Preview

Summary: The Indian Residential School System In Canada

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
804 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary: The Indian Residential School System In Canada
Over the past few decades, there has been many distinct perspectives and conflicts surrounding the historical context between the Indigenous peoples in Canada and the Canadian Government. In source one, the author P.J Anderson is trying to convey that the absolute goal of the Indian Residential School system in Canada has been to assimilate the Indian nation and provide them with guidance to “ forget their Indian habits”, and become educated in the “ arts of civilized life”, in order to help them integrate into society and “become one” with their “White brethren”. It is clearly evident throughout the source that the author is supportive of the Indian residential school system and strongly believes that this system was beneficial to the integration …show more content…
Eventually, during the late 18th and 19th century, the Indian act was passed and the government started portraying a major role in the administration and development of these schools. Children were forcibly removed from their homes and brought to these schools where they were bound to learn Christianity, English, cooking and other needed skill to integrate into society and the industrial field. Even though they were able to learn some beneficial skills, many suffered from physical and sexual abuse as well as complete assimilation and cultural loss. To this extent, the government was benefited through this system since they had found a logical and functional solution to solve the “Indian problem” which was a worry they challenged since their arrival during the colonization period. To a massive extent, the government was successful in imposing Eurocentric views towards the FNMI people and their attempts at cultural assimilation. However, during the late 19th century, the last federally run residential school closed. Eventually, the government acknowledged Aboriginals in Canada and a reconciliation statement was created in …show more content…
To what extent has the government tried to resolve the issues between FNNI people and the Eurocentric government and how effective were their attempts throughout history? In source one, in the quote by Indian superintendent P.G Anderson, he describes the government's determination to inflict the Indian residential school systems on the FNMI communities, and their goal to assimilate the indian culture into the Eurocentric society. His response to the question is that the Canadian European government has had and always will have a superior power to the first Nations minority in Canada, and that their attempt to resolve the “Indian problem” was successful through the establishment of the indian residential school system. Source two responds to the question through a symbolic drawing of a courthouse with the name “reconciliation” and having only one block built in the project which was the 2008 residential school apology. Additionally, the construction site has a sign stating “UNDER CONSTRUCTION; Completion: UNKNOWN”. In this source, the answer to the question is clearly displayed through the cartoon, that the relationship between the government and the FNMI people is not strong. To a certain extent, the government has previously attempted a more peaceful resolution to the ongoing conflict between the cultural interdependence, but there still

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Ever since it was passed in 1876, the Indian Act has stirred negative feedback. It is a paternalistic and intrusive piece of legislature that essentially controls the political and day-to-day lives of the First Nations people. It is an Aboriginal versus white struggle that has lasted for more than a century. But now this is not entirely true. The indigenous communities of Canada have internalized the contents of the Indian Act and made it Aboriginal versus Aboriginal. This essay will attempt to explain why this reversal has happened and what it has done to the indigenous identity.…

    • 915 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The children were taken away to these schools for most of the year (Arnold, 2000, p.209). The people who took them away (often Indian agents assigned to the school) were luring the children into doing a fun activity However, in reality, they were being kidnapped. When the children were studying, the books which they used referred to First Nations people as savages (Arnold, 2000 p. 209). The books also taught the children that the beliefs of non- Aboriginals were better than the beliefs of any other society. The children were often beaten badly if they misconducted themselves or if they spoke their native languages (Pittman, 1989). In 2008, the Canadian government issued a statement of apology to the First Nations people of Canada. This is a first step in preventing any more harassment to the First Nations people and to provide a better quality of life, for not just the First Nations people, but for all…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2008, Prime minister of Canada, Stephen Harper issued an apology statement from the government of Canada for residential schools and the damage they caused to the aboriginal people. In his apology, he recognized what the real purpose of residential school was, “ to remove and isolate children from the influence of their homes, families, traditions and cultures, and to assimilate them into the dominant culture”. Harper said that the government thought of Aboriginal people as inferior and unequal to them, thus they enforced a school system that forced children out of their home, their comfort zone, and their communities. Their main purpose was to kill the beautiful culture, tradition and communities of the Aboriginal people.…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first and most essential step towards the goal of assimilation was the segregation placed between Native children and their families while attending Residential schooling.6 Before fully developed Residential schools had been established in Canada the government had attempted to approach the education of Natives much less aggressively and implement day schools on the reserves. However, these day schools did not produce the results the government aspired to because the children's culture and lifestyle was still primarily being formed at home.7 Due to the lack of reinforcement of day…

    • 1541 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The First Nations of our land have endured hundreds of years of suffering. Ever since the first significant European contact the indigenous people have been treated as sub-humans; savages with no religion, intelligence, or right to live. This general idea has carried through-out the history of our supposedly great country; Canada. This essay will examine the residential school system in depth. It will then relate the Canadian Government 's actions in response to residential schools, good and bad.…

    • 2817 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Canada 1900

    • 2908 Words
    • 12 Pages

    o Residential schools had been set up under the 1876 Indian Act because the Act stated that the federal government was responsible for the education of Canada’s aboriginal childrenFirst Nation…

    • 2908 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    He acknowledged the damaging impact of the Indian Residential School System on indigenous culture, heritage, and language. The PM renewed Canada’s apology to the Aboriginal peoples and promised to fully implement the TRC Calls to Action.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However Canada tries to hide a dirty little secret, and that happens to be residential school. Residential schools came to into effect in the early 1870s and the last one was not close until 1996.("The Residential School System."). As mentioned earlier, the charter was no created until 1982, this means Canadians were breaking the first section of the charter, which are the fundamental freedoms ("Rights and Freedoms in Canada."). Residential schools were designed to "kill the Indian in the child"("The Residential School System."). Contrary to what the public believed back in the 1870s, these schools were not always the best for the children, they were taking from their families and force to follow a religion and language that was not their own.("The Residential School System.") Canadian aboriginals were subjected to all kinds of abuse while attending these schools. ("The Residential School System.") Emotional, Psychological, physical and most importantly sexual abuse were found in almost every school.("The Residential School System.") Many Canadians are under the notion that residential schools were designed to teach aboriginal children about catholic religion, this is not the truth.The truth is that residential schools were also underfunded compared to the white schools.("The Residential School System.") and although the children were taught Christianity, the children were groomed to became house maids or farmers.("The Residential School System.") The majority of children who were sent away at the age of 18 only had a fifth-grade education. ("The Residential School System.")this type of Trauma had to be endured by many generations of Canadian aboriginals. The so call " free" education came with a deadly price.In 1907, medical inspector P.H. Bryce reported that 24 percent aboriginal children were dying in residential homes, this number did not counter in the number of death of children…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sikhism In Canada

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages

    the aboriginal peoples are the original inhabits of Canada . the Canadian government believed that the children of the aboriginal people were going to be the start of assimilation. it was with that idea the government decided to create residential schools . the government thought that taking these children and putting them in schools would make lose their culture and identity . by 1910 around 150,000 children were forced to attend these school. they were taken to schools hundreds of miles away and were only allowed to see their families every 10 months. 50% of children died due to terrible living contents and many were diagnosed with tuberculosis because of unsanitary conditions , bad diet , and poor medical care.many children were physical , mentally ,and sexually abused .in 2008 Stephen harper apologized for the tool the people who were forced into residential schools . some people believe that there is a long way to go until the government is forgiven, others have already forgiven the government.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Residential Schools

    • 912 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The First Nation people have a proud and long history that combines rich culture and spiritual traditions. For a century, from the 1880s until 1980s more than 100,000 First Nations children in Canada attended residential schools. The placement of residential schools for the First Nations children has led to serious amount of damage. At the schools, they were banned to practice their beliefs, culture and speak their language. The children suffered from emotional, physical and sexual abuse. Due to these events the First Nations in Canada suffered a significant loss of their culture and traditions, and suffered a negative affect in their future.…

    • 912 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    To this end, the Indian Act was created in 1876. Members of Parliament viewed the Indian Act as a way to motivate the Indians to educate their children and become contributing members of society. However, due to cultural superior thinking, MPs did not believe Indigenous peoples could meet this goal on their own accord within the boundaries of their own culture. Therefore, in order to complete the goal, MPs thought it paramount that Euro western curricula be taught to the next generation of children . It was believed that as the adult Indigenous population could not be swayed – as was evidenced by only a single person voluntarily franchising under the Gradual Civilization Act – the focus should turn to the children, who could be indoctrinated into the superior European culture. In this way, Indian residential schools were introduced and legislated through the Indian Act. However, for the first eight years the Canadian government and churches (who ran the schools with federal funding) came to realize that once more indigenous parents would not voluntarily give up their right, in this case, the right to raise and educate their children the way they saw fit. A voluntary call for parents to send their children to residential schools was not meeting the goal set by the government for student enrollment. MP William P.C. Paterson, referring to a letter sent by a Reverend Wilson, claimed that the assimilatory processes was not working as had…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Residential Schools

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the 19th century the Canadian government believed it was responsible for educating and caring for the country’s aboriginal people. It though that native peoples best chance for success was to adopt Christianity and Canadian customs. Thus, in 1857 the Gradual Civilization Act was passed to assimilate natives. Children were the main targets, because it was believed that it would be easier to mould a young child as opposed to an adult. By assimilating the aboriginal children into the lower fringes of mainstream society, they hoped to diminish or abolish native traditions within a few generations. Schools run by churches upon government funding were created in order to separate these children from their homes. They were later named residential schools and were established with the assumption that aboriginal culture was unable to adapt to a modernizing society. In 1920, attendance became compulsory for all kids ages 7-15. Agents were employed by the government to ensure all native children attended. Many were taken by brute force and others separated from their siblings. In all, about 150 000 kids were removed from their communities and forced to attend the schools.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The worst aspect of Canada’s residential schools is the endemic abuse by the Europeans to the first nations children emotional, physical and sexual for which they are now know. Most residential schools close in the 1970’s. Criminal and civil suits against the government and the churches begin. Over 10,00 law suits have pass and the government, Stephen harper and churches issue a formal historic apology on behalf of the institutional racism that exist against the first nation people in front of an audience of aboriginal delegates. Institutional racism is constant as a pattern as it is there in the past and is still present today in Canada. The living standard of Indigenous people in Canada falls short of those of the non-indigenous and they along either other visible minorities remain as a group, the poorest in Canada. There continue to be barriers to gaining equality with other Canadian of Europe’s ancestry. The life expectancy of first nation’s people is lower, they have less high school graduates, much higher unemployment rates and incomes are…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1860, the United States government began pushing Native American children into schools, it was portrayed as a way to help Native people assimilate into common American society. However, as time passed the United States government felt that they needed to completely remove all tribal influence in order to civilize the Native population. This radical action is summed up best in the term, “Kill the Indian save the man” . In order to accomplish this the government began implementing the use of off reservation boarding schools. These off reservation boarding schools stripped American Indian children of their culture, and identity by forcing them to change themselves mentally, physically and spiritually.…

    • 185 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Another form of discrimination that was placed upon the Aboriginal population was the assimilation families and children faced through the integration of residential schools. The idea behind residential schools was to try and “civilize” the Aboriginal nation. Children were taken from their families and were forced into forgetting their language, traditions, hunting and gathering skills, until they were entirely “European”. The discrimination faced by the Aboriginal nation still to this day is well beyond horrific. In her article “The Queen and I: discrimination against women in the Indian Act continues” Lynn Gehl states that “the goal of the Indian Act was one of assimilation and the arduous task of civilizing the savages--a national agenda” (Gehl, 2000). Residential schools, paternity laws, denied access to Indian status and criminalization of Indigenous culture imposed from the government are all examples of how the Aboriginal population has been racialized and discriminated from European settlers and the country of…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays