Preview

The Only One Barred Out Analysis

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1625 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Only One Barred Out Analysis
Immigrants from all over the world make the journey to America for many different reasons but with one goal in common, a better life, and they have been doing so for centuries. What makes America what it is today is it’s diversity, a “melting pot” of cultures and traditions coming together as one. But this is not how the White Anglo Saxon Protestants from the 19th century (WASPs) viewed it. WASPs did everything in their power to keep immigrant groups like the “dirty Chinese” and “violent Irish Catholics” out, giving them negative stereotypes and creating laws to mark them as an inferior race. In the political cartoons “The Irish Declaration of Independence That We Are All familiar With” and “The Only One Barred Out” it is clear that the artists are portraying how …show more content…
They immigrated to America to escape China’s overpopulation, imperialism, natural disasters and lack of jobs. Not only did WASPs label them as inferior but other immigrant groups despised them as well since they were willing to do labor for cheaper pay, taking all the available jobs. The scene in the political cartoon “The Only One Barred Out” exemplifies what Chinese immigrants went through during the 19th century when WASPs created the Chinese Exclusion Act. It shows a Chinese man sitting outside of a large door labeled “Golden Gate of Liberty” keeping him from coming into America. His skin is yellow, he is wearing a traditional Chinese outfit and his hair is in a queue. The immigrant is sitting on his luggage that label words like order, peace, industry and sobriety showing what he has to offer coming into America. The large gate has a sign that says, “Notice- communist, nihilist, socialist, fenian & hoodlum welcome but no admittance to Chinamen.” The expression on the Chinese immigrant’s face is that of disappointment with his face resting in his hand. (“The Only One Barred Out,” Frank Leslie's illustrated Newspaper,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The United States of America has been called the “melting pot” of the world. It is a country that is open to diversity and welcomes culture, race and ethnicity of all sorts, for as long as it complies with its laws. United States become a nation rich in immigrants who found new home in a foreign land. Most of the big and key cities in the United States are culturally and racially diversified. This diversity is taught to be an asset of the society. If not understood well, this diversity may also lead to internal and external conflicts such as discrimination and stereotyping. Stereotyping can be as harmless as thinking that Chinese cooks the best orange chicken or Indians have the best chicken curry, but it can also be as destructive as stereotyping Muslims as potential terrorists or Mexicans as potential illegal aliens. Stereotypes come in different forms and it is also apparent in the news, media, television, songs and…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    John F. Kennedy once exclaimed, “Every American who ever lived, with the exception of one group, was either an immigrant himself or a descendant of immigrants(A Nation Of Immigrants page 3)." John was known for his irish-catholic heritage, and he served as one of our most beloved presidents. John A. Treutlen was the first naturalized citizen governor. Treutlen’s parents were raised with British ideals. When Treutlen went off to America to make something of himself, his parents called him worthless (D). However, he rose above his heritage to bring great ideas to American policies. Treutlen wasn’t the only citizen considered worthless. In fact many immigrants feel like this when they come to America. They want to prove to their families (and themselves) that…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    El Otro Lado Analysis

    • 2247 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Immigrants are the least appreciated in this country, which is the most ironic thing considering that this country is only really made up of immigrants. Having blond hair and blue eyes doesn’t mean anything, because European settlers came from Europe, not America. The only real people that belong in america are the native indigenous people of the americas. Yet, that’s what immigrants have to be to be accepted into a world where these traits are so valued, a common norm, as if the world revolved around them,to simply try to be “white” in a place that isn’t even white to begin with. The fear that runs in the blood of immigrants comes from the fear that they not only will be ridiculed but will be killed for being who they are. The tone an immigrant mother makes to warn her children that different is unacceptable, that your culture should be kept but not “overdone.” Your language is to be spoken but only in certain situations, and in front of other people, it will be seen as rude. It’s baffling to only hear that the people who only come here to be better people and find better opportunities are only dismissed as scum and no better than the rich privileged people we call the face of our country. Times have changed, The United States isn’t as racist, but that doesn’t make it any better if you’ve been keeping up with politics or…

    • 2247 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not all of the arrivals remained on the East Coast. Many of the fresh faces decided to move further into the nation, and with them followed strong opposition. One case of discrimination went as far as reaching the Supreme Court, where Chinese laundry operators were charged with violating an ordinance; the Supreme Court determined this to be a case of racial discrimination (Document E). It is shocking that discrimination reached such a high level with no authoritative figure to stop it.…

    • 514 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Like past immigrants who came from Germany, Ireland and other places around the world. Chinese people in America faced many challenges when migrating. They felt like outcasts. Some experiences for the Chinese were in racist encounters and the feeling the way that Nazli Kibra felt when she came to America. She had always thought of herself as an American when she thought of herself as “the American kid on the block,” (Source F) until she went to school and she felt outcast and that “Whites think they own the world and the rest of us are just here for them.” (Source F) They felt as though they did not fit in in America. For Kibra, the Americans that she noticed at her school were people who were “VERY white, very wealthy. These kids owned sports cars and went to Rio for the weekend.”…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Certain groups of Americans opposed open immigration. Many of these people did not want new arrived immigrants to have the right to vote until they have lived in the United States for 21 years. These were often referred to as the Nativist groups. These Nativists were the old type of American immigrants who looked down on these new immigrants and wanted to shield America from them. Nativism did speak out against the Chinese immigration on the West Coast. Nativist arguments say that Chinese immigration would create race antagonism throughout the entire public. This means there will be hostility among the races so there would be separation among the country. In 1882, the Chinese Exclusion Act suspended Chinese immigration for ten years and prohibited the naturalization of the Chinese. The Chinese were once a great asset to America. They came over from…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Step: 1 What happened between the 1860’s, when Chinese were welcome, & 1882, when they were excluded?…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Chicago Chinatown

    • 1867 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The motivations for the Chinese to come to the United States are similar to most immigrants. These motivations are what most people call "The American Dream." These could be looking for a better life, having a better job, running away from political issues. However, for Chinese these American dreams were not too easy to achieve at first compared to other immigrants. Chinese suffered a lot more obstacles and discriminations because they are relatively small and easy to be targeted on. Even more the legal system passed a law in 1963 forbidding Chinese to testify against white men in court. This anti-Chinese action was most critical in the Pacific Coast; as a result, it caused the dispersion of Chinese that had settled in California to the mid-western and eastern states.(Chicago-Chinatown, 1996)1…

    • 1867 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    All the immigrants that came made a strong local presence, even though they were poor. Each nationality had their own little place or town. That is why a lot of cities now have china towns and other immigrated towns. Most immigrants lived in tight apartments or houses, most apartments were filled with many families. One apartment held the same nationality of immigrants, an apartment that was designed for 3-4 people a group or 10 or more could’ve been there. According to document 1 (Chinese Immigrant lee chew Denounces Prejudice in America, 1882 .pg 72) a Chinese boy goes from china to San Francisco and is treated unfairly. He gets a job but is shunned upon. He gets $3.50 which he saves $3 per week. They were not allowed to bring their wives in to America and marrying an American is an outcry. Other immigrants are allowed to citizens if they pass Chinese men aren’t allowed to be, according to him all the other immigrants are below his nationality. But the Chinese are fit to become citizens if they were allowed to be.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, a Polish immigrant wrote a letter in 1913; he stated that following, "I go 4 times to teacher, and must pay $2 weekly. I wanted take board [to like] in english house, but I could not, for I only earn $5 or 6 in a week, and when I pay teacher $2, I only have $4-3 and now english board house is too dear [expensive] for me." He also says in his letter, "But my friends are polish people- I must stay with them" (document 5). This letter shows how Polish people were discriminated against and had to stick together. The letter also explains the struggle that the immigrants went through to learn the language so they can communicate with the American people. They had problems with how their low income was, and it affected their lively hood. Immigrants could not afford basic luxuries. Another example, is that the typical immigrant faced nativists. Nativists are white American citizens of the United States; who believed that immigrants should not be allowed into the country and that they are ruining the country. Nativists wanted to restrict immigration to protect themselves and their children from ruinous labor and business competitions (document 4). Nativists also encouraged the Chinese Exclusion Act which is an act that excluded Chinese Labors to enter the United States and it said that any person who originated in China, and then left America would not be…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay About Chinatown

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Following the completion of the transcontinental railroad and an increasing number of legal discrimination and harassment cases, the Chinese ventured East from the pacific coast. They had been attracted to the U.S. in lure of gold and job opportunities so that they could provide for their families back home, but after being met with backbreaking work, restricted and squalid living conditions, and constant abuse directed at their different dress and customs, these immigrants took their chances and looked towards different places to settle down. One of those places was…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the early 19th century, the United States began to re-think about its stance on immigration. As the numbers of immigrants increased, questions about the leniency of the American government on immigration were raised by the “Progressive Movement”. Consequently, the United States began to employ a closed door policy of immigration. Chinese male immigrants, who had been coming in masses, inspired the implementation of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which forbade further immigration of laborers of Chinese descent. This act forced prohibited Chinese males from bring over their families and destroyed possibilities of citizenship for Chinese immigrants by making them permanent aliens. Furthermore, in 1907, adding to the isolationist stance of the U.S., the city of San Francisco attempted to remove Japanese students from white schools and put them in segregated schools with Chinese students. The Japanese government was infuriated by with this comparison to the Chinese; this led to the establishment of the Gentleman’s Agreement. This was an informal agreement stating that the Japanese government would restrict further immigration of their people to the United States and, in return, Japanese children in San Francisco would be able to attend school with white children. Over the next half century, further restrictions on immigration were implemented, many based on racist assumptions that immigrants were inassimilable and could not be Americanized. However, we see examples in Nisei Daughter, where the children like Monica and her siblings became Americanized and came to detest the strict Japanese culture their parents were raised in. this contradicts the assumption that immigrants would not assimilate.…

    • 1605 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    As one of the economic super power nation, the United States of America is a place where many immigrants leave their homeland to come to. Among all these immigrants group, Chinese immigrant is a huge percentage throughout history and the first group of Chinese immigrants into American dates back to between 1849 and 1882. During that period of time, Chinese citizens felt civil disorder, poverty, and suffering in their homeland under Qing dynasty in 1840s. In order to escape the absoulte monarchy, they got opportunities to coming to American for build railroad as well as the gold rush in California. Unfortunately, when this group arrived American society, they faced much difficult issues with the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. However, Chinese improved their communities and united…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chinese Exclusion Act

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the document “Political cartoon”, It is about the protection of Asians and how America should be equal to all men; it points out that America is supposed be equal to all men, the Irish and the German are just like any other Chinese in America, they are all immigrants, it should be fair. This document created in 1871 it correlates to the time when there was a lot of violence towards Chinese people and…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the third chapter of Takaki’s book, ‘Stranger from a different shore- Gam Saan Haak’, talks about many Chinese immigrants moves to America for getting jobs. At first, the majority of Chinese immigrants went to California for the gold mining or the Gold Mountain. Takaki mention that, at first the Chinese were welcome to the America and offering working opportunities to them. However, because of their skin tone, language, faces were considered to the threat to the mining area. In May 1852, to halt the threat, the committee recommended the enactment of a foreign miner’s license tax. (p.81) Then the new tax required the foreign miners had to paid 3 dollars a month whom did not want to become a citizen.…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays