Preview

Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar Vs. Plutarch’s Julius Caesar

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1562 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar Vs. Plutarch’s Julius Caesar
"He doth bestride the narrow world like a colossus"�(Julius Caesar 1.2.142-43).

These words were spoken by Cassius, a character in Shakespeare's play Julius Caesar.

He is speaking about Julius Caesar and Caesar's arrogance and overconfidence. This quote also shows how Shakespeare perceived Julius Caesar as a prominent and influential man of his time. However, this view is not shared by all of the biographers that chose to write about Julius Caesar. In fact a famous ancient writer named Plutarch depicted Julius Caesar as a power-hungry and arrogant man in his biography The Life of Caesar. Plutarch was one of the world's first modern biographers and his work is still used today. Even Shakespeare used him as a historical reference in his play on Caesar.

Although this is the case, Plutarch and Shakespeare's portrayals of Caesar and the events that encompass his life are quite different. But who's to say which one is correct? That is where the work of Suetonius comes in. Suetonius was another ancient writer that lived over one hundred years after the assassination of Caesar yet Suetonius had access to important archival records and literary sources that are now lost. Therefore, it can be assumed that his account of the life of Caesar in The Lives of the Twelve Caesars is fairly accurate. So when Shakespeare and Plutarch's biographies are compared with Suetonius' work, Plutarch comes out the winner in validity. Although Shakespeare and Plutarch's descriptions of the events surrounding the life and death of Caesar are somewhat similar, the differences outweigh the parallelism by far. Some of the most obvious differences include: the way Caesar was viewed by the people, the fact that the conspiracy was known about, and the detail and lack of detail regarding Caesar's assassination. Equally important are the differences in the character and personality of Julius Caesar himself.

Plutarch describes Caesar as ambitious and self-centered, whereas Shakespeare makes Caesar

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Works of literature often feature characters whose pride or selfishness creates problems. In William Shakespeare’s ‘’Julius Caesar’’, Caesar’s pride creates problems because it causes him to overlook the warnings signs that point him towards his demise. Thus Caesar’s experience with pride ultimately leads to his tragic demise.…

    • 77 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In Shakespeare’s ’Julius Caesar,’ what characters say and think about each other, has a significant impact on the ways in which they themselves, are…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assessing a Queen Plutarch and Octavian both write damning accounts concerning the behavior and actions of Marc Antony and his lover Cleopatra. While Plutarch appears to take a more objective approach, Octavian sets out to condemn the former general and the Egyptian Queen. He declares that Cleopatra is everything a woman of nobility should not be and the soul reason Antony has gone so far astray. Octavian goes on to label Antony as “either irrational or insane” when referring to the mental state of the former roman general. He argues that for a roman man of such great esteem to have been lead so far astray only the worst type of woman could have infected his mind, leading to his scathing description of Cleopatra.…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a large amount of differences between the play interpretation of Julius Caesar and what really happened. For instance, Brutus in the play was extremely different than real life Brutus. In the play, he was best friends with Caesar-well, until he killed him. However, in real life, Brutus hated Caesar. He was never supportive of Caesar, and truthfully never loved him.(Musaj and Prezi Inc.) In Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, he uses Brutus’s strong love of Rome, his honor, and his willing to do anything for the good of Rome to show that Brutus is the tragic hero.…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As Cicero states: “men may construe things after their fashion”, in the midst of subjective conflicting perspectives upon a certain personality, what would you draw from it? William Shakespeare lends this thought to the audiences of his time as well as ours through the play, Julius Caesar. Was Julius Caesar really the noblest man that ever lived, an ambitious tyrant, or both? Enhanced by the personal values of Cassius and Brutus, we can discover that studying the conflicting perspectives of Caesar and his power can bring us closer to the truth of his character whilst cultivating a more diverse and provocative insight to Shakespeare’s context and audience.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Shakespeare’s tragedy Julius Caesar clearly presents conflicting perspectives of the assassination of Caesar, a powerful and respected leader, viewed by the conspirators as overly ambitious, but by Marc Antony as a loyal servant of Rome. Brutus and the conspirators believe that Caesar’s death is necessary in retaining democracy, whereas Antony regards the act as brutal murder.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Julius Caesar Flaws

    • 2477 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Caesar’s tragic flaw is his pride, which leads him to believe he is invulnerable to mundane threats, which ultimately leads to his death. In act one scene one, tribunes Flavius and Murellus believe that “these growing feathers plucked from Caesar’s wings will make him fly an ordinary pitch.” Although their effort fails, the statement likens Caesar to Icarus, an important figure in Greek mythology. Icarus and his father Daedalus, trapped on the island of Crete, build feathered wings and try to escape. But Icarus, proud at what he has accomplished, soars too close to the sun, melts his wings, and drowns in the ocean. Shakespeare uses this classical allusion to hint to the reader that Caesar will meet a similar fate because of his pride. Caesar’s own language indicates this flaw: “Caesar is turned to hear,” he says to a soothsayer; unlike Brutus and Cassius, who use the humble “I” when referencing themselves, Caesar uses his own name and all the connotations of power that come with it. Caesar subsequently rejects the soothsayer’s prophecy, saying scornfully, “He is a dreamer. Let us leave him.” Caesar immediately disregards the soothsayers threat, showing that he believes himself invulnerable. Because of this belief, Caesar tends to ignore what displeases him and listens to only what…

    • 2477 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cassius admits that Caesar is treated like a god and recalls events of Caesar’s physical weakness. Caesar was a powerful man who planned to become the supreme ruler of the Roman Empire in order to solve the many economic, political and military problems the empire was against. While, there were people that feared such a powerful man because this dictator threatened his/her position. Cassius voices his reason for Caesar being unfit to rule, Cassius says, “Men at some time are masters of their fates: The fault, Dear Brutus is not in our stars, But in ourselves, that we are underlings” (Shakespeare, I, i, 139-141). Saying that it is not his/her fate to blame, but that is his/her own fault that they have not done anything to make them great. Cassius blames his and Brutus’s lack of will to grant Caesar to power. Cassius and Brutus’s jealously of Caesar makes it unjustifiable to kill him. In her article, Alice Shalvi argues, “Shakespeare implicitly condemns the conspiracy, then, on two scores: firstly, because it inevitably involves moral corruption even in the best and noblest of men and, secondly, because murder is always no matter in what…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The exposition of Julius Caesar, Shakespeare immediately presents the ideals that underpin the differing views of Caesar’s rising power through his two protagonists, Brutus and Cassius. Both characters posses different interpretations on Caesar’s reign on Rome, one being loyal to Rome and a love and respect for Caesar “I love him well” but the other being a spiteful and vitriolic towards a “feeble old tyrant.” This highlights the notion of Cassius’s selfish prejudice towards his own contentment, which is only shown behind closed doors. Brutus on the other hand is victim to Cassius’ vitriol and becomes the pawn as he is manipulated “poor Brutus, with himself at war,” Brutus is troubled emotionally, torn by his patriotism and his respect for Caesar, above all he has an undying love for Rome, “Brutus had rather be a villager than to repute himself a son of Rome.” It is this love for Rome that causes such internal turmoil for Brutus, through Shakespeare’s use of juxtaposition of characters, he is able to highlight to the audience, the lengths that man will go to in order to…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    An arrogant person is someone who thinks they are more important than other people. Caesars eventual destruction is led by his arrogant personality which causes him to be killed. Caesar feels no shame in what he does. He killed Pompey because Caesar wanted more power over the people. Pompey was Caesar's friend but Caesar killed him so he could rule Rome alone.…

    • 189 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who is the real tragic hero? Many have come to this question when it comes to the play of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare. Many scholars believe that the title of the play should be called Marcus Brutus instead of Julius Caesar because Julius Caesar was not the tragic hero of the play. A tragic hero is one that makes a mistake or mistakes that either lead to their death or their defeat. Brutus was the one who had the mistake of being over confident, was impatient and was gullible which led him to his down fall.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The influence of the writings of Plutarch of Chaeronea on English literature might well be made the subject of one of the most interesting chapters in the long story of the debt of moderns to ancients. One of the most kindly and young spirited, he is also one of the most versatile of Greek writers, and his influence has worked by devious ways to the most varied results. His treatise on the Education of Children had the honour to be early translated into the gravely charming prose of Sir Thomas Elyot, and to be published in a black-letter quarto 'imprinted,' as the colophon tells us, 'in Fletestrete in the house of Thomas Berthelet.' The same work was drawn upon unreservedly by Lyly in the second part of Euphues, and its teachings reappear a little surprisingly in some of the later chapters of Pamela. The essay on the Preservation of Good Health was twice translated into Tudor prose, and that on Curiosity suffered transformation at the hands of the virgin queen herself into some of the most inharmonious of English verse.…

    • 2067 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Julius Caesar,” William Shakespeare took us on a deeper level with some of the characters, and by doing that, we saw their pride. “Pride makes us artificial and humility makes us real” Thomas Merton. This quote explains the characters very well because their prideful actions made the people look at them in a different way. After reading this, you should be able to see how having pride did not end well for the men at the time.…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From this, the reader finds that Brutus foresees Caesar turning his back upon his subordinates once he attains the highest power. Brutus ends his soliloquy with an analogy comparing Caesar’s status at the time to a serpent in an egg. When hatched, or when Caesar was given power, he would grow ‘mischievous’, or playful with power at the expense…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cautious, cunning, and crafty are what describes Antony as a person when he gives his motivating and memorable speech about Caesar. Julius Caesar was just murdered by the conspirators and Antony finds out about it. Part of the conspirators also wants to kill Antony, but Brutus thinks they will be “butchers” (Shakespeare III.i.166). During Caesar’s funeral Antony avenges his friend’s death. With great patience and inspiring words, Antony turns the crowd against Brutus, even though he pretends to be the conspirators’ friend. In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Antony’s speech to persuade the crowd to turn against the conspirators was proved effective through his use of pathos and logos. His voice was thoughtful and ever so credible to the people. This is why they trust Antony and his playful words.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics