Preview

State of Manchester Circa 1800

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
613 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
State of Manchester Circa 1800
DBQ: Manchester A city of prowess should be as hygienic as it is regal. Manchester circa 1800 was indeed a city of great proportion, although its cleanliness was in no question due to the lack thereof. A result of industrialization, Manchester’s quality of living deteriorated. Industrial expansion took priority over the inhabitants. To their detriment, modest changes had been made to aid in the effort to further the progress of a better Manchester for all. The Industrial Revolution impaired the health of the people, expanded while harming the working force, and polluted the condition of the city. Maintaining Manchester was no easy feat. Most didn’t bother or care about the upkeep. “People live longer because they are better fed, better lodged, better clothed, and better attended in sickness and these improvements are owing to the increase in national wealth which the manufacturing system has produced.” (Doc 3) Historian and Member of Parliament, Thomas Macaulay, states in his point of view and I believe that as a historian he is a reliable source of information. However his ties to the Parliament cause me to sally between believing and not believing. Manchester also ran rampant with disease and grime that doesn’t seem to be treated. “The annual loss of life from filth and bad ventilation is greater than the loss from death of wounds in modern wars.”(doc 6) Writes Edwin Chadwick, a public health reformer whose firsthand point of view seems rather frank and sordid. “Unless you have visited the manufacturing towns and seen the workers of Manchester you cannot appreciate the physical suffering and moral degradation of this class of the population”(doc 7) Women’s rights advocate, Flora Tristan writes in an earnest fashion. The environment Manchester workers long endured had been an egregious lack of concern for the laborers by the factory owners“If you visit a factory, it is easy to see that the comfort and welfare of the workers have never entered the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Driving down Manchester road was a trip down memory lane. I am currently familiar with much of Manchester road and it booming activity. So much has been built and added in the past twenty years. I did not realize how far into the city Manchester went and so it was a new experience for me. Much of Manchester Rd. in the city is very industrial with the train tracks running parallel to the road much of the time. There were trains present. As we approached Maplewood, the tracks disappeared, leaving behind the barred windows and dilapidated buildings, giving way to a cute little town and the sidewalk shops. Suddenly you saw lots of people walking around. Prior to this I had seen a couple of rough looking people sitting at bus stops but that was all. It only got better. As I drove along I realized how old the places like Glendale and Rock Hill and Kirkwood are. Whereas toward the end in Ballwin and especially Wildwood everything was so new still and in some instances still under construction. Instead of building new homes like these places Kirkwood and some areas closer to the city are in the process of tearing down old homes and building new ones in their place.…

    • 2122 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Factory System Dbq

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Page

    In the 1800’s I think the factory systems were bad people got very sick and hurt. They should have changed the working conditions because the factory systems were very bad. In document A the people said They had to work from 5 in the morning to nine or ten at night, and on Saturday's they had to work until 11-12 at night. They were dirty and people got diseases. In document C they said They broke elbows, scraped arms and got beat up. They could not tell the truth about there treatment or they would get in trouble. In conclusion, the factory systems were bad and it was not good for the workers.…

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Garden City Case Study

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages

    At this time, the lack of government intervention was leading to major health consequences in overcrowded areas lacking appropriate sanitation and housing. Ebenezer Howard intended to provide a lifestyle for the garden city residents in line with city life, with a greater focus on the health of the inhabitants. While Howard’s original design was never implemented, the model he created led to a number of experiments eventually emerging in the form of New Urbanism with the aid of Nolen (Stephenson, 2002, Page 113). A number of issues led to the failure of the design, all partly relating to the complexity of starting a city from the ground up. However, the lessons provided by Howard and those that followed in his footsteps provide lessons for contemporary urban…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Apush Dbq Essay

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Documents A and C are more reliable because the authors get to experience the setting firsthand. John Birley, the author of Doc C, was a factory worker himself and gave insight of the a worker is like. Not only did Dr. Ward visit 3 different factories, he got to treat the victims of the unsafe atmosphere. Having multiple experiences with the factories give these authors a more specific input on the factories. Documents B and D present an unprofessional and weak claim, stating that they believe the working conditions are not harsh. The striking difference between Documents B and D and Documents A and C is the lack of evidence B and D provide; the authors of B and D only visit one factory whereas A visits three. Dr. Holmes (Doc B) and Mr. Baines (Doc D) hold biased views in favor of the factory owners, however they fail to provide accurate evidence to support their claim. Due to their lack of evidence, it is hard for the reader to believe the argument Dr. Holmes and Mr. Baines are trying to convey. As a result of the cruel living condition of the working class, factory workers undergo unfair treatments producing an unhealthy…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chadwick’s first major impact was his 1842 ‘Report on the Sanitary Conditions of the Labouring Population’, in which he showed that the poor were living in dirty, overcrowded areas which caused a huge amount of disease, and also that many people were too sick to work so they became poorer still, resulting in the rest of the population needing to pay higher taxes. Not only did Chadwick highlight the problems, he also suggested potential solutions. He proposed that in order to make towns into healthier places, authorities needed to improve drainage and sewage, remove refuse from the streets and houses, provide clean water supplies and appoint medical officers. His report resulted in Parliament passing the first British Public Health Act in 1848, establishing local and central Boards of Health.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The revolution has also led to the complete deterioration of our surrounding environment. With the introduction of thousands upon thousands of factories, along with the different means of transportation that we not obtain, we are all now the direct victims of pollution. Streets that used to be beautifully paved, covered only by the morning’s sunlight, are now coated in filth and debris. Manchester has been one of the most affected towns, with it now resembling a trash can instead of a city that inhabits 70,00 people, a lot whom are factory/coal miners. While outside a local pub, in which the “front of the doors, filth and garbage abounded” (Document 6), I overheard another conversation of a couple of older mine workers, all appearing to be…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Civilizing the Machine

    • 867 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The article begins by summarizing the effects of the Industrial Revolution. Although it is shown with high admiration by Americans, Kasson also states, “Manchester’s contrasts both fascinated and repelled: the advanced technology and immense productivity of its factories; the unbelievably primitive, cramped, and diseased hovels; the vitality of its magnates; the feebleness and despair of their workers.”(1.5). This description and another reporter’s comment on the revolution help to summarize the basic idea that, although many ingenious and productive systems and products evolved from the Industrial Revolution, many of the citizens we subjected to horrendously poor conditions which were extremely harmful to human health. This disgusted the Americans who both admired and sought ideas from this event but were also repelled by the idea of this type of subjugation on their own citizens.…

    • 867 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unit 12 Public Health P2

    • 767 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The conditions in the 1800s were really bad as there was a poor sewage system which caused diseases, street doctors who walked around with dead bodies in the street. There were also piles of dirt on the street what the children would play in; they would also start playing with rats that was attracted by the dirt and rubbish that was on the street. People would hang their washing out in the street which made it easier for them to catch diseases. Also there where a low amount of houses which meant people with less money would have to stay in hotels in which where made from wood so they were not very secure.…

    • 767 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There were unhealthy conditions and air pollution from all the factories. Also, there were unfair and unsafe conditions in factories, which resulted in people having medical problems. For example, in document 1, someone is interviewing a worker from a factory. The worker exclaims that he began working at the age of 10; he worked from five in the morning to nine at night and had one period of 40 minutes in the 16 hours at noon for a meal. Also, he wasn’t educated and could only read, but not write. More examples of bad factory conditions are in document 2, where another factory worker was interviewed about their experience in the factories. The man has damaged lungs, improper leg muscles, and he would die in a year. His doctor says it was caused by dust in the factories, overworking, and an insufficient diet. His brother died from a bad cut from a machine and of infection. The worker also stated that he knows that nearly a dozen children died during the two and a half years that he worked there. These examples show that there were many negative effects of the Industrial…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Doctor by the name of Michael ward was interviewed on the conditions he saw in the factories that summer.(House of lords committee and Michael w. 1819) He stated he couldn't breath when he entered. He also stated the health of the children was worse to the conditions of other factories. Dr Ward wasn't the only one who had a say in proving factory life was horrible.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Industrial Revolution Dbq

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Throughout different places in the world the people that worked as laborers had to go through many harsh conditions that affected their health conditions. The working conditions were not fair at all because if the owners of the…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, a French socialist, Flora Tristan recognizes the fatal conditions and constructs a poor view on the Industrial Revolution and it's effects. She expresses her opinion about the life quality in Manchester, “they are wizened, sickly and emancipated, their bodies thin and frail, their limbs feeble, their complexions pale, their eyes dead” (Doc 7). Not only was the population dying at frightening rates, but the citizens disapproved the machines and factories replacing them in the work force. Also, Frances Anne Kemble crudely speaks about the protests against machinery and the government's inadequacy to sustain a healthy, happy community(Doc 4). As described by Tocqueville, Manchester’s populace lost it's optimism and had degraded back into the savage (Doc 5). Consequently, society’s way of thinking devolved from enthusiastic and passionate to despair and misery. Noticed by Edwin Chadwick, as well, was, “an adult population short-lived, reckless, and intemperate, and with habits of sensual gratification” (Doc 6). He observed the hopelessness of each worker transporting from one tortuous burden to the next. Ultimately, some occupants perceived a negative view of the Industrial Revolution due to the treacherous conditions and demoralized…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The growth of the industrial era caused the growth of the city; the growth of the city had fueled the industrial era to explode with growth, and over population of foreign countries that did not have the economy nor the opportunities for employment along with poor leadership. America was a growing country in industry and wanted cheap labor, the immigrant was the simple/easy answer to the greed of the business of industry. The growth of the city outpaced the ability for the local offices to extend the ability to provide proper garbage collection, clean water, and proper sewage systems in the poorer areas of the city; this caused the deterioration of the conditions.…

    • 2282 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Social Entrpreneurship

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages

    * In Rochdale, a workers' co-operative was set up to provide high quality affordable food in response to factory conditions that were considered to be exploitative…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Following the onset of industrialisation and the sustained urban growth of large population centres in England, the buildup of waste in the cities caused a rapid deterioration in levels of sanitation and the general quality of urban life. The streets became choked with filth due to the lack of waste clearance regulations.[2] Calls for the establishment of a municipal authority with waste removal powers were mooted as early as 1751 by Corbyn Morris in London, who proposed that "...as the preservation of the health of the people is of great importance, it is proposed that the cleaning of this city, should be put under one uniform public management, and all the filth be...conveyed by the Thames to proper distance in the country".[3]…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays