Toulmin Analysis of "It's the Abc Oscars: Anything but Crash"

Good Essays
Toulmin Analysis of "It 's the ABC Oscars: anything but Crash" The article "It 's the ABC Oscars: anything but Crash" can be found on the MSN News website. It is written by Erik Lundegaard, a movie critic whose opinion can be found regularly on MSNBC, in the Minneapolis Star Tribune, and in the Seattle Times ("Erik"). The article includes the basic elements of the Toulmin Model and can be analyzed according to the model. In the article, Lundegaard claims that the motion picture Crash should not be included on the ballot for best picture at the 2006 Academy Awards. The author 's claim is a claim of value, because it asserts his evaluation of the picture. Lundegaard supports his claim by stating his opinion that the movie gives an unrealistic view of a serious subject: the combination of race and class. He says the movie is not practical because the characters in the movie literally verbalize their racially-charged thoughts. He offers several examples of this from the movie. An Asian woman claims that Mexicans do not know how to drive. A Mexican makes fun of the way the Asian woman speaks. A white gun store owner calls a Persian man "Osama" and blames him for terrorist attacks. Lundegaard states that many people probably have thoughts similar to the statements in the movie, but rarely ever make the thoughts known to others. He also says the movie has another problem: "it assumes that by showing us the two extremes of a single character it 's giving us a full character." He demonstrates this through a few examples from the movie including scenes when Matt Dillon 's character humiliates an African-American woman and later risks his life to save hers. The author states that seeing two extreme sides of a character does not give a good view of the full character. Lundegaard warrants his claim with the principle that a movie with these problems should not be nominated for an Academy Award. The warrant is based on ethos because


Cited: "Erik Lundegaard." Rotten Tomatoes 2006. 28 Feb 2006 . Gass, Robert, Ph.D. "Toulmin Model of Argument." 28 Feb 2006 . Lundegaard, Erik. "It 's the ABC Oscars: anything but Crash." 28 Feb 2006. 28 Feb 2006 .

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    without overstepping any boundaries. The Toulmin method is essentially a guide for analyzing the structures of arguments. Nevertheless, this method is more effective for arguments with no absolute truths or clear solutions. This lets the writer know how to use and understand the information. There are six elements for presenting arguments in the Toulmin method: claim, grounds, warrant, backing, qualifier, and rebuttal. These elements of a Toulmin analysis can help one as both a reader and a writer;…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Toulmin Analysis of "Attraction" In "The Mystery of Attraction," Harville Hendrix claims that attraction between human beings is based on a number of factors that ultimately leave human beings baffled on exactly how humans experience such intense emotions as seen in romantic love and why so many couples tend to have complementary characteristics. He supports this claim by explaining several theories of attraction. His biological theory of courtship states that "we instinctively select mates…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    toulmin analysis

    • 505 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Delphine Webster Mr. Jackson Marijuana vs Alcohol Marijuana is the most used illicit drug in the United States. You have been encouraged to believe that marijuana causes lung cancer and is a “gateway” to harder drugs. The truth is that marijuana is widely used in a manner quite similar to alcohol. Adults might consume it before enjoying a dinner party with friends. Friends might have a little before engaging in a spirited game of ultimate Frisbee. And spouses – yes, even some couples you know…

    • 505 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ABC Analysis

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages

    ABC Analysis What is it? There is nothing simpler than a business set up- gather capital, invest it with a proper business plan in mind and reap the profit! However the mechanisms involved in the second step of the process involves a lot of calculations, prior proper planning and formulating effective business methods. Generally if it is a small business set up the steps are simple but as the business continues to expand, the number of assets of the company increases and to maintain these assets…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Abc Analysis

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages

    ABSTRACT The ABC analysis is a well known and practical classification of inventory items based on the Pareto principle. The purpose of ABC analysis is to classify the inventory into different groups of A, B, or C, according to importance based on measure of a criterion. Traditionally, the classification of inventory into the A, B, or C categories have generally been based on dollar value per unit multiplied by annual usage rate, commonly known as dollar usage. In recent years, several multi criteria…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hi Lindsay, I completely agree with you when you mentioned how people do not utilize a Toulmin argument as much because a lot of people do not have strong opinions on topics anymore or at least they do not express it. When I was making my response to this prompt and had to find an example of where people use the Toulmin argument format I had some trouble. Your explanation helped to answer my problem.…

    • 75 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    abc analysis

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages

    ABC ANALYSIS In supply chain, ABC analysis is an inventory categorization method which consists in dividing items into three categories, A, B and C: A being the most valuable items, C being the least valuable ones. This method aims to draw managers’ attention on the critical few (A-items) and not on the trivial many (C-items). The ABC approach states that, when reviewing inventory, a company should rate items from A to C, basing its ratings on the following rules: A-items are goods which annual…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Toulmin Model

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Back on “1958” Stephen Toulmin proposed the six terms as a model of communication designed to analyze the court room rhetorician’s argument. These included the three legs of communication, which are writer, subject, and audience supporting the claims of fact, value and policy, in others words, claim is an author’s proposition in which he/she is trying to prove a statement. In addition, Wayne Brockriede and Douglas Ehninger brought to coaction the six key terms in Toulmin model connecting the three…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ABC Analysis

    • 809 Words
    • 2 Pages

    ABC Analysis for Towels More Towels and More is a small family company that is looking to expand their company. Out of the three types of stores they sell too (major retailers, specialty retailers, and gift shops), gift shops has the highest contribution margin so the CEO believes in order to have a successful expansion, they need to pursue gift shops. The marketing manager on the other hand would like to utilize the Activity Based Costing (ABC) approach to analyze the high customer distribution…

    • 809 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To illustrate the Toulmin Model, there is a situation where two friends, Amy and Penny, are arguing about which one of them would buy a particular dress. Amy claims she would because it suits her. As a result, Penny tells her to prove it. Amy explains how the dress is in her size, the color goes well with her, and that Penny only has enough money to buy some pants. With this new information, the data, Penny makes a realization, the warrant, of how her friend has a point so she lets Amy buy the…

    • 96 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays