Preview

Civil Resistance

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
650 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Civil Resistance
Civil resistance is political action that relies on the use of nonviolent resistance by civil groups to challenge a particular power, force, policy or regime. Civil resistance operates through appeals to the adversary, pressure and coercion: it can involve systematic attempts to undermine the adversary's sources of power, both domestic and international. Forms of action have included demonstrations, vigils and petitions; strikes, go-slows, boycotts and emigration movements; and sit-ins, occupations, and the creation of parallel institutions of government. Civil resistance movements' motivations for avoiding violence are generally related to context, including a society's values and its experience of war and violence, rather than to any absolute …show more content…
The phenomenon of civil resistance is often associated with the advancement of democracy. It is not easy to devise a method of proving the relative success of different methods of struggle. Often there are problems in identifying a given campaign as successful or otherwise. In 2008 Maria J. Stephan and Erica Chenoweth produced Why Civil Resistance Works, the most thorough and detailed analysis of the rate of success of civil resistance campaigns, as compared to violent resistance …show more content…
Criticisms of the central thesis of Why Civil Resistance Works have included forming judgement about whether a campaign is a success or failure is inherently difficult: the answer may depend on the time-frame used, and on necessarily subjective judgments about what constitutes success. Some of the authors' decisions on this are debatable. Similar difficulties arise in deciding whether a campaign is violent or non-violent, when on the ground both strategies may co-exist in several

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    One specific cause for resistance referenced multiple times throughout the book is raising the minimum wage of the peasants working on sugar and cotton plantations. In 1980, 80 thousand peasants participated in a strike to demand a minimum wage of 5 quetzals (Menchú, ch. 32). Many of the indigenous population’s protests, such as the aforementioned, were peaceful, but the depiction of their organized resistance by the U.S. media is confined to the stereotype of militant, armed…

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    He describes the groupings of various people throughout the United States, stating that, “numerous ad hoc groups were formed-and are still formed- in communities when particularly outrageous events occurred.” He goes on to describe the Citizen’s Committee for Justice, a group that “attained unusual success, and the local gun law was changed after a Riverside policeman had killed a fleeing youth” (Grebler, 533-534). Grebler effectively shows that people have consistently gathered themselves into groups to create a unity of people through which to express their complaints, and on rare occasions, their requests are granted. Although it is not often that a wish from the proletariat is granted by the bourgeoisie, the act of defiance develops the sense of self-efficacy. What follows is one of the most important ways in which the proletariat can give itself power and take charge of the situation that has been forced upon them.…

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They outline that civilian defense forces as a permanent and defensive form of pro-government militia that officials will often use to harness civilians during a counterinsurgency campaign. The authors argue that a civilian defense forces will reduce the problem of insurgent identification. This will lead to a reduction in state violence that targets civilians. Nevertheless, they also claim that these actors can and will undermine civilian support for insurgents, which can lead to rise in rebel violence targeting civilians and overall escalation of violence. the evidence in this article shows that a permanent civilian defense forces decreases the state’s use of indiscriminate violence, but causes a rise in insurgent violence. They also demonstrated that by making civilians the epicenter of the unconventional war effort, civilian defense forces increase the overall loss of life in civil conflicts, at least in the short run. “This underscores the significance of civilian support and control in determining the type and level of violence in civil wars” (Clayton…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nagler (2004) supports the idea that nonviolence works by saying that the outcome of using nonviolence is not a by-product but a result (pg156). This is referring to nonviolence not being a last resort and how it is mostly successful and not just a coincidence. Nagler (2004) also stated “violence sometimes works but it never works; nonviolence sometimes works and never fails to work” (pg129). Nagler is stating here that nonviolence is not weak but is a powerful tool that should be used just like any other method of combat. In India, Gandhi used nonviolence to free his people from the British rule. Martin Luther King Jr. used nonviolence also in the civil rights movement and it showed great success. In Egypt protesters occupied a public square which resulted in a 30 year ruler stepping…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cited: Drinan, S.J. Robert F. "Civil Disobedience." Novelguide: Free Study Guides, Free Book Summaries, Free Book Notes, & More. 2000. Web. 08 Dec. 2010. http://www.novelguide.com/a/discover/eamc_01/eamc_01_00444.html…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Twentieth Century, the great leaders Mohandas Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, and Martin Luther King Jr. all used non-violence to bring about change to their respective countries. What made nonresistance work was the charisma of the leaders to persuade the people to not fight back, the peaceful protests, the leaders’ willingness to accept their punishments, and their struggle for unity.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even with the supporting evidence throughout the book for the Political Process model, I fail to see how it can be the sole explanation for such a large and successful movement. The inclusion of the more analytical details seemed to overcomplicate the subject rather than aid the explanations. I would like to have seen more information on the actual historical events and not just the pieces that are referencing the political aspects which support the authors claim. I would have also like to see more information about how the actual politicians and constituents were dealing with the rise of the insurgency since their approval of the movement would be necessary for the movement to have gain the success that it…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Civil disobedience is a form of protest in which protesters deliberately violate a law” (suber). It is a way for society to reform itself to reflect its current values while maintaining its fundamental ideals. Some may argue civil disobedience is a “slippery slope” leading to anarchy or it cannot be justified in a democracy. Civil disobedience, while not optimum, is a way to accomplish change with the intent of reform and stabilizing communities.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The history of violence in the world is well documented. However it is also possible to use non-violence to bring about change. This DBQ will look at two countries where a non-violent movement was successful.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout history the world has witnessed acts of terrorism motivated by different groups of individuals fighting for a multitude of causes. These individuals have come from various races, religions, and ethnicities. Yet as different as they appear to be, we can still find similarities between them, for instance, groups such as the Tupamaros in Uruguay, the Ku Klux Klan in the United States, and the Irish Republican Army are motivated by vastly different beliefs which they consider a justification for terrorism. However, the underlying concept of these groups, by using acts of terror as a means to an end, is by and large shared by all of them. This paper will evaluate the hypothesis made by Cindy Combs which states, “The forces of oppression that have caused men to rebel have not changed over the centuries; what has changed is the willingness of the oppressed to use previously unthinkable means to achieve their objectives.”1 (Combs, p. 35.). It will also examine the strengths and weaknesses of this statement as it applies to case studies of the groups mentioned above.…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do we live in a world where violent resistance is no longer a realistic option to oppose an oppressive regime? The Kenny reading showed that non-violence is a path that can lead to regime change. Why is that? Is it because a non-violent struggle is morally superior to a violent one, and is therefore difficult to oppose? After all, it’s difficult to justify violence against those who struggle without violence, for human rights, justice and democracy, things most people desire. To repress them would be a blatant violation of basic human decency, whereas in an armed struggle, repression can be justified, and implemented on a mass scale, in the name of stability. Perhaps a non-violent struggle is also superior to an armed one because of the question it poses? When a government faces a rebellion, its survival depends on its ability to out-kill the other side. But in a non-violent struggle, the government’s survival depends on its legitimacy in the eyes of the people. The struggle therefore becomes over votes, and rally sizes, both of which governments cannot win over easily when they are struggling against the numerically larger and more in-touch members of civil society. This could explain why governments often rely on crowd dispersal and repression, to combat non-violent activism.…

    • 265 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With so much violence nowadays, it seems like there is no other way for opposing sides to act. I found it extremely interesting that nonviolent actions “dramatically outperform” violent ones even in cases of authoritarian regimes and dictatorships. Both articles gave me a small sense of validation; I’m not crazy for believing in the power of organizing and nonviolence. Chenoweth’s examples of successful movements, especially those in grave conditions, was also extremely uplifting.…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history many different tactics have been used to try to stop violence. Gandhi was one of the most successful in using non violence to resolve a conflict. A very unsuccessful protest was Tiananmen Square. There are many different determining factors in order to have a non violent protest succeed or not work.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Way Of War Essay

    • 2988 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The civil aspect is shaped in the form of resistance. “No State has the right to war in order to achieve rational–not reasonable–interests.” After the war versus the Soviets–a war initiated in part by the leftist party in power in Afghanistan at the time (1979) in order to obtain moral and strategic support from the USSR–Afghanistan entered a cruel and prolonged civil war. The many distinct tribes contended for power and the Taliban succeeded. Although there and they were the triumphant and the unfortunate, the conservative and extremely tribal thought was present in any side. The success of some did not destroy the present, the constant thought of the immediate past. The Taliban concept (with a central government exiled in its own country) is present in form of support and a sense of misplaced nostalgia by the periphery. The support that ideological hegemony brings (once found by the US troops in Iraq) does exist, though in rachitic quantities in…

    • 2988 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The revolution in the Arab world unfolded exquisitely but with dramatic repercussions. High unemployment rates, the oppression of political freedoms, and the overwhelming presence of corruption led to a rise in unrest amongst many in the Arab world -- which set off a domino effect amongst states in a fight for democracy at home. It all began in Tunisia in December 2010, and quickly escalated into a campaign for change that would reach across the region, and move the world. By the time the conflict reached a boiling point -- governments in Egypt, Libya and Yemen would also be ousted in an uprising that would make history. What couldn’t be predicted however, were the various means to which the conflict would culminate for the dictators themselves.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays