Preview

Amputation Research Paper

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1333 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Amputation Research Paper
A Path to Amputation For Body Integrity Identity Patients
In this paper, I will argue that amputation is an ethically appropriate medical intervention for patients with Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID) as long as certain criteria are followed. My argument for this is based on the fact that it is every medical professional’s ethical responsibility to relieve patients from their suffering and there is an inherent lack of alternative solutions to treating BIID. It might be objected to this that amputating a healthy limb inflicts unnecessary harm unto patients with BIID. However, I will show that not allowing patients with BIID to obtain treatment in the form of amputation it only prolongs the patients’ psychological distress and physical
…show more content…
Many people think that patients who desire an amputation of a healthy limb must be mentally unable to make a sound decision. However, by requiring therapy it ensures that a professional is confirming that the patient is capable of making a sound decision. Another argument is that patients requesting an amputation do not understand fully how difficult it is to live with an amputated limb or that they will be unnecessarily living with a disability that they should not have to live with. To solve this issue, the patient will have logged time spent living like an amputee would before the amputation to ensure that they understand every difficulty they will face as an amputee. Through this, the patient would understand the challenges of being and amputee and be able to make the fully educated, sound decision whether or not their suffering outweighs the challenges of being an amputee. Finally, there is the argument that other treatments may help the BIID patient without requiring an amputation. This issue is solved by both requiring therapy and by requiring the patient to search and try other treatment options. Ultimately this process would allow BIID patients a path to treatment, whether it is found before or after amputation, and would prove that amputation is the best treatment for every patient who did not find an alternative solution while completing the …show more content…
I argue that it becomes unethical to not allow patients with BIID to receive an amputation because it is prolonging the patients’ physical and psychological suffering when other BIID patients have reported that amputations have worked to lessen the effects the condition. In response to the first objection of needing to strength the criteria, I am reluctant to agree. Patients with BIID often desire an amputation so strongly that they attempt the procedure themselves or purposefully injury themselves in order to receive their amputation. Requiring BIID patients to wait too long or inflicting too stringent criteria may encourage BIID patients to take matters into their own hands, rather than pursue the safer route of getting an amputation by a medical professional. Self-attempts to amputate endanger the life of patients with BIID, making this a pressing medical issue. For these reasons, I believe that the criteria laid out are appropriately designed to allow a reasonable path to amputation for BIID patients while recognizing and accommodating the issues of opponents to amputation by

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The fact that media glosses over the sadness and grief that can result from an amputation and its primary focus being the tangible achievements of an amputee, perpetuates damaging stereotypes. Such stereotypes, specifically the…

    • 1547 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Phantom Limb Pain

    • 5731 Words
    • 23 Pages

    Phantom limb pain first arose during the sixteenth century by a French military surgeon, Ambrose Pare (Weinstein, 1998). He described this as pain being perceived from a part of the body which no longer exists, therefore belonging to neuropathic pain syndromes. The phantom limb is generally described to have a tingling sensation and a definite shape that resembles the limb pre amputation. Moreover, some claim to feel it move through space in the same way that the normal limb would have, for example, walking, sitting and stretched out (Melzack, 1973). Almost all amputees would report these non painful sensations immediately after surgery (Nikolajsen et al, 2005). Initially, the phantom limb feels normal causing the amputee to use the limb for its would be usual purposes…

    • 5731 Words
    • 23 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Leg amputation of a war veteran or for medical reasons such as diabetes, in which their dementia has gone back to a time in their life where they could once walk using both of their legs and they are trying to do so. This could cause aggression or sadness for the client when trying to explain to the client that they must not try to walk without assistance as they “may fall and hurt themselves”. Age-related degenerative diseases, such as Macular Degeneration where extra help is needed in assisting with walking, also consideration of placing objects in…

    • 1191 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Terri Schiavo Case

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Recent cases have drawn attention to the issue of individual autonomy, and what is sometimes referred to as ‘the right to die’. Adult patients who are mentally competent have the right to refuse medical treatment even when that refusal can lead to worsening ill health and even death. This refusal of treatment may only be ignored when statutory law provides for treatment without consent, or a judge makes an order that overrides the patient’s consent. While this is largely accepted when patients are physically and mentally competent, it becomes a complex issue when a person is mentally competent, but due to physical incapacity are in care because they are unable to care for themselves. A person may be mentally competent but due to being a quadriplegic…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poignant story of Jean-Dominique Bauby’s life begins in December 1995, when he finds himself in a hospital, recovering from a severe coma, both paralyzed from head to toe and unable to speak. Though Bauby’s mind is still intellectually intact, he is diagnosed with what most people call today, “locked-in-syndrome”. Through his powerful words, Bauby, the author and narrator of this story, takes us on a journey filled with pain, loss and courage. I believe that though Bauby did indeed have a disability, he only fit into two of the three definitions categorized as having a disability; these being, function barriers (impairments) , activity barriers (Disabilities) and participation barriers (Handicap).…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Everyday many Americans and others across the world are in need of artificial organs, which is are man-made devices that are implanted into a person to replace their own natural organ and to perform the same functions as that natural organ would. The ability of this to succeed has been one of the biggest achievements in medicine and still continues to save the lives of people everywhere. However, this subject also brings up a lot of controversy. The main problem is that the supply of organs available is less than the great demand of patients needing them, therefore, there has to be way that decides how the organs will be distributed amongst the patients. There are many methods this can be done, but when doing so, one should not take into account a person’s “social worth” and neither should they account for self-inflicted injuries. If it is taken into account, then it is not promoting justice as fairness.…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    As adults and human beings we have certain inalienable rights to make decisions regardless of whether they are deemed as poor or inappropriate by others. One must take into consideration the level of understanding and competence a patient possesses to assure they are informed of all options and repercussions; the other must be whether the individual is harming anyone other than themselves by making said decision. Once those issues have been taken into consideration there must be an allowance for an individual to make their own well-informed choice, even though as a practitioner, we may feel it is not in their best interest.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “When it comes to healthcare, ‘bad people’ are as equal as the rest of us” (646). When someone is sentenced to execution it is decided by the criminal justice system, not the medical community. The justice system views these peoples’ social worth as so low that they deserve to die for the crimes they have committed. “The state’s determination of social worth only finds that the condemned prisoner no longer deserves life—a far higher bar than a determination that he or she is no longer worthy of healthcare prior to death”(646). In the medical community, the goal is to save lives. Appel also points out that even though kidney transplants do increase survival rates over dialysis, just because someone doesn’t get a transplant, this does not necessarily mean that they will die. He says that kidney transplants tend to be more of a life-enhancing surgery, as opposed to a life-extending surgery. On the argument that to give a kidney to someone who will die soon anyway is a waste of a perfectly good organ; Appel says this objection is invalid. A small percentage of death row inmates are ever actually executed, seventy-five percent of death sentences are appealed and overturned and that one in fifteen death row inmates is acquitted. Because of these statistics, Appel says that to ignore these peoples’ requests for kidney transplant would be morally wrong.…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The international community is attempting to crack down on the issue. Doctors Against Forced Organ Harvesting has been charted as a contribution to mankind to protect ethical medical practices that further human dignity. The newly formed organisation aims to provide society and the medical community with objective findings of unethical and illegal organ harvesting. Forced organ harvesting and/or the removal of organs from a donor, without obtaining voluntary consent is considered to be one of the most barbaric forms of slavery and one of the greatest crimes against humanity, as well as a threat to medical science in…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    According to the article Organ Transplantation, “Organ transplantation refers to the process of surgically removing one organ from a human or animal, known as the donor, and implanting it into a recipient human.” Kidneys, livers, hearts, lungs, intestines, the pancreas, and the skin transplant successfully today. Two types of transplantation surgeries include autografts and allografts. An autograft alludes to a surgery performed on the same person. Allograft surgery pertains to an organ transplant from one person to another (Organ Transplantation). Most scientific studies emphasize on allograft surgeries, for danger accompanies removing organs from one person to place in another. Surgeons classify transplantation as one…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Social Work Case Study

    • 1860 Words
    • 8 Pages

    * Body Image Anxiety: Many feelings and aspects of recent amputee’s lives are affected by the loss of their limb including lowering of self-esteem, depression, higher levels of general anxiety and poorer perceived quality of life. This is not the case with all amputees, but Frank Bertollini is experiencing this anxiety because of the loss of his left lower leg and foot.…

    • 1860 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unit 14 Childcare Grade B

    • 6289 Words
    • 26 Pages

    The 'medical model' sees disabled people as the problem. They need to be adapted to fit into the world as it is. If this isn't possible, then they should be shut away in a specialised institution or left alone at home, where only their most basic needs will be met. Usually, the impairment is focused on, rather than the needs of the person.…

    • 6289 Words
    • 26 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In other words, the Act outlines that individuals cannot donate organs for specific benefits, such as reduced sentencing in the case of inmate organ donation. However, inmate organ donation in itself does not override the legislation, especially in the case of death row prisoners donating after execution. Furthermore, while opponents to inmate organ donation often cite ethical concerns, such as the coercive nature of prisoner donation, the continued ignorance of prisoner organ donation overrides the autonomy of the inmate as an individual. Despite the fact that prisoners experience revocation of specific rights, “they are not ‘owned’ body and soul by the state. Prisoners still possess the autonomy to make certain decisions” (Bagatell, Kahn, and Owens). Moreover, as Dr. Huige Li has continuously rhetorically questioned his colleagues through his seat on the Doctors Against Forced Open Harvesting board, “If prisoner organ donation [remains upheld as] theoretically correct, what can prevent it [from] happening?” (Tatlow). Essentially, Li distinctly demonstrates the government’s inability to continuously blatantly ignore the prisoner population as…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    identity disorder. Our research begins with looking into the history of this diagnostic category, while it also includes…

    • 2798 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mental Capacity Act Nvq 5

    • 6650 Words
    • 27 Pages

    4 Any actions taken or decisions made on behalf of someone who lacks capacity must be done in their best interests, after considering what is known about their preferences (unless they have made a relevant and valid advance decision to refuse medical treatment. It is still…

    • 6650 Words
    • 27 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics