A Rumor of War is a book bases on personal experiences of the author Philip Caputo during the Vietnam War. Philip served in the United States Marine Corps (USMC). He was deployed in South Vietnam during the Vietnam War. When he came back he chose to become a journalist. He is renowned for his book A Rumor of war which he wrote 10 years after returning from war.…
He, like every boy his age, is intrigued by the concept of going to war to fight the Vietnamese and return home a hero that will be welcomed back with applause and appreciation. "We went overseas full of illusions, for which the intoxicating atmosphere of those years was as much to blame as our youth." (Caputo xii). This false sense of the romanticism of war contributes to his initial lean towards instability because it allows Caputo to begin the war in a world that still protects him from the harsh realities that have yet to be witnessed as he enters Vietnam.…
At the beginning of the book private Archie Lemon thinks about the war that suppose to “end injustice,” and that he doesn't mind getting killed, because the people coming after him will live in “happiness and peace” (23). Such a false propaganda is recognized by soldiers fifty pages later. They realize that the war “was brought about moneyed interests for its own selfish ends,” because idealism and patriotism have nothing to do with the war. They call it brutal and degrading, and, “fools who fight, are pawns shoved about to serve the interest of others” (96). March in the 30s recognizes of what the war becomes in the twenty first century; a character name Sergeant Theodore Donohoe back then sees the war as a business (because today it is fought for the territory or land resources); he states that in order to get anywhere in it, one has to adjust oneself to its peculiarities and “play the cards the way they fall” (30). Unfortunately, not a lot of soldiers have learned or will ever learn how to play this game…
John Morton Blum retiree of Yale University depicts “combat soldiers as largely disconnected from the geopolitical goals articulated by President Roosevelt.” Each soldier had his own individual motivation entering into the war but all had the same reason to win the war, to make it home. Home was what encouraged the troops to fight. The Saturday Evening Post ran a series asking soldiers what they were fighting for, they were quoted saying “I am fighting for that big house with the bright green roof and the big front lawn”...“that girl with the large brown eyes and the reddish tinge in her hair.” Blum describes the GI as a homely hero, the common good man and the peoples' hero. The soldiers had no visible purpose but winning the war so that he could return to comfort.…
I certainly enjoyed this autobiography. After reading this book about the author, Philip Caputo, as a young man enlisted and trained so hard to become an American Marine Lieutenant in the Vietnam War, it gave me a whole different perspective of the war. My views of the Vietnam War are usually from the stories my family used to tell me when I was little, but I have never heard it from the viewpoint of a lieutenant. I already knew that when there is a war declared, the war is always attractive to young men who know nothing about it, and even though the men know nothing about the war, the men drafted in the war are…
It is hard to comprehend how traumatic the war really was for those men. Tim O’Brien touches on this matter often through out the book. He mentions that often there are no words to truly describe the horrors the witnessed and the demons they faced inside themselves. O’Brien does his…
There were many conflicts in the story that Caputo had to deal with, one being his ethics. After seeing what napalm or other types of attacks do he became disattached from reality to the point that all he wanted was to die. “I saw their living mouths moving in conversation and their dead mouths grinning the taut-drawn grins of corpses. Their living eyes I saw, and their dead eyes still-staring. Had it not been for the fear that I was going crazy, I would have found it an interesting experience, a trip such as no drug could possibly produce. Asleep and dreaming, I saw dead men living; awake, I saw living men dead.” This is an example of the things he saw out in Vietnam, this is what caused his pain and suffering. This was one of the biggest internal conflicts of the story saying that he had to go through that everyday which caused him lots of pain. “Ethics seemed to be a matter of distance and technology. You could never go wrong if you killed people at long range with sophisticated weapons.” This is just another example of the conflict of ethics. Ethics is one of the main things that Caputo had to deal with throughout the war, it is also one of the main issues citizens of the USA had with the…
Of all of the burdens that the men have to carry to war, I find the most evocative to be the weights of memory and one another. They had lives before the war, and some will not live to the end of the conflict. Memories are a true burden. They’re the remainders of a tangible reality, a reality that the soldiers view as unattainable. The guys are young men who lust, love, party, and play, but they are stuck in a completely unwelcoming environment in which they must kill to survive. War isn’t pretty, but the soldiers need to carry the weight of what they remember in order to stay grounded in themselves. The weight of one another also keeps the soldiers in touch with reality and with each other. They all share fear, longing, and responsibility.…
Tim O’Brien’s, The Things They Carried, contained different memoirs that truly bring the actions of war to life for the reader. Obrien’s book expresses the real feelings a solider faces while getting ready to go into war, in war, and post war. Through his vivid descriptions the reader is able to emphasize with the emotional burdens and stresses solders must go through while on duty. We are able to observe the different coping mechanisms solders must endure, including, cutting them selves off from reality and preoccupying their mind with other, sometimes meaningless, thoughts .The chapter that had the largest impact on myself was “Night Life.” For me this passage truly depicted not just the physical, but mental battle soldiers must go through; and the extreme measures taken to relive themselves from the intensity of battle.…
How do you decide what is true and what is false? In war the line blurs even more. We hear war stories and wonder about the truth of these stories. We love to believe the stories of heroism and bravery. Now how do we know that these stories are real and not created propaganda? The Things They Carried by Tim O?Brien is a fiction book that shines some light on war stories. This complex book focuses on a complex war. The Vietnam War was complex for the reasons surrounding it. Some of the reasons were; the question why we were over there, governments that told half truths on what was going on, and the style of fighting was totally different compared to the past wars. This new style is called guerrilla warfare. O?Brien writes stories that make you…
This meant that even though they were required to carry the physical load and bear the emotional consequences, they still had to “fight” for survival. Every characteristic or thought was taken in a positive manner and helped them develop confidence and motivation that lead them to overcome the devastation of war. For example there was an epiphany for Jimmy Cross at the end of the story when he realized the predicament of not being focused in war. This lead him to burn the letters, which shows a great deal of confidence and motivation, developed during war. The act of him burning the letter made sure that he was willing to forget the fantasies about his girlfriend Martha and become focused in war. He had managed to acquire the courage by simply an incident that could have potentially proven to be fatal. Therefore this helped in developing confidence and the ability to be focused while also motivating him to be alert in war. Therefore this gives us insight that the author provides details about the consequences of war faced by the soldiers not only physically but also mentally such as fear, love and grief. The ability or mental strength required to overcome the atrocities of war is immense and this is intensified by gravity of the precarious situation. “They carried their reputation.” Thereby leading to this conclusion that war has many social and personal consequences that are reluctantly compelled onto a soldier but it undeniably lead to the development of confidence and…
The war in Vietnam in the 1960’s was an extremely controversial topic among the American public. America’s role in the war was questionable, and thousands of young men were drafted into the army against their own personal beliefs. In If I Die in a Combat Zone , author Tim O'Brien argued that the Vietnam War was unjust through his depictions of violent events during the war, how the war affected both the soldiers and innocent civilians, and the inhumane duties required of the soldiers.…
The history of war is what many spend time reading about in textbooks. Few, however, experience war and all that it encompasses. David Leckie, a marine during World War II, uses his book, Helmet for My Pillow, to share with readers the truth of what it was like to be a soldier. Rather than skimming the surface of his time on Parris Island and the Pacific Islands, he goes into unmatched, excruciating detail; every trench dug, every shot fired, and every fallen soldier passed was recounted by Leckie. Setting this story apart from any other, the first-hand accounts of combat, unlikely descriptions of the day-to-day actions of the soldiers, and the heart that Leckie intertwines with each part of his story all combine to make this thought-provoking,…
"How to Tell a True War Story," is an indictment of the war as an honorable…
He begins the book with Joe is saying goodbye to his family and leaving, and he remembers some of the pro-war propaganda that he had seen, such as “their lives if necessary that democracy may not perish from the face of the earth” (36). Trumbo is bringing up the idea that going to war was a noble cause, and if you die it would be justified. Joe later says that “ a man will have to die in order to protect his life,” and explains that people have never asked the dead if dying for a cause is worth it (116). Joe, however, is almost dead. He is unable to move, feel, or communicate. Trumbo is conveying the idea that the stories that people go to war for are wrong, the end result is not what the government is saying it is. Also, he is saying that nationalism or strong feelings towards a specific country are dangerous. The government is able to take advantage of those feelings and use them to convince people to go to war. They can make it seem like losing their lives was a good thing, that they have to die in order to be a good citizen, and if those people hold where they come from as very important, they will go and die to fulfill what their country has set for them. His use of the myths and narratives lets him talk about the fundamental parts of why people go to war. Many people go to war based on these ideas of nobility and necessity, and Trumbo thinks that the government is wrong in using systems that convince people to go to war. Myths and narratives are some of his central tools in the book, and he uses them to bring up the idea that people may not actually be receiving what they signed up…