Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Sinclair Ross's Praire Isolation by Symbolism: "The Lamp at Noon"

Good Essays
913 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Sinclair Ross's Praire Isolation by Symbolism: "The Lamp at Noon"
"The Lamp at Noon" is a short story that focuses on the reality of the desiccated, secluded, and expansive prairies. Set on the haunting Canadian prairies, weather emulates the emotions of Ellen, a housewife desperate for freedom of the dustbowl lifestyle. The authority of wind and dust seem to taunt Ellen and her husband, Paul, into desperation. Ross applies symbolism across the pages of "The Lamp at Noon" to inform the reader of the lonely emotions that are wrought by the desolate and barren prairies.

In Ross's short story the use of three important symbols is crucial. The first is the lamp, which on the whole embodies the spirit and optimism that Ellen feels towards her marriage to Paul. " [Ellen] lit the lamp," (7) just prior to her much anticipated lunch with Paul, where she would argue her sentiments about eradicating their lives of "[t]histles and tumbleweeds" (10). Before lunch Ellen seemed confident that, this time, Paul may finally understand her growing concerns about the prairies - she lights the lamp, just as she lights her hopeful feelings. As Ellen waits for Paul by the window the "lamp reach[es] out through the open door" (7) towards Paul, subsequently it is Ellen who is reaching out to Paul. In the course of the couples fiery discussion "the lamp [ ] threw strong lights and shadows on their faces," (9) denoting Ellen's dimming hopes that their conversation will be as optimistic as she. Paul was "compelled by his anxiety"(14) to return to the house, after exiting their discussion abruptly, to resolve his matters with Ellen. But his return was not greeted with Ellen; it was greeted with Ellen's vanished hope that Paul would ever understand her - "the lamp [was] blown out" (16). Ellen's hopes and confidences in her marriage and life with Paul were muted as she blew out the lamp - the light of their relationship.

A second important symbol is the merciless dust. The dust in "The Lamp at Noon" compels frailty of Paul and Ellen's marriage and the unsettled particles that come between them. The particles of dust that separate Paul and Ellen are of Ellen's concerns for vanity and the better things life may offer, and of Paul's ideals of independence. The dust particles, having been afloat for "thr[ee] day[s]" (9), become so "impenetrable" (7) between Paul and Ellen that they can barely see each other - they are blinded by dust to one another's needs. Ellen's "own throat was parched with dust" (8). As Ellen becomes frustrated with her and Paul's colliding hopes she flees into the heart of the dust storm, which ironically symbolizes every particle of Paul and Ellen's emotions colliding with one another. As Paul discovers Ellen at the end of the story, her dust-strewn hair is "in matted strands around her neck and face" (17). The dust of Paul's emotions has infiltrated her until she is lost and has no hope of continuing without Paul's help. Here is where she realizes that "tomorrow will be fine" (17)

The "[d]emented wind" (7) becomes the most helpful symbol in assisting the reader in decoding Ellen's push and pull of emotion. The wind in "The Lamp at Noon" embodies Ellen. The paragraph in which describes how Ellen "fix[es] her eyes upon the clock" (8) proves to be the most effectual in alluding Ellen as a flurry of wind. As Ellen is isolated in the house, awaiting Paul, she hears her own sentiments, which the narrator describes as wind - " [t]he wind in flight, and the wind that pursued," (8). The wind in flight images her desire to hold back her feelings, but as she sits and reflects about her rage at Paul, her wind in pursuit "sh[akes] the eaves apart"(8) in anger. Ellen's apprehension to keep her feelings from Paul "spr[ings] inside the room, distraught" (8) as if it were lost, but her more powerful sensation to tell Paul "shook the walls, and thudded tumbleweeds against the window" (8) . As a result of her isolation in a tiny farmhouse, Ellen has acquired time to revel over her desperate feelings of solitude. At the latter end of the story Paul finds himself experiencing isolation as his wife has for years. Sitting alone in his barn the "wind persisted as a woman's cry" (14) - Ellen's cries for freedom were heard in the wind. As Ellen has fled the home into the storm, her anxiety grows and affects Paul as the wind "wails through the loft" (14). Paul hears the wind scream Ellen's complaints of the dust, and the boredom created by the prairies. Thus, it is easily seen how the wind has embodied Ellen's passions and created an emotional storm that afflicts Paul and Ellen's "isolated acre" (7).

In both "The Lamp at Noon" and "The Painted Door", another prairie based piece by Ross, Ross employs weather to imitate the feelings of the key personalities, but more importantly he uses prairie landscape and weather to exemplify the fissures between husband and wife. Crying winds, lonely moments, and climatic symbolism are features of both short stories, which implies Ross's message of the prairies - the isolation will keep one frantic for freedom. The effect of domestic light, fogging dust and raging wind has created a foundation for the reader of "The Lamp at Noon" to base conclusions of the prairie lifestyle. Through these three significant symbols Ross has created a tempest of emotion between two isolated personalities.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Story Of An Hour Theme

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The theme of “The Story of an Hour” to me is sad, there is a moment of joy, also there is confusion in the story. I think it’s sad because there is death in the story. Nobody likes death! Mrs. Mallard has a moment of joy, she feels free. She has freedom from her husband's death. I find it also confusing how Mrs. Mallard celebrated her husband's death. She didn't seem sad one bit. I feel these are the reasons these are the themes of “The Story of an Hour”…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Although there was evening brightness showing through the windows of the bunkhouse, inside it was dust". This shows that the light tries to get in but never manages to penetrate the darkness. This is important to the themes of the story because workers' hope for a future farm is just like the light while the cruel reality is like the darkness. Their efforts to realize this plan is just like the light trying to penetrate the darkness, but their dream shatters at last, just like the dust inside.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Short story, The Painted door, by Sinclair Ross, follows the life of a woman and a man living on a quiet, secluded farm. The woman, Ann, is a very confused person who is seemed to be unsatisfied with her marriage. Her Husband, John, is a very hard working farmer who works his hardest so that he can provide for him and his wife. He enjoys the simpler things in life, yet his wife, Ann, cannot. Nothing is good enough for her. Her selfish ways are evident in her attitude toward the material things in her home environment and in the way she treats her husband. Through the heavy use of imagery in the story “The Painted door” Ross effectively shows how lonely Ann is.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I believe that the sunlight represents the virtue and goodness in each person. I am not quite sure about the windblown trees, but maybe it could symbolize the tormenting that Hester and Pearl have gone through, especially Hester in the town square, when she was forced to wear her Scarlet letter, and Pearl being ostracized for “being the product of a sin”.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    But its chief significance lies not in these "readings," surely not in its "ultimate meaning," which may or may not be revealed, but in its power to stimulate such efforts and in the still more potent emotional effects it produces in those who behold it. Some of the townspeople are amazed, others awed; some are fearful or intimidated, others perplexed or defensively wise, while yet others are inspired or made hopeful. For all the emphasis on interpretive hypotheses--and there is much--there is as much or more on the accompanying emotional impact. And both, of course, are characteristic of the symbol, the latter more profoundly than the former. Symbols, as D. H. Lawrence remarks, "don't `mean something.' They stand for units of human feeling, human experience. A complex of emotional experience is a symbol. And the power of the symbol," like the power of the minister's veil, "is to arouse the deep emotional self, and the dynamic self, beyond comprehension" (Lawrence 158). The "strangest part of the affair," remarks a physician, "is the effect of this vagary, even on a sober-minded man like myself" (Hawthorne 41).…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When people are lonely and bored, they tend to reflect on their lives and the issues they have. This is precisely what happens in Sinclair Ross's "The Painted Door", where the author explores adultery, a topic which was taboo back in the thirties, the time when the story takes place. This is a story about a woman named Ann, who, ironically, discovers her true feelings for her husband, John, by cheating on him with his best friend, Steven.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    3. In what ways does the natural landscape serve as a metaphor for Ann’s emotional…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    loving and caring qualities of the husbands toward their wife's. In "The Painted Door", John, whose married to Anne, devotes a lot of his time to working in the farm. His goal is to pay off his mortgage as soon as possible and wants to be able to buy nice clothes for his wife. He's takes his wife into consideration when it comes to her feelings. For example, "[John] tried to brighten [his wife].(Pg.232)" when she was upset about him going to his fathers hou... In the story by Sinclair Ross “The Painted Door” the main character, Anne, represents a weak, unhappy, selfish and insecure woman who is not pleased with her husband’s life choices. Employing the Feminist approach to “The Painted Door” reveals striking aspects that would otherwise be…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The dust is the first significant symbol Steinbeck uses to represent the migrants and their struggles. As the dust filled the air in Oklahoma, families watched their lives settle to nothing along with the dust, “The men were silent and they did not move often. And the women came out of the houses to stand beside…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Veil

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages

    10. What does the phrase “darkly understood” on the top of page 243 refer to? What does the snatching away of the veil possibly symbolize?…

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    What holds a relationship together? How do relationships go the way they do? What in a relationship causes it to tremble and fall apart? According to this short story "The Painted Door", communication is what determines how the relationship would start and how it will end up. Communication is the foundation of a healthy relationship. The author develops this theme through three main aspects of the short story: character, conflict and symbols.…

    • 849 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The second method that the author uses was characterization - another major factor of foundation for a good read. Ross used excellent descriptions for the two main characters. This is because they could be related to fairly easily, and realistically. Ellen's strong and hopeful feelings which dance around the idea of a better, healthier and even a little more "rewarding" life are nicely depicted. The reality of her hopes, however, is that the things she wants and needs most are unattainable, which links her feelings to the theme of isolation. So, if she can not produce these things, she just sits and waits for a…

    • 1018 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Canadian Prairies are notorious for its winter’s harsh, unforgiving climate. They represent not only humankind’s perseverance for survival, but unrelenting isolation, and the despair that can follow. In “The Painted Door” by Sinclair Ross, a discontent housewife gives into temptation after being left alone by her husband. A person will resist isolation, because when left alone, they will give in to temptatious thoughts, affecting their view on their relationships. Physical solitude will dictate if an individual choose to give into temptation. An individual’s independent reflection after giving into temptation will reveal their true feelings, making them decide on what they really want. Ross develops the idea that isolation will influence how one will…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the poem “Nighttime Fires” the speaker of the poem is remembering the speaker father’s wild obsession with burning houses at night and how the speaker had to go with the father to these burning houses with the family. The father is a casualty of the rough economy and this anger toward his bad luck is the reason he loves seeing these macabre scenes. The speaker in “Nighttime Fires” vividly illustrates the lasting impression that the fires and his father’s fascination with them, had on his childhood and the relationship with the father.…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Lamp at Noon

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Second way that the author help defined the character is by using characterization. Sinclair used outstanding description for the two main characters. This is because they could both relate fairly, easily, and realistically. Ellen’s strong feeling which revolve around the idea of a better, healthier and even a little more “rewarding” life are nicely depicted. The reality of her hopes, however, is that the thing’s she wants and needs most are unattainable, which links to how isolated she feels. Ellen feels if she doesn’t acquire these glamorous items, she gets depressed. Ellen just sits and waits for a better opportunity, and her…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays