Preview

Sandra Gilbert Gender

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
551 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Sandra Gilbert Gender
Freud and Sandra Gilbert meet at Starbucks to discuss Ophelia in Act 4 scene 5. Gilbert is examining Ophelia’s madwoman image while Freud is diagnosing her with hysterics.
FREUD: Ophelia is to be diagnosed with hysterics, because she is bringing her fears into account when she is singing her song. Especially the part where she says, “He is dead and gone lady/ He is dead and gone”(93) she is realizing that her father is gone. This is her female trouble and she needs to be treated medicine for her hysterics. Her female trouble is prompted by her sexuality because she has a uterus and that is where her hysteria is coming from.
GILBERT: So, you believe she is a madwoman?
FREUD: I believe that she has hysterics because she is having a fantasy about Valentine’s day and showing it through her song. She is also relating injustice to her father’s death by saying “At his head a grass green turf,/ At his heels a stone” (93). So, if that is what you call a madwoman then, yes, she is a madwoman.
…show more content…
According to you, Oedipus complex manifests itself at the age of five. You say that the Oedipus complex is where a boy unconsciously is fighting for the love of his mother with his father. We could simply say that Ophelia that since her mother is not in the picture Ophelia does not have to fight for the love of her father, because she already has it. This makes his death send her into a depression. Shakespeare uses madwomen Ophelia to show Hamlet as the hero of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A great example of a character who presents an abnormal state of mind is Cherry. This Lewis-addicted romantic and compulsive liar brings lightness to the play which lifts the atmosphere among the cast. Her obsession with Lewis and childlike behaviour forces the reader to categorise her as abnormal, this is also used as an opportunity to lightly explore some aspects of the human condition of those living with a mental illness and their relationship with the sane characters surrounding them.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She did not delve into much detail about how her actions affected her relationships with her family and her lovers, which we can assume could be strenuous at times. When she begins to discuss the issues of having children of her own, she even goes so far as to question if people with manic-depression are in danger of becoming endangered. She says that if we eventually rid the world of people with manic-depression using genes and prenatal diagnosis, we risk the world of becoming a much blander place. After some quick research, it becomes clear about her stance on artistic creativity and psychological illness as she has written an entirely different book on the subject. I find this view of hers to be a stretch, and that not every artist must have some sort of psychological…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ophelia was another character in the story that lost her mind because of her father’s death. She was mad acting like foolish and this madness has caused her several psychological damages. Ophelia much like Hamlet has experienced the exact same thing when her father has murdered. The dilemma drove her into madness because she had no control over her emotional pain. She might become depressed because of the conflict between her father and Hamlet. She could not handle traumatic experience when she lost her father; she became insane to ultimately drown herself in the river.…

    • 95 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I was shocked by the madness of Ophelia, and the manner in which Gertrude approaches the situation, both were unexpected. Earlier in the novel, the relationship of Ophelia and her father is revealed, and it pears to be a very weak relationship, based on the oppression of her under her father’s rule. From this relationship that the two share I would never assume that Ophelia would be driven mad by the death of her father. I sympathize with Ophelia since she has endured so many pains, first discovering Hamlet’s madness, then discovering the death of her father. She is entirely alone in her sorrow, and the King and Queen do nothing buy agitate her and pick at her wounds. Also in this scene Gertrude refuses to see Ophelia, and only agrees when…

    • 167 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Is Ophelia driven mad by her love for Hamlet, or is she the victim of a society that has created impossible expectations for its women? Had she the license to think for herself, Ophelia might have reasoned…

    • 171 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1. Both Ophelia and Marjane experience bouts of deep depression. In what ways are the conditions that contribute to their respective depressions similar and how do they differ? What, other than the difference in their temperaments, might account for each responded to her sorrows?…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Laertes And Ophelia Essay

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The primary destruction of Laertes and Ophelia’s psychological success stems from their immense fixation on a degree of the Freudian complex: “the dysfunctional bond with a parent of the opposite sex that one does not outgrow in adulthood and that does not allow one to develop mature relationships with their peers” (Tyson 17). Thus, Laertes and Ophelia constantly suffer from being “driven, by desires, fears, needs, and conflicts of which they are unaware” and in this case, these issues come from the loss of direction and affection from their mother (Tyson 12). This piece of the general Oedipus fixation is more applicable to Laertes as his childhood distress comes from a significant member of the opposite sex in his life. Being separation from…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Joan Montgomery Byles’s view of Ophelia’s behavior in “Ophelia’s Desperation” and Sandra K. Fischer’s view of Ophelia’s behavior in “Ophelia’s Mad Speeches” contradict each other and present opposing explanations. Byles’s view is that Ophelia is defined by the male roles in her life (i.e. her father, brother, and lover). Fischer’s view is that Ophelia is simply grieving the loss of her father and fails to break the hold of the men in her life. These two analyses present opposing explanations because one author is saying that Ophelia simply cracked because she has lost her father and she just could not handle it and the other is stating that Ophelia went mad and committed suicide because she was tired of just sitting around listening to the men in her life tell her what to do and when; with all that built up anger and aggression Ophelia needed an outlet to diffuse the situation and so she took her anger out on herself and drowned. Looking closer it is obvious that Byles’s view is the more accurate of the two.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin, Ophelia, the beautiful damsel in distress, became a minute distraction before Claudius’ big plans. Hamlet's mad love for Ophelia created a different love story, one resembling the tragic ending of Romeo and Juliet. Constantly taking orders from her father and brother Ophelia was never in control, and in turn was losing control of her mind. Claudius knew how to use Ophelia and then dispose of her once her deed was completed. Throughout the play, Ophelia stayed close to Hamlet, becoming a mere distraction to Hamlet while Claudius planned his death. Ophelia started observing Hamlet's behavior change for the worse and shouted, ‘Heavenly powers, restore him!” (3.1.151). Ophelia completed her task by grabbing Hamlet’s attention and was…

    • 198 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ophelia Character Analysis

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The dismissive behaviour of Polonius and Laertes dehumanizes Ophelia and keeps her separated from the decision making “adults”. In one instance, Polonius instructs her to “think [herself] a baby”. In her interactions with these characters, Ophelia’s opinion is not asked for or valued she is largely cast aside or used as a tool. In Ophelia’s first appearance she is constantly reminded by Polonius and Laertes of the “danger of desire”, Laertes advises her that he “best safety lies in fear”. (Act I, Scene III). It is made clear early on that Ophelia is being taught to fear relationships, leading to long term isolation. These repressed emotions may relate to her fixation on desire during her madness. Polonius also dismisses Ophelia’s opinions on Hamlet’s behaviour saying, ”Affection? Pooh! you speak like a green girl”. Throughout all of Ophelia’s interactions with her father she maintains formal titles and language, referring to Polonius as “my lord”. By submitting to the perception of her inferiority Ophelia alienates herself from others. Even before her becoming insane, Ophelia is marginalized and removed from others, a the true outsider within…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Hamlet, madness is portrayed through both Hamlet and Ophelia, but while Hamlet feigns his insanity, Ophelia truly goes insane by her father's murder, and the unjust harshness of Hamlet. They each share a common connection: the loss of a parental figure. Hamlet loses his father as a result of a horrible murder, as does Ophelia. In her situation is more severe because it is her lover who murders her father and all of her hopes for her future as well.…

    • 512 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gabrielle Dane, writer of Reading Ophelia’s Madness, says, “motherless and completely circumscribed by the men around her, Ophelia has been shaped to conform to external demands, to reflect other's desires”. stating, all her life man had controlled her. Since her father was so controlling his death caused her to lose her sanity, she had the freedom to do and way whatever she wanted, she had power but didn’t know how to handle it. Also her madness stems from her relationship with hamlet. in her third song she says, “before you tumbled me, you promised me to wed.” (he replies) “so would i ha’ done, by yonder sun, an thou hast not come to my bed.” Everything ties together, her father did not want her to have an intimate relationship with hamlet but she did, then after hamlet rejected her in marriage she can only feel more guilty about not listening to her father. In Mechanics of Madness in Hamlet, Macbeth and King Lear by Shweta Bali she says “Ophelia undoubtedly loses her mind and is driven to commit suicide primarily by the overbearing attitude of the men in her life” . also referring back to the book Act 4, Scene 5 King Claudius says “poor Ophelia divided herself and her fair judgment”. stating that she has gone mad. I think what Shakespeare was trying to say about the women in this time was that when they have power…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In William Shakespeare's Hamlet, the character of Ophelia is being portrayed quite like a victim. This simple, innocent young woman falls victim to many things. She is the victim of Hamlet's harassment, the victim of manipulation by many, the victim of her own flaws of being obedient, indecisive, and weak both mentally and eventually physically. Ophelia is unfortunately not very strong willed and is placed in the crossfire between many things and is unable to escape them. Gerald Chapman similarly agrees in the below quote taken from his book Essays on Shakespeare.…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The people around her start to realize that signs of depression are present and she receives the recommendation to go see a therapist by the name of Doctor Gordon. Esther feels disconnected from Doctor Gordon and starts to hate him. Her animosity towards him starts to increase after he schedules her for electroshock therapy. Esther describes her therapy as “something [that] bent down and took hold of [her] and shook [her] like the end of the world” (Plath 117). She then continues by stating “with each flash a great jolt drubbed me till I thought my bones would break and the sap fly out of me like a split plant” (Plath 117-118). The descriptive imagery that she uses conveys her resentment towards the treatment. Esther then wonders “what terrible thing it was that [she] had done” (Plath 118). Esther loathed Dr. Gordon because of the pain that he put her through. This electroshock therapy eventually causes Esther’s condition to worsen; the exact opposite of the original intentions of the treatment. Between the indifferent Dr. Gordon, her nagging mother, and the pressure of society the constant thoughts of suicide start to plague Esther’s…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    study in the Victorian era. However some believe Ophelia to be stricken by alternative conditions including infantile regression, sexual repression or schizophrenia stated by RD Laing, due to the absence of herself, the essential person. The ideas of Hamlet and Ophelia’s insanity are effectively represented by Shakespeare through the use of Imagery and dialogue. Insanity is seen as a result of the complexity of man whether that be directly or indirectly affected.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays