top-rated free essay

Delegated Legislation

By ivykow Sep 26, 2010 662 Words
Delegated legislation in its various forms is a necessary source of law in a progressive society. Parliament simply cannot keep up with the need for law reform demanded by society. The government formed within Parliament has to fulfill the promised reforms (among other agenda) and there is definite pressure to see that these reforms are passed within the particular session. The lack of specialized knowledge among MPs’ make DL a necessary avenue to ensure reasonable and effective content of the law. It would be unreasonable to expect MPs’ to have specialised knowledge and understanding on a wide variety of areas. Delegated power is also necessary to enable a particular minister or body of people to issue laws to deal with emergencies and unforseen contingencies. Passing an Act of Parliament is a particularly lengthy process and therefore unsuitable to deal with emergencies.

There are numerous concerns over the contribution of delegated/ secondary/subordinate legislation as a source of law in the UK. The bulk of reform via DL is alarming eg 100 Acts to 3000 pieces of DL and the concerns are justified. Delegated legislation(DL) is a generic term for legislation which is passed by a subordinate body to whom Parliament has delegated law making powers. At a higher level, DL passed by the Privy Council or cabinet ministers or ministers are called Orders in Council , Statutory Instruments and Ministerial Regulations whereas DL issued by Local Councils are called ‘by laws’ .

Undeniably, these laws are not passed by Members of Parliament as the peoples’ legislative representatives but by bodies controlled by the executive due to their unique position as a power within Parliament and having a degree of control over Parliament. This threat is compounded by the practice of sub delegation within the ministry. The first part of the statement above is therefore valid as the idea of democracy is based on a nation governed by laws passed by popularly elected representatives rather than the executive. The making of DL by executive ministers/bodies is also contrary to the ideals of the Doctrine of Separation of Powers which is practiced in most democratic nations.

The latter part of the statement is therefore arguably justified in that the practice of L is a very high price to pay as a source of law today. Despite this concern it is undeniable that DL is a necessary practice to ensure smooth governance of a nation. These concerns have however been addressed by the various forms of parliamentary, judicial and political controls operating to ensure that the threat is contained or reduced.

The Parent Act itself provides boundaries to the exercise of power by the subordinate body and also provides guidelines eg the requirement to consult, and method of approving the delegated laws. The Joint Select Committee on Statutory Instruments has the function of scrutiny and review of such laws to ensure substantive and procedural validity. The House of Lords also acts as a review body of all delegated legislation.

The courts have an important role to ensure substantive and procedural validity of the DL through the process of Judicial Review. DL issued by the subordinate body in excess of its authority or for an improper purpose or without following the mandatory guidelines in the Parent Act can be challenged and quashed on the grounds of Ultra Vires(R v Commissioner for Income Tax exp Cure and Deely; Aylesbury Mushroom Case; R v Sec of St exp Fire Brigade Union).

In a democratic society, the ultimate control lies with the people(the political sovereign) by passing a vote of no confidence against the government of the day through their representatives in Parliament if the government has issued unreasonable DL. A minister issuing unreasonable SI may also be forced to resign according to the convention of individual ministerial responsibility. Tin conclusion, the threats to democracy are sufficiently addressed through the avenues for review and controls over the creation of DL provided these avenues are used effectively.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • What Is Delegated Legislation?

    ...What Is delegated legislation? • Delegated (or subordinate or subsidiary) legislation refers to those laws made by persons or bodies to whom parliament has delegated law-making authority • Where acts are made by parliament, each principal act makes provision for subsidiary legislation to be made, and will specify who has the power to do ...

    Read More
  • Delegated Legislation

    ...INTRODUCTION Delegated legislation refers to the rules and regulations, which are passed by some person or body under some enabling parent legislation. The Interpretation Act 1967 defines it as ‘any proclamation, rule, regulation, order, by-law or other instrument made under any Act, Enactment, Ordinance, or other lawful authority and having ...

    Read More
  • Interpretation of delegated legislation in india

    ...INSTITUTE OF LAW NIRMA UNIVERSITY INTERPRETATION OF DELEGATED LEGISLATION IN INDIA Project Work (INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES) By: Nidhi Jain LIST OF CASES R.Vs. Burah (1878) 3 AC 889 Jhatindra Nath Gupta Vs. Province of Bihar AIR 1949 FC 175 ...

    Read More
  • Delegated Legislation

    ...Delegated Legislation is law made by a body other than Parliament.  Parliament gives others the power to pass delegated legislation in a parent or enabling act.   Act of Parliament (Statutes) - Primary Legislation Delegated Legislation (i.e. statutory Instruments) - Secondary Legislation      The Town Hall in Rugby - local bor...

    Read More
  • mens rea and delegated legislation

    ... Mens Rea and delegated legislation Alexandra StoicaMens rea: the guilty mind of the defendant The difference between s18 and s20 of the Offences against the person act 1861 is the mens rea required. Mens rea must be distinguished from motive. Motive can be relevant in some crimes. Intention:...

    Read More
  • Primary and secondary legislation

    ... English Legal System Assignment 1: Essay Question 1 In order for society to function smoothly certain guidelines need to be put in place and throughout England the standards need to be upheld. These set of boundaries are also known as ‘The Law’ and this system is vital to ensure English citizens are protected as well as aware of their r...

    Read More
  • subsidiary legislation

    ...Subsidiary Legislation Subsidiary legislation, also referred to as delegated legislation is the law that is brought into being by authorities, persons or bodies other than Parliament, under power conferred by either the Constitution or Parliament. The purpose and limits of such subsidiary or subordinate law making powers will normally be set ou...

    Read More
  • Outline Current Legislation, Guidelines, Policies and Procedures Within Own Uk Home Nation Affecting the Safeguarding of Children and Young People.

    ...and local guidelines, policies and procedures for safeguarding affect day to day work with children and young people. In a school, nursery or educational establishment, Government Legislation and policies and procedures within the establishment ensure that all children are kept safe and protected from harm. All establishments must have these p...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.