In the first few paragraphs she writes in a first person tone, observing the box man, she uses words such as, “silent fervor”, “dogged by luck”, and that he sits with “slow care” and opens newspapers “with ease”, which would be opposite of what most people would think of a “lonely” person, but actually he’s living a life of solitude. She then uses words such as “bland stares”, “strangers”, “exile” to describe the lonely people, the lady down the hall and the lady in the shop.
She provides the two examples of the lady in the shop, having a lonely lifestyle and assumes that she is all alone, she has kids but don’t want to see her, and she also talks about the lady down the hall that spends her time watching tv all day, which would seem normal to us, this provides her with credibility or ethos.
She then demonstrates pathos, when she consistently questions herself “may she not know what the box man knows” or what the lady does after eating at the shop past 6pm, or the lady who sits at home watching tv all day. Later on she starts to understand the box man, where as he can choose to listen to people or not, he lives in a free caring life that he chose to be alone and friends with himself rather than the women who did not choose but fell into loneliness.
She finally comes to the conclusion that the box man conquers over loneliness by choosing to live in a life of solitude and become a friend of his own, to understand himself completely, compared to the women who don’t know what to do anymore or seem very lonely, but instead he is very happy with his own carefree life and able to be happy, and in the last sentence she says “One could do worse than be a collector of boxes”, telling us that there’s worse life styles than being in solitude.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
This essay implies to the reader that loneliness isn’t always a vile thing. The author compares somebody who has absolutely nothing in life but enjoys the solitude, to people who roam through life alone, seeking for company—but never find it. The author compares the chosen lifestyle of the box man, to the undesired for loneliness of the victims. The author explains that although one may be poor and alone, it does not mean that one is unhappy. For example, in paragraph 12 it is explained that the mayor has offered him help, but the box man pushes it away. In paragraph 18 it is described how the box man enjoys his dark life. It is portrayed that life is a solo journey and that one may be much more miserable by going through life accompanied than by being a collector of boxes.…
- 743 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
To start off, Ascher uses the rhetorical strategy of compare and contrast to reflect on the nature of solitude. She compares the characteristics of the people she studies to additional items to give us a clearer picture of the scenario. Ascher first compares the Box Man to a book she read as a child. She utters that the book, The Boxcar Children, reminisces her of the Box Man because in the book, orphan children learn to live independently and choose wise alternatives to survive alone just like the Box Man lives independently and makes use of what few resources he has. Ascher compares her experience reading a story and why that story reminded her of the Box Man. She employs this comparison to exaggerate the brilliant fortune she tries to portray of the Box Man being alone to prove to us that being alone by choice isn’t strife but that it is something to yearn. Next, the author contrasts the Box Man’s good fortune with that of a woman who eats soup alone every night and that of a woman who subsists alone with cats. Ascher describes the woman that eats soup alone as someone that is discontent because she has nil to live for anymore. The woman doesn’t get any visitors and she shows no signs of having someone special in her life that cares for her and vise versa. Basically Ascher depicts the woman who eats soup as a miserable elderly who is unhappy because she is…
- 883 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
She speaks of how she longs to live like the children in her favorite book, The Boxcar Children, “never worried” about their “next meal” and to be “ingenious with simple things,” similar to the Box Man (9,10). She almost expresses envy toward the boxman’s content attitude even though he is homeless. Ascher further explains that the Box Man should not be confused with lonely individuals, such as the woman in the coffeeshop or the woman who lives across from the author, who both appear to have their material necessities but live bland lives of unchosen solitude, seemingly waiting for someone to approach them. She conveys a sense of pity toward the women, also acknowledging that people like them are everywhere. She juxtaposes the women and the Boxman through the use of diction which expresses the perceived prolonging of time and the uneventfulness of the women’s life, and diction which brings the Box Man into the story with a pleasant image. For example, she explains how the woman has a “vacancy of expression” and “drags” her food out, splitting her crackers “first in halves and then halves of halves” (14, 13). She also uses words such as “exile,” and “outcasts,” to convey the unchosen solitude of the two women. Furthermore, the highly detailed description of the picture of the family the woman in the coffee shop receives highlights the possible lack of those things in her life. Ascher in…
- 719 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This sort of obsession is shown through her internal monologue, short stories, and imagery when she stays home from war to care for her mother, continues to search for her brother, and takes in a stranger from off the streets. While caring for her mother, brother, and Joe made the narrator feel secure, staying isolated from the rest of her town to do so only delayed her exposure to the dangers of the…
- 1085 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In The Box Man, by Barbara Lazear Ascher, the protagonist reveals that a life of solitude need not always be lonely. Though the Box Man lives a life of solitude as a homeless wanderer, Ascher describes his “grand design” and “grandmotherly finger licking” to convince readers that their assumptions about homeless people are unfounded – and that they can live a dignified life. By describing the Box Man as “dignified” and “at ease”, Ascher paints a vivid picture of a man who chose a life a comfort and solitude and defeated loneliness by becoming his own…
- 97 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Barbra Lazear Ascher’s “The Boxman” is a composition about loneliness and different aspects of it. Ascher takes loneliness and portrays it in different characters such as the Box Man, the lady in the coffee shop and the lady in in her apartment. She shows that the simplicity of chosen loneliness is less painful than the complications of loneliness forced upon you.…
- 423 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout both stores, the protagonists go through changes in their lives, judgements by society and the act of feeling worthless due to isolation. Together, Mrs. Wright and Olenka demonstrate changes in their lifestyle after marriage when what they love can no longer be in their possession. At the same time, both are judged by the members of their society without knowledge on the events in their lives. Isolation from neighbours and the community result in Mrs. Wright and Olenka growing the sense of insignificance to others. Isolation also creates psychological changes in the characters’ well-being. If they only have the opportunity to love one thing, they will never want it taken out of their hands and if it is they will be left with a scar. On the whole, over a long period of time, isolation creates negative effects on human beings and can create a whole different…
- 1421 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
In particular, just after one of her more innocent-sounding remarks about marriage, the narrator states, “I get unreasonably angry with John sometimes. I’m sure I never used to be so sensitive. I think it is due to this nervous condition” (Gilman, 71). Although she says it is probably due to her condition, the reader cannot help but wonder why, only a few paragraphs later, she reveals that despite her love for writing, “He hates to have me write a word” (Gilman, 72). This narrator is clearly feeling trapped in a marriage that does not allow her freedom. Meanwhile, as a man, her husband is free to come and go. This inability for her to express herself in a meaningful way eventually leads her to associate herself with the woman in the wallpaper who looks to be, like the narrator, behind bars or in a cage.…
- 661 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Everyone in their lifetime desires the comfort of a friend, but will settle for the attentive ear of a stranger. In the novel, Of Mice and Men, Steinbeck shows how lonely people were during the 1930’s. He teaches a grim lesson about the nature of human existence, and how the characters in the story had to admit at one time or another to having a profound sense of loneliness and isolation. Although each character had their own secluded troubles, Curley’s wife, Crooks, and Candy, suffered the most from loneliness.…
- 984 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Samantha McPherson R.Bishop English 1312 Comp II Online 6 Oct. 2011 Miss Brill & Miss Emily Emily Grierson from “A Rose for Emily” and Miss Brill from the story “Miss Brill” are two women that are trying to relive their past in the present time. In these stories, you are taken into the lives of two elderly women living very different lives, yet sharing many characteristics. You wouldn’t think to compare these two characters, but if you do, they are strikingly similar in many ways. In addition to being significantly alike, they also have their obvious differences. From the very beginning of both stories, we can tell that the women are lonely.…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
She was afraid to open up and meet new people. She thought she would continue to live her life alone; however, that wasn’t the case. At the end, she being to go out more and met new people.…
- 1132 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
As a result of the narrators "temporary nervous depression" (221), her husband takes her to a secluded estate that is away from the road and the nearest town. In his efforts to help her, he decided that it would be best to keep her locked upstairs in a room that is called a nursery, although it resembles a room for an insane person that was perhaps kept there once before. And although she disagreed with his ideas and believed that "congenial work, with excitement and change, would do her good” (223), there was not much she could say to him directly. He "assures friends and relatives that there is really nothing wrong" (222) and manipulates the situation by making it seem that she is the one that is control, when really he is the character in the story who is making uncalled for actions.…
- 1486 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
She is a very imaginative person. She believes that her house is haunted and terrors herself with nightmares about big scary monsters. She turns her imagination on to neutral objects like the house and wallpaper so she can somewhat ignore her frustration. The narrator becomes very focused on the wallpaper in her house. She later identifies herself as the lady trapped in the wallpaper. She’s able to see that other women are forced to hide behind domestic patterns of their lives when she is the one who truly needs to be rescued. In the end, she is “free’ of the constraints of her marriage, society, and her own efforts of her…
- 667 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Jonh Locke uses a soft but entertaining speech to describe the story of Dr. Box, a very intelligent personage but at the same time with some psychological conditions, sexual conditions, and other kinds. The plot idealize you in a hostile environment with strong sexual content, although not from a grotesque sight, but rather sensual. At the same time, the personage is counseled by a psychologist, who believes understand what goes through the mind of Dr. Box, but knows only a small percentage of the actual history of the surgeon, who has some little vices at all accepted by the society, from murder, sexual assault, identity theft, among others, all very intelligent made by Dr. Box, who has an incredible wit. The story will delve into a psychological…
- 149 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
as the loneliness she faces. Lawson’s use of imagery in the harsh description of the…
- 272 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays