Preview

toba tek singh

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1047 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
toba tek singh
"Toba Tek Singh" is surely the most famous story about Partition, and very possibly the best one. I'd argue that it is in fact the best, and that most of the other good candidates are also by Manto. This story was one of his last ones; it was published in "Phundne" (Lahore: Maktabah-e Jadid) in 1955, the year of his death.
The story is told by a reliable but not omniscient narrator who speaks as a Pakistani, and seems to be a Lahori. The narration is for the most part so straightforward that the narrator's voice seems even naive (or faux-naif, depending on how we want to read it). The narrator reports to us with apparent matter-of-factness a series of events that are not quite as straightforward as they appear. The time frame, for one thing, is oddly jagged. The first two paragraphs take us to the Wagah border itself, where the lunatics are described as having already arrived. Then we drop abruptly into a very long flashback: we return to an earlier time, when the inmates in the Lahore asylum first learn of the proposed exchange. We follow their reactions and behavior, until at the very end of the story we once again arrive at the time and place of the first two paragraphs.
A much greater oddity is that the whole story, as we're told in the first sentence, takes place "two or three years after Partition," so it seems highly implausible that not only the lunatics, but the people around them as well, can't figure out where Toba Tek Singh is; the district isn't even anywhere near the border, so after "two or three years" there could hardly be any confusion. But it's a tribute to Manto's narrative skill that on the first reading, this question doesn't even occur-- and perhaps not on the second or third reading, either.
We don't meet the main character until well into the story, when we've gone through an illustrative sequence of other lunatics. The narrator reports that everyone calls the main character "Toba Tek Singh" (though in the whole course of the story we

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    * As Najaf flees across the border from Afghanistan to Pakistan, he becomes sentimental about the loss of his homeland. While he discovers freedom, he is torn between what he has left behind and his hope of what is to come. When Najaf reaches Australia, this conflict of emotion is a constant throughout his time in Woomera. There is a battle in the heart and mind of the Woomera detainees between feelings of hope and despair.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As I read the first two pages of chapter twenty I pictured what Amir had witnessed and felt an overwhelming feelings of empathy, sorrow and gratefulness that I would mostly never have to see that in my life and how when he walked through his old neighborhood all his old memories would forever be haunted by ruined and death ridden place he once called home. This is another window that shows the reader another daily event Afghan’s witnessed walking through there own or old neighborhoods. For example it said, “I had a friend there once,’ Farid said ‘he was a very good bicycle repairman. He played the tabla well too. Then Taliban killed him and his family and burned the village.” This quote was an example of one of the several thousand Afghan’s who have seen or heard of family, friends or neighbors killed by the Taliban for a plethora of unknown reasons. This two pages reveal to the audience one out of plenty troubling and horrendous ordeals that people dealt with for possible all their lives living in Afghanistan after the war.…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Set against the backdrop of the gradual rise of the Taliban, the novel follows the life of it’s the narrator, Amir, who faces a personal crisis when he witnesses an act of violence done to his loyal friend and servant, Hassan, which he fails to prevent. The guilt of his inaction overwhelms Amir and he eventually forces Hassan and his father Ali to cease their servitude, much to the dismay of…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    2003 Apush Dbq Analysis

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages

    One inevitable impact the division had on the people was perhaps one of the greatest refugee crises and migration in history. Over 10 million people moved between India and Pakistan. For the most part, the Hindus generally moved into the Indian subcontinent while the Muslims, who feared Hindu domination, migrated to East and West Pakistan. In Document 8 it shows that there were around 8.6 million Muslim refugees that migrated out of India into either East or West Pakistan. In addition to this extraordinary refugee crises, another effect the division of India had was border tensions. The tensions between the borders of India and Pakistan resulted in India being at the “receiving end of Pakistan’s heavy shelling” and “heavy bombing” (Document 9b). This shows that not only was there a large scale migration crises, there was also several attacks and possibly deaths and casualties from bombs. Also, in document 9a it that states that another effect of the division was that there were “two armed conflicts (in 1965 and 1999) and numerous clashes between Indian and Pakistani forces”. This highlights the various facets of the tensions and problems the division of India had on the Hindus and Muslims. It is inevitable that the division of the region greatly affected the people who lived there by causing the largest migration in human history, armed conflicts, and…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During periods of chaos and war, extraordinary occurrences happen where least expected. In a land where many religions are accustomed, Afghanistan’s citizens are divided by these religions. However in the case of safety, two religious groups come together, believing in the same idea. The Hazara and Pashtuns are religious groups with conflicting opinions and different leaders. But Qadem, a known Pashtun to Najafs Hazara family knows Najaf would ‘surely be killed’ if he was to remain in his homeland. It is there that the two groups, although nervous, put aside their differences and conflicting beliefs and ‘entrust’ their lives with one another for the safety of their own futures. Qadem helps Najaf seek asylum from Afghanistan and in turn this leads to him becoming a refugee.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel ‘The Rugmaker of Mazar-e-Sharif’ by Najaf Mazari and Robert Hillman, reveals the life tale of an extraordinary person, Najaf Mazari. In Najaf Mazari’s life he goes through many difficulties, such as the time that he spent in Woomera that made his life much better than it was, but it is also the continuous and numerous war and conflict in his village and across his nation of Afghanistan. Najaf, his whole life has revolved around difficult decisions and choices, some of these decisions made him get caught by the Taliban. To get through all of this he created options and with the help of his belief in God and the support of his family, he is able to keep pushing on to reach his goal of finding a better life for him and his family.…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Najmah Research Paper

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Who would stop him from killing you and taking everything? You will die if you go back!”(256).This means that even if Najmah gets back to her home, her uncle could kill her and take the land, because he is a man and women aren't allowed to have land. The initial threat of the Taliban, bandits and her uncle are stopping her to her destination. (STEWE-2)When Najmah makes her decision to leave to go back home she says, “For there is great value to live in a village called Golestan which means ‘beautiful garden’”(270) This shows that she is happy where her home is and she feels best to stay where she is. (SIP-B)Najmah goes home to fulfill her father’s wish to live in the beautiful mountain, where she feels safe and is the only place that will ever feel like home, knowing that he land has been in her family for generations.(STEWE-1) When Nur reconnects with Najmah the first words that slip from his mouth are, “ Baba-Jan is dead.”(253). Najmah knew something was wrong because Nur was by himself. Najmah remembered how her father told her to make sure to keep the land for him so his brother doesn’t steal it. With him dead, Najmah wants to do what father would have wanted. (STEWE-2) But that’s when Najmah was arguing with Nusrat about what’s the better choice for Najmah’s future, Najmah states, “ We have no choice but to go back to Golestan, Uncle or someone will take our land if we don’t go back. It was our father’s last wish that we should keep our farm land from the hands of the taliban or uncle.”(256). This shows that Najmah isn’t afraid to die trying, because she wants to make sure her father’s dying wish will come true. (CS) With Baba-jan dead, Najmah changes and takes away her safety to do what right, and that is to go back…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hazaras In The Kite Runner

    • 1321 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The relentless Pashtuns constructed a tough life on the Hazaras as can be seen in the Kite Runner, but some seemed to still gather happiness with the little freedom they had. Once the Taliban came to power the most gruesome days of the Hazaras had just become, as everyone feared for their life. The present life of a Hazara and potential they are granted is only something dreamed of during their darkest years. The relationship between Pashtuns and Hazaras has now been remolded into a life lived with each other, in further equality then ever experienced…

    • 1321 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As Hazaras, we had waited for the day that we would be treated as equals. I recalled the day that the Taliban moved in and put an end to all the fighting and my mother telling me “Afrooz we are going to be safe.” The expression on her face, I remember fondly the hope that sparkled in her eyes, she radiated this excitement and feeling of hope. Things however turned sour very quickly after the Taliban had took over, the group that we thought off as saviours, began massacring Hazaras like us. Kabul had become a dangerous place for Hazaras like us. The Taliban would knock on doors demanding any Hazara servants to be released so that they could publicly execute us. Hazara villages would be torched until nothing but ashes remained while they stood with around, shooting anybody trying to…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The government advertises a civil war, by expressing hatred towards the ethnical minorities in Afghanistan, primarily the Hazara. Pashtuns are taught to hate the Hazara because of the history and slight religious difference the two people have, despite both being Afghans. As Amir’s curiosity about Hazaras grows, he thinks, “School textbooks barely mentioned them… I found one of my mother’s old history books… people called Hazaras mice eating, flat nosed, load carrying donkeys…”(10). The corrupt and biased government has erased the Hazara nation from the school textbooks, and curriculum. Both, Pashtun books and people don’t have pleasant to things to say about the Hazara; who by some aren’t even considered to be humans. When the new government took office in 1996, many people celebrated, but the Hazaras know their fate in Afghanistan. In a letter from Hassan, he writes, “We all celebrated in 1996 when the Taliban rolled in… Hassan in the kitchen. He had a sober look in his eyes… God help the Hazaras now… two years later they massacred the Hazaras in Mazar-I – Sharif”(224). When the Taliban came into power all the Pashtuns celebrated, they had false hope of an end to their problems. The Taliban eventually become the worst thing to have happened to Afghanistan. The Taliban’s hatred for the Hazara is even more severe than the past governments of Afghanistan. They massacre innocent…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    * Farid - growing up in Mazar-i-Aharif, in Jalalalbad. His father joined the jihad and fought the Shorawi in Panjsher Valley and ate locust to survive.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They Say I Say Hosseini

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This review explains how Hosseini’s story “mirror[s] Afghanistan’s political, social and religious tensions and complexities.” The review also discusses how Hosseini believes that “storytelling must be privileged in the novel” and how the intent of the author is to “keep Afghanistan and its travails in the public’s consciousness.” It emphasizes that this is a novel…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The relationship of the two boys Amir and Hassan who were the Sultans of Kabul has come to an end after Hassan got raped by Assef, a famous bully of the neighborhood. Since Amir was grown up as a self-defend less kid, he couldn’t help Hassan and felt guilty for not doing anything for him. The guilt has developed as the time passed until Amir decided to kick Hassan and his father out of the house. After a few weeks of Hassan and his father’s departure, the Russians invaded Afghanistan and Amir left the country behind with his father Baba and escaped to Pakistan.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I belong to the ethnic Punjabi community. We are a friendly people, known for our resilience, love of adventure and good food, vibrant music and the pulsating Bhangra dance, apart from our ability to work hard and adapt to new situations and immerse in new environments, making them ours. My grandparents, paternal and maternal, moved to Delhi during the mass migration of 1947, when India and Pakistan became two sovereign nations. My grandfathers, both qualified engineers, etched new lives in what for them was then a foreign land, and pursued successful careers, while my grandmothers rebuilt their homes from scratch.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Son the Fanatic

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The main character in the story is Parvez, who’s a good example of an immigrant being well-integrated. He emigrated from Pakistan, where he was taught the Koran. He underwent indignity during this, and subsequently he avoided all religion; he even prefers jokes to rules. Even though he has a wife and a son, he spends most of his time “living a boy’s life” with his fellow taxi drivers; playing card and avoiding their wives. The narration of the story is 3rd person narrative and is therefore limited, but we see the conflict from Parvez’s point of view, which engenders surprises. “Parvez sprang across the hall and set his ear at Ali’s door. A muttering sound came from within (…) The boy was praying.”(l. 130-134)…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays