Preview

Similarities Between Taliban And Jacoban

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
716 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Similarities Between Taliban And Jacoban
TALIBAIN VS. JACOBINS
“All I know is that history repeats itself and people are going to want to experience the world. But I know then they are going to have a better appreciation for what is here in Maine.”
John Baldacci (purposefairy.com). An example of this quote would be the similarities of two revolutionary groups, the Taliban and the Jacobins. These groups are both similar and different at the same time. The similarities might come from the reason that they both were looking to spark revolutions and make changes. The differences might come from the type of people involved, time period, and even the region. The Taliban is different from the Jacobins in the following ways. First off is that the Taliban was in a radical Mujahedeen group, meaning Islam played in important role in their decision
…show more content…
Beginning with the Jacobins and the Reign of terror, during this time the Declaration of Rights of Man were created by the National Assembly which was made up of the Third Estate (commoners). The Declaration indicated that all men were equal, the obligation of the government was to preserve the natural laws of men, the law only has the right to prohibit those actions which are injurious to society, and much more that deal with human rights and equality (chnm.gmu.edu). On the other hand The Taliban made some very different reforms in Afghanistan. They include some of these: “Whipping of women in public for having non-covered ankles, ban on women being treated by male doctors, ban on women appearing on the balconies of their apartments or houses” (rawa.org) and many more restrictions and punishment for women. As was demonstrated the changes of the Taliban in Afghanistan are much more focused on taking away rights and other violent and radical things involved with Islam. Contrary to the Jacobin’s reforms that focused on emphasizing to grant rights to the people of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Taliban started in 1979, when the Soviet union invaded Afghanistan. The Taliban is a group of Islamic extremist in Afghanistan. The Taliban enforces many laws, they believe that Islam should be followed strictly. They force women to wear long black cloaks and a headscarf, and if the slightest amount of skin is shown the woman will be punished. The Taliban follow a strict version of the Sharia which is a traditional interpretation of the Koran.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story, the Taliban are trying to take control of Afghanistan. They do not let anybody get in their way. The taliban go around “ slaughtering men like goats, slitting them open and leaving their blood to soak into the ground” (staples, 12). Clearly, many people live in fear of these blood thirsty human beings. Also, the taliban “ lock the people of entire villages in their homes” but not only that, they “burn them to the ground” (staples, 12). The taliban just cares to torture people, they do not care the cost, who gets hurt or anything else. The taliban affects how people live their everyday lives, such as going to school, making money or working, and even daily events such as when there was a bombing at the Bazaar. Also they have very strict rules that seem extreme to people who live in the west and have different freedoms. Some of the rules include how long your beard is and clothing. At one point in the book Asma has an incident with a member of the taliban when she had very little skin showing, “your in violation of dress code, the man said to Asma” (staples,96). These rules take away the rights of many innocent people in the book. Many other rules are in place like “playing music, laughing out loud, keeping a bird to hear its song in the morning, putting pictures of beautiful scenes on the wall, reading books, flying kites” (Staples, 12). These rules are much…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One would be they both strongly believe in standing up for what you believe in and not bending to the will of others. This is shown through Ali’s defense in his Islamic belief and Thoreau’s strong individualism. Another similarity between the two would be their beliefs in civil disobedience. This would be a similarity because neither Ali nor Thoreau believed in, or wanted to use violence in their protest. This is because of Ali’s Islamic belief [people of Islamic faith do not believe in violence] and simply because Thoreau couldn’t be more nonchalant about what people thought of him. The difference between the two comes in the way their protests were carried out. Thoreau remained under the radar merely writing about what he felt and believed in. While Ali, on the other hand, made all his actions and views public and wanted everyone to know what he had to say the moment he said…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some of the similarities between the two included the attitudes against them. As it was during the World Wars, where Germans were automatically assumed to be Nazis just because they identified as German, after the 9/11 attacks, Arab and Islamic America were automatically assumed to be terrorists. It seemed that, in both cases, it was a generally accepted and believed idea, that heritage and ethnicity drove everything about a person as an individual, whereas that was not the truth at all. Even more than decades later, German Americans are still considered “Nazis” and Muslim Americans are still addressed as “Terrorists.” Universal blame for the terrorist attacks and for the World Wars was placed on all those who identified as either of these groups.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A man called Sayyid Qutb (1906–1966) insisted that the Qur'anic injunction to toleration couldoccur only after the political victory of Islam and the establishment of a true Muslim state….Every Sunni fundamentalist movement has been influenced by Qutb. Most spectacularly, it has inspiredMuslims to assassinate such leaders as Anwar al-Sadat….The Taliban, who came to power in Afghanistan in 1994, are also affected by his ideology. They are determined to return to what they see as the original vision of Islam….Only religious broadcasting is permitted and the Islamic punishments of stoning and mutilation have been reintroduced….The ethnic chauvinism between the Pashtun tribe and the people in the north, and the harsh treatment of minority groups is also opposed to clear Qur'anic requirements. The Taliban's discrimination against women is completely opposed to the practice of the Prophet and the conduct of the first unmah (Muslim community).…

    • 2889 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    An ideology of revolution through an improvement of rights system was in Michael Ignatieff’s article “Democracy and Rights Revolution” (2000). He revealed that this transition, which started from the 1960s, has effects on both improving overall equality, and defending people’s right to be different.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Taliban regime took control of Kabul and implemented their interpretation of Islamic laws in the year 1996. The arrival of the Taliban marked a timeline completely different known to the women in Afghanistan. Paul Watson wrote an article in the L.A. Times about a doctor who experienced and witnessed the many medical mishaps due to the Taliban laws. Watson stated, “The Taliban were so obsessed with hiding women from men’s eyes that even a male surgeon could not see his dying patient’s exposed flesh” (Watson1). This statement describes how the women couldn’t be seen by the men, even if it was a doctor trying to save his female patient. In public the women had to wear a burka that covered their body from head to toe. Exposure of their bodies would lead to the women getting beaten, stoned, and raped by the Taliban. These actions were very much extreme for the women in Afghanistan to live by. They were not just supposed to wear a burka,…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In these two particular time periods, there were a substantial amount of similarities. The most apparent one was that everyone lived in fear; scared that they would be prosecuted based on accusations, whether they were factual or not, and the personnel in both scenarios made the situations as serious as they were.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Under The Persimmon Tree

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Taliban have created a war in their homeland, which in turn causes civilians to pay for their behavior, as “many people have been killed by American bombs” (Staples 172). The Americans have no choice but to bomb these areas to protect their own citizens, and sometimes civilians might get in the way. The lives of innocent Afghans have been ruined and “you can tell by looking at them that they have no food and little clean water, all they live on is dreams of their farms, which no longer exist” (Staples 186). The Taliban are greedy and have no feelings towards people other than themselves. Rumors have been spreading around villages that “they lock the people of entire villages inside their houses and burn them down and how they slaughter men like goats” (Staples 12). These terrible acts have turned lives upside down and brought havoc upon a once peaceful place. The people are constantly abused by the Taliban, and “many are missing a hand or a foot or an eye. So many of them have terrible wounds or scars” (Staples 185/186). The way the Taliban treat women is disappointing. Najmah has heard how they “whip women whose shoes make a sound on paving stone" (Staples 180). The Taliban have scared the women so much that they "hide their bangles away because if they're caught wearing any jewelry it will be stolen and they will be beaten” (Staples 180).…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sociology 300 Essay

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages

    One reason women’s rights are restricted is the lack of education and illiteracy of Afghan women. Being illiterate prevents a woman from studying Islam. Therefore, when someone tells her something is Islamic, she automatically believes him because she has no way of knowing otherwise. Not only does illiteracy prevent Muslim women from studying Islam, but it also prevents them from studying their legal rights and the Qur’an. Studying the Qur’an and legal rights would cause women to understand what really is Islamic. Women may lack knowledge of how women live in other nations. Therefore, these women do not resist their lack of rights because they are uninformed of alternative lifestyles of women. In 1921, women’s…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1900s, life for women in Afghanistan was advanced and satisfying for Afghan women. There were many opportunities for females to form their own lives and live for themselves, with no men or law holding them back. However, once the Invasion of 1979 began, the Taliban began to rise seizing control of the government. Changing laws and restricting women’s life in educational, social, and governmental aspects, life for women became an everyday challenge. Now, women are being to grab the reigns of their life and take back their freedoms, but seem to find challenges on their way to success. The harsh rule and laws from the Taliban has set freedoms in Afghanistan backwards, poorly affecting all levels of Afghan society. Because of the Invasion of 1979 and the rule of the Taliban, Rights…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Swallows of Kabul

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Taliban is taking over Kabul day by day with their intense cruelty. They may be the law, but they don’t enforce it in the peoples’ best interest. They turned Kabul from a city to a hopeless wonder. From their strict laws such as no music, no public affection, and pure cruelty towards women, Kabul revolves around the Taliban. Ever since they have been in charge the city has changed, and not for the good. They even started public executions where they are constantly killing people, innocent and all. In the very beginning of The Swallows of Kabul a mullah states, “She has no right to his mercy, no right to the pity. She has lived in dishonor; so she shall die.” (13-14) being accused of prostitution, a woman is stoned at a public execution. Without any pity the Taliban kills a citizen because of alleged prostitution. As people gathered to watch the horrible event, the Taliban deceived and lied to those who watched to make them think that what they was doing was justified. The woman was not asked or given a chance to explain herself, but she was quickly executed. The action of killing a person so heartlessly shows that the Taliban do not care about the people of their own community. They turn people against each other by feeding them lies, so in the end everyone will abide by them right…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Afghanistan women basically have no control over their lives. The author of the article states, “Up to 80 percent of marriages in poor rural areas are forced or arranged” (www.trustineducation.org). Forced marriage is a complete denial of human rights. Humans are given the constitutional right of free will. As humans these women should be able to choose if they want to get married, and who they marry. But that right is overwritten when their fathers decide to sell them off to other men. Afghan women are seen as objects that can be sold and bargained for by men. Another injustice stated by the author, “Married girls do not continue their education and remain illiterate” (www.trustineducation.org). After these women are forced to be married they are also forced to discontinue their education. Education is another right given to humans. Afghan women are forced to stop their education so they can get married and take care of the children they are expected to birth. It is assumed that they will not need an education because their husband will have one. This is an injustice because this leaves women uneducated and unable to progress in their future career. They are expected to stay home, clean, and take care of the children while the men provide for the family. The author also states, “Young wives also have low status in the family and are more likely to be abused by their husbands and/or in-laws”…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kite Runner

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The rise of the Taliban traces back to the Reagan presidency when he did not fulfill his promises to Afghanistan after the Afghan-Soviet War. From there Islamic Fundamentalists formed an extremist’s party known as “mujahideen” or as we know it, The Taliban. The Taliban has continuously used questionable tactics to run their regions and are constantly under scrutiny from western nations such as the United States. One problem in particular is their treatment of women. The Taliban also resents western influence, which is a main source of their bad reputation through their unwillingness to conform. They look at the United States as revealing and barbaric through its culture and hobbies. In the Middle East they are also convinced that public execution and brutality is acceptable, which is one of the top reasons their tactics are so scrutinized. The real problem is that they are very close-minded minds and they believe that everything they do is gospel and anyone who differs or goes against it is completely wrong, no ways around it. When they took away the rights of women in the 1990s, the Taliban believed that what they were doing was moral because of their anti-American sentiments regarding the American attitude towards women’s education and sexuality. The Taliban believe that taking away women’s rights will protect the Islamic people from corrupt western influences.…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Taliban

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages

    "The Taliban enforced strict adherence to their interpretation of Islamic laws. These laws included restrictions on most modern forms of entertainment. They also included personal restrictions on dress and grooming. For example, the Taliban forced men to wear beards and women to wear veils. Those who violated the Taliban's law were punished."…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics