Why Is Dr Roylott Guilty

Sherlock was not guilty due to the fact he did not know that Dr. Roylott would be bit by a snake; swamp adder. In the story, “The Adventures of the Speckled Band,” Dr. Roylott was murdered by his snake the he had trained over a period of time. Audience may believe that Sherlock was guilty and many think that he was not. In Sherlock’s offense, he did not mean to kill Dr. Roylott; meaning that the murder of Dr. Roylott was not premeditated. Also, Sherlock was self-defending himself. Sherlock did not want to die and he also had to protect the lives of two other people because it was his job. Helen had to hire Sherlock to protect her from her peculiar husband. Another reason in which that Sherlock should not be guilty is Sherlock did not know that Dr. Roylott was sitting in the chair next to the ventilator. Sherlock was certain that Dr. Roylott killed Julia and wanted to murder Helen due to money concerns.
Roylott premeditated Julia’s death, that does not mean that Sherlock premeditated Dr. Roylott’s death, Sherlock self-defended himself. Sherlock yelled, “See that Watson! See it!” Meaning that Sherlock was in complete terror and did not know what to do. Since a swamp adders venom can kill a person in ten seconds, Sherlock had to think of something quickly. The only thing that he could think of was to swat at the snake and end it back up the ventilator. Also, on behalf of Sherlock, he did not know that Dr. Roylott would be sitting in the chair next to the ventilator. In attempt to send to send the snake up the ventilator, he aroused his temper ad mad it angry. So the snake basically kill the next person it saw and make them fall as a victim. One of the many thoughts going through Sherlock’s head is if the swamp adder bit him, he would die, which is another reason he was self-defending himself. Sherlock did not know that if he were to send the snake back through the ventilator, Dr. Roylott would be sitting right next to the opening of the