Preview

Romeo and Juliet - Guilty Deaths

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1305 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Romeo and Juliet - Guilty Deaths
Guilty Deaths
The Shakespearian play Romeo and Juliet is a well known story about star-crossed lovers whose fates end in tragedy. The deaths of these two lovers can be held responsible on two main characters, Friar Lawrence and the Nurse yet out of the two, who is more liable? Friar Lawrence is a priest who marries the two lovers, gives Juliet a fake potion to prevent her from marrying Paris, fails to send the letter to Romeo telling him about his plan and selfishly runs away from Juliet in fear that he would get into trouble for his involvement. The Nurse is Juliet’s lifelong caregiver who helps Juliet and her lover get married, becomes their “messenger” and later on in the play, changes her mind on who Juliet should be with. The physical actions and guidance of both the Friar and Nurse demonstrate their liability for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Although, it is undeniable that Friar Lawrence is more to blame than the Nurse on the deaths of Romeo and Juliet through his guidance, advice and physical actions throughout the play. In the play, Romeo and Juliet are very young and constantly seek advice and guidance of people older and supposedly wiser than them, like Friar Lawrence and the Nurse. What is unclear to them is that the advice and guidance that they receive comes with many consequences, and for Romeo and Juliet, it is death. Throughout the course of the Shakespearian play, Friar Lawrence gives the couple a lot of advice and guidance. To avoid marrying Paris, he tells Juliet to pretend to be dead with the help of a special potion he made. As part of the plan, he was supposed to inform Romeo of this arrangement yet he fails which later costs him his own life along with Juliet’s. “Come I’ll dispose of thee/ Among a sisterhood of holy nuns/ Stay not to question, for the watch is coming/ Come, go good Juliet. I dare no longer stay/” (Shakespeare 5.3 155) demonstrates how selfish he was as he left the Capulet tomb and let Juliet kill herself instead of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Friar Lawrence’s second monologue occurs during the morning of the wedding day of Juliet and Paris, a little after the Capulets find their daughter “dead”. He comforts the Capulets by saying that Juliet has achieved the highest form of happiness by dying and entering heaven. However, this monologue foreshadows Juliet’s future death with her lover but both the audience and the Friar know that Juliet isn’t dead and is merely sleeping. In a previous scene, Friar Lawrence devised a plan to help Juliet get to Romeo and gives her a sleeping potion that would make her appear dead for two days. One could speculate that Friar Lawrence only wanted to rise in power and gain recognition by making peace between the Capulets and Montagues. If he had actually…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tragedies happen all the time in the world, books, and even plays. But these bad things always happen to everyone; there is no such thing as a perfect life. In the magnificent play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare, the tragic death of these two star-crossed lovers, Romeo and Juliet, takes place at the end of the play. Although there are many people to blame for their deaths, one person can for sure be blamed for this. Friar Lawrence is the character most responsible for the two star-crossed lovers deaths at the end of the play. For one thing, he never made sure that the letter got sent to Romeo, and that he kept their marriage a secret to the two families.…

    • 122 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    First of all, this choice is selfless on his part because he is willing to lose respect in order to end the feud, but this choice was also not a wise choice. By letting the two marry, he is also putting the children in bad positions because his plan for the families’ feud to end may not work, thus threatening the relationship between Romeo and his parents, Juliet and her parents, and the families’ hatred to one another all together. Eventually, complications in his plans occur, such as Romeo’s banishment, and Juliet’s engagement to Paris. So, Friar Lawrence ends up concentrating on Romeo and Juliet’s love and discarding the thought of ending the feud. He opens many windows and creates many opportunities for the couple so that they can be together; this outlines his role in the play. Friar Lawrence provides methods for Romeo and Juliet to reunite, by giving Juliet an elixir to fake her death, and attempting to get Romeo (whom he sent to Mantua) to meet her in her tomb where she would awaken, and hence they would live “happily ever after”. Although Friar Lawrence had good intentions, the results of those actions were very unfortunate, and ended up taking the lives from who he initially tried to…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Friar Laurence gives Juliet hope of seeing him again by giving her a sleeping potion, and promises that she will awaken with Romeo by her side. He is trying to help her back to her love. But in a turn of unfortunate events, Friar Laurence’s letter to Romeo about his lady’s ‘passing’ didn’t get received, but the news did. Romeo came back with death on his mind, and in the end they both met their tragic fates. Friar Laurence did not want any of this to happen, but him giving Juliet the potion further thickens the plot by adding a final climax to the epic love story. He unintentionally killed the two he spent countless hours trying to protect. Closing the play with an ironic, twist…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After Romeo got kicked out of Verona, Juliet was upset and didn’t know what to do, so friar was keeping Romeo in the basement until Juliet came to see him. The priest told them the plan that Romeo had to go to a different town to live until he got the prince to let him back in Verona. Juliet was upset because Romeo was kicked out of Verona, but her father thought she was sad because of Tybalt’s death. So he arranged a marriage not knowing that she already married to Romeo. Juliet said she didn’t want to marry Paris. Her father got really angry and told her she will marry him or be kicked out of the house. “Go home, be careful, say you will marry him, sleep alone without the nurse, drink this vile of liquid that will put you in a death-like coma for 42 hours. Then, when you go in the family vault when the 42 hours are up, Romeo and I will be there to get you to Mancha with Romeo.” (2, 3 6) Friar is telling Juliet how to get out of marrying Paris. She wouldn’t have to do this if Friar Lawrence had just said no to this in the first place. Friar sends a letter to Romeo to tell him of the plan, but he doesn’t get the letter so he believes that Juliet is dead. Romeo then goes to an apothecary to get a poison that will kill him so he can be with Juliet. Poison has brought him to an immediate end. He killed himself to be with her, so she picked up his dagger and drove it though…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Friar Lawrence did many things that influenced the lives of Romeo and Juliet. One of the things he did was give Juliet a potion that would lead people to believe that she was dead. Now the Friar believed his plan was good but it was really an act of deception against her parents. If Juliet had told her parents of the legal marriage between her and Romeo, she may have been disowned by her father but she would have been with Romeo which is what she had wanted. But instead the Friar suggested to deceive the family which could end badly."A greater power than we can contradict / Hath…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Friar Lawrence advised Romeo that Prince had given him ald lesser sentence for killing Tybalt, he should of sent him away without the idea of seeing Juliet again. Especially since Paris has now visited Friar Lawrence to arrange his marriage to Juliet. When Friar Lawrence was given this news by Paris he should of immediately sent notice to Romeo. But instead he is now helping Juliet set up her own fake death by providing her a sleeping potion to make it seen like she is dead. When Juliet asks Friar Lawrence what she should do and what help he can be, he immediately gave her hope when he spoke, "Hold, then;go home, be merry, give consent to marry Paris: Wednesday is to-morrow; To-morrow night look that thou lie alone, let not thy nurse lie with thee in thy chamber; Take thou this vial, being then in bed. And this distilled liquor drink thou off: When, presently, through all thy veins shall run A cold and drowsy humour; for no pulse shall keep his native progress, but surcease." If Friar Lawrence had not given Juliet that vial of potion, she would not have taken it. If he really thought he was helping them both, they could of been together by simply letting Juliet go to Mancua. To go to these lengths simply put Romeo, Juliet and Paris in harms way.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, right after Romeo is banished Juliet comes to him for help; however, instead of being an adult, he gives her a poison to put her in a deathly sleep. Friar Lawrence is a major character that has a lot of pull in the play, but he’s also easily pushed into things he shouldn't agree with. When Juliet comes to him in hope of something to take her to Romeo he gives her a potion made of a plant. He gives an unstable 14 year old girl poison; there had to have been a better idea than that rattling somewhere in his brain. He comes up with this elaborate plan to trick the Capulets into believing their precious daughter is dead. They don’t bury her but put her in a tomb with others of both houses. She’s not even put in a casket. This then brings us to the second issue that Friar Lawrence make, he trusts people with things they should not be trusted…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When he says "Shall Romeo by my letters know our drift, and hither shall he come; and he and I shall watch thy waking, and that very night shall Romeo bear thee to Mantua." (Act 4, Scene 1), he tells Juliet how everything will be all right. Unfortunately, for all his good intentions the play still ends in tragedy.<br><br>Friar Lawrence is a man who is not afraid to take risks when he feels it is necessary to help someone. For example in Act 2, Scene 6, when he marries Romeo and Juliet, he is risking his reputation as a Friar so he can help the two lovers. Also, when he says "Take thou this vial, being then in bed, and this distilled liquor drink though off;" (Act 4, Scene 1), he is suggesting that Juliet drink a potion so that she might make believe her own death and avoid marrying Paris. This is an extremely risky thing to do because anything might happen to Juliet while she unconscious.<br><br>Even after all Friar did to help Romeo and Juliet the play still ended in tragedy because of Friar Lawrence's short sightedness.…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Friar Lawrence does many things to assist Romeo and Juliet during the play, but he also does a few things that speeds up their deaths. An indirect way he sped up their deaths was creating the intricate plan of faking Juliet’s death. It was well intentioned, but after numerous unplanned incidents, it ends up doing more harm than good. Romeo never received the letter containing vital information on the fake death, and therefore believes Juliet is dead, saying, “O my love, my wife, death, that hath sucked the honey from thy breath hath had no power yet upon thy beauty” (5.3.91-3). He ends up committing suicide. Without Friar Lawrence’s plan, Romeo never would’ve been tricked into believing Juliet was dead and killing himself. No matter how well intentioned, Friar Lawrence’s plan was a huge disaster. In the last scene of the play, Friar Lawrence asks Juliet to leave the monument where her dead husband lays, and she says no. Friar Lawrence says nothing else and leaves her there. He knew that she would do anything for Romeo, and now since he was dead, she could very well be suicidal. Yet he just left her in there, without another word of persuasion. Just seconds after he leaves, she says, “Poison, I see, hath been his timeless end. O churl, drunk all, and left no friendly drop to help me after! I will kiss thy lips” (5.3.167-9), and kills herself…

    • 992 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Friar Lawrence Blame

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Due to Tybalt’s death Lord and Lady Capulet wanted to make Juliet happy again so they made arrangements for Paris and Juliet to get married which caused a problem because Juliet was married to Romeo. Juliet was so conflicted on what to do so she talked to her Nurse and decided to speak with Friar Lawrence. Friar Lawrence says to her "I do spy a kind of hope, Which craves as desperate an execution, As that is desperate which we would prevent. If, rather than to marry County Paris.” Friar Lawrence comes up with a crazy way on how Juliet can fake her own death. He tells her that if she really would do anything rather than marry him then he will give her a special potion that will kill her for forty-two hours but he cannot guarantee that it will work 100%. Being a priest he offers Juliet the option of suicide if she truly does not want to marry…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Prior to proposing the eight-step plan to Juliet, Friar Lawrence feels a sense of obligation in protecting her. Even though he cannot yet see the dangers of his seemingly foolproof idea, he is trying to keep her from killing herself. While his decisions to help Romeo and Juliet have extreme consequences, he cannot see them because of his motives. Towards the end of the play, as the two families are discussing what could have led to the deaths of their children, Friar Lawrence expresses his stance on the topic, claiming, “To rid her from this second marriage,/Or in [his] cell there would she kill herself” (5.3 250-251). When Friar Lawrence claims, “in my cell there would she kill herself,” he says that he had to step in and make a plan with Juliet in order to keep her from causing herself any harm. Additionally, he cannot see the consequences of his actions due to the fact that he is stuck in the present time. At the moment, the most important thing on his mind is saving Juliet. As seen earlier in the play, Friar Lawrence knows that Juliet is suicidal, and creates a “foolproof” plan in order to save her from…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today an important verdict will be passed that will bring justice to Juliet, and help her soul rest in peace. Over the years there has been an ongoing feud between both the Capulets and the Montagues, which has not softened over time, but has only grown generation by generation. Both houses have never benefited from this feud, but have only lost their loved ones, their only heirs. Here, we are of course talking about both Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet. Gentlemen, during the proceedings you have heard what both sides have had to say regarding the inevitable demise of young Juliet. Now the question can finally be answered as to, WHO is to be blamed for her premature death? Sources reveal…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She had trusted the Friar to help her save her marriage with Romeo and make sure she doesn’t end up marrying Paris. To ensure Juliet from not marrying Paris and to stay united with Romeo, Friar Lawrence had come up with a plan. His plan for Juliet was to “Go home...give consent to marry Paris… take thou this veil, being then in bed, and this distilling liquor drink thou off… I will watch thy waking and that very night shall Romeo bear thee hence to Mantua” (p.750). Friar Lawrence had ensured that there wouldn't be any flaws to this plan. But what had happened was that Romeo didn’t get the letter and came to Juliet’s tomb and had killed himself. After waking up from her coma-like state, Juliet had seen her husband lying dead on the ground. She decided that “[she] will not away...haply some poison yet doth hang on them to make me die with a restorative.... The I’ll be brief. O happy dagger!” (p. 769-770). Juliet had killed herself because she thought that a world without Romeo was equivalent to no world at all. Without Friar Lawrence’s carelessness and ignorance in the plan, Romeo wouldn’t have killed himself and neither would Juliet. He was the cause of their deaths because of the failures in his plans.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the tale of the two star-crossed lovers, Romeo and Juliet rely on their closest confidant to keep their almost sacrilegious relationship a secret. Their closest confidant, the supposedly righteous Friar Lawrence deserves a major punishment, such as death. From the start, Romeo went to the friar for guidance. In Act II, Scene iii, Romeo sees the friar for the first time in the play. In this scene, Romeo entrusts his secret love of “the fair daughter of rich Capulet” (line 62) and convinces a contradictious Friar Lawrence to marry them. Similarly, Juliet confides in the friar as well. After finding out about her arranged marriage to County Paris, Juliet seeks help from the friar’s “wisdom” (IV.i.53) to come up with a plan that will stop the marriage and allow her and her Romeo to live “happily ever after.” Unfortunately, this immense trust failed the lovers when Friar Lawrence created the elaborate plan that would lead to their demise. Moreover, the friar created the plan specifically to cover his tracks, because of his cowardice and fear of the families. finding out about secretly him marrying Romeo and Juliet. Not only did the friar responsible for indirectly killing Romeo and Juliet, but he also married them without informing the Capulets or the Montagues. He deserves a punishment as vile as execution for his actions.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics