In this paper, the topic I would like to discuss deeper is the inconsistency of the text. That’s because the inconsistency can be seen and analyze in many form inside of the text. The inconsistency can be seen in the form of the contradictory words or phrases, and also from the shifts or instability in the continuity of text. The text which I will use in this paper is the song lyric. The title is “Come Undone” sang by Robbie Williams. This song was written by Robbie Williams, Ashley Hamilton (son of George Hamilton), Boots Ottestad and Daniel Pierre. This song was recorded in 2002 and released in 31 March 2003. According to Robbie Williams web page, “Come Undone” song was initially banned from radio because of its explicit content. “Come Undone” was the second single to be taken from Escapology album in the spring 2003. Based on the chart highlight from Robbie Williams web page, “Come Undone” reached No.4 in the UK charts. A hit throughout Europe, it also made its mark on the South American airplay charts, reaching the Mexican top ten.
This song tells about a man who comparing the people to show the imperfectness of the people in the world. Whether they are not perfect, they still have the right to be love. The man inside the song called himself a scum because he felt he has disappoint and hurts his mother. He hurts his mother by using the imperfectness he has and yet he still love his mother and hope that he wouldn’t hurts his mother more.
About this song, Robbie said that, "So unimpressed but so in awe' - that's the dichotomy of me. I think it's another one of those songs where I just want to dissect a perception of myself. ‘Because I'm scum and I'm your son' is not to my family. I saw Tupac come out of a courtroom once, and he said ‘you put me down, you say I'm this that or the other, but I'm a product of your environment, and I'm still your son, America.' That touched me. And I am England's son. And I'm not scum, but I've felt like it." For the foundation of my theory in analyzing this song, I would like to use the post-structuralism and deconstruction theory. The post structuralism theory appeared in the late of 1960s and the two figures who are known closely related to the appearance of this theory are Roland Barthes and Jacques Derrida (1930-2004). Kari Boyd McBride said, “Post structuralism rejected the theory that one could map the structure of a language or culture. Rather, meaning is constantly slipping from one sign to the next. Signifiers do not produce signifieds; they merely produce an endless chain of signifier” . Jacques Derrida used Saussure's insights to develop Deconstruction, a perspective that focuses on the lack of a truth "out there" or at the center to provide meaning. Based on Dr. Kristi Siegel web page, “Post-Structuralism (which is often used synonymously with Deconstruction or Postmodernism) is a reaction to structuralism and works against seeing language as a stable, closed system. ” According to Beginning Theory (Peter Barry .2009), “the deconstructionist looks for evidence of gaps, breaks, fissures and discontinuities of all kinds “(p.69-70). Deconstruction theory has three stages in analyzing the text. They are the verbal, the textual and the linguistic stage. The verbal stage involves looking for the paradoxes and contradictions. The textual stage involves looking for the shifts or breaks in the continuity of the text. The linguistic stage involves looking for moments in the text when the adequacy of language itself as a medium of communication is called into question. (p. 71-73) There are some reason that make me choose the topic, the song and the theory to be analyze in my midterm paper assignment. The first is the topic is interesting when we analyze it using the deconstruction theory. In this theory, we must be able to think of the author’s intention through the iteration he made. So we must able to think out of the text. The second is the song is...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document