Preview

The Bacchae

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1506 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Bacchae
Edward Norton once said, “All people are paradoxical. No one is easily reducible, so I like characters who have contradictory impulses or shades of ambiguity. It's fun, and it's fun because it's hard.” In other words, just like people, character’s expressed in stories should be portrayed as inconsistent to make them be more human and realistic instead of just one-dimensional. In the play The Bacchae, by Euripides, the Dionysus is displayed as absurd in order for the audience to be provoked in a way to question what constitutes justice, forcing them to ask themselves whether notions of justice in this world are illogical.
By presenting cases where justice is claimed to be enacted by a character, Euripides encourages speculation as to whether the punishments delivered are reasonable. Pentheus is portrayed as a character subject to pride. He is the ruler who governs through violence and threats, always seeking to reassert his own authority. His pretence, is one of civic order. He sees the Bacchae festivities as a direct threat to his governing of the land But he is unwilling to listen to the entreaties of both Cadmus and Teiresias that preach caution as the best method. Pentheus dismisses the prophets’ advice that “You rely on force; but it is not force that governs human affairs” ( ) Teiresias explains that wisdom dictates observing Dionysus’ ritual, explaining this would be a shrewd move, avoiding any grounds for blame. Just like Pentheus himself, “the god is glad to receive honor” and considering his power it would be petty to deny him it. Instead, Pentheus exhibits his own willfulness, his unbridled pride, continually. When it comes to matters concerning his own power, he refuses to back down for any reason, and this is his downfall. Since one is supposed to respect the gods it is not in the least bit surprising that Pentheus is punished for this complete disregard of men’s duty to the gods. Yet Euripides deliberately complicates the issue by having

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the play Bacchae, Euripides describes a world filled with hypnotized citizens—Thebes; a world that consists of a god spreading his religious beliefs and views. For instance, Dionysus, the protagonist of the play, is portrayed as a divine god—god of wine, theater, and happiness. This divine god prevents the young King of Thebes—Pentheus, from governing his society. In addition, in order to maintain a successful and stable society; the citizens of a society must obey the laws and its leader. Therefore, one is able to argue that King Pentheus is no longer the King of Thebes—Dionysus is the new king. The citizens, especially the women, in Thebes began to ignore the laws of their society; the moment they began to worship Dionysus—a god who King…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is not difficult to understand why Sophocles resorts to dramatic irony in the construction of his play. He is working with much the same problem a modern-day playwright would face in fashioning a play around the Cinderella motif: audience familiarity, leading to a lack of suspense. It is difficult to maintain audience interest when the conclusion and the events leading up to it are obvious to everyone. To circumvent this difficulty, Sophocles saturates his play with dramatic irony, riveting the audience with the awareness that they know more than Oedipus, letting them cringe with the delicious knowledge of the misfortunes he will face. Sophocles employs the blindness of Oedipus to such advantage that he creates an atmosphere similar in many respects to that of a modern horror film. The audience knows the destination well and has probably been there before, but the journey is too pleasurable to forego.…

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though Cadmus tells Pentheus the error he is making by not worshipping the gods, Cadmus is still not spared from punishment beyond the loss of his daughters, grandson, and home. Despite his own worship of Dionysus, the God punishes Cadmus because he does not honor Dionysus for the right reasons, and because of his association with non-­‐believers. The chorus defines the blessed worshipers of Dionysus as “those who know the mysteries of god” (158.72). This is the relationship that one must have to truly honor the deity.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indeed in the Odyssey, there are examples of people breaking the law of the Gods, for example Tityus in Book 11. He was left with vultures ‘plucking at his liver [...] whilst his hands were powerless to drive them off.’ This was due to the fact that he had assaulted one of Zeus’ partners; therefore it seems fair that Odysseus takes revenge in a similar fitting manner. Indeed, for at least some of the suitors, the punishment seems to fit the crime. Rather fittingly, the first to be killed was the leader of the suitors, Antinous. He was killed in a manner which does seem appropriate, as he reached ‘for his fine cup to take a draught of wine’, he was killed with a spear by Odysseus. As Antinous had broken the rules of xenia and lived a lavish lifestyle from Odysseus’ keep, it seems fair that he be killed. As well as this, the third suitor, Amphinomus, is killed when ‘Telemachus hit[s] him from behind, midway between the shoulders, with a spear.’ As this was a prophecy by Athene, it certainly does seem fitting that this prophecy be fulfilled by Odysseus. Prior to this, the second suitor to be killed was the right hand man of Antinous, Eurymachus. He attempts to talk his way out of death, which is ironic as he often used his cunning tongue to escape from situations and…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At last, Theseus, the duke of Athens, also has a strong power to control people. Though he is very authoritative, he neglects others’ feelings. For instance, at the end he accepts Hermia and Lysander’s marriage, and he decides to “over-rule your [Egeus] wishes” (IV: i: 184) but actually, Egeus is not very happy about that. Theseus should discuss with Egeus or convince Egeus why he makes this decision. People…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another example of wrong doing towards Pericles is Cleon and Dionyza. Thasia supposedly "dies" while giving birth to Marina. After Thasia's body was thrown overboard, the storm stops. Shakespeare uses the passage 3.1.22-26 to show how much Thasia meant to him. In the quote by Pericles in the passage after the death of his wife, Thasia, Pericles shows deep emotion. Shakespeare uses a spondee in the first line, "O you gods..." This shows stress on how Pericles feels about the gods. He doesn't curse them, but deeply believes that they control his fate. In this passage, the spondee…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This ancient Athenian murder trial centralizes around the expectations of marriage, the role of women in ancient Greece, and the dangers a husband faces after failing to properly supervise his wife. Euphiletus stands accused of the murder of Eratosthenes, his wife’s lover. According to Athenian law, if a husband finds his wife in bed with another man, it is the husband’s right to determine what penalty the male adulterer will face. The Husband could demand he pay a fine, or even justifiably kill him. The time period of Euphiletus’ trial had come to acknowledge financial compensation as the common settlement for such offenses. Eratosthenes’ family is having Euphiletus prosecuted for premeditated murder; leaving Euphiletus to convince a jury his actions where perfectly legal. He must paint himself as the real victim, a respectable law abiding citizen forced to uphold the law and carryout the proper punishment Eratosthenes earned. All to protect the honor of his wife, children, home and name as best he could. If his defense fails in the eyes of the jury, Euphiletus will face execution.…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Telemachus’ house is overrun by suitors trying to marry his mother, Penelope, since Odysseus has been gone for years and is presumed dead by almost everybody. The suitors embody what it means to be an awful guests and “feed on another’s goods and go scot-free” (Homer 1.187). They all make fun of their host and have intruded on their space for years on end trying to marry Odysseus’s wife while consuming all of Telemachus’ food and drink. All of the suitors were punished my Odysseus and Telemachus when “Odysseus aimed and shot Antinous square in the throat” (Homer 22.15) which started the blood bath. Odysseus and Telemachus got help from the gods to rid their home of the suitors. Because of their bad behavior they get punished by the gods. This also happened on Odysseus’ journey when he landed on the island of the cyclops and met Polyphemus. When Odysseus asked him to be hospitable towards him and his men, the cyclops replied by saying “you must be a fool, stranger, or come from nowhere,/ telling me to fear the gods or avoid their wrath!” (Homer 9.307-308). Polyphemus, one of the worst hosts in The Odyssey, started eating Odysseus’ shipmates and locked them in his cave when he caught them stealing some of his cheese. Odysseus wanted to kill him then and there but wouldn’t be able to get out of the cave, so he soon came up with the plan to get him and…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Upon reading Greek tragedies, many similar themes and tropes would often reappear as a way to tell the audience that the story which they are reading is a tragedy. One of these tropes was the seeking justice. Whether if the justice for another person or their own gratification, justice was a major influence in these plays. Two examples of such tragedies were the Oresteia and Hippolytus. In both, the death of one character sparked a chain reaction that leads others characters to find ways to avenge the fallen ones. This would usually entail more death to come, and cycle of violence seemed to be endless until the gods stepped into the fray to resolve the conflict that the humans simplicity could not. While many could interpret the god’s actions as the law because as powerful beings, they…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In nearly every tale, the story line contains multiple characters whom depict both good and “evil” qualities. In other words, they reveal opposite interpretations. These drastic differences can be drawn due to the lack of specifics in the reading. One interpretation may portray a character as pure and innocent. In another, they may appear at fault. Shakespeare’s famous play, Hamlet, illustrates this notion through an accumulation of characters. Of the many, Ophelia may strike one as the innocent virgin, or rather the selfish and corrupt whore. An overall analysis may be useful in determining which portrayal is more accurate.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medea: Jason's Demise

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As is archetypal to all Greek tragedies, ‘Medea’ by Euripides chronicles the downfall of a noble hero, Jason, as a result of a combination of factors like fate, hubris and the will of the gods. In ‘Medea’, the hubris of the main character, Jason, was his pride. This drove him to betray his wife Medea’s trust and defy moral parameters set by the gods. Euripides employed the hubris of Jason and his act of disobedience towards the gods as a reflection of Athenian society of the time and used this as an attempt to correct the progressively immoral ways of society. This piece focuses on pride as Jason’s hubris and its contribution to his imminent downfall.…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Bacchae

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cadmus carefully tries to persuade his grandson by adding, 'For even if you are right and this God is not a God, why say it? Why not call him one? You have everything to gain from such a lie'(20). Pentheus shows no respect for the elderly or their wisdom by replying, 'Go! Run to your Bacchic revels. I want none of your senile folly rubbing off on me!'(21). This response alone reveals a great deal about his disposition. He will not let any 'old fools' tell him what to do. However, it is ironic that Pentheus' rejection of the advice of these 'old fools' proves to be his first step towards his fatal end.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To the Greeks, life was all about striving to be the best you can be. They tried looking upon their actions and that of their neighbors to decide what was right and what was wrong. Greeks believed that there were superior deities to petition to. Although they were superior, they were not exactly good examples to look upon. These gods were merciless and unjust with their decisions and actions. For example: the story of Zeus and Sisyphus. Sisyphus helped the god of rivers to find his daughter and rescue her from being seduced by Zeus therefore Zeus punished Sisyphus in the afterlife. His punishment was to push a rock up a hill, and just as the top was almost reached, the rock would slip out of his hands and fall back down leading him to repeat the process all over. This punishment was unjust because Sisyphus did an action that to others would seem like a good cause, but to Zeus it was hybris. Hybris is a general insult to a god. Greeks revered their gods, but even though they had a higher power they would not follow their examples which made them to be more self-reliant and…

    • 2279 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Acting on Emotion

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Sophocles designs his plays to instruct his audience members to behave morally correct. People’s actions are ruled by their emotions (jealousy, suspicion, anger, pride, and love) and it leads to negative effects for them. But when acting in a sage demeanor, it gives evidence to a person’s character. Sophocles writes his characters to be ruled by their emotions and to teach people to behave in a prudent demeanor. Sophocles designs his plays to have the people of authority act in an immorally correct fashion.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Hesiod’s piece, “The Works and Days”, Hesiod addresses his brother Perses about how to be a good and virtuous man. Hesiod calls upon Zeus to direct his speech in explaining to Perses how to describe the true way to exist. He starts by explaining the difference between healthy competition and trouble and fighting, Hesiod says “It was never true that there was only one kind of strife. There have always been two on earth” (Lattimore, Hesiod’s Works and days, 2010, p.19). That one is evil and builds up towards war while the other is harsh, but promotes his strife with reward. He goes on to say that being clever and creating short cuts is not a trait worth having. Hesiod gives the example of when Prometheus stole fire from Zeus and in turn, future generations were punished because of Prometheus’ cleverness and deception. He relates this to his life and the time when he and Perses’ father died. This was a prominent theme in the poem and conveyed the injustice Hesiod felt towards his brother. There were issues splitting the inheritance between the two men, and Hesiod accuses Perses of coercing and bribing the “kings” residing over this matter. This is why Hesiod created this poem – to address his brother on his short comings and explain ways of how to improve them.…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics