India Italy Coutroversy

Topics: India, Kerala, Italy Pages: 31 (14611 words) Published: April 14, 2013
2012 Italian shooting in the Arabian Sea
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
2012 Italian shooting in the Arabian sea|

The shootings occurred off the coast of Kerala state, India|
Enrica Lexie at Kochi|
Location| Indian Contiguous zone|
Date| 15 February 2012
16:30 IST (disputed) (UTC+05:30)|
Attack type| Shooting|
Deaths| Indian fishermen: Ajesh Binki and Gelastine (Valentine)| Perpetrators| Italian Marines: Massimiliano Latorre and Salvatore Girone (accused)|

The incident sparked a major diplomatic row between the governments of Italy and India, with Indian police immediately opening a murder inquiry, and the Indian Coast Guard later intercepting the ship and arresting two Italian marines suspected of being involved in the shooting. The two Italian marines were released after 105 days in judicial custody under strict bail conditions and assurances from the Italian government that they will remain available to answer charges before Indian courts. The Indian government allowed the marines to travel to Italy in February 2013 to vote in Italian general elections, after receiving assurances from the Italian government that the two marines will return to India. However, on 11 March 2013 the diplomatic row escalated into a stand-off when the Italian Foreign Ministry unilaterally announced that the marines will not return to India to stand trial. [1] On 21 March 2013, Italy backtracked from their decision and sent the marines back to India. Contents [hide]  * 1 Shooting * 2 Indian Coast Guard intervention * 3 Victims * 4 Diplomatic fallout * 5 Major disputes * 5.1 Time and location of the shooting * 5.2 Legal jurisdiction * 6 Arrest and incarceration of Italian marines * 7 Investigations * 7.1 Indian investigations * 7.2 Italian investigations * 8 Court proceedings * 9 March 2013 diplomatic crisis * 9.1 Background * 9.2 Stand-off * 9.3 Climb-down * 9.4 Aftermath * 9.4.1 India * 9.4.2 Italy * 9.4.3 Public Opinion * 10 Other issues * 10.1 Olympic Flair, the Greek tanker * 10.2 Intervention by Catholic Cardinal of Kerala * 10.3 Monetary payments to victims * 10.4 Italian Navy flags display on Formula One cars * 10.5 Impact on anti-piracy measures * 10.6 Link to Finmeccanica VIP helicopter bribery scandal * 11 See also * 12 References| [edit] Shooting

The MV Enrica Lexie was traveling from Singapore to Egypt with a crew of 34 including 19 Indians and accompanied by six Italian marines from the San Marco Regiment, while the fishing trawler named St. Antony had left Neendakara in Kerala with a crew of 11 to fish for tuna. According to the Indian Coast Guard, Indian government sources and the crew of the fishing boat Saint Antony, the incident occurred at approximately 16:30 IST (11:00 UTC) on 15 February 2012, when the fishing boat was returning from a fishing expedition and happened in international waters off the coast of Kerala. The captain and owner of the St. Antony, Freddie Louis, said that their boat was returning from their fishing expedition and was waiting for the tanker to pass when the security men on board the tanker fired at the boat “without provocation”. According to him, the firing lasted for two minutes, killing driver Gelastine immediately and injuring Ajesh Binki; soon after the trawler steered out of the firing range, Binki succumbed to injuries.[2][3][4] Umberto Vitelli, the captain of the Enrica Lexie, claimed that the Italian naval guards opened fire in self-defence against armed pirates.[5][6] In the court affidavit filed by the two marines urging the Kerala High Court to quash the FIR (First Information Report) against them, the document states: "The master of the vessel increased the speed of the ship to 14 knots (about 28 km/per hour) and reduced the speed to 13 knots once the piracy attack was averted. The master...


References: 38. ^ REUTERS (6 March 2012). "Italy summons Indian ambassador over marines ' arrest". 
39
42. ^ "W.P.(C) No. 4542 of 2012 Massimilano Latorre Vs. Union of India, (2012) 252 KLR 794". Kerala Law. 29 May 2012. 
43
58. ^ a b "Fishermen killing: Kerala Police form special team to probe mid-sea murder". The Times of India. 2012-02-21. 
59
78. ^ "Italian naval guards remanded to 3 days police custody". IBN Live. 2012-02-20. 
79
80. ^ "Killing of fishermen: Kerala police get court nod to seize arms from Italian ship". The Times of India. 2012-02-21. 
81
82. ^ "Fishermen firing: Italian ship can’t leave port without paying guarantee". Daily Bhaskar. 2012-02-22. 
83
84. ^ "Fishermen shooting: Two Italians’ police custody extended". The Week. 2012-02-23. 
85
86. ^ "Fishermen murders: HC offers out-of-court settlement option". MSN News. 2012-02-28. 
87
88. ^ "Fishermen deaths: Italy files fresh petition, wants representation during weapon examination". NDTV. 2012-02-29. 
89
90. ^ . The Economic Times. 2012-02-29 http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-02-29/news/31110596_1_enrica-lexie-indian-fishermen-giulio-maria-terziBare URL needs a title. Citation has no title
91
92. ^ "Plea to enhance compensation dismissed". IBN Live. 2012-03-01. 
93
94. ^ "HC tears into Italian plea in shooting case". Hindustan Times. 2012-03-01. 
95
96. ^ "Court extends custody of two Italians till March 5". Manorma Online. 2012-03-01. 
97
98. ^ "Will you abide by Court order, HC asks Italy". IBN Live. 2012-03-03.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Italy India Shooting Issue Essay
  • Italy Essay
  • Easter in Italy Essay
  • FDI in India Essay
  • India Essay
  • India Essay
  • India Essay
  • India Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free