Preview

What Are Graphic Novels: Are They Worthy Of Being Taught?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
998 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Are Graphic Novels: Are They Worthy Of Being Taught?
Graphic Novels: Are They Worthy of Being Taught?
Since the dawn of man to present day, illustrations have always been an effective way of storytelling. From cave paintings to graphic novels, this form of literature has always been able to tell stories the same way more traditional works have done. In Art Spiegelman’s graphic novels Maus I and Maus II, he looks into the horrid events of the Holocaust by interviewing his father, Vladek Spiegelman, who was a Jew living in Auschwitz, Poland at the time. Through interviewing his father, Spiegelman learns of the vile events that his father has gone through. He retells his father’s experiences through his detailed works of art. Although many are against graphic novels and call them unorthodox, graphic
…show more content…
This is shown in Spiegelman's Maus I when Vladek talks about how the Jews children were treated. He says, "Some kids were screaming and screaming. They couldn’t stop. So the Germans swinged them by the legs against the wall…and they never anymore screamed" (Spiegelman 108). Vladek’s witness to these gruesome executions show us what victims of the Holocaust endured. It educates the audience and it puts the readers in the shoes of the victims and what they underwent. Graphic novels also serve a purpose of educating readers through the use of short texts in the panels. When Art was driving with his wife he tells her of his conflicting feelings by stating, “I guess it’s some kind of guilt about having an easier life than they did… I feel so inadequate trying to reconstruct a reality that was worse than my darkest dream” (Spiegelman 16). Since his father went through the Holocaust while he didn't, it makes him think about his father’s perspective and it educates him about what his father endured. Just as Art analysed the Holocaust from interviewing his father, through his art, his graphic novels also allows the reader to look into the events of the Holocaust. There may be a lot of lessons students are missing out on just because graphic novels are not used very often within an English

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As Vladek develops as a character during both the graphic novels, he shows that he is not a compassionate and understanding character, before, during or after the Holocaust. He manages to make it through his war experience with a great deal of luck, and intelligence. His experiences have left him scarred emotionally, causing him to live a selfish, conservative life similar to how he lived during the Holocaust, because he became so accustomed to that lifestyle throughout the duration of the war. The text, at times, seems to go out of its way to emphasize Vladek's limitations as a human being . For example, his racist attitude when Francois picks up a black hitchhiker, "...you went crazy or what?!" "I had the whole time to watch out that this SHVARSTER doesn't steal us the groceries from the back seat!(p.99,Volume II)" His treatment of women is another prime example, "Your father! He treats me as if I were just a maid or his nurse... WORSE!- Mala (p.130,Volume I)" As well with his inability to deal with Artie. Vladek is portrayed as a victim, as someone very ordinary, without any privileged insight into what has happened to him or why. If we are seeking here some illumination of the events we witness, that does not come from anything Vladek has to offer.…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, no one can doubt that this novel does in fact have a lot of literary value. This novel has contributed a lot to nonfiction/memoir novels that are about being a victim in the Holocaust. He vividly illustrated his predicaments in the novel, and was a not afraid of being a little graphic where it was necessary. He would describe dead victims clearly, like this following excerpt: “The two men were no longer alive. Their tongues were hanging out, swollen and bluish. But the third rope was still moving: the child, too light was still breathing… And so he remained for more than half an hour, lingering between life and death, writhing before our eyes…That night, the soup tasted of corpses.” This novel contributed to the gruesome yet real category of Holocaust victim memoirs. It was descriptive enough to be like a movie playing in my head while I devoured each word. It was a real piece of literature that doesn’t let the readers forget the cruelty and torture that the Holocaust’s victims had to face.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis: Despite writing about such a heavy topic in such a deceptively playful medium, Maus was very effective in telling Vladek’s holocaust story because it shows rather than tells the holocaust from Vladek’s and Artie’s perspective while capturing both of their emotions, the drawings aide Artie in showing the metaphor of the power system, and makes reading Maus much more understandable.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pathos In Night

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages

    While describing the rough times he and his father go through in the concentration camps, Wiesel makes sure to use imagery that would make the audience feel sorry and despair. For example, when Wiesel states, “never shall I forget the little faces of the children, whose bodies turned into wreaths of smoke beneath a silent blue sky”, it gives the reader a sense of uneasiness and empathy for the author as he had to experience the cremating of children’s bodies. One of Wiesel’s main goals when writing this narrative was to reach the readers heart so they could get a sense of what it was like to witness the environment surrounding the concentration camp.…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The imagination I come across all starts with Ms. Bernstein’s, her whole life is pretty much what the book is about not just the Holocaust. In my opinion it made her personal experiences so real. Ms. Bernstein’s talks about her childhood, schooling, family and how she traded. Ms. Bernstein’s was very detailed about her tragedies. The only thing I didn’t like about the book was that Ms. Bernstein was very detailed during her horrific experiences.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For my Rhetoric In Practice Project, I decided to write a comic book which brings out the in-depth meaning in stories and thus helps readers or the audience comprehend the stories better. We know that all fairy tales have morals and lessons. But not every reader is able to grasp every moral from them. Some messages might be hidden and difficult to understand unless you read it a couple of time and exclaim, “Ohhhhh”. When I first read the prompt, I had thought about a lot of different genres to convey my message which is that “Appearances can be deceptive” but I felt that I could make something interesting which could catch the attention of the readers. In today’s world, where there are great animated movies, comics have taken a step back from…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pathos- this is effectively used frequently through out the text so that the speaker gets the audience to be emotional. An example of this is when he says “ to be abandoned by god is worse than to be punished by him” (444). By saying this, the speaker get the audience to empathize with the victim, put themselves in the victims shoes, which gets the emotions and feeling across to all the members of the audience and get then engaged. He uses human emotion as a way to speak out against the holocaust and then speaks of the horrors of it to trigger emotion from the audience “Over there, behind the black gates of Auschwitz, the most tragic of all prisoners were the “Muselmanner” as they called. Wrapped in their torn blankets, they would sit or lie on the ground, staring vacantly into space, unaware of who or where they were—strangers to their surroundings...” (444). This creates a feeling of horror and helps the…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The English curriculum requires that students read different types of texts, and graphic novels are slowly being incorporated. Due to the historical and social justice perspectives I chose, I will focus on how to use this in a history classroom. In my experiences, Residential Schools are typically taught as a series of facts such as when Residential Schools opened and closed and how many students probably attended. While students learn about Residential Schools, the horror is hard to recognize through this manner of learning. I would use these books as a textbook while discussing Residential Schools. Robertson even includes a free teacher’s resource for classroom use (Robertson, n.d.). As I teach the facts in class and show students documentary clips and bring in other resources, students would read through the books. As we read, students would make connections between the graphic novels and the other materials I present. I appreciate the graphic novels because they do not just deal with the Residential School time, they also show how the schools affect Aboriginal peoples today. I would spend several classes discussing current problems caused by Residential Schools and have students make these connections. I would ask students to pull out images from the graphic novel and add them to the timeline of Aboriginal history, alongside images from the Blanket Exercise. I believe the personal,…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Maus Research

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Spiegelman's Maus II is a graphic novel and I believe Spiegelman chose this format because it is the only way to discuss the Holocaust while simultaneously conveying the impossibility of doing such a task. The Holocaust was such a horrific event that there is no way of truly representing it. Spiegelman realized that everything is a representation. He also realized that representing every aspect of the Holocaust was something that simply cannot be done. It is impossible to capture something free of representation. Spiegelman wanted to write a story about the Holocaust but he was very cautious in his construction. Maus: Volume II is constructed with precise self-awareness and self-devaluation to tell to a story about the Holocaust, while also writing a story about the impossibility of trying to capture this tragic event within the extremely limited parameters of representation.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dr. Seuss Father

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The sound repetition makes it easier to memorize the stories. When the child can remember the words they feel like they are reading. Both child and parents know they only memorized it, but the child's confidence is boosted, and then next time the challenge of reading will be easier. The illustrations in the stories also help children learn to read. Most stories have made up words to follow the wacky rhyming patterns. These words can often not be understood by child or parent making the child, again, feel confident about reading. The illustrations can help the children figure out the word they do not know.In all of his works the illustrations create metaphors. Some of the best examples are back to his famous story, And To Think That I Saw It On Mulberry Street. When the child is traveling to school, he is carrying a large book that looks uncomfortable. This represents the child not enjoying…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the article “Resistance During the Holocaust”, it listed multiple ways Jews preserve culture in ghettos. Many of them would create poetry and art as a way to maintain culture: “ Other forms of resistance included… maintaining religious customs; drawing, painting, or secretly photographing observed events; and keeping records of ghetto life and hiding them… ” (¶ 6). By creating art and taking records during the Holocaust, many Jews were able to maintain internal meaning. It also allowed them to have some sort of freedom. While the Nazis were trying to trap the Jewish and strip them of rights, one thing they could not take was their creativity and mind. They took advantage of this, as a way to give them some hope. On the contrary, those who support active resistance may debate that a successful attack on the Nazis may give people more hope than art. While news of a successful attack did administer hope, art gives people more hope because it keeps records and it preserves memory. By keeping records, many Jews were able to preserve the memory of who they were. Future generations could learn about them and the Holocaust. Furthermore, the Jewish were not the only ones who would resist by maintaining their culture. Native Americans used this method to resist against white settlers in the early 1800’s. When U.S. settlers began to seep into Native American land, they would attempt to convert Native Americans into Christians; instead, many Native Americans refused to convert to Christianity. Furthermore, during the Trail of Tears, many survivors passed down stories of how they suffered. By preserving their culture and keeping records, both the Native Americans and Jewish were able to inform future generations what they suffered, but also what to avoid from happening…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Do you know how many comic books are sold every month throughout the world? Between ten to twelve million comics magazines are sold every month. However, a million dollars are spent by comic’s fans. Comics are the most interesting and effective way of storytelling and it has started its journey since people painted narratives of animals and hunting on the walls of their cave. The purpose of this paper is to show how comics can worth literature and its reflection on education and our society. For the paper’s flexibility I am taking the Avengers movie, different articles about comics and literature which will clearly show comics and its effect on literature. From the Avengers comics we can understand how comics can influence us. There arises much controversy that comics are a waste of time and it cannot be a part of literature. In my paper I will show that comics can be part of literature in three ways like it is the most interesting and effective way of storytelling, it can be educative and it has social influences.…

    • 3170 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The project displayed the life of Jewish people who escaped the holocaust compared to those who were sent to Concentration Camps. This project is meant to honor all Jewish people who were oppressed during WWII and to show the choices and sacrifices they had to make. On the left, the collage shows people who went into hiding or fled during WWII. On the right, the collage shows people being taken to concentration camps, people in concentration camps, and the Nazi Gestapo during WWII. The message this art sends is the severity of the situation these people were in. That if these people don't run or hide, they and those of whom they love will perish in the hands of the Germans’. This project is meant to put a face…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ever since then comic books have changed the world in many ways. You actually won’t believe this, but comic books have actually invented a few things. Donald Duck discovered Minecraft, Spider-Man invented ankle tracking monitors; Captain Marvel Jr. inspires everything about Elvis Presley, D.B Cooper was inspired by a comic book character, and the Fantastic Four’s cosmic rays will give you superpowers (Mccallum). Do you still think comic books are useless? I think they have definitely moved up on a higher importance level ever since the first one was created. I was surprised to find out that comic books or any other graphic material containing cartoons or animated subjects can actually benefit people when learning certain cultures, scriptures, or even history. Using comic books to learn is actually pretty genius. Think about it, when you pick up any sort of book, what’s the first thing you do? You look at the image on the front cover, you read the back of the book for a summary, and as soon as you do that you open the book to see if there are any visual pictures. I know I’m guilty in doing that. Face it; the majority of people want to see color, pictures, and animation. Hillary Chute, a teacher at the University of Chicago’s English department is interested in teaching new ways; her teaching includes comic book journalism. She likes to call this sort of teaching that she does “learning through graphic narratives” (Chute). She…

    • 2428 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Maus

    • 1844 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Whenever a Holocaust story is heard, a certain respect for the survivors fill the air. It is almost impossible to think about the hardships millions of survivors and non-survivors were forced to face many years ago. In The Complete Maus, renowned author and cartoonist, Art Spiegelman, creates flashbacks and real time dialogues that flow smoothly as he paints an ideal picture of the horrific events of Holocaust. Maus is a story written in present tense with past events retold through conversations between son and father, Artie and Vladek Spiegelman. Realities of the Holocaust are seen firsthand when Art, an aspiring artist, interviews his father about the Holocaust in an obvious attempt to seek answers to the mysteries of his father, suicidal mother, dead brother, and his life in general. Spiegelman fills his story with two main parts; the true story of a Holocaust survivor, and how the survivor progressed. The first explains Vladek Spiegelman’s experiences as a young Jewish man leading up to his imprisonment in Auschwitz. The second, references Vladek as an old man recounting his history to his son, and the complicated relationship between the two. It is a difficult process for both father and son, and through their progression, both men were dramatically affected by the Holocaust. Change in guilt and personality traits are seen throughout the story.…

    • 1844 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays