Preview

The Boat Alistair Macleod Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
747 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Boat Alistair Macleod Analysis
Conflict in “The Boat”

In our daily life, we always try to avoid conflict with others in order to make a good relationship to benefit each other. However, in a story, it needs to do opposite thing since conflict is the engine to start and drive the story progress. In “The Boat” by Alistair Macleod, the conflict between the mother and father effectively reflects the clear theme that people’s feeling is complicated exposing the impact of change that resulted from the conflict between tradition and modernization in Eastern Canada.”
1.The conflict between the mother and father reflects people’s different attitudes toward the change of life style. The mother loves traditional life; the father favors new life. The mother tries to keep the tradition
…show more content…
The conflict between tradition and modernization also deeply causes people’s interior conflict through father and the narrator’s inner mind contradiction. The narrator remembers that his father had little interest or passion for the work he performed. "And I saw then, that summer, many things that I had seen all my life as if for the first time and I thought that perhaps my father had never been intended for a fisherman either physically or mentally" In the father’s inner mind, he is always struggling between doing the traditional work that he did not like and looking forward to his own life. Maybe the father realized that it was too late for him to make the change because he was too old and had spent his entire life with the boat and the sea, so he left it up to his children to go out and make the changes, to leave behind the family traditions and choose their own paths in life.
The father, a fisherman who clearly would have preferred to get an education, but he does not realize her dream since it is too late when he is clear sense of it.
The narrator also encounters an interior conflict. He loves study and want to go back school. However, his father’s example let him feel he is liable to assist his father fishing. "I thought it was very much braver to spend a life doing what you really do not want rather than selfishly following forever your own dreams and inclinations" With this realization he decides to give up his "silly shallow selfish dream" of completing high school to enter into tradition and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In present-day society, families go through several problems and arguments regarding numerous issues which would have been considered unacceptable in past times. Throughout a variety of different cultures, the level of respect and obedience for one’s parents has diminished while the negotiation of conformity and rebellion has risen. This statement is supported and evidential in two different stories, “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan and “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker. Although these stories represent different cultures, they both exemplify the values and importance of family relations; as well as demonstrate in every culture families face social problems. In both these stories, two major topics stood out which allowed me to compare each one to one another. These topics were mother-daughter relationships and obedience as a whole.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Robert’s childhood was full of regrets. Walton disagreed with his father because his father did not want him to persue the seafaring life. Before Walton’s father died he gave Robert’s uncle his last dying wish to forbid him from joining any type of voyage or life at sea.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Alistair MacLeod’s short story, “The Boat”, there are many examples of where human emotions are attached to places and/or objects; known as physicalization. The emotions these things show, also depend on the person they are being viewed by. There are examples of how one space can have two very different emotional attachments. These differences in opinion can cause tension in some relationships and are there with a constant reminder of the contrast between two people.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The dad had no choice and was compelled to become a fisherman. In his young years, the father’s fantasy of going to university was thwarted, likewise because as being the only son in his own family, his parents’ wanted to sustain the heritage of fishing. The narrator’s mother is a housekeeper and her obligations are to either repair clothes ripped on the boat or make food for the boat. Every day when the narrator’s dad returns home, his wife’s would greet him saying “Well, how did things go in the boat today? “Well how did things go in the boat today?” (MacLeod, 262) The word boat embodies prison to the father. The father feels like he is on a life sentence where there is no way out and he is subjected to one job, fishing. He never wanted to lead the life of a fisherman but since he has no other job and is responsible towards his family the father was forced to work. The narrator’s father is confined by his line because he never had the opportunity to exceed and get a better education. Overall, the father never resent about his job as he knows he has a family and it is his job to keep them fulfilled and…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The short story “The Boat” by Alistair MacLeod embodies the idea of coming of age. It is an elegiac narrative dealing with the consequences of decision making. The story is of a professor at a Midwestern University who chooses to leave his fishing community in order to pursuit knowledge; however he is unhappy and sad about his present life. While the story unfolds the narrator’s past, he is trying to deal with his emotional struggle of rejecting tradition behind and excluding himself from the village he loved. Although he neglected the fishing life, the protagonist was torn between practicing tradition and the outside world. These two concepts of life leave him distressed as he affirms: “I wished that the two things I loved so dearly did not exclude each other in a manner that was so blunt and too clear” (19). After leaving his community, he now mourns over the loss of his father, his estrangement from his mother and the neglect of tradition and natural relationship between the sea and community, he dearly loved. This essay will explore how the narrator, who was once a part of the fishing world and tradition, now attempts to make sense of his life after having have to choose one between the two things he loved equally.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite the mother’s countless efforts to oppress the need for change within the lives of her children, the narrator’s father seemed to have had the upper hand in the development of their children despite his limited efforts. An evidence of this can be witnessed in the occupation adopted by the narrator; as described by the line “I have to worry about being late and weather I have a clean shirt and weather my car will start and about all the other countless things one must worry about when he teaches at a great Midwestern university.” (Macleod 93) Portraying quite clearly that the narrator chose to pursue the path that his father had started him on. As opposed to the path that his mother had liked for him to have been on. Furthermore, proving that change is something that everyone adores, regardless of their age. And it was the father’s ability to accept that change within the lives of his children that allowed for him to have a greater impact upon their lives that their own mother.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Families Comparison EssayA family is a most precious identity a person can have. An individual from a noble, average or poor family can be distinguished by the character, acts, behavior, and living style. A person spends most of his time in life with the family and thus the family contributes the most in an individuals growth, thinking and behavior. When we think of a western family, the standard nuclear family comes to mind, working father, stay-at-home mom and a flock of children. This is no longer the case, in the past 50 years the family has changed significantly and continues to change. These changes are greatly due to the equalization of women's rights and the massive expansion of available communications technology. In many families nowadays both parents work and when the children are young are put into daycare services that just were not around in the past. It is now worthwhile for both parents to work since many companies provide the aforementioned daycare for free. Women also have greatly increased earning potential since they are just as educated and will now make the same amount of money as men for doing the same job. Women are hired these days to do other jobs than to be secretaries and nurses. The families of 1950s are considered as ideal and are also known as nuclear families. It consists of a working husband, a housewife and their children mostly two in which the elder one is boy and the younger one is girl. The families of 1950s and mine have a lot of differences because of the change of culture in the society. They include the structure, role, values of education and outlook on future.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Boat Nam Le

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Change is part of the human condition and affects myself, others and the world in diverse and complex ways.”…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Blue Wind Dancing

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The role of conflict serves as two fold literary device. It’s first purpose is the standard motivating factor in the story. However, it’s also used as a subtle reminder of the reader how society molds us into different people. By conforming to the white man society norms “is to make us always dissatisfied—getting a hill and wanting a mountain.” This made me stop a moment and have a moment of introspection. I think this is great literary device to maintain the reader’s attention and raises the critical question: is one’s society better than the other’s? This question is answered by the author with effective comparison and contrast of the two societies.…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Boat

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In “The Boat” by Alistair Macleod, the boat, and the ill-fitting clothes he wore significantly represent the confinement and the father’s inability to break free from tradition, reinforcing that tradition can suppress one’s dream for greater things. To begin, the boat itself is a symbol of the fathers bounding to the sea, showing his obligation to follow customs. The boat is categorize with a “marine clutch and a high speed reverse gear and was painted on an oblong plate across her stern. Jenny Lynn had been my mother’s maiden name and the boat was called after her as another link in the chain of tradition”(Macleod 3) The high speed reverse gear depicts how the father is not moving forward along with the light green name of Jenny Lynn that demonstrates the father’s sacrifice for the fishing custom to support his family. The Jenny Lynn that he receives through tradition gives him a constant reminder that his way of life may never change and that his dreams are out of his reach. Furthermore, the clothing in his closet symbolizes the father’s imprisonment with tradition. The narrator mentions “his ill-fitted serge suit, the two or three white shirts that strangled him and the square black shoes that pinched” (Macleod 4) The square black shoes that pinched him means that the life of fishing that he inherits does not fit, the life he lives is simply to overpowering that it damages him. The white shirts that suffocates him shows the struggles he faces everyday that he is unable to separate from. His attire is so inflexible that it was leaving him trapped in one place incapable to grasp his own desires. Lastly, at the father’s death his departure speculates that it is suicide to liberate his son and himself from an unhappy future bringing the fishing tradition with him. When the father’s body is discovered “the white green stubble of his whiskers had continued to grow in death. Physically as he lay there with the brass chains on his wrist and seaweed in his hair”(Macleod…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Boat - Essay

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The short story “The Boat” by Alistair MacLeod that was written in 1968, is a story about conflict between tradition and freedom. The father is a fisherman who only continues his job because he is chained through the past of others. The family son is restricted from his education because he spends a lot of time on the boat worried about his parents expectations. His mother believes that he will carry on and take his fathers place in the fisherman position. When the father is not out on the boat, he is in his room reading, to escape the world of imprisonment and monotonous duty. The mother of the family believes that the tradition of being a fisherman in the boat, is the only right way for her husband and children to continue living their lives. The author is trying to tell us to follow our dreams in life that won't keep us chained and unhappy and to never limit your options. As the father is unable to live freely, he is chained to his job through tradition.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, I would say that, for the most time in life, an individual encounters some situations where he has to adopt the present leaving its past behind, or one has to compromise with the situation in order to be accepted in the world. The new perspectives influence a person’s life by forcing him to sometimes sacrifice its beloved habits. It also influences an individual’s…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compare and Contrast

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the essays “A Conversation With My Father” and “Everything That Rises Must Converge,” I was able to find a good amount of comparisons, and also differences in the relationship between the parents and their children. ‘‘In A Conversation with My Father’’ we noticed how Grace, seeing her father in his ill state, was trying to please him in every way. Creating a simple story about a woman and her trouble life. But her not so optimistic persona had an effect on her father. But the author’s main goal was to please her bedridden father wish, so even if it wasn’t her usual all style she made attempts to give the story the life that her father had in mind. (31)…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Field’s also highlights the negative effects of generational expectations by placing Icarus’s story into a modern setting because in our current society this problem is more pronounced, so when Icarus’s story is placed in a contemporary setting the generational expectations are much more pronounced and easier for the reader to comprehend. In the contemporary setting Mr. Hicks is representative of Icarus and in this contemporary retelling instead of dying—like Icarus did in the myth—Mr. Hicks had to live out his life in the mundane society of the twenty-first century. The fate that Mr. Hicks suffers is far more tragic than the fate of Icarus because Mr. Hicks is forced to live with the disappointment of not being able to live up to his father’s example. He is stuck with the constant reminder of how average he truly is by being surrounded by sameness of the suburbs, and was forced out of his bright world of knowledge and possibilities into the cold, dark world of reality where people do not care about each other and violence reign…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Seafarer Essay

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Why do we love the sea? It is because it has some potent power to make us think things we like to think.” Robert Henri statement not only applies to himself but it also explains many other human’s feelings towards the ocean. This passion is significant in “The Seafarer” by an anonymous Anglo-Saxon scop. “The Seafarer” intertwines the positives and negatives of a life at sea. The story goes through the sacrificial day to day life of a sailor. The voyages cause many controversial scenarios in the sailor’s life. Although sailing a life at sea is very interfering to a normal life, the Seafarer still loves the life he lives and also finds himself on a much deeper spiritual level than any ocean depth he has ever came across.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays