Empire’s philosophers saw it as distasteful and their government officials saw it as beautiful.
Romans in favor of technology praised it for its beauty and usefulness. Hans in favor of technology praised it for its efficiency and protection. However, there were members of both
Han China and the Roman Empire who disliked technology because it could monopolize industries and its users were seen as dull and unskilled.
Romans that had a positive attitude towards technology were very passionate about it.
Not only were roads appreciated for their usefulness but they were described as having grace and beauty (Doc 6). Roads were not the only things that Romans cherished, they also became very proud of their aqueducts. One Roman general raved about the abundance of water they had due to aqueducts, and even compared them to the pyramids of egypt, however this general may have been biased due to the fact that he was the water commissioner of Rome and most likely described the aqueducts as better than they really were in order to make himself look better as a professional (Doc 8). Both of these Romans sharing their excitement about new technology shows their positive attitude towards it. Han China citizens that had a positive attitude toward technology loved its efficiency and the protection it could offer to their country. Han government officials ordered that staffed water conservation offices should be made in order to prevent floods (Doc 1). Han China had decided that their solution to a flood natural disaster was to be equipped with the proper technology to avoid it. A Han philosopher discussed the evolution of technology in his writing, explaining how it has gotten more efficient over time (Doc 3). He saw technology as a good thing that would benefit society. In a history text explaining the rise of technology, it was said that governor Tu
Shih created items like a waterpowered blowingengine so he could save his common people labor, however this document may be unreliable due to the fact that this text was a governmentsponsored history made for the citizens of China, most likely to make the Han
Dynasty appear good (Doc 4). Some of Han China saw technology as a useful and efficient.
They thought everyone would benefit from it.
There were also members from the Roman Empire and Han China that did not find technology to be as great as others thought. Roman philosophers thought that laborers using technology were degrading themselves and had no skill (Doc 5). They also believed that a smart mind was far more important than technology and tools (Doc 7). On top of this, a Han government official believed that the revolution of technology was monopolizing industries, leading to high prices and low quality in goods (Doc 2). Both Roman Philosophers and Han government officials disliked technology, the philosophers saw technology as a tool laborers used to slack off and government officials thought that technology was monopolizing the economy. A document that would have been useful would be a perspective from a laborer in Han
China or the Roman Empire. All of the documents given were written by high up government
officials, or high class philosophers. Most people actually using technology at that time were lower class laborers. Their view would be the most accurate on how efficient or terrible technology was.
Romans who liked technology adored its beauty and practicality. Chinese who liked technology boasted about its efficiency and usefulness. Those who didn’t approve of technology saw it as disgraceful and bad towards the economy. Despite its popular use in both countries,
Han China’s opinion on teachnology was mixed in the way that philosophers found it to be extremely efficient and government officials found it to be monopolizing, and the Roman
Empire’s opinion was split between the government officials who thought it was beautiful and the philosophers who thought it was distasteful.
DBQ Essay Scoring Rubric
(20pts per Rubric point)
This list is abbreviated. For more complete scoring rubric details, see the handout from class.
Basic Core:
1.
Has acceptable thesis – 1 of 1
2.
Addresses all documents (or all but one) – 1 of 1
3.
Supports thesis with evidence for all (or all but one) document – 2 of 2
4.
Analyzes point of views in at least two documents – 1 of 1
5.
Analyzes documents by grouping them in two or three ways – 1 of 1
6.
Identifies and explains the need for an additional document – 1 of 1
Total: 7 of 7 (x20 = 140 out of 140)
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
On the last years of Rome, the Roman Empire faced many problems. The Romans suffered from inflation, unemployment, and barbarian invasion. Inflation was the rise in prices of food and water. Since the food and water was so expensive, the poor couldn’t buy it so they died or had hard times living without food. Unemployment was a big problem in the Roman Empire. Most of the poor and farmers did not have any jobs so they over crowded the cities, overcrowding of the cities was bad for the rich and the poor. The barbarian invasion was horrible, since they burned roman houses and killed many of the citizens. The barbarians were Germanic tribes that invaded Rome to destroy their land. The Roman had many accomplishments during their time. Many of the accomplishment were making concrete, creating aqueducts, having a good government, created the column, and having indoor plumbing. The concrete was to build roads, buildings, and vaults. We use concrete to build most stuff today too. Romans also had aqueducts that brought clean and fresh water to the cities. Today we use aqueducts to hold water. They also had a very stable government. Thru Roman Republic was very good, they also had judges who judged fairly. The Romans also had columns that hold their buildings up. On the columns the Romans usually carved pictures on it. Indoor plumbing was also one of the Romans accomplishments. The Romans waste goes through the sewers and in to the Tiber River. Today the Roman Empire influences our community with their building with concrete, there buildings, and the construction of aqueduct. Today we use concrete to build most of our buildings, walls and some roads, but most of our roads today are made out of asphalt. The Roman buildings were very prestigious designs. Today we use most of the Roman designs to build pure materials. We mostly use their designs on buildings. Today we use an aqueduct to preserve our water. We also use it to keep animals in too, or to keep…
- 346 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The ancient civilizations of Rome and Han China shared both similarities and differences in their social, political and economical views.…
- 260 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In Document 6, the advancements made by Gaius Gracchus are stated by Plutarch, a Roman high official. The Romans created vast roads, paved with quarried stone and tightly packed sand. Bridges were built over streams and ravines that interrupted the flow of the roads. The roads were measured mile by mile through the use of stone columns, and other stones were set beside the roads to help those who rode horses to mount without the help of a groom. This can be seen as a sort of technology since the usage of the stones was replacing the help of a groomsman. In Document 8, Frontinus tells of the Roman aqueducts and its transportation of water. The volume of the aqueducts was measured by calibrated scales. There was such an abundance of water not only was it used for the public, but for…
- 1073 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Technology is the base of a civilization. There are, of course, many things far more necessary than technology, but the great empires of the early common era relied greatly on the use of modern tools in their daily lives. Two well known civilizations that relied on the use of technology are the Han and Rome ; however, their views wavered greatly, and yet, were related at the same time. Both civilizations worked hard on advances in water technology. Rome , as apposed to the Han Dynasty, is more self centered in their inventions, and ultimately, focused more on beauty, while the Han went for the cheaper alternative.…
- 1021 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In documents 1 a Han government official sent a letter about their concerns stating, “I request that you establish water conservation offices in each district and staff them with people who are experience in the ways of water”. This shows that the government officials were not willing to give their constructive criticism, they believed that the jobs should be filled with people who are experienced in that field. In document 2 another government official…
- 440 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Titus Livius was quoted as saying, “Rome has grown since its humble beginnings that it is now overwhelmed by its own greatness.”, and his statement could not be more right (Livius 1823). During its reign, Rome quickly became the most technological and engineering advanced empire of its time. This became undeniably clear to its citizens when these advancements improved their overall health, safety, and living conditions. These achievements not only allowed for Rome to expand its borders exponentially, but also allowed the empire to support a strong community and dominate the seas both through military prowess and through trade. Among many of the Romans engineering and technological feats, the aqueducts of Rome and their innovative shipbuilding advanced their culture remarkably.…
- 603 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Roman and the Han were by far the most technologically advanced civilizations of their time. The time period for both of the societies depicted whether or not the people were inclined to their advancements or not. Much evidence goes to show that both the Roman and Han societies attitudes towards technology in B.C.E. were more negative and in C.E. they leaned more positive. In the documents given, it is evident that during the B.C.E. both the Roman and Han’s attitude toward their technologies were negative. Little did they know how helpful they would turn out to be and how they would revolutionize the world forever. This is first apparent from an excerpt from a Han government official. He states that they need more water conservation offices that are staffed with people who are experienced to aid the local community with the floods (doc. 1). This exemplifies that the people were dissatisfied with the lack of officials to keep the community organized and free of danger. This negative theme is also seen in a passage written by a Han government official (Han Guan) who is complaining about the iron tools and how they were made better when they were made individually by the common people rather than mass-produced by the state. He also touches on the fact that salt and iron prices have sky rocketed so the common people could not afford to season their food and make tools for themselves…
- 1174 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The Han and Roman empires have their fair share of technological advancements, how each civilization reacts to them is different however. Since the beginning of time we as humans have always needed to advance but not every human being believed so. In the Han and Roman empires, as in many others, the attitudes towards these kinds of advancements were mostly positive but there were some negative outlooks.…
- 855 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
When comparing attitudes towards technology in Han China and Ancient Rome during the Classical period, there were both similarities and differences. One way in which they were similar was that both their attitudes towards technology were that it was a necessary part of a civilization, because it helps to regulate an empire. One way in which they were different was that while Han believed that technology was a gift from higher powers, Rome believed that technology was useful but not to it’s full potential or fit for people of this community. Documents 1, 2, 5, and 7 all hold the attitude that technology in these civilizations was completely necessary. Documents 3 and 4 hold the attitude that technology is a gift and relates to their religion. Documents 6 and 8 hold the attitude that technology is an artistic and inventive process.…
- 744 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Documents 1, 2, 3, and 4 all have a positive attitude towards technology and that it should be useful to and help the common people. In document 1, it talks about preventing flood prevention, selecting a person as chief hydraulic engineer, ordering inspections of the waterways, and supplying enough workers to those who are to carry out the repair work. This shows that the Han cared about the common people. In document 2, it talks about the tools and how when they were produced by the families they were well made, but when they were produced by the state using convict labor, they were more crude and not very functional, showing that the Han cared about how well the tools are working. In document 3, it…
- 462 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Han utilized their technology more to the fullest and took pride in what they invented. In Document 1 it shows that technology was not just used as a luxury, but was used a necessary way to help prevent disaster. In this case the Han were trying to prevent flood and had walls canals and pools. There were also people assigned to inspect and repair these technologies to help their people by preventing floods. The Han took pride in ability to keep their people safe from floods and other disasters. Document 2 focuses more on how the government monopolized the making of tools and made them more cheaply and with less quality than the actual workers themselves did. Then the government raised prices on iron and some of the poor had to digress to older technology. Two examples of this is iron became too expensive and wooden plows were now being used instead of iron. Another…
- 825 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Hans respect technology and the people who use it. In China, 2nd century B.C.E. a government official stated that he wanted to organize their labor force with the use of technology so they could help to prevent a disaster from occurring when and if a flood takes place. This could help the people from getting hurt and their property from getting destroyed (Doc. 1). Huan Guan, a Han government official during the first century B.C.E. was concerned about the lack of technology and poor government policy that is affecting the people. Haun Guan was trying to say to the Han government that using convict labor to make tools and monopoly on salt and iron is causing devastating affects towards the people and feels that the government can solve this problem by using the available technologies. Even though Haun Guan is a government official himself, he shows interest in helping the people and is very critical towards the current government policies that are in place (Doc. 2). Huan Tan, a upper class Han philosopher during 20 C.E. is expressing his…
- 926 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There is no doubt that things that benefit people and gift are considered positive. A Han government official (Document 1) wrote to local officials in order to advise them on how to use their technology to prevent floods, showing his interests in maintaining the empire so that it doesn't fall. Not only that, Han Guan, another government official (Document 2) goes against the way the government is monopolizing the making of technology and that technology should be made by the people, since government made technologies are brittle and costing the government more money as not much salt is being produced. It is very interesting that an official would speak against the government, but it may be due to the fact that the scarcity of salt is costing this official money. Both officials may also be looking to maintain their positions or get higher ones once the emperor sees how well they are looking after the empire, which can only be maintained with the help of technology. Others in Han society consider technology as a gift from enlightened leaders. Huan Tan, an upper-class philosopher (document 3) mentions that Fuxi invented some technology which was efficient and beneficial to society. Fuxi, is said to be a wise enlightened emperor which means that since Fuxi made it, it is no doubt a great gift. There is also some government sponsored history (Document 4) which characterizes Tu Shih as a just and commoner loving man who developed technology in order lift some of the burden of labor off the people. Technology was Tu Shih's gift to the people and Tu Shih, was considered a Fuxi. Therefore this government sponsored historian also considers technology a gift.…
- 699 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Han and the Romans both had very passive views when it came to technology, both sharing the "good is good enough" mindset. This appears through people of high class wanting higher quality materials and laborers, the Han enjoying a superb invention but not outwardly seeking to improve it, as well as the Romans appreciated fantastic inventions without searching for ways to improve…
- 64 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Although Doc 6 is about the admiration for another’s work, that is the end of the Roman compliments. Docs 5,6,7, and 8 all include some type of judgment in them. Whether it’s appropriate jobs for men, the lack of an inventor’s brilliance, or the superiority of Roman technology, there is definitely a hint of snobbery.…
- 449 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays