Preview

The Garden Party by Katherine Mansfield

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
638 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Garden Party by Katherine Mansfield
This essay is written by Liesanne den Hollander
On the date of 4 October 2011

This short story, written by Mansfield, tells us about Laura, who is a girl belonging to the upper class, about her garden party, and about the death of a workers man. Since Mansfield’s father was a successful businessman , she also belonged to the upper class. Therefore, it is prominent that Laura and Mansfield seem to share the same opinion about class differences; which is that everybody should be treated equally. Furthermore, the implied author in this narrative shows some similarities with the real author, this is for the main reason that they both do not like the narrowness of class differences. From the author we logically move on to the implied reader. The implied reader is the ideal reader of a text, which means it has certain opinions that are conform to the text. However, there can be multiple sorts of readers in ‘The Garden Party’. The ideal reader is the one sharing the opinions of Laura. These views are mainly related to class differences, but also to life and death. Another reader is the resistant reader, who does not agree with Laura’s opinion and probably thinks the way classes are treated is just fine. The events in this narrative take place in a chronological order, which means that there is no real mismatch between the narrative content and form. Also, something interesting in this narrative is the use of inter clausal connectives. A. Rodrigue suggests this supports the cohesion of the narrative. When this text is read it gives the impression that a cultural code is required; which, in this case, involves knowledge about class differences. Furthermore, another feature in this narrative is the ending. It has an open and partly unresolved ending . This type of ending is characteristic for modernist narratives. This narrative starts with a voice, the focaliser, which draws the scene for us. After a while this focaliser shifts; first to the gardener, then

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    also gives way to understanding how objective reality is conveyed in this story on a social level. In…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    White uses a chronological structure to keep the reader engaged with the text throughout the narration. He establishes his story by introducing his morals and his beliefs that “if I worked hard, was a good person, and always told the truth, the world will be my oyster,” which subsequently is crushed. Nevertheless, being aware of his upbringing contributes to understanding why the event affects his perspective deeply and why he “sat down crying silent tears of disappointment” as throughout this time he was believing in a false statement. Also, the detailed account of the day, from the “usual trip to the bank,” and a “pleasant day” to the becoming of a “real-life Coalhouse Walker” creates suspense and a sense of connection with the text to a point where the reader can visualize the events taking place, and feel the tension and confusion, when the author is bewildered by the actions of the stereotypical society. Furthermore, the first person narrative adds to the connection because the reader can identify the anger and be a part of White’s thoughts.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The virtue of toughness in the face of the Bush 's harshness is an important aspect of the Australian Legend, and central to Henry Lawson 's short story, "Water Them Geraniums." This toughness is made possible by mate ship that is often associated, for example in Lawson 's Mitchell stories, with masculinity. In this essay, I will argue that Lawson has broadened mate ship to incorporate women who appear to be the frontier of the Bush. Firstly, identification of Lawson 's personal history that connects with the characters and themes in "Water Them Geraniums" will be discussed. Further discussion on how Lawson 's narrative and style are used in the short story to incorporate the elements of the Australian Legend. Followed on by how the Bush 's harshness is tough on women who are the frontier in the Bush trying to evade the madness. Concluding with how mate ship combined with humor has been given importance in the short story.…

    • 1327 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In both of Katherine Mansfield’s stories, “The Garden Party” and “Bliss” we can find this “multiple personality” in the main characters. In the first one we have Laura, who is a young lady of a well-positioned family in an upper class neighborhood. The young woman’s world is presented almost like a fantasy; the description of the environment is filled up with “perfect beauty”. The girl is not like the other members of her family, she seems to reflect about the things she is doing and is affected by the non-immediate world around her. Laura is afflicted by her doubts, she is constantly struggling with her social aspirations and the materialism that surrounds her; she wants to embrace all her goods and privileges, but at the same time cannot ignore that there is much more in the world than wealth and money. She is trying to understand what the right thing to do is; she is afflicted by her doubts and cannot be indifferent to others like his family. The character truly realizes about this when she finds out that her working-class neighbor has died in a tragic event. The girl feels it is not right to celebrate a party when their neighbors are saying goodbye to a member of their family in such a sad way. Laura tries to convince their family to cancel the party, but they don’t take her seriously and even attack her, crushing her kind-hearted gesture. The character is trapped into this materialistic and indifferent world, while she is trying to determine how she should be living her life; the way she believes she should be living it or the way society expects her to live it? In the second story, “Bliss” we are presented with Bertha Young a woman in his thirties that has an overwhelming feeling of bliss and happiness at every occasion of her life. She considers that she is living a perfect life, a good husband, a kid, a good social status, everything anybody would want. But the truth is that she is living a fake life. She is an “immature” woman and has a cold relation with…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    III. Through the appearances and actions of Mr. Nilson and Mr. Tandram, one can truly see how rigid the Victorian upper-middle class was. “His firm, well-coloured cheeks, with their neat brown mustaches, and his round, well-opened, clear grey eyes, wore a reassuring appearance of good health. Putting on his black frock-coat, he went downstairs.” The two neighbors are IDENTICAL when it comes to appearance. It is almost eerie. Both men look at the tree holding their paper behind their backs. The posture, attitude, clothing, and physical characteristics are all the same. This serves to show just how alike all of the upper-middle class is. Both of the men wear black frock-coats. The black is symbolic of the death that they will die. They are…

    • 636 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    her. The beginning of the story is told from the white people 's perspectives as they see an old black woman come to their church and go inside. Inside the church, the point of view switches to the usher who tells the old black lady to leave. The point of view then switches back to the white women inside the church, who take it as a personal insult and feel the most threatened about the old black lady being at their church. They rouse their husbands to throw the old lady out. The perspective then changes to the old black lady. This constant changing of point of view is useful in that it portrays the fears, thoughts, and feelings of almost everyone in the story. Firsthand, the reader is able to know what the people are thinking and why. In the end, the point of view briefly returns to the white people who were at church that day. The story ends with the perspective of some black families wher. The beginning of the story is told from the white people 's perspectives as they see an old black woman come to their church and go inside. Inside the church, the point of view switches to the usher who tells the old black lady to leave. The point of view then switches back to the white women inside the church, who take it as a personal insult and feel the most threatened about the old black lady being at their church. They rouse their husbands to throw the old lady out. The perspective then changes to the old black lady. This constant changing of point of view is useful in that it portrays the fears, thoughts, and feelings of almost everyone in the story. Firsthand, the reader is able to know what the people are thinking and why. In the end, the point of view briefly returns to the white people who were at church that day. The story ends with the perspective of some black families who witnessed the old lady walking down the highway. ho witnessed the old lady walkiher. The beginning of the story is told from the white people 's perspectives as they see an old black woman come…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    The partaking of society is evident in many stories. Often society’s role is especially evident and plays a huge part in a story’s plot. In most situations, a rejection—whether by society or by the main characters themselves—occurs that typically results in complete isolation from the outside world. Such is seen with John Updike’s “A & P,” William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily,” and Katherine Mansfield’s “Miss Brill,” as the main character is generally has a dispute with society in some way. By analyzing the main characters in these stories, one can come to a conclusion as to how the contrasting of society with the main character gives insight into a character’s thought process and assists in developing him or her.…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    The initial descriptions of setting and geography influence the purpose of any character, theme or symbol. In the book “A Lesson Before Dying” the courthouse and segregation along with syntactic balance patterns play an important role in influencing those three things…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author has achieved the purpose of this novel. The text is conveyed effectively to the reader. The colloquial style contains a tone that varies between disgust and bitterness; which strongly enhances our understanding of the novel. The narrative structure is presented as a flashback; requiring the reader to interpret the text based on their knowledge. The writing techniques are also used cleverly. The author describes the man characters psychological breakdown indirectly, yet the reader still recognises the breakdown. This is because the author uses two distinctive writing techniques.…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Feminist Analysis of The Color Purple by Alice Walker In Alice Walkers The Color Purple, we have the narrator, Celie, writing letters to God talking to Him about what is going on in her life. The setting of the story takes place in the state of Georgia where Celie, the main character, plays the role of a typical feminine stereotype throughout the novel.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The speaker of the poem tells of his visit to the Garden of Love and of the chapel that is now where he used to play as a child. Instead of welcoming him in, the chapel has 'Thou shalt not' of the Ten Commandments written over the door. The speaker sees that this negative morality has destroyed the garden as well, transforming the 'sweet flowers' to graves and tombstones. The emotionless ritual of the priests 'walking their rounds' threatens to choke out the speaker's life itself. …

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Narrative Instance

    • 1428 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Most of authors or writers are telling their emotion, opinion, thoughts, and feeling through their masterpiece. They usually make a story and smuggle their opinion or thoughts into the story. Sometimes the reader does not realize about it because they hide them well behind the story they made. Some of the writers use a narrator to be a mediator for them to deliver their opinion or thoughts about something. For example when the writer wants to express their protest about their family background and he or she cannot tell anyone or when the writer thoughts about his or her environment, so that they will express it through their story. It happens sometimes but not all of the writers do this. Talking about narrator, this is a very important aspect in a story. Narrator is somebody who tells a story. Narrator will guide the reader where the story goes, why the story happens, and also how the story happens. The concept of the story and what the narrator role of the story is called narratology. It would be better if we know the definition of it first. Narratology is one of literature approaches that examines the ways of narrative structures between our perception of both cultural artifacts and the world around us. To understand narratology theory we have to know the difference between these three important entities. They are story, narrative, and narration. According to Gerard Genette, the story generally corresponds to a series of events and actions that are told by someone (the narrator), and represented in some final form, producing a narrative. As a field of study, narratology looks at the internal mechanisms of narrative, the form taken by a narrated story. Narratology has some branches that can be used for analyzing literary texts. Such as narrative mood, narrative instance, level, and time. This essay will discuss and analized David Lodge’s Changing Places using…

    • 1428 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Narrative

    • 2516 Words
    • 11 Pages

    A narrative is a story, whether told in prose or verse, involving events, characters, and what the characters say and do. Some literary forms such as the novel and short story in prose, and the epic and romance in verse, are explicit narratives that are told by a narrator. In drama , the narrative is told, but not evolves by means of the direct presentation on stage of actions and speeches of the characters. It should be noted that there is an implicit narrative element even in many lyric poems. In William Wordsworth ‘s “The Solitary Reaper”, for example, we infer from what the lyric speaker says that, coming unexpectedly in the Scottish Highlands upon a girl reaping and singing, he stops, attends, mediates, and then resumes his climb up the hill. While this paper is based on the comparative study of any two texts on the basis of narrative mode. Hence lets begin too discuss what narrative mode is all about, well it is the set of methods which the author of a literary, theatrical, cinematic, or musical story uses to convey the plot to the audience. Narration, the process of presenting the narrative, occurs because of the narrative mode. It encompasses several overlapping areas of concern, most importantly narrative point-of-view, which determines through whose perspective the story is viewed and narrative voice, which determines a set of consistent features regarding the way through which the story is communicated to the audience. This paper, based on the stylistic analysis of the point of view in two texts Araby and The Last Leaf well it tries to explore the narrative strategy of James Joyce and O. Henry .…

    • 2516 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As T.S. Eliot once said, “Every age gets the art it deserves and every age must accept the art it gets. A complex age like the 20th century, upset by two World Wars and marked by unrest and ferments, couldn’t as result produce anything but complex art, mainly resulting, more than in any previous age, from experimentation. The search for new forms of expression, which affected all branches of literature, was carried on first of all in fiction and novel. So far novelists had concentrated above all on plots, and their main preoccupation had been with characters in society, since they thought that the function of novels was to present people in a social context, so that they became mirrors of their own age. The English novel was essentially bourgeois in its origin and throughout the 18th and the 19th centuries it was firmly anchored in a social world. The novelist used to make digression, address the reader, comment on his own performance, and he was faced with a relatively easy task : he was expected to mediate between his characters and the reader, relating in a more or less objective way significant events and incidents in a chronological order. The existence of accepted social values and standards of behaviour led to the presentation of a social pattern which was familiar territory to both reader and writer. Naturalism brought nothing new from this point of view and the structure of the novel remained basically unaltered. In the 20th century, instead, preoccupation began to shift from society to man himself; characters became all important, because of their inner selves and not because of what was going on outside and around them. The novelist rejected omniscient narration and experimented new methods to portray the individual consciousness; the viewpoint shifted from the external world to the internal world of a character’s mind. The analysis of a character’s consciousness was influenced by the theories about the simultaneous…

    • 1531 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays