Preview

Analysis of Sandra Cisneros' Short Stories "Barbie-Q" and "My Tocaya"

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1014 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis of Sandra Cisneros' Short Stories "Barbie-Q" and "My Tocaya"
Two stories that are abundant with feminist views and stereotypes are Cisneros' Barbie-Q and My Tocaya. In both stories, we see characters struggle with what it means to be a woman. Cisneros explores the standards women are held up to, and the standards they make for themselves. Cisneros does a wonderful job of bringing out the worries, fears, and Otherness that women frequently grapple with in their daily lives. She writes her tales, all the while reflecting and dismantling stereotypes of women. Cisneros, when participating in a project titled Interviews with Writers of the Post-Colonial World, stated: "I guess my feminism and my race are the same thing to me. They're tied in one to another, and I don't feel an alliance or allegiance with upper-class white women" (Jussawalla, Dasenbrock, 74).

It is important to understand some background on the tremendous role society has in shaping people's views of themselves before plunging into the story. Author Leticia Romero explores in her essay Barbie-Q: A Subversive or Hegemonic Popular Text?what message Ms. Cisneros was trying to communicate with her audience. Romero states: Sandra Cisneros cleverly-and rather strongly-questions these traditional values of society, and unveils the hegemonic ideology that attempts to manipulate and subordinate the social groups marginalized by the dominant class (Romo, 2).

In Barbie-Q, we are introduced to two little girls and their respective Barbies: Yours is the one with mean eyes and a ponytail. Striped swimsuit, stilettos, sunglasses and gold hoop earrings. Mine is the one with bubble hair. Red swimsuit, stilettos, pearl earrings, and a wire stand. But that's all we can afford, besides one extra outfit apiece (Cisneros, 14).

It is interesting that one of the girls refers to one of the Barbies as having "mean eyes". This is probably a reference to the homogenization these girls have been exposed to. In that little girl's simple observation, a complex question is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    2. Why does Prager call Barbie ‘masculine’ in paragraph 5? Does this description contradict Prager’s view of Barbie as an unattainable and inappropriate feminine ideal?…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to gender stereotypes, girls and boys are expected to act in certain ways that are fundamental in the eyes of society. Girls are expected to be quiet and part of the obeying gender, while it is anticipated that boys are always up to no good. Similarly, in the article by Messner (2008), Barbie Girls Versus Sea Monsters: Children Constructing Gender, boys are represented as loud and aggressive, while girls are feminine and more respectful. Boys are shown to be on a verbal chant, while the girls cheer for all. In Fitzhugh’s novel, it is of central importance to note that although the common assumptions are rejected, Fitzhugh is able to positively argue that it is natural. The concept of new realism, where new topics and issues formerly taboo are addressed in…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Poem “Barbie Doll” by Marge Piercy is about a girl who struggles with her body image. The speaker in the poem acts as an observer; watching the girl encounter different experiences as it related to her body image. Today’s generation is much similar to the life of the girl in this poem. Girls are forced to keep up with rising standards that are overwhelming and destructive. This poem uses form, imagery, and word choice to express how society chooses not to accept girls who do not represent the “ideal” woman.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Barbies are one of the dolls in today’s world that can be seen as both a positive learning tool and a negative way of how girls see themselves. To children, especially young girls Barbies are seen as role model, the Barbie is something that children can look up to. Barbies have a wide range of jobs; including: astronaut, nurse, veterinarian, police officer, chef, surfer, princess, fashion designer, rock star, olympian, and many more. Instead of Barbies only teaching the idea of running a household, the doll has opened up a whole new field of different things that a young girl can aspire…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Women Hollering Creek

    • 1425 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the story "Woman Hollering Creek" Sandra Cisneros discusses the issues of living life as a married woman through a character named Cleofilas; a character who is married to a man who abuses her physically and mentally .Cisneros reveals the way the culture puts a difference between a male and a female, men above women. Cisneros has been famous about writing stories about the latino culture and how women are treated; she explain what they go through as a child, teen and when they are married; always dominated by men because of how the culture has been adapted. "Woman Hollering Creek" is one of the best examples. A character who grows up without a mother and who has no one to guid and give her advise about life.…

    • 1425 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is Barbie Harmful?

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Blonde hair, blue eyes, business woman, rock star, princess and doctor, can you guess who? It’s Barbie. To be beautiful is to possess qualities that give great pleasure or satisfaction, and for most, Barbie is the epitome of beauty. For years Barbie has been a doll that has been living in the hands of girls of all ages. Some girls start getting Barbies as young as three years old and continue to collect these dolls sometimes into early adulthood. But are these dolls a positive influence on young girls? Barbie is harmful because she gives a false perception of beauty that effects the self esteem, health, and ethnic concerns of young girls.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the poem “Barbie Doll,” author Marge Piercy utilizes four well-developed stanzas to depict a scornful view of American society. Applicable to all time periods, “Barbie Doll” narrates the short-lived life of a young girl despised by society for her appearance. Barbie Doll is like a fairytale, full of plasticity, fakeness, and fantasy. However, unlike a fairytale, “Barbie Doll” ends with society applauding the funeral of a princess that was torn apart into pieces and then worshiped. Written with varying tones of sadness and depression, vivid imagery, and compact concrete details, “Barbie Doll” presents a fact that society for centuries has blinded from view.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I remember getting my mother’s old Barbie dolls and wondering why her long blonde hair was different. Since Barbie’s were created there has been several different versions of these dolls. Controversies came in an uproar about the skinny, white, long blonde haired Barbie. So, the Barbie company created African-American or brunette and men Barbie dolls. Other issues people had with the dolls were this mistreatment of the dolls. For an example, “Malibu Barbie, shimmery and golden. My parents couldn't afford the Dream house, so my doll lived in a pinewood box. I hand-sewed her bed and sofa with jagged, tangled stitches. I gifted her hand puppets and sock dresses, then chopped her hair into uneven patches. I grew a year older and gave her up to my brother and his friends, who ripped off her head and crammed her body with firecrackers. Her limbs, caked with black soot, scattered in the front yard, discovered by the dog weeks later.” (Ibarra, 34) Personally I don’t think they way children treat their toys should be a huge controversial issue. Children are going to do whatever they want with their toys. Some kids may throw their Barbie’s around or they may treat them like their “Babies”. (Omni, 16, 76.) Omni made an article about a lady named Barbara Bell who had some different view toward her responses from the disrespect of the Barbie’s. “Hearing of her experience, Bell's colleagues suggested she channel Barbie. So, Bell started the Barbie Channeling Newsletter. For $3, she sends readers Barbie's answer to a personal query along with a copy of the newsletter. “"I go into a light trance," says Bell, 44, whose nickname is also Barbie, "”and the words come flying out. There are 700 million Barbie dolls in the world with no voice that's real." Do Barbie’s or dolls in general have a mind of their own to show…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Barbie Paper

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Page

    When hooks writes “we know Barbie was born to be alone" she means that Barbie was made to be by herself. Unlike Baby, Hook’s black baby doll, Barbie was manufactured as an adult. Barbie was made to be all by alone, no family, no kids, and no friends except the imaginary ones that people create for her. Baby also comes with no family, kids, or friends but she was made to be cared for. Hooks mentions "she [Barbie] never does housework, washes dishes, or has children to care for", Hooks speaks about Barbie and the careless attitude that she was given. Barbie is a tall, thin, white, blonde hair and blue eyed doll. Barbie dolls are made to look a certain way and be portrayed in a certain way. People influence what makes you who you are they influence your identity. Without others around and someone that cares for you, you do not have a successful identity. Without your identity you are alone. Without Hooks, Baby would have nothing, no doll houses or clothing, but Barbie without hooks, would still have her clothing and accessories. Barbie is still holding the same image. Barbie’s image gives girls bad self-esteem and unreal expectations of themselves. This image portrays Barbie’s identity, her identity that makes her born to be alone.…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 1950's Barbie Doll

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Barbie’s success has not come without cost. If you mention her name in group of adults or friends and nearly everyone will offer an opinion about the toy. In the 1950’s Barbie is the debut as the “teenage fashion model” is mirrored the sophisticated glamour of 1950’s stars like Marilyn Monroe, Rita Hayworth and many more. The Barbie doll was seen with high arched brows, pursed red lips, a sassy pony tail with curly bangs. Barbie’s figure was high fashion and model-esque, with pale,…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Barbie Doll Essay

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The theme of the poem, “Barbie Doll,” by Marge Piercy is the overwhelming pressure society exerts on females to be stereotypically attractive and the willingness to go to great lengths in order to achieve “perfection.” Many females, especially teenagers, are faced with this feeling every day. Growing up during the age of advanced computer technology and social media only exacerbates this problem. Many adolescent girls can relate to the fear of being bullied because they do not fit into the category of what is considered culturally beautiful. Marge Piercy uses her intense word choice to evoke emotion in readers about feminism, as well as the everyday struggle girls encounter trying to live up to society’s standards of…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Seen through Rose-Tinted glasses:” The Barbie Doll in American Society. By Marilyn Motz; supports the highly debated topic that the toy Barbie produced by Mattel is a bad influence, on young girls. Motz is claiming that the young female child envisions herself as Barbie, and with Barbie resembling an older more mature woman. Something that Barbie’s age group cannot obtain, in till they grow older and more mature themselves. However, Barbie is just a toy, her resemblance, her actions, as a doll is, solely up to the child. Adults looking into their daughter’s childhood are simply over thinking what a three to eleven year old can produce inside her mind.…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Can you guess who I am? I was born March 9th, 1959 in the United States of America. I am made of a very special material that never ages. I am 11 ½ inches tall and I weigh 6.4 ounces. I have long blonde hair and blue eyes. I am such a busy girl; you can find me just about anywhere! Even with such a busy schedule, I have always found the time to work. I am a baby doctor, a zoo doctor, a preschool teacher, a babysitter, a vet, a pizza and pastry chef, a racecar driver, and a cheerleader! But most importantly, I am the queen of fashion! I love to travel but I also love to spend time at my “Glam House!” While I am there, I love taking a swim in my “Glam Pool,” cooking up a storm in my “Glam Kitchen,” catching…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Girl” & Barbie Doll

    • 2455 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In contrast, the short story “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid suggests that women are sentenced to patriarchy as a result of socially constructed gender stereotypes. She criticizes the idealized patriarchal norms and pressures which overshadow the lives of women. Starting early on in their childhood, little girls are explicitly exposed to the pressures and expectations of how they should live. As a result of gender stereotypes, young girls are brainwashed to believe that their role as a woman is a domestic homemaker and that they should always be kempt and maintain a feminine outer appearance. Kincaid ultimately criticizes how women and girls are trapped under a system of patriarchy that can not be erased.…

    • 2455 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this short piece, “Our Daughters, Ourselves” by Stevie Cameron the many feats that woman have overcome in recent years are highlighted, as are the many setbacks. This piece is basically a summation of a daughters life from an over-cautious parents point of view. Although this is a short piece of writing, it does indeed touch on some of the sexual differences that still exist in our society today such as male-dominated post-secondary fields like engineering and how equally qualified woman don’t usually receive the same level of jobs as men with similar academic credentials. The piece is told from the perspective of what I can assume is a mother that went through the same sexual differences in her era and is only hoping that her daughter does not have to go through the same hardships, only to find that society still isn’t equal no matter how much progress we have made. Cameron supports her whole piece of work at the end by mentioning the tragic events of the Montreal Massacre and how all of their lives parents have been telling their daughters that they can do whatever they want and have equal opportunity only to have their dreams burned down by a sexist male who could blamed woman for his failures. I found this article interesting as I found a correlation between the reading and many topics that I learn about in my Human Resources courses such as creating equality in the workplace and equal opportunity for both sexes.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays