Preview

Three Dirges Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1138 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Three Dirges Analysis
The three Dirges incorporates a lot of foreshadowing, symbolism, and imagery. It is based on the Guatemalan civil war. It lasted six years and was fought between the government and several Guatemalan groups. The government forces were very much condemned for committing genocide against the Mayan population of Guatemala. It began with the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency commanded by Colonel Carlos Castillo against Jacobo Arbenz. “Three Dirges” gives you a sense of fearfulness. “Don Lazaro begins with a flashback of the Colonel himself, he said, Don Lazaro, you’ve got five boys in Comitan teaching the campesinos how to read. That’s subversive. That communist. So tonight, you have to kill them’… Now, what can I say? You tell me! What can a man …show more content…
This gives the reader a sense of foreshadowing that Lazaro was ordered to kill the five boys. The commander looked at Lazaro ordering him to sit down while rolling a sharply yellow pencil between his fingers without moving his eyes. The dark sky foreshadows the misery when the deaths of the boys occur. The words “dark,” “black,” and “gray,” set the tone of what happens. The “blanket of fog” symbolizes hopefulness. The “ruby lining” of the sky symbolizes the blood. When the five boys were about to approach death everyone wept and lamented what was about to occur. One of the Indians who was with Lazaro already feared what was about to happen his heart was filled with terror. Colonel Guzman then again said to Lazaro “ You have five boys catechists working for the American priest in Comitan. They’re teaching the campesinos how to read. Right? Pressed the colonel. Maybe even you, eh?” Don Lazaro was quite shocked to the colonel’s words and was not able to face the commander. The colonel was demanding in telling Lazaro what had to be done that night. "I think you understand me plainly enough," said the colonel. "Well, you continue to listen to me! They're communist subversives, these boys," said Colonel Guzmán. "So tonight, Don Lázaro, tonight you have to kill them. Every one of them . . . all five!" ( ) Each man was being escorted by an older man and …show more content…
If he failed to do what he was asked his troops would kill every living thing in the town. He did not know how to explain to the boy’s parents what the colonel himself said. He was astonished and could not find the right words to say to explain a horrific crime. The families of the boys were extremely terrified and angry to know that they would not be able to do anything. Also, mentioning the tragic events where the military killed many people in Cuarto Pueblo, the massacre in Puento Alto, and all the things that the military has done to many boys. The only things that the family and boys wanted was hope and an answer to why all of this was happening. The five boys foreshadowed their death about to happen “Perhaps even now, the soldiers are here, up there in the hills already, watching and waiting to see what we will do!”(

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    09 English Studyguide 1

    • 2226 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Why did the rebels attack the towns so fiercely? What was their goal? Does it make sense to you? (p. 24)…

    • 2226 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Olson and Randy Roberts confront the difficult question of who was ultimately to blame for the complete destruction of the villages of Son My. The military named the village of Son My containing My Lai, My Khe, and Co Luy ‘Pinkville’ in reference to the color designated to the region by combat maps. Pinkville resided in the Quang Ngai province; an area known to the military to be largely occupied with Viet Cong and Viet Cong sympathizers. U.S. military and civilian leaders were beginning “to view the war in terms of territorial conquests, not the attainment of the villagers’ support”. Charlie Company 1st Battalion, 20th Infantry under Captain Ernest “Mad Dog” Medina and Lieutenant William Calley arrived in Quang Ngai in 1967. Olson and Roberts immediately point out the emphasis the company’s training had made regarding obeying orders at all costs. Right away they raise the question of whether or not there is a conflict between following the orders of superiors and following one’s conscience. Paul Meadlo, a rifleman in C Company, recalls what he took from his training: “…you’re trained to take orders from the first day you go to that damned service, and you come back and, all right, you want to try some people that had to take orders”. To make matters worse, C Company’s leader of the 1st Platoon, William Calley was incompetent. All four sources agree on the fact that Calley was painfully ordinary and demonstrated the bare minimum of what was necessary of an officer. He could hardly even read the military maps. His promotion to Lieutenant came at a time when there was a shortage of second lieutenants, but most certainly not because he was well qualified. As the platoon moved throughout Quang Ngai, his poor leadership was evident. He constantly got his men lost and Captain Medina often referred to him as “Lieutenant Shithead”. Aside from being an evident poor leader, the company was becoming discouraged and frustrated by the guerilla-style warfare the VC…

    • 2693 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is very frightening walking around the area because one can erupt and kill the soldier. “Kill him if he’s lucky. If he’s unlucky, he will be turned into a blind, deaf, emasculate, legless shell. It was not warfare. It was murder” (288). I never thought that being in the war was that intense. Everywhere people went, they have to look around for grenades, mines, guns, rifles, or even the enemy around because they would never know what or who would be shot first. One day, Caputo and his platoon planned to ambush the Viet Minh at a village near Danang. They were settled to fire at the Viet soldiers, but they saw many people trying to run away to a place to protect their children, they had their doubts. Even when they see the all these Vietnamese people, especially the innocent ones, see many deaths and injuries through the battle from their actions, all they have to do is face the truth and move on. When I read this, I thought about my family, when they tried to run away to safety. They saw many close family and friends die during the one in many battles that happened in the war, and it is tragic for me to see when they cry about it once it a…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Soldiers’ lives were lost one after the other, day by day as the war went on. In the beginning of the novel, Paul’s company received a short stay after two weeks of fighting. Only 80 men out of 150 were still alive. The cook didn’t want to give the survivors the rations that were meant for the dead men, but eventually agreed to do so. The soldiers dealt with the many deaths and their aspects changed with their wants. For example, food and double rations of cigarettes were more important…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    : "Don Lazaro, you've got five boys in Comitan teaching the campesinos how to read. That's subversive. That's communist. So tonight, you have to kill them." Don Lazaro, the mayor of the war torn village, San Martin Comitan, seems to have no choice but to carry out this heartless command. His response is indicative of a desperate man searching for answers, yet already resigned to carrying out the task at hand. "What can I say? --you tell me!" cries an anguished Don Lazaro to the villagers. Is he pleading for their understanding, or asking for a miraculous solution that would alter the path that lay before him? It is this uncertainty that, when coupled with melancholy foreshadowing, leaves the reader at a suspenseful crossroad; suspecting that events are transpiring, but doubtful as to the outcome.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is hard to comprehend how traumatic the war really was for those men. Tim O’Brien touches on this matter often through out the book. He mentions that often there are no words to truly describe the horrors the witnessed and the demons they faced inside themselves. O’Brien does his…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The trauma of what happened to Finny had taken a toll on him and made him feel he was dead. “I could not escape a feeling that this was my own funeral, and you do not cry in that case.”(Knowles 194). The following eight lines focus on how insignificant a soldier’s death is in relation to a war being won or lost. The last two lines of the first stanza center around how the war for the young men was fought in school rather than on the actual battlefield. “(When we left high school nothing else had died, For us to figure we had died like.)”. The same could be said for Gene and Finny and how they died before their actual battle started because of the heartbreaking events that took place before they could even put on a uniform. This relationship is demonstrated in the book when Gene says “because my war ended before I ever put on a uniform; I was on active duty all my time at school; I killed my enemy there”(Knowles…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O’Brien uses several rhetorical strategies in this story. A strategy that is easily found in the story is imagery. He uses a lot of sensory details to help the reader know what it feels like in a certain situation. “Except for the laughter things were quiet,” (67) and “You hear stuff nobody should ever hear,” (69) are some quotes that describes the sounds the soldiers are hearing. O’Brien uses sight as a big component for setting up the setting and describing what the soldiers saw. “A handsome kid, really. Sharp grey eyes, lean and narrow-waisted…”(67), “A deep pinkish red spilled out on the river, which moved with no sound…(68). Another rhetorical strategy that O’Brien uses is motif. The motif that he uses is “…true war story…” He uses this phrase throughout the story to help the reader understand how to write a story. “A true war story is never moral.”(65). This quote is basically saying that a true war story tells it how it is; it doesn’t try to make things easier for the reader to digest. “You can tell a true war story if it embarrasses you.”(65) This quote is saying if you don’t want the offensive words or phrases then you don’t want the truth of the story. “In many cases a true war story cannot be believed.”(68) The last strategy that O’Brien uses in this story is irony. There are many places in this story when O’Brien’s ideas contradict themselves. When Curt Lemon dies, O’Brien describes it as beautiful. “…when he died it was almost beautiful, the way the sunlight came around him and lifted him up…”…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Bra Boys

    • 2974 Words
    • 12 Pages

    This technique is used to make the audience question the natural brutality of the soldiers. The inconsistency of the disorganised group of captives provides a sharp contrast between the two opposing forces, creating a clear image in the audience’s mind of victim and attacker. Time is an important aspect of “The Third of May” similarly to “Run Lola Run”. The progress of time is evident in the procession of the damned, the central figure about to he shot and the corpse of the man in a pool of red blood.…

    • 2974 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Fighting Ground

    • 2482 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Jonathan wrongly interprets the fear he sees in his father’s eyes as cowardice. Readers know it is not cowardice that prevents his father from allowing his son to become a soldier. Rather, it is love for his son and the fear he could die that keeps Jonathan’s father from giving Jonathan permission to become a soldier. Additionally, Jonathan’s older brother joined the Continental Army a year before the story takes place and has not been heard from since. Jonathan’s parents are full of worry and sadness for his older brother and can’t bear to let Jonathan go.…

    • 2482 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paul Keating

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The absence of deflection maintains the sincere and solemn momentum of the occasion, focusing on the remembrance of past conflict as a lesson for the future. His speech encompasses a didactic statement for the future, “for out of the war came a lesson …” showing his audience that unknown solider has “taught us a lesson”; that ordinary people are not ordinary.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Things They Carried

    • 2212 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The words that Tim O’Brien used to describe the war were mind boggling. It made me realize anything can happen at any minute and anything can change at any moment. It’s hard to imagine what the soldiers must have felt so young in such a terrifying and unforgiving war. To constantly live in fear of death is unimaginable. The descriptive language of this passage helped clarify how the soldiers felt and perceived the war; by expanding my mind on how feelings and emotions can change as rapidly as clock ticks. This is an extremely powerful passage as it presents war in a way that may not be typical or expected.…

    • 2212 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Things They Carried

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lieutenant Jimmy Cross is a young, carefree man who is still searching for his future. Without realizing what he was getting himself into, he applies for the Reserve Officers Training Corps at his college in New Jersey. Many of his friends knew he did not care about the war. Even Cross himself never gave it a second thought. He never thought he would actually go to war by taking the Reserve Officers Training Corps course. Later that year, he is drafted to the war as Lieutenant of several men under his charge, and he is unsure about everything he does. He had no desire to be a team leader, let alone lead a group of men into a blind war. Up until the day he was drafted, Jimmy Cross did not care for the war and what was happening. Being only a sophomore in college, he was still a young man with no experience when it came to war and being Lieutenant.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Sunflower

    • 2287 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Simon began to doubt his choice to leave the soldier without offering the forgiveness he sought. Simon was shuffled to different work camps until he was sent to Block 6 where death was imminent. After the war he joined a commission to investigate war crimes. After seeing a field of sunflowers, he decided to visit the soldier’s mother. After the encounter, his doubts remained. In the concluding paragraph, the author…

    • 2287 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many men were dying in this camp. May it be from disease or simply lack of supplies the focus of the matter is that they stayed until the end of their lives. They believed in this cause enough to never give up and had pushed through the hardships as much as one possibly could. About half of the men were far too ill for battle. (Doc. A) Every soldier was needed and haven been stricken with illness made every healthy soldier a necessity. Approximately 1800 to 2500 men had lost their lives to the wide spread disease so even the smallest attempt to help fight the war was very much appreciated. (Doc. A)…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays