top-rated free essay

Compare And Contrast Essay 3

By Josealexx Nov 30, 2014 821 Words
Jose Alexis Ortega
Professor Cormier
English 110
6 October 2014
Compare and Contrast: A Reading Analysis
Throughout dozens of decades the subject of the Earth’s environment has been in the hands of human beings; however, society is in the brink of finding out the true importance of living a sustainable life due to all the allocations of whether saving our natural resources is the next step for mankind. In fact, in the matter of the following years the subject of environmental science will fall upon the words of contemporary society in a rapid state. Earth is limited in natural resources and it is important for human beings to not fall in oblivion which may lead to a lifestyle the humans have not yet witnessed. Maude Barlow, a leading voice against U.S.—Canada Free Trade Agreement, speaks on behalf the issue of water consumption which doubles every twenty years; it is almost more than double the rate of the human population growth. Barlow reports that as the world moves toward increased globalization, the value of natural resources will be on the rise. This situation will give those who have control over resources, such as water, more economic and political power. In addition, Wendell Berry, an educator with the National Endowment for the Arts award, describes American culture as a foolish equation of “limitlessness” with “freedom. Berry then looks to Marlowe’s Faustus and Milton’s Satan for prescient examples of our currently self-obsessed and selfish society, and to art in general for ways to live in a more sustainable way. A well-known writer and environmentalist challenges America’s attitude toward energy resources as delusional. As the title of this selection suggests, this attitude will have the gravest consequences for the planet Although both authors indicate a serious concern on the allocation a disruption of Earth’s limited resources, the way they try to approach the audience are exceptionally different.

Initially, Berry’s and Barlow’s use of language is different from one another; however, they do have similarities. To begin, Barlow has a very analytical, academic tone appealing to logos. For example, throughout Barlow’s essay there is a significant amount of statistics and facts from a variety of sources. “The number of large dams worldwide has climbed from just over 5,000 in 1950 to 38,000 today” states Barlow. Not only this gives the author the academic tone needed to persuade an audience, but it provides effective proof for the audience. Moreover, Berry approaches the audience through the use of pathos. An example is the words taken to describe human being such as animals. Berry states, “But to define ourselves as animals, given our specifically human powers and desires, is to define ourselves as limitless animals—which of course is a contradiction in terms.” Berry’s use of language is appealing to the emotions of the reader in order to have an emotional reaction towards the subject. Although both authors use of language differ, the passion for living a more sustainable way of life impact the reader. Their passion for environmental science make their use of language have discreet similarities.

Furthermore, both authors use of rhetorical strategies differ from one another. Barlow chooses a classic argument development with specific subject-centered points designed to get the reader to agree that water should not be treated like a product to be sold to the highest bidder. She wants us to think about what water is to us. Barlow uses argumentative language and examples. Berry relies on more generalized and philosophical arguments designed to get the reader to think about the “big picture” of why we treat our natural resources the way we do and why we should not.

Moreover, Barlow and Berry choose different critical foci for their arguments. Berry is secular throughout her essay. However, Berry’s approach is more spiritual and philosophical due to the use of the Christian religion and cultural history. The effect on a secular approach is much more effective in contemporary society due to the fact that it is direct and filled with statistics and facts rather than from readings. In addition, the spiritual approach could hurt an argument, but it also has its pro’s. Modern society is still very spiritual and believe in their designated religions and due to the prior knowledge on readings. There is an effective approach in both passages because it has to do with the same subject. Both authors would be influencing both halves of the world.

To conclude, although both authors had an effective argument within their passages, Barlow has the upper hand in approaching and persuading the audience. Berry’s secular and directness towards the audience is much more effective and provides the needed information. In contemporary society most people rather have the facts at hand than having to do readings to understand the spirituality of the subject. In addition, the readings helped me as an individual to understand both approaches to an argument.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Compare and contrast essay

    ...Brown Brothers; How Negative Stereotypes Affect Polynesian And Maori In New Zealand 'My demographic is: high school cleaning ladies, fast food burger-making, factory boxpacking, rubbish truck drivers, bus drivers, taxi drivers, sober drivers and living off the pension joy riders — I am a dropout.' These are all ideas raised and challenged b...

    Read More
  • Compare and Contrast Essay

    ...AP World History, Period F April 23, 2012 Compare and Contrast Essay Although they are two totally different battles, the Normandy Landings and the Battle of Gettysburg have many similarities and differences. The Normandy Landings are also referred to what most people recognize today as D-Day. It took place on June 6, 1944 and was an allie...

    Read More
  • Neisha Essay Compare And Contrast

    ...Topic: Compare and contrast bullying and peer pressure. Thesis: Bullying and peer pressure are comparable in terms of its consequences, benefits, drawbacks and prevention strategies. Sub topics Topic sentences 1 Consequences Bullying and peer pressure are different in terms of its consequences 2 Benefits Benefits vary in bu...

    Read More
  • Compare and Contrast Essay

    ...EN101/A Compare and Contrast Essay Spring 2013 School Life in Korea and America Education system is one of the most crucial characteristics that define one nation. Furthermore, secondary education system is especially valuable; since one’s self-esteem starts to form during adolescence. Since my parents decided to move to America when I was ...

    Read More
  • Compare and Contrast Essay

    ...Emerson and Thoreau share similar views on life. They share similar views on life like thinking that it should be taken with simple steps and with ease, living life the way you want to, and appreciating the little values that come along with it. Thoreau states that life should be simple and that “being in the now” is taking over. Everyday ad...

    Read More
  • Compare or Contrast Essay (Movies)

    ... SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE, BUILDING AND DESIGN THE DESIGN SCHOOL FOUNDATION IN NATURAL AND BUILD ENVIRONMENT Name : Tan Ming Howe Student ID : 0320199 Films Selected : Interstellar & Inception Word Count : 948 ENGLISH 2 (ELG 30605) Written Assignment 1 : Compare/Contrast Essay Lecturer : Cassandra Wijesuria Submission date : 8th April 2015 ...

    Read More
  • Compare Contrast Essay

    ...Jeleigha Ritter Compare-Contrast Essay Although both Spunk and Joe compete for Lena’s affection, Lena admires Spunk due to his physical appearance, wealth, and reputation among the townsmen. Though these men clearly have different backgrounds, they both have one thing in common, which is their affection for Lena. Both men share a love for Len...

    Read More
  • Compare and Contrast Essay (Cellphones)

    ...Page 1 INDIVIDUAL PROJECT UNIT FOUR (COMPARE and CONTRAST) SCHERICE WIMLEY AMERICAN INTERCONTINENTAL UNIVERSITY Page 2 Abstract page In this paper I am to compare and contrast three cell phones for my company or organization’s use. I have researched the three phones that I like; I also have to give my recommendation for...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.