Racial Profiling

Topics: Race, United States, Ethnic group Pages: 5 (1321 words) Published: August 18, 2013

Analysis of “Racial Profiling and Criminal Justice”

Domenica Martinez

Colorado Mesa University


Research Question

I chose to analyze article titled “Racial Profiling and Criminal Justice” which is written By Jesper Ryberg within the Journal of Ethics; March 2011. This journal article was discovered within the EBSCO Host library. Ryberg’s thesis states “The main argument that has been presented by advocates of the use of racial profiling as a law enforcement tactic is that race (or ethnic) characteristics help the police to target those more likely to be criminals.” They are stating they will apprehend more criminals by using racial profiling. Ryberg’s major arguing factors are that the cost to benefit ratio is not worth it. Ryberg points out that terrorists adapt to the racial profiling and prove it is non-beneficial. The final argument presented is profiling a specific minority may help to decrease the sum of violations but at the same time increase the criminal rate as a whole by failing to notice the large number of inhabitants in our society.

Research Terms Defined

Ryberg’s resources appear to be justified with the given facts to support his arguments. They are all significant arguments and cannot be classified as which has more value than the next or which is more important as they are all valuable arguments. I feel Ryberg has written “Racial profiling and Criminal Justice” with a non-bias and non-judgmental position. ANALYZING RACIAL PROFILING AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE3

Ryberg did not use comments such as “I feel this way because” or “I believe” and he was very neutral in his beliefs and assumptions. Ryberg did not exaggerate the value or worth of his ideas or use aggressive techniques in his article. His journal article was informative, easy-going and stimulating.

Ryberg used many different resources to draw conclusions on racial profiling and criminal justice. Ryberg researched Department of Philosophy and Science Studies in Denmark to discuss and enclose in his findings. His resources reaffirmed that racial profiling saves time and is convenient. Arizona would find this convenient since they border Mexico but one must consider that the United States consists of nearly every race, culture and ethnic group in the world. Due to these factors, it is concluded that time is wasted with search and question and seizure of suspected illegals. When asking random groups of people who are more likely to be apprehended, searched and seized by law enforcement the answer is African Americans. Studies by researchers have proved that Whites are more likely to possess drugs, weapons and stolen property, so why still use these outdated profiling tactics? Ryberg states that racial profiling, although outdated, is still widely used by law enforcement in our United States because more often than not more criminals are apprehended due to the use of racial profiling. Studies on cultures, housing projects, education, geographical areas are all contributing factors which have assisted in the cause and effect of racial profiling in the criminal justice field.



The first main topic Ryberg wrote about is the lasting effect that racially profiling personnel who are suspected to be in a terrorist group. He states “it has been suggested that the use of racial profiling as a means of catching terrorists will, due to the ability of terrorist groups to adapt to racial characteristics in the recruitment of members, fail in the long term”. This is a very touchy subject to comment about...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Racial vs Criminal Profiling Essay
  • Racial profiling and law enforcement Research Paper
  • Racial Profiling Research Paper
  • Racial Profiling Essay
  • Racial Profiling Essay
  • Racial Profiling Essay
  • Racial Profiling Research Paper
  • Racial Profiling Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free