Preview

Compare and Contrast Jack and Simon from Lord of the Flies

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
587 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast Jack and Simon from Lord of the Flies
“Lord of the Flies” by William Golding is a savage tale of a group of boys who survived a plane crash and became stranded on a mysterious island. At first there is hope of a rescue and there is a sense of order amongst the boys, but as as time goes on the boys become uncivilized and chaos overtakes them as well as the fear of an awful Beast that lives on the island. One of the themes in the book is based on moral principles in the sense of good and evil in man. Two characters that contribute to this moral or Biblical theme are Simon who resembles Jesus and Jack, being the most savage and violent of the boys, who favors the devil. On the outside you may not be able to detect who was the kind or who was the mean person. Both boys were described similarly because living on the island had affected them in the same way. Simon is described as having hair that was a coarse mop of black hair hanging down, dark skinned, barefoot, and wearing only the remains of shorts. Jack is described as having long hair, skin that was dark with a mess of freckles, barefoot and dirty. Besides them both not paying much attention to their physical appearance the similarities stop there. In reality, one is cruel and savage and the other is kind and civilized. Simon cares for and tends to the others as if they were family, while Jack is selfish and only cares about his own well being and is fixated on killing as many pigs as he possibly can. The more cruel Jack becomes, the more control he takes over the group and they begin to follow his lead and behave violently. Simon concentrates on what needs to be done to get rescued and Jack would be content to live on the island forever as a savage. Just like Jesus understood the moral truth, Simon realizes that the Beast is not an animal, but rather the savagery that man is capable of. He tries to reveal this to them, and just as Jesus was crucified for the truth, the group beats Simon to death. The way that Simon and Jack

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Jack was at first a nice child, but after living on the island for so long turned into a savage. Jack took advantage of everyone being young and tried to take control over everyone by becoming somewhat a dictator. Jack would soon lead all of the children into savagery. Jack teaches the children how to jab with a spear using Robert as an example. This foul example leads the tribe into killing Simon without even noticing because their mindset is on killing and blood.…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For the boys on the island their fear controls them more than they control it, Golding extends Simon's death on page 154 to convey that all the boys are fearful of the beastie and where too caught up in the pig dance and started attacking Simon when he came barreling into the horseshoe. A second example is when Ralph calls Jack “a beast and a swine and a bloody,…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite almost all of the characters going through transitions due to the changed circumstances, Golding depicts Jack as the most explicit figure. “Jack and Ralph smiled at each other…The point tore the skin and flesh over Ralph’s ribs”. Initially, when Jack first shows up on the island, we realize that he is a leader of a choir, marching in military style. Although this foreshadows Jack’s totalitarianism and dictatorship, it still shows the typical characteristics of a typical teenage boy, wanting to take on leadership roles and smiling whenever possible. However, as Jack becomes obsessed with hunting pigs and eventually putting on the mask, he turns savage and gruesome beyond return. The fact that he uses a spear to attack Ralph immediately after Piggy’s brutal death shows Jack has completely lost his rationality and sense of human being.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie, “Lord of the Flies”, portrays how man is naturally good, but can be persuaded in negative ways by someone bad. Jack’s cold, brutish behavior largely impacted all the others. From the beginning of the movie, Jack’s insensitive actions foreshadowed his behavior for the rest of the movie, such as when Simon fainted, and Jack said that he is fine and acted like it didn’t matter. Throughout the film, the other boys on the island were consistently being influenced by Jack’s uncompassionate characteristics. Although Ralph was voted as the captain for the whole group, most of the boys ended up being on Jack’s side and followed his bad habits. Even though Piggy was on Ralph’s side, he was also influenced by Jack. One night, Simon was killed because the boy’s because they thought that he was the beast. When the boy’s all found out, Piggy didn’t believe that what they did was murder, when it really was. In the end of the movie, after Ralph fought with Jack about getting Piggy’s glasses back because they were stolen, one of Jack’s members rolled a boulder and it fell on Piggy, leading to his tragic death.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Lord of the Flies by William Golding, Golding emphasizes the conflict between two opposite impulses that are inside every one of us: whether to follow the rules and be in order, or to go into violence and turn into savages. Golding expresses this by using the protagonist and antagonist of the story, Ralph and Jack.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    William Golding’s novel Lord of the Flies is the story of a group of English school boys who crashed-landed on a deserted island and have to survive on their own. There are many characters who change throughout the course of the story, for example, characters like Simon and Piggy continued to gain confidence throughout the novel. Although all the boys go through character changes as a result of being taken away from the strict structure of English society, the character of Jack changes most through the course of the novel from the leader of the choir to a somewhat savage leader.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The only boy on the island that understands the truth about humans, tries to save them from their self-destruction. Throughout the book, Simon represents a Jesus-like figure. He helped Ralph with the shelters, handed ʻlittlunsʼ food and was very perceptive about the true meanings of the world. When the boys believed in the beast, he was the only one who knew the truth, ʻmaybe there is no beast . . . maybe itʼs only usʼ (Golding pg 111). Simonʼs death represents the idea that goodness is weaker than evil. The murder of Simon is the point of no return for civilisation on the island and shows that even decent people like Ralph and Piggy are capable of committing heinous crimes. His death unlike Jesus did not lead them to salvation but lead them to destruction and a deeper inner evil. After Simons death, Jack the leader of his tribe, became merciless and cruel. Jack often used other characters fears to control the people on the island. ʻMy hunters will protect you from the beastʼ (Golding pg 185). Jack is the first of the boys to succumb to his inner evil and become a savage. This is ironic because at the beginning of the novel he says, ʻWeʼve got to have rules and obey them. After all, weʼre not savages. Weʼre English.ʼ (Golding pg 55). He uses the fear and evil within all the characters to force them to follow under his dictatorship. Throughout the book Jack has a crazy obsession with hunting, the more times he kills the less civilised he would become. Jack is the one responsible for sending the boys on the island into this deep dark evil that they cannot seem to escape from. As Jack becomes more evil as the book progresses, Golding makes him the representation of the evil in every man. Lord of the Flies is a deep and meaningful novel, with a pessimistic view on human life. Golding uses the characters for his novel, the setting of the island and the symbolism throughout the book to show the potential for destruction and chaos in the world. The idea that evil is…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the course of William Golding’s Lord of the Flies, the characters of the boys changes drastically. In the beginning, the boys are very disorganized and overwhelmed. Overtime, that disorder is changed into the organization of two separate groups of boys that have completely different ideas of how to run the island. This causes tension and hatred between the boys. In the scene of Simon’s death, Golding uses leery imagery, distinctive and violent diction, and dark figurative language to show the boys’ dynamic transformation from lost and naive school boys to savage and ruthless beasts.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Simon was constantly made fun of, and had a reputation as “batty” and weird. He was different from the other boys liked being by himself. Whenever he tried to speak in front of the other boys, they made fun of him and “the laughter beat him cruelly and he shrank away defenceless to his seat” (Golding 89). Simon was an independent boy who usually sat by himself in the bower. He hardly tried to fit in with the others. Simon also suffered from epilepsy which gave the boys more reasons to make fun of him. The other boys took advantage of the fact that Simon is different and weak compared to the other boys on the island. Simon’s vulnerability made it easier for the others to make fun of him because they knew he wasn’t violent and would try to fight back. It brought out the rotten beasts within them. Feeling superior to someone can make a person feel like they can do anything they like towards others. It can lead to ill-treatment and…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Foreshadowing In Piggy

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He is disrespected and ignored by the other boys, even though he is one of the most wise, logical, and intellectual boys on the island. When Jack proves his savagery and how oppressive he can be by killing the sow and placing its head on a stick, Simon wants to prove that the beast does not exist, so he sets off to prove that the beast is nothing. In his efforts of coming back and telling the group that there is no beast, he is mistaken as the beast and brutally killed. “Kill the beast! Cut his throat! Spill his blood!”(152) At this point the boys are rapidly losing their…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the “normal” boys stranded on the island quickly becomes evil. Jack learns to kill when first arriving on the island he starts with pigs and ends with humans. “I was choosing a place” “I was just waiting for a moment to decide where to stab it.” On page 31 Jack, Ralph, and Simon go out to explore the island. While exploring they come across a trapped pig, Jack attempts to kill the…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The classic novel, Lord of the flies, by William Golding, follows a group of boys stranded on an island with a lack of any adult supervision. Throughout the story, the boys progressively change as the island takes its toll. They transform from innocent children to primitive savages. Jack was one of these boys, originally the head of the choir who takes the role of the “hunter” on the island. Golding thus uses Jack’s violent and aggressive mannerisms to show how fear distorts reality and enables the abuse of power.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The English author William Golding was a former Navy Officer, who as the conflict of good and evil throughout his service. He used that experience to create the classic novel Lord of the Flies. The novel focuses on human nature’s way of civilization and society through children. The characteristics of three important characters show the sides of human nature. Jack represents the evil, Piggy the innocent, and Ralph the good. Golding takes a closer in depth look at whether evil is in everyone or not. These 3 children in the Golding’s novel symbolize the picture of humanity on a larger scale then the microcosm of the small tropical island in Carol Sea.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fear In Lord Of The Flies

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the midst of danger, one will make irrational decisions. On the island, the boys are faced with many types of fears. Once the boys hear that there is a “beastie” on the island, one of Jack’s first ideas is to hunt it down. When Ralph doesn’t agree that they should be out searching for the beast, conflicts arise among Jack and Ralph which result in the separation of group. Without Ralph and Piggy, Jack’s group eventually turn to savages and do as they please, not feeling guilty or caring for a thing that happens. The boys recite an incantation right before Simon stumbles upon the camp and is brutally murdered by the boys, thinking that Simon is the beast. “Kill the beast! Cut his throat! Spill his blood!” (Golding 152). The death of Simon is a major turning point in the story because it signifies the boys’ major deterioration in morality and how less and less careless they’ve gotten since the crash. Another type of fear the boys are faced with is the fear of Jack. As the novel advances, Jack becomes more and more of a ruthless tyrant. He uses Roger to torture Samneric and by that action, he shows that he is powerful and whoever doesn’t listen to Jack will be punished…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lord of the Flies

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Deep inside each individual is a psychological choice to be made between good and evil. In William Golding’s novel, Lord of the Flies, this choice and its subsequent results are represented by Ralph and Jack. With no rules and no adults on the island to guide them, Jack gives into his evil desires. Whereas Ralph struggles to maintain a sense of humanity and constantly tries to strive to do good. Both started off as English schoolboys, but when left alone on the island human nature tends to make the choices.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics