You have been invited to a conference on Roman archaeology focusing on life in the Roman Empire. Using your research from the sites at Vindolanda and Pompeii, explain the similarities and differences between the two sites.
You must include aspects of everyday life and values and beliefs. You must refer to the artefacts as examples to support your response.
Introductory paragraph:
Vindolanda and Pompeii are two sites that were included in the Roman Empire. They shared a number of things in common as they both had Roman influences. Some structures were similar as were artefacts that have been found and beliefs and attitudes that they shared. However, they were also very different. Vindolanda was an auxiliary fort (located south on Hadrian's Wall) built in order to defend the borders of the rapidly growing Roman Empire against northern tribes who were referred to as possible threats. Yet Pompeii was a large, prosperous town that inhabited approximately 20, 000 people and was engulfed by Vesuvius; an active volcano.
First paragraph: (In this paragraph outline the similarities between the sites)
Both Vindolanda and Pompeii were Roman towns. They shared similar religious beliefs as they both worshiped and valued different Roman god and goddesses who were each in charge of their specific field. For Vindolanda this was demonstrated through the Altar dedicated to Jupiter of Doliche which was used to worship a 'son' of Jupiter; a god with great power. Likewise, a shrine was found in the Cassa di Vettii, Pompeii which was used for worshiping lares who are also categorized as Roman Gods. People from Vindolanda used Roman currency to purchase goods.
This is evident from a coin discovered through the excavations of the site. We know that this formed part of the
Roman currency as it depicted Faustina who was the wife of a Roman emperor; Marcus Aurelius. Likewise, the people from Pompeii used coins as a currency in order to pay for goods and services as shown by a Sestertius coin depicting Marcus Aurelius. The two sites had many related Roman influenced structural forms which played a vital role in their society. A specific case of this for both Vindolanda and Pompeii were the suburban bath houses due to the fact that they were both architecturally designed based on typical Roman bath houses. Therefore, from the available evidence it is evident that Vindolanda and Pompeii shared many similarities in terms of structures, currency and aspects of life as they were both Roman.
Second paragraph:
While there were a number of similarities between Vindolanda and Pompeii, there were also many differences between these places. Vindolanda was a military fort in Britain and predominately occupied soldiers or military related people. This is reflected in the types of artefacts and structures found at Vindolanda, such as the workshops used in order to make weapons and armour as well as gladiator glass. In contrast, Pompeii was a prosperous provincial town in southern Italy, a few hours from Rome. They used shops to trade with people within the town.
This can be seen through bakeries and butchers. The housing in Vindolanda was also very different to that in
Pompeii. In Vindolanda the majority of soldiers were housed and slept in barracks which were places back to back with little space between them and the Commanding officer had his own house. On the other hand, housing in
Pompeii was more sophisticated. They were immensely decorated with stylish paintings, frescoes and sculptures to
improve the aesthetics of the environment which is seen in the Cassa di Vettii and Viller of Mysteries. Whereas life in Vindolanda revolved around the military, the people of Pompeii had a more relaxed lifestyle. Soldiers had to constantly train and prepare for battle in case of an upcoming threat however Pompeii just lived a calmer life and as many households possessed courtyards, many trips would be made there to admire the aesthetics. Thus it is evident that Pompeii and Vindolanda, while being influenced by Roman culture, were different through the factors of lifestyle,
Concluding paragraph: (In this brief paragraph summarise the main points from your response).
The discovery of the sites at Pompeii and Vindolanda has provided archaeologists with a lot of information about both sites. It is evident that although they have many aspects in common such as currency, structural forms, and religious beliefs, there are also factors that make the two sizes very different which include
Exposition Scaffold
An exposition text is used to argue or present a point of view. Usually the exposition ahs three main parts:
1. An introductory paragraph which outlines the main argument/point of view that will be developed in the response. 2. A series of paragraphs to present each idea. A new paragraph is begun to introduce a new idea. The paragraph structure should be followed:
a. Topic Sentence: The main idea is outlined
b. Elaboration: Provide more information to expand on the main idea.
c. Example: Evidence is presented to support the idea.
d. Explanation: Explain how the example reflects the main idea.
e. Concluding Statement: Briefly summarise the main ideas in your paragraph.
3. A concluding paragraph which summarises the main ideas presented in the previous paragraphs.
Word bank to show Comparison:
Similarly
Likewise
Also
As do
Similar to
Both
Like
Word bank to show Contrast:
Although
But
However
On the other hand
Differs from
Alternatively
Yet
Whereas
Instead
In contrast
These include
Word bank to introduce examples:
For example
For instance
Such as
As shown by
Including
This is demonstrated
While, as
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The Herculaneum bodies were found by the sea, whereas the remains in Pompeii were found there.…
- 403 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
As the ship crept around the stretch of land that shielded the bay of Pompeii, all eyes turned onto the small town. Horror and anxiety could be seen in all the sailors’ eyes, especially Tarquinius. What they were looking at was not a small town, but instead a lack of a town. Hordes of ash covered what used to be Pompeii. Nothing was left to be seen. Only silence remained. The year was now 79 AD, the year in which Vesuvius erupted and effectively wiped Pompeii completely off the map.…
- 1212 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The dramatic change from basically independent Samnite town to a Roman colony had of course a great impact on Pompeii’s townscape and the lifestyle of its inhabitants.…
- 1064 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Archaeological and written evidence has revealed to us many great revelations about the past, in this case, the past concerning household gods in Roman life during the first century AD. These revelations help us understand both their role and importance.…
- 940 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are various impacts of the changing methods of 19th and 20th century’s archaeologists in Pompeii and Herculaneum. Changes by archaeologists like Fiorelli, Spinazzoa and Maiuri have impacted and contributed to the discovery and knowledge of the past and attracted many archaeologists, historians, scientists and even tourists from around the world.…
- 406 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
deities were the same as the Greeks', but with a few changes. The Italians also…
- 466 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Life for children in Pompeii was hard. They were forced to work along side their parents, as the offspring of the wealthy went off to school.…
- 5425 Words
- 22 Pages
Good Essays -
Religion and death was an important part of everyday life in Pompeii and Herculaneum. Romans, like the Greeks and Egyptians were polytheists who worshipped a variety of gods. This is evident in the temples, household shrines, cults and tombs that were found in the cities.…
- 561 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Before the Roman colonization of Pompeii in 89 BCE, there was certainly considerable Roman influence in the town. For example, the Pompeiian magisterial positions of aidilis and kvaisstar were very similar to the Roman positions of aedile and quaestor. Still, the Romans brought many changes to public life. They instituted their own system of government, as well…
- 483 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
New research has immensely impacted on our understanding of daily life in both Pompeii and Herculaneum. Experts in archaeology, science and other fields have revealed copious amounts of information about people, buildings and food found in the two cities prior to the eruption in 62 AD.…
- 796 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
When war broke out the Romans would pray to Mars, Phoebes, Demoes, and Bellona. They prayed for wisdom, strength, and to fight without fear. With this thought the Romans conquered most if…
- 1074 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
* The Greek and Roman gods were a center of the lives of the noblemen, providing them with topics for conversation and reasons to donate money for the “good of Rome” in the form of temples and statues in their honor. Although it would seem that the Romans are fiercely committed to their religion, it is obvious in scenes like the dinner services at the house of Kalandion that they do this only for political gain or attention.…
- 2257 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Religion was an important part of everyday life in Pompeii and Herculaneum. It defined the way in which society went about things, and had a large influence in both towns. There were many differing religions available to the people of Pompeii and Herculaneum, ranging from foreign cults like that of the Egyptian god Isis, to cults that believed the emperor himself to be a god. All of these differing religions seem to be openly accepted and therefore indicates a fairly open societal mind when it came to religion. Evidence supporting this ideal teaches us about how they followed religion and the methods and locations for which they celebrated and worshipped associated deities.…
- 1264 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
This paper compares and contrasts the Greek and Roman Cultures. This paper compares and contrasts distinguishing elements or features of early Greek and Roman cultures, including illustrative or significant examples of the various features. This paper discusses the elements of both Greek and Roman culture such as: government and geographical terrain, economics and trade practices, art and architecture, and philosophical and religious beliefs. This paper will give readers clearer picture of the Greeks and Romans.…
- 508 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Romans worshipped their gods in a temple. They made sacrifices of animals and precious items to their gods. They believed that when their emperor died he became a god and sacrifice was also made to the emperor.…
- 320 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays