Debby Lopez, Katie Pham, Visish Srinivasan, Catiana Syllien, Marie Christine Uwamahoro Drexel University
ECON 240 1
Dr. Edward A Tomczyk
12 November 2006
Economic Analysis of Outpatient Care Centers vs. Hospitals
A recent phenomenon in the health services is the burgeoning of outpatient healthcare centers. Particularly vigorous growth has been observed in centers that perform diagnostic tests and simple surgeries and procedures like colonoscopies. At the current state, outpatient care centers outnumber hospitals in Pennsylvania. Furthermore, these centers now perform one of every four surgical and diagnostic procedures in the state (Levy 2006). However, the trend applies nationwide, and other states could easily follow suit. Many critics have commented on the negative and positive aspects of this trend. What remains to be determined are the long term effects (on health and the economy) of this paradigm shift, in terms of the wellness of the community as well as economically. Proponents of the movement have pointed to the lower overhead for these clinics trickling down to lower costs for patients. However, critics skeptically question whether the real benefits are for the patients or simply as a mechanism to stuff physicians' wallets. When considered as firms in the marketplace, it is evident that these two groups, both servicing the health needs of the community, have vastly different balance sheets and income statements. This transfers over to a difference in operational functionality, profitability, and cost structure. Furthermore, the disparity of financial motivations that is visible in the varying profit margins is of concern to the community. All of these are important considerations to be made when considering the economic implications of this new phenomenon.
The most important aspect of this shift to analyze is the health aspect how effective and safe are outpatient clinics in relation to inpatient clinics. In an article published in the New England Journal of Medicine, a consortium of physicians observed the effectiveness of various treatments and long term mortality rates of patients. It found that there was no significant change in the mortality rates and effectiveness of the treatments when observed in the long term; thus, outpatient clinics were a viable alternative (from the health perspective) to inpatient centers. Aside from severe cases, outpatient centers even provided better care in the psychiatric unit as well as some others.
The trend of outpatient care centers is not a recent one; it has been ongoing since the early 1990s. In the first five years of the decade, outpatient visits rose by 27%. This trend has only continued to grow, as health care groups strive to streamline in the face of rising costs. By applying techniques of quadratic regression on the data provided by the House Ways and Means Committee, one can see the level of growth is gaining momentum the rate of the change is increasing quite rapidly. Thus, as we delve deeper into the first decade of the millennium, the trend continues as outpatient centers eclipse the inpatient centers.
As stated before, one of the major advantages of the outpatient clinic as opposed to a traditional inpatient hospital is the variance in costs, which often correlates with a variance in prices to patients. A study done at the Veterans Hospital in Palo Alto, CA evaluated the finances of their substance abuse and psychiatric centers in outpatient and inpatient settings. These are two of the areas that are often praised by those who tout the superiority of outpatient systems over hospitals, as they are high-cost to hospitals. As compared to other studies done in the field, it was found to be more accurate as the Department of Veterans Affairs ran the operation in conjunction with Stanford; this allowed for an in-depth view of the proceedings as well as a closer comparison since the two programs were run by the same group. The study found that...
References: Hearle, K., Koenig, L., Rudowitz, R., Siegel, J. M., Dobson, A., & Ho, S. (2003, 2003). Drivers of expenditure growth in outpatient care services. The American Journal of Managed Care, 9, sp25-2p33. Retrieved November 7, 2006
Martin, A., & Leslie, D
February 1999. Date retrieved November 7, 2006 from http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/281/7/644
U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. February 1997. Date Retrieved
November 7, 2006 from http://www.gpo.gov/congress/house/ways-and-means/sec1.pdf
Armstrong, David (2006). U.S. Seeks to More Tightly Restrict Doctors ' Billings for
Levy, Marc (2006)
The Miami Herald. Retrieved November 7, 2006 from
Harvey Jay Cohen, John R. Feussner, Morris Weinberger, Molly Carnes, Frank Hsieh, Philip Lavori. (1996).
The New England Journal of Medecine
John B. Pollard, Ann L. Zboray, Richard I Mazze. The International Anesthesia Research Society. (1996).
Economic Benefit Attributed to Opening a Preoperative Evaluation Clinic for Outpatients, 83,407-10
Please join StudyMode to read the full document