Preview

Paul Williams Views On 9/11

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1738 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paul Williams Views On 9/11
September 11, 2001 is a day woven in the fabric and collective memory of the American people. Now, instead of two towers there are two pools and instead of a financial center there is a massive memorial museum dedicated to the destruction of that day. Dealing with tragedy-- especially on a large scale -- is always contentious. On the topic of such memorial museums, Paul Williams, in his piece, “Memorial museums and the objectification of suffering” highlighted the complexities and issues that arise in giving physical form to cataclysmic tragedies. Williams, in addressing the memorial museum, laid out the major issues that he considered paramount: the use of images and artifacts; use of a destruction site; issues pertaining to the visitor …show more content…
The use of the site lends the question: Could the 9/11 Museum have been placed anywhere in the country, or even anywhere in New York? The answer is a resounding no. For many museums, the location of the institution is second to the objects inside the building. The 9/11 Museum, however, rests on sacred ground because the space is a public graveyard for the thousands of people who died in the attack. Therefore, as hallowed ground, the location of the Memorial Museum is paramount to the objects in the collection. To further illustrate the gravitas of the site, according to the New York Times, 1,115 people’s remains have not been identified and remain stored below the museum/memorial (In ‘Ceremonial Transfer,’ Remains of 9/11 Victims Are Moved to Memorial”). The issue with the 9/11 Museum though lies not in the location but rather in the presentation of the location as an authentic site of destruction. As Williams noted, there is a danger in terms of reception when a memorial museum displays a place as, “what we see is what was” (p.227). In this vein, as a visitor to the 9/11 Memorial Museum, I did not feel any emotional pull to the physical site as a place of destruction because the entire space was too hygienic and palatial to conceptualize in the abstract. In addition to conceptualization, Williams also noted a strange twist in logic in that, “while physical …show more content…
History, and the representation of the past in any form is almost always controversial and political. For the 9/11 Memorial Museum, remembering and commemorating 9/11 is political because of the vast array of parties that have some stake in the tragedy. Due to the web of viewpoints, a Museum Memorial, in theory, as Williams theorized, “provide a public forum for discussion” (p. 233). The 9/11 Memorial Museum, perhaps in an effort to appear above the politics, made little to no mention of the global aftermath to the attacks and such changes in the U.S like the creation of the Department of Homeland Security. Such context is a key part of “public forum” and by just honoring the memory of the dead, the Memorial Museum is failing to be a place that can evolve to examine the effects of 9/11 on the country and the globe. On the topic of commemorating the dead, I felt the museum fell into the trap of portraying the victims not just as private citizens but more as national martyrs or heroes. Williams noted this issue in relation to the Oklahoma City bombing where Clinton equated such sites as Gettysburg and Valley Forge with the bombing (231). Private citizens dying in a public nature, though tragic, does not constitute heroism. Indeed, there were heroes in 9/11, but not every person who perished, no matter how tragic the circumstances,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Over a span of about twenty years Lonetree explores how new museum theory changed interpretation of the same subject and how different museums interpreted decolonization to varying levels of success. Lonetree argues that successful examples of decolonization in Native American museums includes tying the history to the Native community, relating the history to pre-colonization until today, and including the hard truths of western colonization on Natives. She sums up her idea of successful museum interpretation as incorporating “one of the most important goals...is to assist communities in their efforts to address the legacies of historical unresolved grief by speaking the hard truths of colonialism and thereby creating spaces for healing and…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Memorials or monuments are important because they are a symbol or reminder of life changing events or lost loved ones. For example, the 9/11 monument is a remembrance of a tragic event that happened in 2001 when terrorists attacked and around 3,000 people were killed. Although the memorial is not a bad thing it can be closure for families who have lost someone, also it is a reminder to take more precautions to prevent things like this happening in the future. The 9/11 monument also recognizes the many people who lived through this tragic event.…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The commentary “No Firemen at Ground Zero This 9/11” by Michael Burke conveys a message that many people agree with after reading. On the 10th anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, New York City mayor Michael Bloomberg is not allowing any first responders to be honored at the memorial ceremony. Burke argues that the fireman and other first responders should be honored. Any true American that knows about the tragedies of the 9/11 terrorist attacks could see why Burke’s argument should be seriously considered by mayor Bloomberg. Burke uses credible sources, vivid imagery, and single sentence paragraphs to get his message across to readers.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The date of September 11, 2001 is a date that possesses great significance globally. To most, it is remembered as one of the greatest tragedies of Western Civilisation. The Smithsonian Museum and their representation of the tragedy, 9/11, makes apparent how one’s personal experience to a particular situation, fabricates what is considered ‘history’. On the home page, colouring is used in ‘September 11’ in which red is the predominant colour, connotating to bloodshed and suffering. This technique is implemented to shape a saddened response, even to those unaffected by the event. Furthermore, in ‘objects on view: World Trade Centre’, the inclusion of the fire fighter doll, starkly juxtaposing with the other objects on show, heavily evokes empathy through its connotations to a young child, suffering. The empathy drawn from such an object is what is most wholly remembered by those who respond to the site, materializing that individuals understanding of ‘factual history’. Again, one’s interpretation of history is formulated through the ‘Missing Persons Material’. The image constructs a more intimate relationship with the man, and is supplemented by emotive language describing how ‘sadly, Jeff was never found alive’. The emotive language further deepens the respondent’s sense of empathy felt for those affected by ‘9/11’, and generates a deplored perception of what is believed to be history. Finally, one’s personal belief of the history of ‘9/11’ is concreted through the photo of ‘Lorraine Bay’s’ log book in ‘objects on view: Shanksville’. Again, red colouring is strategically implemented by the Smithsonian Museum to evoke feelings of fear, further portraying the agonizing circumstances of the day. The log book provides stronger insight into ‘Lorraine’s’ personal life, strengthening the audiences connection with the individual and engendering the feelings of compassion. It is this evocative presentation of the website…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Poole’s tone through his descriptions of the growth and architectural development of Arlington National Cemetery is astonishment. Poole’s detail included in his writing when talking about the building of the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier really illustrated how amazed he was by the time it took to make it to perfection. Poole used this same tone when he was describing the incredible growth and transformation the cemetery went through after the civil war. The cemetery went from a military fort to a giant cemetery in a very short period of time. Poole’s impressed attitude when discussing the growth of the cemetery allowes the reader to share the same impression of the growth.…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ground Zero Summary

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the essay “Ground Zero”, written by Suzanne Berne, the author makes her claim on how the empty site that was once the New York World Trade Center, is more visible with the adjusted eye without the tangible existence being physically there. The absence of it is said to be much more potent and looking at “nothing” is in fact “something”. However, the eyes of every visiting viewer fixated their undivided attention on the vast space of the site that resembles your typical construction platform. The acts of curiosity, horror, and grief depicted in the minds of people refills the space of that historical disaster. As a result, those horrific events penetrate through their thoughts causing them to relive the moment the disaster occurred and you can actually see the images of buildings collapsing, the falling of towers, the loud wailing of sirens, as well as running office workers. To know that such devastation happened in that very spot is known as unbelievable, but the reality of it all is its absence. To not see with the human eye the true effects of its occurrence was dissatisfying, yet it provided a broader prospective on what happened September 11th.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    9/11 Memorial History

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages

    One of the most tragic events in the United States history was the Twin Tower attacks. The Twin Tower attacks happened on September 11th 2001, over 3000 people died. So where the towers stode they made a memorial, the 9/11 memorial. The memorial honors the people who died during the attacks. With the two waterfalls and lots of trees many people go to see the memorial. Have you?…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Tom Bernstein's Ground Zero

    • 2814 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The sprawling mess of flesh and steel recombinant that was created on the morning of September 11, 2001 left thousands dead. The scene of Ground Zero would go on to haunt survivors and the general public alike. The terrorist attacks which were wrought that day destroyed a landmark, a large and populated piece of a city, and most tragically the lives of thousands of innocent people. Yet with death there is also rebirth, and this example is no different. However, over the past years we have witnessed the controversy and chaos which has surrounded the precarious nature of how and what to rebuild over the incredibly sacred land that now makes up Ground Zero.…

    • 2814 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    JFK Museum

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Sixth Floor Museum at Dealey Plaza was nothing short of an amazing experience. It provides an abundant amount of interesting information about John F. Kennedy and goes into a lot deeper depth than just the day of the shooting. I have always loved going to museums and finding out interesting things about the past, and it is even a bigger thrill when you are actually at the place where history happened. The Sixth Floor Museum provides information about JFK's early life, family, campaign runs, and shooting. Most of the museum is just on one floor of the building, yet it fits so much information and diagrams in it. It is also well organized and makes you follow a path that shows all of JFK's historical moments in chronological order and not just giving out information at random moments. The museum also shows the window that Lee Harvey Oswald peered out of to snipe down the president with the boxes where he propped his rifle. In addition, there are voice recordings playing from when the event took place to give you a closer experience. Even after fifty years since the shooting, it is still a haunting site see as you can almost picture the event happening right in front of you. And just incase you cant picture the event at first by looking out the window, the museum provides and helpful glass cased diagram of the buildings and roads showing exactly where in Elm St JFK was shot and where the shots were coming from. I felt the information given was unbiased and appeals to all people for it gives straight facts about what happened during JFK's presidency and the day of the shooting. Even for the people who do not believe it was Oswald, the museum also provides a whole bulletin board filled with conspiracy theories making sure that nothing is ruled out.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq Monument Analysis

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The location of a monument needs to be considered when memorializing an individual because it can add emphasis to their remembrance. However, building a monument in an eerie location can distract visitors and or take interest away from the audience. For example, the Christopher Columbus Monument in Riverside Park located in Easton, Pennsylvania (Source B) correctly honors the prolific…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    German playwright Frank Wedekind famously said of monuments that they “... are for the living, not the dead.” A memorial does not serve any purpose for those it commemorates, rather, they educate and remind those that visit of the enshrined individual(s) or event. They also vary greatly in scope with one memorial being dedicated to the entirety of American forces in World War II while another could be dedicated to a single soldier. In the case of the George Rogers Clark National Historic Park, it serves as a historic site wherein a number of those involved with the Illinois campaign are memorialized in present day Vincennes, Indiana.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    "The use of names was a way to bring back everything someone could remember about a person. " They stated in Source G. But it doesn't always have to be about a certain person. It can be about a matter that happened and impacted the world, the US, or us as a people. For example, World War 2. The whole world knows about it, schools teach it, people talk about it. Many died and they made an exhibit for the ones who died in it. So we can remember what happened. Put it in a peaceful place, so people can go and quietly remember the memorial. Put it in a beautiful place that people will actually want to go too.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    These museums that she examines in her book exist in cities that themselves are undergoing major political and industrial post World War II transformations. The clear comparisons between the struggles African-Americans faced in their daily lives and the struggles to get these museums up and running is obvious. The issues surrounding the creation of the museums directly mirror the civil rights issues that African-Americans struggle with day to…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One must think with a great deal of precision and infallibility when memorializing history. The creator should have a sense of where it will be placed, the size, significance, and the pros/cons of it. Any memorial is a stamp of history, because it outlines an important person or event. It has a chance of effecting people while appealing to their emotions in positive or negative way. So when an agency is considering memorializing an event or person in a monument one should have a feel of how it would affect the mass population.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Honor Is Important

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A funeral is an event where a group of friends gather to mourn the death yet honor the life of the deceased. The day is reserved to gather and remember and tell stories. We must remember that by honoring them we may have lost a loved one yet they’re not forgotten. Similarly, memorials recognize a person’s actions and honor their sacrifice with a tribute. The horrifying day of September 11, 2001, where over 3,000 lives were taken by Islamic extremists hijacking and crashing four planes was a national disaster; yet, as a country, we stood together and built the 9/11 Memorial Museum to honor the lives that were taken in the attack.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays