Preview

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Separation From Canada

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
851 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Advantages And Disadvantages Of Separation From Canada
Since 1980 Quebec had the desire of separation from Canada and many people know it as the Quebec sovereignty referendum. Separatism is when a province or state like Quebec would separate to create a country of its own. That concept was rejected by about 60% of the Quebecois during 1980 when the first voting took place, although they voted again during 1995 and 51% of the Quebecois did not agree with the desire of separation. Meaning that 49% of Quebecois voted “Yes”, which shocked many people and making them think of the possible effects that could occur if Quebec ever did separate from Canada. Many realizing that the Quebec economy would exhibit several weaknesses, and more disadvantages than advantages. The separation of Quebec could potentially …show more content…
Quebec is the main reason of Canada being a bi-lingual country. After they separate there would not be as many French speaking Canadians and potentially lead to Canada becoming an English speaking country only in which case Canada would lose all of our individuality and a huge reason that makes Canada a unique country. Canada is known for it diversity and multicultural traditions and unfortunately the separation could make people think that Canada is falling apart. Without Quebec, Canada would not have an identity of its own; when tourists think of Canada they also think about maple syrup, poutine as well as Hockey, all of which originated in Quebec. With the loss of such elements of Canadian culture, it could be ( ADDD SOMETHINGHRRE). Moreover, the Quebec separatism would lead to Canada losing a huge part of its identity.
Quebec has been a part of Canada from the start of confederation during 1867 and they should not end that by Quebec should not portray that if there is ever conflict between a state or province with its country, they should consider separation. As can be seen the Quebecois separating from Canada is a destructive decision that could cause a massive drop in their economy, problems with the redirecting of imports and goods and many negative changes in the Canadian lifestyle and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Some pros were that the colonies would be stronger and more independent. the colonies would have strong central government to control the defense, taxation, postage, currency etc. also the Britain abandoned the mercantilism so the colonies would have to unite in order to survive because Britain no longer provided the colonies with the guarantee on market and it got its material from other countries for a lower price. this made the colonies go in depression because people had no jobs and they needed someone to buy their goods and products .…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The era of late 1700’s was a period of great change in North America. After the French and Indian war ended in 1963, Great Britain’s control of North America’s east coast caused more interaction between the American colonies and Canada, which was a French colony prior to the war. In 1774, the Continental Congress wrote to the inhabitants of Quebec in an appeal which was entitled, “Appeal to the Inhabitants of Quebec.” In this appeal, the American colonists expressed their great joy that Quebec was now a part of the English colonies, and the main thesis of this appeal was that the inhabitants of Quebec had earned the right to have the same rights as the colonies under a just form of government, and that the best way for them to achieve that was by joining the American colonies. These ideas that the colonists had were very persuasive, and they provided a…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    making Canada an all the more just society. Possibly not the equitable society, or even…

    • 242 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After learning about the rebellion of 1837 and constantly taking notes, I realized the rebellion was not successful in overturning the government but it did unite both Upper and Lower Canada together. This was able to take away any differences of the two cultures, English and French. The impact did not happen immediately as intended though. In fact it caused the government to get back at the reformers and concentrate more on their punishment such as transportation, hanging, flogging and deaths for the rebels, instead of working on fixing the colony. You can tell that Canada had a serious political problem that was in desperate need to be improved.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I believe that bilingualism is central to Canada’s identity, as well as other languages. Pierre Elliott Trudeau has said that, “Bilingualism unites people; dualism divides them. Bilingualism means you can speak to the other; duality means you live in one language and the rest of Canada will live in another language”.…

    • 603 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Historiography of Quebec

    • 4346 Words
    • 18 Pages

    There has been a great deal of contention surrounding the revisionist perception of Quebec’s normalcy and the traditional understanding of Quebec as a distinct entity. The former attempts to substantiate the shift away from traditional…

    • 4346 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Immigration plays a big role in Montreal’s political and urban geography. Montreal is the primate city of Quebec. The Quebecois work extremely hard on language preservation and maintaining their cultural identity. French is the primary language spoken in Quebec. The Quebecois have the lowest birthrate in all of France. Quebec faces a major problem. They need to bring in immigrants to keep their culture alive, but their culture is also changing by letting in all of these immigrants. Quebec is divided into two areas where there are the English on one side and the French on the other side. The English pose a major threat to the Quebecois. The Quebecois realize that guarding their language is the only way to preserve their culture. In attempts…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There have been many issues between Quebec and the rest of Canada over the years. Trudeau believed that bilingualism…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The cause for separatism also caused another reason for turbulence within the province of Quebec, as well as creates a divide within Quebecois society. “Ce discours, qui fusionne nationalisme et socialisme autour de l’idée de décolonisation, s’infiltre dans le débat qui fait alors rage au Canada français entre les nationalistes de droite ou non séparatives et la gauche antinationaliste, pour renvoyer les deux camps dos a dos” (Lapointe, 2008 pp. 299). Those who we’re anti-separatist we’re viewed as non-nationalist in the eyes of those who supported the separatist movement, and those who were against the separatist movement felt a sense of resentment towards those who viewed them as anti-nationalists. While whether or not separatism would be a necessary factor for movement is debated throughout Canada to this day, at this time, this idea was a relatively new and radical opinion. In fact the time period of the 1960s was the very beginning of the whisperings of Quebec sovereignty, with such organizations developing such as the Rassemblement pour l’Independence nationale or RIN. This invoked the development of the more radical parties such as the FLQ, which would go on to become a violent organisation that cast a darker shadow over the Quebecois separatist movement. Of…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On The Flq Crisis

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Thesis: The October crisis was a significant event in Canadian history that depicted the conflict between Quebec and Canada, and the different views that Quebecers and English Canada had. This crisis dep…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One of the major aspects of being a Canadian citizen is to be entitled to your freedom. Therefore, I would like to explain to you the right to practice any religion you support or no religion at all. To clarify, freedom of religion is the manner in your personal life where you are free to practice any religion you like. You are welcome to choose if you want to be a Christian, Muslim, Buddhist Hindu or no religion at all you are free to do so. Having the opportunity to choose whether to believe in a religion or not is important to gain the respect we have towards other people. As long as we do not abuse the valid laws which protect the rights and freedoms of others, we are able to live peacefully. Our Canadian government is a great supporter of people's religions due to the fact that there are no state-sponsored religions. They are not allowed to prefer some religious beliefs or groups over others. As a result, the Canadian government is open towards all the religions and do not discriminate their choices. Regardless of what you believe or practice, protecting freedom of religion is a critical part of ensuring that all people are treated with dignity and respect.…

    • 244 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As a part of Quebec’s youth and up and coming younger generation I have witnessed the conflicts between the French- English divide since I could remember and it is important that the needs of both sides are full filled or at least compensated for, future generations need to focus on other issues and need to resolve the French-English divide in a fashionable matter so that both sides can work together and benefit from each other such as the increase of speaking French in schools and businesses. Cleavages are defined as “a politically significant distinction among identifiable groups in a given population” (L7, S5). Language is an important cleavage in Canadian society (L7, S6), Canada is known to being a diverse country the population consists of many different types of people, cultural backgrounds and value systems each of which should be respected and tolerated by every citizen of this country. The English-French divide has persisted over time as a result of events and decisions by governing bodies that have continued to fuel the divide (L7, S7). There are different solutions to the language issue among French and English speakers but it takes time and although the divide has changed a lot, the past 20 years we aren’t where we want to be just yet and it is up to future generations to solve this problem. Further issues such as the compact vs contract theory will be discussed and also in recent news the dispute over the Charter of values the Pauline Marois government seek to put in effect that has sprung up a dispute other issues that will be discussed are Bill 101 and the disputes over the equalization of payments that has become a major topic for discussion and a large part of the French-English division if future generations were to resolve these topics they would be one…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Each province and territory contributes to the Canadian economy in its own special way because of its own unique resources and culture. The West provides oil resources and mining while Central Canada specializes in manufacturing. Nonetheless, if any, of the province's or territory's decide to leave the Confederation, both parties will suffer. Canada won’t…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Canadian History Essay

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Today’s relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada has been relatively steady. Over the years, Québec has certainly developed separately but in association with the rest of Canada. However, without influence from the past, their relationships would not be what it is today. The development of the French and English relationship follows a long and complicated history. Throughout history, tensions between French and English Canada have been evident. Looking back at World War I and II, one of the key issues that divided English and French Canada was conscription. Quebec was against conscription, while English-Canada supported it. However, this is not the only issue that influenced the relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada. Throughout history, there have been many defining moments which have influenced this relationship. This essay will outline three defining moments. The first one is ‘the October crisis’, which caused a national sense of crisis when a French separatist group kidnapped 2 government officials. Then, the passing of Bill 101 which brought a controversy both inside and outside of Quebec. And thirdly, ‘The Constitution of 1982’ which changed the contract that linked Quebec to the rest of Canada. These three defining moments have greatly helped to establish the character of the relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    People are part of many nations and they all have varying importance. For example, we as students are part of nation with our fellow students, yet we are also a nation with our fellow Edmontonians, and Albertans and so on and so forth. Having nations within nations presents a problem with the source in failing to acknowledge who “our peoples” really are. Quebec is an excellent example of this. Throughout history, Francophones have been fighting for rights and independence in Canada. In pursuing their nationalistic goals, there has been a rift between many non-Francophone and Francophones in what is more important: Francophone nationalism or Quebecois nationalism. This has resulted in events such as the FLQ Crisis in 1970 which was an attempt to shed more light on the Francophones through ultranationalistic means, however was detrimental to Quebecois nationalism as it spread negative light on the province and spread fear in not only Quebec but all over Canada. From this event we can learn the real issue is not that: is one nation more important than the other? In the end we all human beings, even though we have our differences that make us into all our nation's, and if are able to “unite” as humanity then conflicts can be avoided. If this was the interpretation of the source than it should be accepted, however further reading shows that this is not the intention of the…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics