Punishment vs. Rehabilitation
Melinda Colon
Kaplan University
CJ101-12AU
William Patterson
January 17, 2010
Justice 2
The United States correctional system uses both punishment and rehabilitation when dealing with offenders. There are many ways that the justice system handles these punishments such as incarceration, probation, and sometimes death. However, punishment does not seem to work. It seems that the only way to effectively handle criminals is with successful rehabilitation.
Punishment in the United States goes way back to the beginning of time, as early as the time before Christ when thieves and murderers were crucified for their crimes. As times passed, we eventually developed better and less cruel ways of punishing offenders. Some of these included jails and prisons, monitoring criminals through probation, and less serious punishments like community service. However, we still put the more severe criminals to death, just a little more humanely.
The biggest form of punishment seems to be incarceration. This is obvious by the number of people currently incarcerated and the overcrowding problems that jails have today. It seems even the most minor, insignificant crimes are being punished by jail time. These crimes include driving on a suspended license, petit theft, and public nuisance. In December of 2009 the Bureau of Justice put out its latest statistics on the current inmate population. There were 2,304,115 people incarcerated in the United States as of December 2008 (Bulletin, 2009, p.8).
Another form of punishment used today is conditional releases. In 2008 there were 505,168 criminals on probation or under supervision. Total conditional releases include releases to probation, parole and supervised mandatory releases (Bulletin, 2009, p.4).
Justice 3
Although incarceration and probation seems to be the primary forms of punishment in the United States, we do still use death as a form of punishment. In 2008, there were 3,215 inmates currently on death row in the United States. California is currently the leading state with 690 inmates on death row, followed by Florida with 403 in 2009.
Punishment is not the only way that we currently deal with criminals. Rehabilitation is another form of justice used, although it is not used as much as it should be. It would seem that some believe incarceration is a form of rehabilitation, when in fact it only becomes a revolving door in which many are no longer afraid of.
There are many forms of rehabilitation. Drug treatment programs, mental institutions, and community service are just a few. Drug treatment programs are an excellent form of rehabilitation. In 2006 there were 265,800 drug related crimes in the United States and 277,900 property crimes which include theft. By helping these offenders to get off drugs, we reduce, if not completely eradicate, the number of drug related crimes and drug related thefts.
I feel the best way to handle criminals is by rehabilitation and not punishment. Not all criminals can be rehabilitated and for these criminals we have punishment such as prison, death, or probation, however, minor crimes should not be punished. Many crimes can be prevented. Let’s take the thousands of drug addicts for example. If we take them off drugs, put them in a rehab, and show them how to live a life clean of drugs, there would be no reason for them to steal to support their habit. This not only reduces the rate of drug related crimes, but reduces the rate of crimes against people. Even violent crimes are committed by criminals on drugs, who are not in a sober state of mind, and with rehabilitation; we can prevent these as well.
Justice 4
Our justice system seems to believe very strongly in taking criminals off the street. However, this is only a temporary solution. If we lock a person up for dealing drugs, we only make matters worse. Most prisoners continue this same behavior even in jail. They bring the drugs in, distribute them to other prisoners, and by the time these other prisoners get out, they too are now drug addicts. A jail is nothing more than a holding facility and a place for criminals to meet other criminals and plot their next crime. If we are going to punish criminals, then we need to also rehabilitate them. The goal of our justice system should be to deter crime not just punish it.
Punishment of crime is not a deterrent. Let’s take the person who is spending a year in jail for driving on a suspended license. He does his year and he gets out, but he still has no license. In order to get his license back he needs a job. His options are to get a job and drive without a license again to get to that job, or rob, steal, and sell drugs to survive because he has no license to get to a work. Now take this same criminal and give him a hardship license free of charge for 60 days, this way he can get to work and get the money he needs to pay for his regular license, now he is no longer breaking the law. If we have to lock him up because he just doesn’t do what he has to do, then we make him work while in jail, and take his money to pay for his license fees, this way when he is released, he does not have to worry about getting arrested again for the same thing.
These are just a few ways that rehabilitation works versus punishment. We should be helping society become free of violence by giving them the resources needed to do so. You may not be able to rehabilitate a murderer or rapist, but at least half of these other crimes can be
Justice 5 prevented if we just focus more on the problems and causes of crimes rather than just punishing the crime and waiting for the offender to do it again.
Justice 6
References
U.S. Department of Justice. (2009). Bureau of Justice Statistics. Washington, DC:U.S. Government Printing Office.
Death Penalty Information. (2009). Death Row Inmates. Retrieved January 14, 2009 from http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/death-row-inmates-state-and-size-death-row-year Schmalleger, Frank. (2007). Criminal Justice Today. Prentice Hall
References: U.S. Department of Justice. (2009). Bureau of Justice Statistics. Washington, DC:U.S. Government Printing Office. Death Penalty Information. (2009). Death Row Inmates. Retrieved January 14, 2009 from http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/death-row-inmates-state-and-size-death-row-year Schmalleger, Frank. (2007). Criminal Justice Today. Prentice Hall
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
United States criminal justice system comes from the European System that England, Holland and France used at the time when we first had the colonists come in to this country. In the early years of the criminal justice system, they were very straight forward on punishment. They would take you in front of the town and have your court out in the open. The town’s people then would hear what you were charged with and then decide your punishment. If you committed a crime sure as, steeling or fighting they would punish you by whipping, cutting off different parts of the body like ears and fingers. Punishments like these were taken place outdoors in front of the town so you were known as a criminal. For crimes as murder, and rape those were more sever and the person was executed by hanging. All of these practices of punishment were in hope that others would not do the same. They did not have a back then they didn’t have a way of knowing if you were mentally ill and need help to prevent you from acting out in a violent way nor did they know how to conduct a crime investigation to conduct a proper crime investigation.…
- 1401 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
References: Mackenzie, Doris L. (2000). Sentencing and Corrections in the 21st Century: Setting the Stage For The Future. Retrieved October 25, 2002 from http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/nij/international/sentence.doc.…
- 5792 Words
- 24 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Critical Issues in the American Criminal Justice System - Sentencing Decisions and the Death Penalty
Bureau of Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs. (2009). Prison Inmates at Midyear 2008 – Statistical Tables: National Prisoner Statistics. Retrieved on 11/28/2010 from http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/pim08st.pdf…
- 4489 Words
- 18 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The complexities of human nature, emotions, thought, morals and ethics have been debated for centuries, and the dilemma of sentencing another human to a form of corporal punishment, incarceration or death, requires a firm foundation in the laws of the land, tempered by years of study and dedication to the law one has sworn to uphold. The several reasons for sentencing of a crime is: Revenge, for an actual or perceived need for vengeance on a violation, usually one that is very personal and emotional in nature. Incapacitation, which is to prevent the criminal from repeating crimes against society by placing them into a correctional facility on a long term or permanent basis. Restoration, is a form of sentencing when the convening authority is attempting to protect the victims by helping them to feel safe and secure. Deterrence is a sentence where the courts attempt to prevent the subject of a crime from offending again. Retribution, which is probably the oldest reason for sentencing was utilized for equal punishment to the crime, drawing from the old adage “eye for an eye”. Lastly is the sentence of rehabilitation, which in societies modern view, the ideal and preferred sentence,…
- 851 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
References: Burea of Justice Statistics Fact Sheet. (1995). Comparison of NCVS and UCR preliminary estimates (DHHS Publication No. ADM 90-1679). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.…
- 1002 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
One objective in the criminal justice system is to rehabilitate offenders. In this paper, I will describe what rehabilitation is in prison, as well as provide the origin of rehabilitation. Next I will give a definition of parole and how it is different from mandatory release. I will also be giving a definition of probation and how probation compares to other forms of sentencing. This paper will also provide a definition as well as the options of community corrections. Lastly, I will critique the current rehabilitation and give my opinion on a better solution to the current parole process, the current probation system, and the current community corrections options.…
- 1422 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
In the United States today the incarceration of offenders is not always the right option for rehabilitating criminals. The idea of putting offenders on probation who are supervised, also with a suspended sentence can assist in the decrease of crime (University of Phoenix, 2011). This paper will discuss the origins of rehabilitation in prison and its definition, the definition of parole and how it differs from mandatory release, the definition of probation and how it compares to other forms of sentencing, the definition and options of community corrections, and the critique of the current rehabilitation options. Also this paper will determine if there are better solutions than the current community corrections options that exist today.…
- 1154 Words
- 5 Pages
Best Essays -
In this paper I will look at why our prisons seem to fail at rehabilitation. I will look at what programs are in place and how they perform. It 's my hope to find there are programs that if put in place, would help us to stop the rise in prison population by repeat offenders.…
- 5359 Words
- 20 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The use of punishment in the American corrections system is crucial to our criminal justice system. The United States has the largest inmate population in the world, with more than 2 million in prisons or jails. (Whyte & Baker, 2000). In earlier days there were several punishment options one which was public shaming. By imposing this punishment, it was with the hope that the punishment would prevent the accused from committing future crimes. We have progressed through history in our punishment options for severe crimes from public hangings of the old days, to the electric chair and now lethal injection. Regardless of what form of punishment is used, it serves its purpose to ensure that criminals receive their fair punishment.…
- 791 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Prisons today, there are about 1,325 state prisons, 84, federal prisons in operation in the US. Today. America’s prison population has quadrupled since 1980. We also punish people by putting them in halfway houses, or group homes. The Federal Prison system is used for the civilians convicted of violating federal laws. Leavenworth, in Leavenworth Kansas. Today the federal systems consist of 103 institutions, six regional offices, two staff training centers, and 28 community corrections offices.…
- 257 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Convicted felons can be punished in many different ways, but one thing is sure it would not be cruel and unusual. Before we look at how we punish offenders we must first understand why we are punishing them. The general purpose behind punishment is to inflict upon criminals some kind of suffering for the crime that they have committed or to protect society from those considered too dangerous to live amongst us. Punishment, a necessary evil, is sometimes required to deter law violators from repeating their crime and to serve as an example to others who would also violate the law. Schmalleger, Frank J. Criminal Justice Today An Introductory Text for the 21st Century (81).…
- 900 Words
- 3 Pages
Better Essays -
Prisons have only been used as the primary punishment for criminal acts in the last couple of centuries. Far more common earlier were various types of corporal punishment, public humiliation, penal bondage, and banishment for more severe offences, as well as capital punishment.…
- 1117 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Bureau of Justice Statistics. (1988). Report to the nation on crime and justice (2nd Ed.). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.…
- 1544 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
As research states rehabilitation is good for offenders to give them a trade, get them the counseling and the help that they may need in order to be able to move back into society. And I believe that everyone makes mistakes and learns differently, some people need to learn the hard way and others need a little guidance. Some people commit crimes over and over and never learn from their mistakes no matter what is taught to them or how many people they may receive help from, they just need that physical punishment and not abuse but to be incarcerated with people telling them what to do 24 hours a day, Many of these offenders are ok with that, others make mistakes and want to learn from them and want to make better choices in the future, so I do believe that punishment and rehabilitation can both be effective in the correctional…
- 750 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Jails and prisons lay at the heart of the Criminal Justice System. These facilities helped forge the concept of rehabilitation. These institutions have changed over time and now reflect the modern methods of housing convicted individuals who need to be reformed or punished.…
- 1591 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays