Preview

Conflicting Perspectives

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1458 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Conflicting Perspectives
Thesaurus definitions for: * Conflict * Perspective * Formed/shaped * outcome
HATSUE AND ISHMAEL’S PERSPECTIVES ON WORLD WAR 2
Throughout our lives we take on certain views on events, situations and people in our lives. These are formed from the positive or negative outcomes of experiences that we encounter. Society’s views on certain issues and the views of those around us influence the outcomes of those experiences. David Guterson’s novel, “Snow Falling on Cedars” and Shaun Tan and John Marsden’s picture book, “The Rabbits” both portray conflicting perspectives that are shaped from past events.
Different experiences of the same event can cause conflicting perspectives. This is the case for Ishmael and Kabou in “SFC”. Gutterson uses this scene as the novel’s core scene where the characters form different views from before and after the war. Tan and Marsden’s “The Rabbits” uses the British Colonization as the core event

Events are sometimes the main causes of conflicting perspectives as people are often faced with events in life which molds their view and hence causes their perspectives to clash. In “SFC” the World War 2 incident act as a vital event in which David employs characters and language techniques to portray the conflicting perspectives through such event. In relation to “SFC”, Shaun Tan and John Marsden’s “The Rabbits” brings out the significance on the ‘British colonization’ in which the audience in introduced to the British and the Indigenous Australians perspectives to this event.
Ishmael and Hatsue act as vital character to which David uses to portray the conflicting perspectives from World War 2. In the early stages of the novel they are lovers who believe that love will conquer all things, including war. When the bombing of Pearl Harbor occurred, Hatsue and her family were forced to set out for an internment camp whilst Ishmael was forced to serve the country. In each of their cases, they both are forced to set into a new

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In today’s Australian society it has now become almost commonplace for us to question our beliefs and what it means to be an Australian. We have always turned to consider our cultural aspects and how they determine a strong Australian identity. The voice of a hot climate, the tone of the red sand, the indifference of man and woman and even the lifestyle of the Australian people all play important parts within our community. However to be an Australian is truly shaped by the kind acts of mateship that we possess within our relationships with friends and family. The mateship of society should not be affected by gender but really truly lie upon the relationships in our lives, which is why I have chosen Priscilla and Red Dog, both with very different ideas of gender and its role within an identity, to compare and contrast the one true Australian identity with the film industry and the impact that gender and mateship are responsible for shaping our society.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Reading is an active process of making meaning of the world we live in specifically the past; therefore our reading of novels is strongly influenced by the connections we can make to other texts. The construction of identity of a character often reflects or challenges the dominant ideologies circulating at the time of a text setting. The Book Thief explores Nazi Ideology in war-torn Germany in the 1940’s, Hans Hubermann and Rudy Steiford openly and secretively defies and challenges the dominant ideologies of this time era. The Secret River is set in the 18th century and focuses on one man man’s journey through life and is progression to Australia were the audience is introduced to the brutal world of Australia and the separation between cultures. The unrequired hate that many men have for Aboriginal men is contagious and due to the fact that it is different to their own culture and there lack of willingness to understand prevents any progression and results in misery for all.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ishmael did certain things that would define him as a creep or even a stalker. He tried to force certain situations when Hatsue did not want to do anything. For example, when Ishmael kissed Hatsue he realized, “He pushed too hard, and she planted one hand beneath the water behind her to keep from falling over.” (Guterson 99). This indicates that Ishmael is being forceful with Hatsue and she deserves to not be treated this way. There were other instances that show signs of him being a stalker. For example, when, “Ishmael returned the following evening; five nights in a row he spied religiously.” (Guterson 105). Ishmael made the wrong decision by trying to force situations out of Hatsue and even went to the extent of stalking her. Hatsue deserves space and did believe having a relationship with Ishmael would mean controversy would start in their community. If I were in Ishmael’s situation I would stop and listen to what Hatsue wants. If she did not want to do anything with Ishamel he should respect that. The author wrote it this way to show Ishmael won’t stop until he gets what he wants. The author advances the plot when Kabuo and Hatsue marry. He uses this to show that Ishamel is deeply obsessed with Hatsue because he tries to talk to her even when she’s…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The movie marks the beginning of mass social and political change that was intensified by World War II. With countless men at war, Australian women were able to enter and overtake male roles in the workforce. As a result, Feminism was strengthening. Along with the Women’s movement into the workforce, Robert Menzie’s 16-year service as the Prime Minister created the ‘Menzies Era’, where great Australian change has said to be recorded. In such a conservative era, political and social revolutions were difficult to adjust to, usually lengthening to process of change. The inability to adapt to frequent changes within society is what may have defined Australia as a nation, and led to the creation of a different national identity from its roots, of British colonization. Alas, during these political changes, Australia was a great conservative and Catholic nation, that believed in the dominance of white culture; Evident in their policies such as The White Australia policy and the policy of Assimilation.…

    • 3698 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    2. The external conflicts in this story include person vs. person and person vs. society. The reason person vs. person is included, because Ishmael has many problems with the rebels he must join in the cruel war that is of Sierra Leone. Not only did these very soldiers burn down his town and take away and later murder his parents, but they also bring horror and death to everyone who gets in their path, for reasons Ishmael could never discern. He must fight next to those that have destroyed the ones he loves, and the country he has grown to call his own. Person vs. society comes into play throughout the entire book. Ishmael and everyone who grew…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mark Raphael Baker’s novel is a combination of fiction and non-fiction which is brilliantly used to express history and culture and what can be achieved when history and memory are fused together to create an impression of the past and its connection with the present in a unique and evocative way. Baker takes us on a journey through the history of his parents as holocaust survivors, casting light on their memories hidden by pain and despair and through the process takes his own journey of self discovery. Baker’s occupation as a historian helps verify the memories and accounts of his parents; Baker uses techniques such as official documents like birth and death certificates, letters, archival documents as well as oral recordings of the memories of his parents as holocaust survivors. Baker’s use of fiction adds to the novel in a new way and helps us remember those whose stories can’t be told; he does this through imagery and evokes empathy from the readers. The 2002 film Rabbit Proof Fence, directed by Philip Noyce is based on three young half cast girl’s journey from Moore River native settlement camp 2400km back to their home in Jigalong the film portrays the true events of Molly Craig, Gracie Field and Daisy Craig Kadibill and the history of stolen generation in 1931 and the men and women behind it. The film shows the history and memories of both the aboriginals and the settlers in charge of Moore River native settlement camp. This allows us to see the perspective of all members. Noyce use techniques such as long shots and extremely close ups to create connections allowing the viewers to emphasise with the loss the aboriginals experienced. The Fiftieth Gate and Rabbit Proof Fence both show culture by speaking in their own unique native tongue this creates awareness to the audience of the history of that particular group.…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The differences of text modes do not limit the similarities in issues and or ideas each mode explores. A documentary and a play would be perceive to be nothing alike, one with a serious front and one aiming to entertain a crowd. But John Pilger’s Utopia and Jack Davis’s No sugar, both explore and showcase the issues the Aboriginal culture faces in a post-colonial Australian society. The issue of Aboriginals being treated as obstacles towards a ‘better Australia’ is apparent in both of these modes, but what separates the modes is the way this issue is presented through the various dramatic and documentary conventions. Through the contrasting…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Snow Falling on Cedars

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ishmael comes back from the war with all these emotions that he still posseses for Hatsue. He sees her in the grocery store, and even though she is holding her newborn baby, he tells her “I am like a dying person… I haven’t been happy for a single moment since the day you left……

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dougy by James Moloney

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The novel 'Dougy' by James Moloney is intended to capture the attention of young readers. It talks about Racial Conflict, Racial Discrimination, Family support, and Determination which is experienced by all the people in the world especially in multi-cultural countries. The story also deals with a range of issues facing Aboriginal society. It tells the readers the fear and misunderstanding between Aboriginals and white Australians that has existed for decades.…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Long Way Gone

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The war is what the book is focused around and it shows how a young boy is stuck in the middle of it. The first thing that happens to introduce you to the war is when 3 boys, Ishmael, Junior, and Talloi went to Mattru Jong. There they heard their home town Mogbwemo was attacked by rebels. The boys then started their journey of running away from rebels to find safe places. As him and another group of boys reach a safe town they were forced into the government army. “He (The lieutenant) paused slowly and continued: “Some of you are here because they have killed your parents or families, others because this is a safe place to be. Well, it is not that safe anymore. That is why we need strong men and boys to help us fight these guys, so that we can keep this village safe” (Beah 106). After fighting the horrible war for a couple years Ishmael was sent to a rehabilitation camp for kids his age. After being in the camp for several months he was finally sent to live with his uncle in Freetown. Ishmael thought he was finally away from the war and could have a semi normal life. One morning he woke up with the ringing of guns shooting. He stayed at the house along with his family but knew he would have to leave. The conflict was never resolved in Ishmael’s story but was avoided by him. He left Sierra Leone to live with Laura in New York…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    English Essay

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The audience gains a greater understanding and appreciation of the consequences and societal issues presented through the author’s texts of changing perspectives. This greater understanding is represented by a wide range of language techniques showing the quality of a change of perspective in life. In the short story ‘Forgotten Jelly’ by Megan Jacobson, it demonstrates how an individual understands the consequences and issues while time progresses, which in turn leads to a change of perspective. Likewise, in the poem ‘Mending Wall’ by Robert Frost, we observe how, as the characters develop, they understand and gradually learn more about the perspective of others and eventually leading to a change of their previous views.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Long Way Gone Reflection

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages

    As Ishmael is going on his journey to find his family, he is hopeful and willing to do whatever it takes in order to find them. But once it has dawned on him that his family has been killed, it seems as if his humanity has been turned off. He becomes a soldier; capable of extreme acts of violence, and is blinded by his own thirst for revenge. Once his family has been taken away from him, he goes numb and no longer cares about anything other than his blood thirst. It is painful to experience this, as Ishmael’s once kind and timid personality has become altered into a drug addicted killing crazed soldier.…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hannie Rayson's play attempts to articulate an Australian identity and suggests that the experience of living elsewhere alters one's perceptions of home. She explores ideas about loyalty and betrayal from the perspective of an expatriate, Meg, and examines to what degree should we criticise or accept the faults of our country and of our loved ones.…

    • 257 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opposing Viewpoints Essay

    • 1550 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Everyone has their own opinion. The person sitting next to you can have an entirely different outlook on something you do. Having different opinions is what makes for interesting arguments. Especially an author and a critic… like Steven Johnson and Dana Stevens. In the article “Watching TV Makes You Smarter”, Steven Johnson believes that TV does make you smarter, while in her article “Thinking Outside the Idiot Box” Dana Stevens completely disagrees and critiques his article. The two have opposing views on the topic. Both these writers use different examples of ethos, pathos, and logos in their articles to back up their opinion and make for an interesting argument. In my opinion, Dana Stevens overall did a better job at using ethos, pathos, and logos to back up her argument. “From the vantage point of someone who watches a hell of a lot of TV (but still far less than the average American), the medium seems neither like a brain-liquefying poison nor a salutary tonic” (Stevens, 2012, p. 298). This quote is what Steven really tries to prove the whole article and back up with her arguments.…

    • 1550 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racism Theme in No Sugar

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout Australian history a racist attitude towards Aboriginals has been a significant issue. The instant the early settlers arrived on our shores and colonised, the Aboriginals have been fighting for the survival of their culture. The Aboriginals have been oppressed and dominated to bring them in line with an idealistic European society. Racism, as practiced against Aborigines, has been defined as the ‘conscious or unconscious belief in the superiority of persons from European ancestry, which entitles all white peoples to a position of dominance or privilege determined by racial origin'. This theme of racism has been put forward by Jack Davis in his stage play, No Sugar, the story of an Aboriginal family's fight for survival during the Great Depression. Jack Davis uses a white medium to present Aboriginal views as a revisionist text. He has used what has been termed "jarring witness" as one who questions and disrupts the versions of others. In this case the Aboriginals present their version of the past which seriously undermines accepted accounts of the official past proposed by white Australians. In communicating the racist and unfriendly attitudes of the leading white ideology, Davis constructs characters, which are continuously under fire and in opposition to the oppressing dominant white society. Davis utilises his characters to confront the audience and…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays