top-rated free essay

Comparative Essay On European Colonialism 1500 1750

By alixiang Apr 17, 2015 1023 Words
September 26, 2014

Comparative Essay on European Colonialism 1500-1750

During the 1500 to 1750s, Europe began their expansion into the Americas. There were many reasons for Spain, France, Portugal, and England to head to the Americas. While the factors driving these European powerhouses to the ‘New World’ were similar in nature, England stands out as the most successful Colonial ruler in most facets of colonization due to its handsoff approach, allowing for the colonies to thrive through successful self- governing, strong economic options in trade and workforce, and flexibility in social, family, and everyday life. The freedom to self-govern afforded to the colonists by the British was a very large factor in the success that England had as a Colonial ruler. The English colonies were given this opportunity by The Virginia Company House of Burgesses, provided they agreed not to attack England. Since many of the English colonists arrived here to escape religious or political persecution, or just to be able to practice their religion in the way they wanted to, giving the colonies the power to elect their own government and set their own rules resulted in greater chance that the colonists were able to achieve that freedom. Contrary to England, the Spanish colonies had a centralized royal government while the General of Brazil and the French king ruled their respective colonies, resulting in no government rights for the colonists. England’s choice to allow self- government proved more successful than the other countries’ decisions to have a monarchial government because it gave its people more freedom and flexibility. The British colonies also had greater economic growth due to a stronger workforce and more viable trading routes. At the beginning, when the English arrived in America, they were not

very successful. They originally settled in Jamestown with the Virginia Company managing the colony. However, the swampy landscape in Jamestown bred disease. In addition, at first the relationship with the Amerindians worked well, with the colonists trading goods such as knives, axes, and utensils used for cooking and fishing, but in time conflict arose, mostly over land. Between the disease and the deadly conflict with the Amerindians, by 1624 a large portion of the original colonists were gone. It was at that time that the English government disbanded the Virginia Company because of its bad management of Jamestown, resulting in more freedom for the colonists to move away from Jamestown and establish their own economies. This expansion allowed colonists to migrate closer to necessary waterways on the East Coast, which increased trade due to the availability of a viable route for shipping, resulting in a stronger colonist economy. This differs from the Spanish and Portuguese colonies where their European governments’ control limited the shipping of trading goods by imposing high taxes on the colonies. In addition, initially indentured servants were used by England, but while that was replaced by the less expensive slave labor, the use of the indentured servants encouraged more growth in the colonies because it gave ultimate land ownership after a period of labor. By comparison, the Spanish colonies forced the Amerindian and indigenous peoples into labor and the Portuguese relied on African slaves due to the fact that they didn’t have enough Amerindian peoples. The French used slaves as a labor system with help from the Amerindians. While these three all provided adequate labor, none allowed for growth because of lack of direct involvement or land ownership by the colonists. Finally, the English relied significantly on private investment to help with the growth and development of the colonies. While France also used private companies to help grow the economy, they weren’t as effective as England because of the tight control over the colonists by the French government. Despite the poor start, the English

rebounded economically and thrived as a result of the good decisions made by the English government, which included the expansion of the colony, the freedom of the people, an indentured and slave workforce, and private investments.

Since there was not strong political control over its colonies by England, the settlers in those colonies had more flexibility socially rather than being overly structured. While hierarchies existed in some of the colonies such as in South Carolina, that was generally not the case in the British colonies. The British colonies had more complete family units which resulted in faster population growth, ultimately contributing to more overall growth. While the wealthier colonists ruled these colonies, in general there were not large differences of status found there. This differs from Spain and Portugal which both had vertical hierarchies and classes of society, which is more similar to the social structure typically found in Europe. The top of the hierarchy in these colonies, such as the Conquistadors from Spain, tried to mimic the nobility in Europe and in the process abused the Amerindians, attempting to conquer them and convert them to Catholicism. King Ferdinand of Spain even sent a letter along with Christopher Columbus demanding that the Amerindians from the Taino-Arawak tribe convert to Catholicism, threatening force for those that don’t comply. The Amerindians ultimately ended up revolting. The French also structured a hierarchy but with the Jesuits on top. These Jesuits were more focused on missionary work than they were on trying to grow the colony. They also tried to convert the Amerindians to Christianity but they failed as well. Overall, these countries’ attempts to organize their governments in a hierarchical manner only resulted in more problems among their colonists and their relations with others.

The English were more successful at ruling their colonies than the French, Spanish, and Portuguese because of England’s policy of granting control to the colonists. This “hands-off”

approach led to increased growth of the colonies, both economically and socially, and was significantly more successful than the tight grip ruling and attempt at religious conversion that the other countries demonstrated.

Bibliography
"Colonial-Indian Relations." Web. 24 Sept. 2014. <http://www.let.rug.nl/usa/outlines/history1994/early-america/colonial-indian-relations.php>. "King Ferdinand's Letter to the Taino-Arawak Indians." Web. 24 Sept. 2014. <http://www.let.rug.nl/usa/documents/before-1600/king-ferdinands-letter-to-the-tainoarawak-indians.php>.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Comparative Essay

    ... Danielle Lindstrom Critical Reading Analysis Essay WRD 103-8:30 Typically when I’m given an article to read I’m not too thrilled. Unless it applies to fashion or cupcakes it is safe to say that I fall into the “I have better things to do” camp along with many of my peers. This mentality, as much as it gets the best of me, see...

    Read More
  • comparative essay

    ... I have sent emails to you to talk about my devised topic. My topic is to talk about memorable characters: round and dynamic, flat or static. These characters play different roles for different purpose. I will choose one character form each of Charlotte's Web and Hana's Suitcase that I find are important to their stories. I will ex...

    Read More
  • Comparative Essay

    ...comments on the similarities and differences between the texts and the significance of context, purpose, audience, and formal and stylistic features. Cranes by Jennifer Ackerman, and To a Waterfowl by William Cullen Bryant, both aim to enlighten and educate their readers on the behavior and beauty of waterfowl. Text 1, Cranes, an article from...

    Read More
  • Comparative essay

    ...Comparative Essay The article “Law, Self-Government, and Gay Marriage” by Benjamin L. Smith and the article “Gay marriage” by Pro-Con Non-Profit Organization deal with the man issue of gay marriage and how it can be beneficial or harmful to today society. The journalists want to prove in what ways allowing homosexual couples to ma...

    Read More
  • Comparative Essay

    ... Life of Pi Vs. The Catcher in the Rye -A Comparative Essay All literature contains a purpose behind it—an underlying message that the author is trying to convey. As a result of this, most novels typically tend to focus on several specific areas, leaving other areas less explored. Setting, main character, and confl...

    Read More
  • Comparative Essay

    ...Heart of Darkness vs. Jumping Monkey Hill Heart of Darkness, by Joseph Conrad is a novel about an English man’s journey to Congo during the Belgian invasion. The novel has been considered by the critics “among the half-dozen greatest short novels in the English language” However, the book has been subject to criticism for its brutal de...

    Read More
  • comparative essays

    ...Introduction Many people today have their thoughts on how the Earth was created. Christians take a biblical perspective of how the universe was created by a creator. One thought that Christians believe is that God created the earth and accomplished this in six days and rested on the seventh day. This is the model of how a week is set up and th...

    Read More
  • Comparative Essay

    ...Modern Culinary Practice’s Influence on Americans As we look around us each day, food’s impact becomes obviously evident. There are restaurants, particularly fast food restaurants, everywhere we look, and we even see food trailers as we take a walk around the city or a park. Americans are dependent on the concept of instant access to...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.