top-rated free essay

My Mother Never Worked

By curlycarlie Nov 20, 2011 421 Words
Carlie Coates
AP English III
Mrs. Pilon
October 21, 2011

In Bonnie Smith-Yackel’s personal essay “My Mother Never Worked”, Smith-Yackel presents us with a situation where she describes her mother as a hard working woman. She starts the essay in the present time with a phone call to a social security office. While on hold, the author reflects on how much her mother worked during her life, but after the operator returns, she informs Smith-Yackel that her mother never worked.

I was surprised when the family did not get the death benefit check. Obviously Smith-Yackel’s mother worked very hard during her life, but all her hard work was not considered “work” because she did not bring-in an income from a public job to her family. Just because the government does not consider her time and labor to be equivalent to a “job”, it does not mean she did not do anything to provide for her family. She had to work extremely hard for her farm and family to survive: all the animals and children needed tending and the only way for this to happen was for Smith-Yackel’s mother to work vigorously on the farm and in the house. To the social security office, this was not considered a sufficient “job” because she was not recognized as an employee who paid social security benefits in the eyes of the government, even though she worked long hard hours and raised a family while taking care of a farm.

I would have been very angry if my mom did not receive the death benefit check, but I would not argue with the government if my she was not eligible for one. My mother has a job outside of her home, where she is paying social security benefits and is supported by the government, but if she did not have a job, I know she would still be a hard working woman. She would work diligently on raising her children and make sure that she could provide for her family. I could only imagine the reaction that Smith-Yackel had when the operator told her that her mother was not qualified for the check. How could that be possible when she spent every daylight hour working? I was hoping that the family would get the check, but the story’s title, “My Mother Never Worked”, told me they would not. It was a predictable ending, yet I still found myself hoping for a different conclusion.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • My Mother Never Worked Summary

    ... While retirement might have disadvantages for people, for others being a retired individual can have different advantages that a normal working person does not have. As mentioned in the essay My Mother Never Worked by Bonnie Smith-Yackel, Yackel mentions how her after retirement workers can receive a monthly income from social security bene...

    Read More
  • My Mother Never Worked

    ...Jazmine Jones Eng. 1101 MW 12:50 My Mother Never Worked 4-16-11 Purpose and Audience 1. That she had a hard working mother that worked harder than people who did “work”. By exemplifying this, it shows the mother to have every right to social security benefits just like anyone else, because she indeed worked all her life. The thesis w...

    Read More
  • My Mother Never Worked

    ...writer trying to make? Why do you suppose her thesis is never explicitly stated? The author’s whole (main) point of in the essay is to make the reader feel sympathy for her mother, because of the hardships she went through working on a farm while raising eight children, which leads us to believe she is deserving of the Social Security benefit...

    Read More
  • My Mother Never Worked Analysis

    ...In the essay “My Mother Never Worked”, by A Bonnie Smith-Yackel. Smith-Yackel tries to collect her deceased mothers Social Security. But the thing was her mother never had a wage earning job. Irony exists in this essay because it makes the reader curious about the how the author feels. In the very same sense, readers can only think of the ha...

    Read More
  • Insight Into "My Mother Never Worked"

    ...Journal of Liberation magazine published in 1975, "My Mother Never Worked," Bonnie Smith-Yackel, author of several essays, book reviews and short stories in various magazines and newspapers, proclaims that society belittles women and the work they do. She does so by sharing a glimpse of the hard labor her mother did in her adult life, such as do...

    Read More
  • Title: "My Mother Never Worked" by Bonnie Smith-Yackel.

    ...begins to recollect some of the faint memories of her mother and the tedious stages of life that she had endured. She uses this introduction as an open door to the story of her mother and will ultimately use this same introduction to close this entry of pain and dedication. Marriage during those days weren't the same as we now know them. Our pe...

    Read More
  • my mother

    ...MY MOTHER Of all the persons in the world, my mother loves me most, and I also love her from the core of my heart. To me, she is like a living goddess who takes all kinds of pain and care for my sake. When I am sick, she spends sleepless nights by my sick-bed. When I come first in my class exami­nation, she becomes perhaps the happiest pers...

    Read More
  • my mother never worked and only daughter

    ...My Mother Never Worked In this essay the words that are significant to getting the authors point across would be Never Worked. The connatative meaning means that her mother never had a job were she received a monetary pay. The denotative meaning is that her mother, in fact worked very hard every day of her life, taking care of her children, h...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.