Preview

Selling Organs Should Not Be Legalized

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1040 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Selling Organs Should Not Be Legalized
Organ donation affects hundreds of thousands of people and their families worldwide. At the end of October 2008, more than 100,000 people were waiting for an organ in the United States alone. Unfortunately, the number of donors is nowhere near that figure. The development of organ transplantation as a standard medical procedure denotes that there is a substantial demand for organs than is adequate to fulfill the current needs (Barber 234). If the organs were readily available as needed, thousands of lives could be saved each year. However, an organ market would redefine the act of donating organs and would in turn decline organ contributions (Childress 71).
Admittedly, many would argue that the legalization of organ markets is both morally ethical and beneficial for the country. For example, some citizens feel it is the American way to allow people be free to auction their individual organs and do whatever they desire with their bodies. Additionally, many plainly declare that sale would increase the supply and not diminish the percentage of altruistic donation (Rothman 70). Finally, advocators for legalization state that it would be a natural incentive to help escalate the amount of donations. To summarize, supporters of organ selling believe that financial benefits might encourage people to donate and should be a normal part of a free enterprise system. Indeed, many might believe legalization of the selling of organs is beneficial. However, organ markets should continue to stay illegal in the United States because selling is unjust, promotes unhealthy greed, and devalues human life.
Initially, selling should not be legalized because it is unjust. For instance, there is a strong economic motive for low-income families to sell their organs yet none for wealthy people to do so. Likewise, the risk of coercion and exploitation, specially of poor people, is considerable. Some insist the rich have been habitually prepared to allow underprivileged individuals to do

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Organs For Sale Summary

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Organs for Sale” is an argument written in response to the on-going ethical debate of a market-based incentive program to meet the rising demands of organ transplants. With many on the waiting list for new organs and few organs being offered, the author, Sally Satel, urges for legalization of payment to organ donors. Once in need of a new kidney herself, Sally writes of the anguish she encountered while facing three days a week on dialysis and the long wait on the UNOS list with no prospective willing donors in sight. She goes on to list several saddening researched facts on dialysis patients survival rates, length of time on the UNOS wait list, and registered as well as deceased donor numbers. While Sally is…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people are simply reluctant to donate their bodily parts. In response to the shortage, proposals have come forth advocating the sale of non-vital human organs.” (Andre, Claire, and Manuel Velasquez. " Organ Selling and Transplants." Organ Selling and Transplants.)…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the “Yes, Let’s Pay Organs” the author Charles Krauthammer talks about organ rewards in Pennsylvania. In 1984 a federal law that declares organ a natural resources not subject to compensation. One of the objections in Pennsylvania ideas would affect the poor: slum housing street crime, small cars and hazardous jobs, while the rich, argued will not be moved by a $300 reward. The article also talks about the pricing of kidneys from the dead that cannot be sold at a market. The Pennsylvania program does cross the line but not all of them. Today people don’t sell organs from the living or the dead is a fence against the commoditization of human parts. There are 62,000 people desperately clinging to life, some of whom will die if we don’t have the courage…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are donors selling their organ(s) to gain profits. Basically, it is the poor who could use the money and thus, selling the organ(s) to the rich. The wealthier buyers would have the upper hand and can easily secure themselves an organ. Indeed it could help save the lives of the rich but how about the poor? Not only do the lives of the rich matter, but generally the lives of all patients who are suffering do too. Priority should be given based on the severity condition of the patient on the wait list, paying attention to the suitability of the organ from the donor to the patient (eg. Blood type). Possibly, the patient’s immune system should match with the donor in order to receive the organ, else it could go wrong (KidneyLink, 2014). If the above system fails, patients might start looking for alternatives to retrieve an organ and in this case, by the back-door option. Some donors believe that they can survive with just one kidney and do not mind selling away one of theirs to either gain money or to save a life (Castillo, 2013). The black market sales of organs has gone as far as social media where some are seen looking to buy organs to help a family member or some to sell their organ(s) to live a better life. Besides this, black market sales is the faster option as compared to being on the waiting list in…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compensating donors for organ donations is one of the most controversial debates we have today. The shortage of organ donations in America is the one of the main reason there is a sudden drive to supplement the possible sources of organs. It first began with the move from donations of organs from cadaver to donations from living donors, and no the debate is rerisen, to the possibility of building a market for organ donations with a financial incentive.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There has always been a debate between creating a legal market for organs rather than accepting the fact that the black market will always exist. If there had to be a decision made regarding the legalization of organ purchases, my answer would be a definite no. Many people can argue and come up with plenty of reasons as to why it should or should not be legalized but in the end the meaning of an “Organ Donor” would be taken away.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is the incentive for people to donate? Many believe that if the buying and selling of organs becomes legal, that this would be a unique way of not only saving thousands of lives every year, but also allowing many people to be pulled out of poverty and live a life where one’s family is provided for (Shafer and Cunningham, 2011).…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There are many critics that believe that paying for organs is unethical. “The World Health Organization (WHO) declared that the commercialization of human organs to be a ‘violation of human rights’ and ‘human dignity’’ (Ram 1). However, there are arguments against this statement because many more people find it more unethical for organs to be sold on the black market or harvested from people for a profit illegally. Without regulation to help more people receive organs, some people may receive organs from executed prisoners in China, or a Chinese prisoner shot specifically for their organs to be sold (“Is it…” 37). According to this article, some people would rather see people being killed for their organs than to allow someone to sell their organ, which they do not have to have to maintain life, for a profit. Becker states, compensation would sufficiently lower the number of organs donated from altruistic motives to dominate the increase due to those sold commercially. Also, doctors and physicians have tried preventing the legalization of organ donor paying by stretching organs to make them available for more than one person. Physicians have tried stretching donated livers to put the tissue into two different patients. They have also tried to develop fake organs to keep people alive long enough to get real ones (Healy 3). However, the question is why would people believe that…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Organs are constantly needed around the world by dying patients and anxious doctors. Sadly, there isn’t enough donors so patients stuck in the waiting list are being left untreated because of the lack of organs. I believe donating should be forced to be mandatory everywhere because people don’t believe they need to. In reality it is our moral duty to help whoever is in need. I plan to present the benefits, problems, and solutions towards this controversial topic.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Currently, the United States is facing a crisis. On average, 20 people are dying every day because there is a shortage of organs. Right now, to receive an organ, one must wait for an organ donor to die, or receive an organ from someone who is willing to give up one of theirs. With technology and medical advances, organ transplants are becoming more successful, effective, and safe. For those reasons, many people would be willing to sell an organ to a complete stranger. But right now, it is illegal for someone to sell their organs. In turn, this has created a black market for organs, and from this, it has caused chaos in some countries. There needs to be a legal market for organs because it will actually help the economy,…

    • 1446 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I agree with your reply pertaining to an organ being priceless. However, I have a respected perspective for those who are for or against, some may even agree to disagree about organ sales. This problem exist today since this is just a controversial topic. For most this is a discussed topic for those who have experienced this tragedy as reality. What about those parents with children who work and their children walking to and from school, or playing outside and an unfortunate act for organ sales relocate nearby? The uninvited or unknown possibilities can hit close to one’s home. Individuals have the right to sign, seal and deliver their own body parts rather it is right or wrong but committing an unlawful act and to harm to others for pocket…

    • 203 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There is a controversy in today's society that organ donation only benefits the wealthy people, but without organ donation not even the poor will have hope for the chance of life. Most people live their lives not knowing the importance of organ donation until they are faced with this dilemma. Healthcare is experiencing a shortage in organ donation and the people that need these organs is only growing (Meckler, 2007). As people with good ethical morals, people are obligated to take part in organ donation because people are in need of organs and tissues, donors give a gift of life, and donors are the ones that minimize the need of organs and tissues in the U.S.…

    • 116 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The National Organ Transplant Act of 1984 (NOTA) bans the buying and selling of organs (www.medscape.org, 2003). The question is, since buying and selling organs is “illegal’ according to Senate Report, (www.medscape.org, 2003) why do people continue doing it? The national Organ…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Organ Shortage

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the United States, there are 120,000 Americans listed on a transplant list, and over 30 die daily due to waiting or other illness that prevent them from becoming recipients(Washington post, 2014). Organ shortages seem to be a massive problem in the world today. According to the CDC, the most common transplants are the kidney, followed by the liver, heart and lungs (CDC, 2014). Deceased individuals only make up 1% of the donations, leading to an organ shortage today. This brings up several topics as to how these organs are obtained, and why certain types of people are getting better chances of getting the organs versus those who are not.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the United States, there are over one hundred twenty-three thousand people waiting to receive a life-saving organ donation, yet only about one out of every eight will ever receive that precious gift, and a second chance at life (optn.transplant.hrsa.gov) The demand for organ donation has consistently exceeded supply, and the gap between the number of recipients on the waiting list and the number of donors has increased by ninety-three percent since 1991 according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. As a result, some propose radical new ideas to meet the demands, including the legalization and sale of human organs. Financial compensation for…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays