose. By the end of the text, the power shift from the ward to the patients becomes more…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nurse Ratched Essay

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “She’s too big to be beaten… She’s lost a little battle today, but it’s a minor battle in a big war that she’s been winning and that she’ll go on winning” (96). Once again, the word ‘big’ is used in a metaphorical sense to encompass the extent of Nurse Ratched's power. Since she has already achieved such a great amount of jurisdiction, the Nurse is primarily motivated to maintain what she already possesses. In order to do so, she has to defeat McMurphy. After all of the power struggles between the two, Nurse Ratched eventually comes out on top. Once she has finally had enough of their games, the Nurse uses her authority and sends McMurphy away. After McMurphy has been gone three weeks, she make her “last play” (274). When he returns, it is obvious what has occurred. The other patients find him lying in a gurney labeled, “MCMURPHY, RANDLE P. POSTOPERATIVE,” and below that is written, “LOBOTOMY” (274). She had sent him off to be lobotomized, which left him brain dead. His body is still alive and breathing, yet he no longer poses a threat to the Nurse and her…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    McMurphy begins his quest of revolution harshly, mocking patients’ flaws and disabilities in order for them to recognize individuality. Harding’s ashamement of his long, white, and dainty hands represent his lack of power. When McMurphy tries to get everyone to vote to convince Nurse Ratched to change their TV time, McMurphy attempts to mock Harding’s hands. McMurphy chuckles at Harding when he doesn’t raise his hand, “Harding, what’s wrong with…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyone wants to be likeable and relatable in today's society. Especially people in high school and people in their teenage years. Most people, want to fit in and follow society to do so. Holden and Charlie both want to be likeable and relatable, but both have a different way of trying to do so. Holden and Charlie are different in many ways when it comes to be likeable and relatable. Any high school teenager would find Charlie as a likeable character, because of what exactly he goes through in the book which is what most teenagers can go through. Holden, on the other hand is unlike Charlie in the way he wants to fit in. He doesn’t follow society and goes against it and does his own things which, most people can not relate to which makes them not like the character of Holden. Charlie being more relatable makes him more likeable because everyone understands Charlie’s problem, and…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After a great night, everyone falls asleep, and in the morning, the day-staff came before anyone can wake up in time. After searching for Billy Bibbit, and finding him unashamed of his actions the previous night, the Nurse gives him a guilt trip, threatening to tell his mother, and then locking him in the ward's doctor's room. Billy commits suicide, and the Nurse tries to blame it on McMurphy's lack of respect for authority. Realising that any chances of surviving are ruined, and that his battle with authority is now at it's final stage, McMurphy sacrifices himself (and consequently his mental-independence) by attacking Nurse Ratched, exposing her as a vulnerable woman, and destroying any sense of authority and control she had left over the patients. This is the final action between two desperate factions: the authority and the autonomy. The showdown ends with McMurphy being captured, but because the other patients see the nurse as a woman, and not as the dominant Nurse, she can never have the same control over them as she had previously…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mcmurphy

    • 1474 Words
    • 4 Pages

    McMurphy is contemptuous towards Nurse Ratched, as he doesn't care that she is in charge of the ward. She can't control him like she can the other patients. He is a rebel and makes it is duty to get under her skin and strip her power right from underneath her. In fact, just a few days after McMurphy's arrival, he makes a bet with the other patients. He says, '"Any of you sharpies here willing to take my five bucks that says I can get the best of that woman - without her getting the best of me?"(73) This is the trait that sets McMurphy apart as a leader and a rallier. The patients look up to his bravery and rebellion and he brings them together, creating a strength like never before. McMurphy's plan to reveal Nurse Ratched's feminism is what builds the strength within the group. McMurphy realizes that if he exposes Nurse Ratched's gender to the patients at the ward, she will become evidently powerless in their new eyes. McMurphy approaches this plan by pointing out her female assets in front of the men. Bromden explains that Nurse Ratched "would reprimand him without heat at all, and he would stand and listen till she was finished and then destroy her whole effect by asking something like did she wear a B cup, he wondered, or a C cup, or any cup at all?"(177) The use of the word destroy shows the huge effect that McMurphy made with comments…

    • 1474 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays