top-rated free essay

The Ethical and Legal Status of the Foetus

By naveen484 May 04, 2013 1088 Words
THE ETHICAL AND LEGAL STATUS OF THE FOETUS
The difficult question of when life actually begins has often led to several complicated and controversial decisions worldwide. Does life commence at twenty four weeks’ gestation, when a foetus can continue to exist outside the womb or twenty two weeks, because of recent advances in bio-medical healthcare? Can this timeline be brought down to eight weeks, when an embryo is deemed a foetus or should life simply begin from conception, as Muslims, Christians, and Buddhists believe? Abortion and foeticide (any act that causes the death of the foetus, including foetal homicide) are the two most commonly debated aspects of foetal law and ethics (Chervenak & McCullough, 2009). Abortion law differs significantly around the world. In Canada abortion is available with no legal constraints. In Ireland, abortion is illegal except when the mother’s life is in immediate danger while in Chile, abortion is illegal with no exceptions for the mother’s life (Zampas & Gher, 2008). Abortion in Australia is governed by state law rather than national law and there are large inconsistencies in these laws between states and territories (Philips, Eltherington, de Costa, & Woods, 2012). Many of these laws originated during the formation of the Australian states at the end of the 19th century although most have undergone various levels of reform since then (Peterson, 2010). Thus far, abortion has only been officially decriminalized in Victoria and the ACT. Legal statutes of all other states have declared abortion legal only if the risk to the mother’s life is greater than it would be if the pregnancy is not terminated. The upper limit of gestation to justify abortion however varies from state to state - up to twenty three weeks in the Northern Territory, up to twenty two weeks in Queensland and possibly up to twenty eight weeks in South Australia (Peterson, 2011). South Australia, Western Australia and the Northern Territory have also recently passed laws legalizing abortion if the foetus is likely to be born with life threatening complications or serious handicaps. In this case, abortion has to be performed in an approved medical facility and recommended by two physicians (de Costa, 2012). The ethics of abortion have been a source of much discontent and debate for several decades. As Malcolm Potts (2010, p. 158) said, “Abortion is not a war with a victory or surrender. It is not a widespread, instant catastrophe like a tsunami. It is simply a slow moving muddy river sweeping along human anguish, suffering and hypocrisy made up of tens of millions of isolated, private events.” Most ethical questions surrounding abortion usually involve the question of abortion in cases of rape, incest or contraception failure. Potts (2010) wrote that the 15 - 20 minute abortion procedure on a teen pregnancy resulting from rape had the potential to radically change the course of the next half century of the girl’s life. The question of whether the foetus is a person with rights and whether the foetus can feel pain has also often been related to the topic of abortion. A recent report by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists states definitively that the foetus cannot feel pain before twenty four weeks although this has been disputed by several medical critics (Cohen & Sayeed, 2011). Pro choice activists also argue that it would be unethical to force a woman to give birth to an unwanted child. Women who choose to abort when they cannot care properly for the child are after all making the most ethical decision available to them. The legal status of the foetus in Australia with regard to foeticide is also currently shrouded with controversy. Presently an unborn human being has no rights under Australian criminal law and is not considered to be a person. Only when the baby is fully removed from the mother’s womb and has independently taken a breath, does it attain the “status of a legal persona” (Walsh, 2010). Foetal conceptions in criminal law again vary from state to state. In Queensland a person can be charged for killing an unborn child by deliberate assault or by the transmission of a serious disease. Western Australia has also planned similar laws but is yet to pass them through Parliament. In all other states criminal charges cannot be brought forward for the deaths of unborn children resulting from incidents such as domestic violence and vehicular accidents where the driver is at fault because the foetus does not have legal rights until it is born (Walsh, 2010). Many of Australia’s foetal laws are antiquated and inconsistent. While foetal homicide laws are under intense debate, opinion polls show that the most Australians support women having the choice of abortion. Political pressure and the fear of these topics influencing elections make it difficult to unify these laws (de Crespigny, 2004) but it is high time that the federal government introduces a single, national law for the legal aspects of the foetus.

Reference List

Chervenak, F. A., & McCullough, L. B. (2009). An ethically justified practical approach to offering, recommending, performing, and referring for induced abortion and feticide. Am J Obstet Gynecol, 201(6), 560 e561-566. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2009.05.057

Cohen, I. G., & Sayeed, S. (2011). Fetal pain, abortion, viability, and the Constitution. J Law Med Ethics, 39(2), 235-242. doi: 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2011.00592.x

de Costa, C. (2012) Medical Abortion: The Australian Experience. Expert Review of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 7(1), 25-30. doi: 10.1586/eog.11.75

de Crespigny, L. J., & Savulescu, J. (2004). Abortion: time to clarify Australia's confusing laws. Med J Aust, 181(4), 201-203. doi: dec10242_fm [pii]

Petersen, K. A. (2010). Early medical abortion: legal and medical developments in Australia. Med J Aust, 193(1), 26-29. doi: pet11164_fm [pii]

Petersen, K. (2011). Abortion laws and medical developments: a medico-legal anomaly in Queensland. J Law Med, 18(3), 594-600.

Phillips, T., Eltherington, J., de Costa, C., & Woods, C. (2012). Knowledge of abortion law and provision of abortion services amongst tertiary students in Far North Queensland. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol, 52(3), 299-301. doi: 10.1111/j.1479-828X.2012.01421.x

Potts, M. (2010) Abortion Perspectives. The European Journal of Contraception and Reproductive Health Care, 15, 157-159. doi: 10.3109/13625181003775146

Zampas, C, & Gher, J, M. (2008) Abortion as a human right - International and Regional Standards. Human Rights Law Review, 8(2), 249-294. doi: 10.1093/hrlr/ngn008

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Legal Ethical

    ...Jamie Clagg December 1, 2014 Abortion and the Ethics Abortion is a subject that touches on various ethical, social, religious, and legal issues. Abortions is a very controversial issue. It is one of the most intensely debated ethical issues. Abortion is defined as: the deliberate termination of a pregnancy. Advocates really only have two sid...

    Read More
  • Moral Status of the Foetus

    ...not widely held in society. The extreme liberal view states that “the foetus is, in most if not all morally relevant respects, like a piece of tissue or a bit of the human body” (Hursthouse, 1987). The extreme liberal view in standard form looks like this: An unfertilised ovum has the same moral status as a piece of tissue. Working forwa...

    Read More
  • On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion

    ...Edwin Carter Jr. Session Paper Draft Applied Ethics October 15, 2010 “On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion”, an essay written by Mary Anne Warren, defend abortion in any stage of a woman’s pregnancy (pg 468). Warren argues that the potential to become a human being is not the same as being human and deserving the same right t...

    Read More
  • AS1 RESEARCH LEGAL AND ETHICAL PRACTICES

    ... PROVIDE A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF YOUR CHOSEN ORGANISATION AND ROLE Ozcare is a leading not-for-profit organisation, providing a diverse range of quality health and human services from over 60 locations throughout Queensland. Our commitment is to provide clients with only the highest standards of care and every day we provide aged care and com...

    Read More
  • legal & ethical

    ... Read the articles below and analyze the ethical and legal aspects of the actions taken by the cola giants. What, if anything, should they do? Indian Coke, Pepsi Laced with Pesticides, Says NGO   By Ranjit Devraj Inter Press Service August 5, 2003 NEW DELHI -- One of India's leading voluntary agencies, the Center for Science and En...

    Read More
  • Legal and Ethical

    ...Jacob Fischer BUS - 340 November 8, 2013 Ryan Kelly The Legal and Ethical Considerations of Marketing in America Paper What is legal and what is ethical can be identical in some circumstances and varied in others. To this end, marketing is an especially challenging industry. It deals with both consumer and industry interaction. The o...

    Read More
  • Do Resuscitate Status: a Legal and Ethical Challenge for Nursing

    ...Do Resuscitate Status: A Legal and Ethical Challenge for Nursing Shawn Wolkart Senior Integrative Seminar Spring A semester, 2010 University of Saint Mary Abstract A status of do resuscitate in those critically ill patients may result in a slow code. A slow code is a situation where the nursing staff decides to do less than th...

    Read More
  • Legal&Ethical

    ...Course: Legal & Ethical Environment Professor: Dr. Libertella Chapter 16 Business Ethics Perspective P419 1. Stewart was not an insider of ImClone and she received the tip from her stockbroker. Does she have an ethical obligation to ask where the tip came from or why the broker was recommending selling the stock? Does the fact that S...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.