Preview

To Kill A Mockingbird Compare And Contrast Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
834 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To Kill A Mockingbird Compare And Contrast Essay
Within the first minute of the movie, I realized there were going to be many considerable differences. Having watched other book to movie adaptations before, I was mindful that not everything can be included in an only two hour film, but I was not expecting so many things to be removed or altered. Honestly, the movie felt very focused on the court case, thus eliminating other equally important scenes. The book, on the other hand, made the court case a major event but not the main focus, choosing to also emphasize settings like First Purchase Church, the conversation Scout and Dill have with Mr. Raymond, and the characters of Aunt Alexandra and Mrs. Dubose. All of which were not included in the movie. The first words written in the book are “When he was nearly thirteen, my brother Jem got his arm badly broken at the elbow,” which is a great introduction, considering Scout then goes on to describe the events that caused his arm to break. Instead of starting with the same great introduction, the movie resorts to using the dull description of Maycomb County derived from page 6 of the book: “Maycomb was a tired, old town, even in 1932 when I first knew it…” Whereas …show more content…
Resembling most movies based on a book, To Kill a Mockingbird was ten times better as a book because of all the background details it includes. The movie does “bring characters to life” especially with facial expressions and dialogue, which it did extremely well in the courthouse with Tom’s sweating and Mayella’s screaming at Atticus. But at what price? Movies have to condense everything including character introductions, causing audiences to not personally connect with a character. For example, with the movie Atticus the audience isn’t aware of his past struggles, how the loss of his wife, or his first case as a lawyer impacted him. The book can go into as much detail as it wants because it can be any

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Learning lessons is a very important part of growing up. Children learn new things every day of their life. Even adults learn something every once in a while. In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, the character Scout is very adventurous and loves to learn; she has many experiences that lead to her being taught many different things about life. On page 12 of Cliff Notes for this novel, John Sova writes “each experience is designed to give Scout a further understanding about certain things in life and about people. In one way or another, every episode leads to some type of learning experience for Scout”. Scout learns a lot of different things about her town’s views, the people who she’s heard about but never really knew, and how to treat others the proper way.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book ‘To Kill a Mockingbird” by “Harper Lee” there were many characters that the movie that was released shortly the book was published and became a best seller. After reading the book, and then watching the movie, I have made some observations on what characters were not mentioned or described in the movie and what bits and plots were not there. To start off with characters, I noticed that there were to characters that were dropped from the book and were not included in the movie remake. There was Uncle Jack and Dolphus Raymond. There are many scenes that I realize are missing in the movie remake of the book “ To Kill a Mockingbird”. For starters, I realize that you never see scouts teacher Mrs. Caroline. In chapter 2 in the novel, you are introduced to Mrs. Caroline and the Cunningham family when scout had to explain to Mrs. Caroline about Walter. Mrs. Caroline asked if Walter Cunningham wanted money for lunch because he had none and Scout was the only student that could explain how the Cunningham family doesn’t borrow or take money from any family or person.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyone in the class notices many differences between the book and the movie. Provided that the book gives detail that the movie cannot show it is a missing part in itself. Aunt Alexandra was not even mentioned in the movie. You didn’t see Scout changing from a young and reckless child, into a mature young lady. That is a colossal piece missing from this movie. Also, nothing was ever shown about finding the gum in Boo Radley’s yard. When Scout told Jem that she took the gum from the Radley property, it informed the readers that Boo would be disturbing enough to set up a poisonous trap for the the children.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many very important scenes are omitted, this can make the film hard to follow at times. Particularly of the scene in the courthouse, because Jem and Scout still take seats with Reverend Sykes, the black man. In the novel we meet Sykes in the scene where Calpurnia takes the children to her church, and the children befriend him. But in the movie, that scene was not present, therefore there is no reason for the children to know Reverend Sykes because the segregation of the 30’s would normally eliminate all friendly contact with a person of the opposite race. Because of the removal of so many scenes, character development is minimal. Another negative point is that Boo Radley, a major character we hear so much about in both the book and the film, does not say anything. In the book he has one lone line, it would have been interesting to hear his voice. These negative points certainly subtract from the…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Books and movies of books all have many similarities and differences. To Kill a Mockingbird is no different when it comes to the book and the movie. In this essay I will be explaining the similarities and differences between the two.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Neither the novel nor film version of To Kill A Mockingbird is superior to the other, just different. In the book you delve more into the separate characters while in the film you see the relationships in action. The book gives you a broader view of everything, but at the same time the movie points out everything that seems important. Lastly, the novel shows Scout as a girl caught in the middle, when the movie seems to paint Scout as a girl without a inkling of what is going on.…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Creating a motion picture from a novel and conveying the author's intended message is a difficult task. Some film makers gracefully meet the challenge, while others fail, warping the original meaning of the novel in order to appeal to he general movie going population. Harper Lee's To Kill A Mockingbird novel to movie transition is a mid-ground between the two extremes. Lee's theme of tolerance is neither completely destroyed nor completely expressed. The absence of characters Dolphus Raymond and Link Deas, along with the change in Dill's personality in the movie contributes to the deterioration of Lee's original theme of tolerance.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These two ways were some of the many ways that I notice the book and the movie were different. Mrs. Dubose seemed to show Atticus’s side of punishment, but it does not really show Mrs. Dubose in the movie. Also with telling the book from Scout’s point of view compared to telling from Jem’s point of view in the movie. These were some of the biggest differences that was able to notice between the movie and the…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most obvious differences between the film and the novel would be the lack of stress for the importance of reading from Scout. For example, when Scout was angered towards Miss Caroline Fisher, because she was ordered to convey a negative message towards Atticus: to stop teaching her how to read. This occasion was…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To Kill A Mockingbird has a novel and a film. The novel may have many similarities to the film, the film might be a little different, but this is what they share in similarities. In the novel and the film they both have Scout as the narrator, and it is being told from Scout’s point of view. When Atticus shot the mad dog, that was in the novel as well as the film. In the novel Boo Radley left gifts in the hole in the tree, and when his brother found out, he filled the hole with cement. In the film there was a visual of what the gifts from Boo Radley looked like, and how his brother filled the hole with cement. The themes were similar, the theme of racism, family, and maturing was given in…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    One scene that wasn't in the movie are the two class scene where Mrs. Caroline is featured and doesn't even mention Burris. In the movie Atticus doesn't break his glasses while shooting the mad dog, where in the book it does. Another issue the movie did was Jem was the only one to find the items in the oak tree and found the first item at dark. While in the book Scout and Jem find the items during daytime. The movie never mentioned the Christmas scene and when it snows in Maycomb. They also missed the scene were the Finch children go to First Purchase with Calpurnia which gives the whole background of the church and people in it such as Zeebo "Calpurnia's son." In the book Jem doesn't go with Atticus to Hellen's house which is what they did in the movie. Another scene they skipped is where Aunt Alexandra has her huge Maycomb Amanuoensis Club tea party. The other part of the book they skipped is when the Finch children read to Mrs. Dubose, her addiction, or Mrs. Dubose's death. A special scene they missed in the movie is where Mrs. Maudie's house catches on fire, and Boo Radley puts a blanket on Scout. This made them believe he is actually real and is probably not awful as they say. One more thing the film missed from the book is when Scout and Dill meet Mr. Dolphus Raymond who always pretends to be drunk, hangs out with the black community, and his colored wife. Last thing in the movie they didn't mention which was in the book is Aunt Alexandra not mentioned in the entire…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As you watch a movie, you can see a big difference between the movie and book. In the book and movie, “To kill a Mockingbird”, there is a difference between them. They are both different because the book has more details about situations that are happening. Also, because of the way you can picture what is going on. They are similar because in some parts in the movie, the characters say the same things as to when you read the book. In my opinion, the book gives you a better understanding of what the story is about because of the details it provides.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To kill a mockingbird is an insightful novel that effectively educates its reader about the discrimination and prejudice against African Americans that was occurring at the time. Through the pity and intensity of Tom Robinson’s trial the reader learns how the rights of African Americans were very different than the white Americans at the time. To kill a mockingbird highlights the pure injustice that Tom Robinson faces, when accused of a crime that he didn’t commit. Due to these accusations Tom’s fate is put on the line and his dignity is robbed from him as the whole of Maycomb assumes that Mayella Ewell is right. Immediately the town people build a sense of hate and anger towards Tom Robinson and attempt to act on their thoughts and opinions. Throughout this text one will learn how not only Negro’s were affected by this prejudice and discrimination but how innocent white Americans, such as the finch family were too.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    the road book vs movie

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A long time has passed since the idea that “The book is better than the movie” was accepted without question. Most of the time, if the movies follow an original script and there is no book version to compare it to, it is most likely to be seen as a great piece of work. However, when a film is present to be compared against a novel, it is inevitably not as great as the original work. There is also a limitation on films due to their format. A three-hour film is considered extremely long and lengthy, and most directors and filmmakers generally try and cut crop and edit out unnecessary and uneventful parts of a certain book to fit a golden rule of thumb that allows for movies to be about two hours long. Because a book adaptation is meant to tell the gist of the story, it is usually concentrated on making it possible to grasp the overall plot in one sitting.…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because of this, it creates worry and suspense in the book, as well as the movie. While reading To Kill a Mockingbird, you experience the scenes in which the events that Scout gets into are bigger than she thought. For instance, Scout, Jem, and Dill followed Atticus to the jail house because they were curious as to where he was going and also because he drove the car, in which he never does. When following Atticus, they eventually found him sitting in front of the jailhouse, as if he were protecting someone or something. Later on while, he was still waiting, a mob of cars pulled up and a herd of men walked suspiciously towards Atticus. Without knowing what was going on, Scout unknowingly sprinted out and interrupted the conversation between Atticus and the men. At these cliff-hanging times, we readers, get a feel for uncertainty caused by…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays