Thoughts on Plato's Republic

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 55
  • Published : July 28, 2007
Open Document
Text Preview
We all know that everyone is unique and we've all heard that no two beings are alike. Yet sometimes, some people think alike, which then causes people to relate with each other, and when a large number of people share beliefs or ideas, then comes a birth of a nation. But I'm not here to talk about forming a nation based on my ideas; I'm here to tell you what I think about Plato's ideas on forming an ideal nation or what he refers to as "The State".

Plato's idea of "The State" is clearly stated in Plato's "The Republic". He tells us that "A State, I said arises, as I conceive, out of the needs of mankind; no one is self sufficing, but all of us have many wants..." When I first read that I had no idea what that line really meant, but when it was explained it simply meant that the State comes from our wants or desires, and as human beings we have an insatiable appetite for almost everything. And yet Plato also says that no individual can supply all of the desires or needs of an individual. This to me is true, because having to satisfy all our needs requires another individual to do that. I guess that explains why God had created Eve, not only because Adam was lonely but also he needed a partner in the Garden of Eden. Plato also tries to give us an idea of a just society, he tells us that people have their own jobs to do; it's either being a Producer, Auxiliary or a Guardian. Plato says that the guardian is symbolized as gold and the producers as bronze. So my thoughts are "how can there be a just state when you can see that the guardian is on the top of the social status pyramid? Isn't there an inequality to that?" To me justice defines equality among the people, and yet Plato dreams of a just society where there are three types of people. But as I understand what Plato is trying to say about having a just society, he does have a point that people should do their own functions. So does that mean having a just state should have inequality somewhere in the...
tracking img